This paper considers whether recent legislation increasing the surveillance and control of sex offenders constitutes discrimination. Recent provisions, including the Sex Offenders Act 1997, the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and the Criminal Justice and Court Services Act 2000 are reviewed. The question of whether sex offenders have been unfairly selected for special treatment is considered as well as the issue of whether the provisions are rightly characterised as punitive.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AshworthA.J.(1999) Commentary on Ibbotson v UK [1999]Crim LR153.
2.
BrownleeI.‘New Labour — New Penology? Punitive Rhetoric and the Limits of Managerialism in Criminal Justice Policy’, Inl. Law & Soc25(3) September 1998, 313–35.
3.
BurnsideJ.P.(2001) ‘The Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 2000: The head of a ‘kiddy-libber’ and the torso of a ‘child-saver’?’, Crim LR425.
4.
CobleyC.(2000) Sex Offenders, Law, Policy and Practice, Jordans.
5.
EnnewJ.(1986) The Sexual Exploitation of Children, Cambridge, Polity Press.
6.
FinkelhorD.(1984) Child Sexual Abuse, Cambridge, Polity Press.
7.
FoucaultM.(1977) Discipline and Punish, The Birth of the Prison, London, Allen Lane.
8.
GillespieA.A.(2001) ‘Children, Chatrooms and the Law’, Crim LR435.
9.
HallidayJ.(2001) Making Punishments Work, Home Office.
10.
Home Office Circular 39/97
11.
Home Office (2000) Setting the Boundaries: Reforming the Law on Sex Offences
12.
HoughM.RobertsD.(1998) Attitudes to Punishment: Findings from the British Crime Survey, Home Office Research Study, No. 179, HMSO.
13.
HowittD.(1995) Paedophiles and Sexual Offences against Children, Chichester, John Wiley.
14.
JanusE.(2000) ‘‘Civil commitment as social control: managing the risk of sexual violence’, in BrownM.PrattJ. (eds.) Dangerous Offenders, Routledge, 71–90
15.
JohnstoneG.(2000) ‘Penal policy making: Elitist, populist or participatory?’Punishment and Society, 2:2, 161–80.
16.
KemshallH.MaguireM.(2001) ‘Public protection, partnership and risk penality: the multi-agency risk management of sexual and violent offenders’, Punishment and Society, Vol, 3, No. 2, April 2001, pp 237–264.
17.
LaceyN.‘Beset by Boundaries: The Home Office Review of Sex Offences’, (2001) Crim LR3–14.
18.
La FontaineJ.(1990) Child Sexual Abuse, Cambridge, Polity Press.
19.
Liberty (January, 1997) Briefing Paper on the Sex Offenders Bill, London.
20.
MarshallP. (1997) The Prevalence of Convictions for Sexual Offending, Home Office Research Findings No. 55.
21.
MarshallP.(1994) Reconvictions of Imprisoned Sexual Offenders, Home Office Research Bulletin, No 36, 23–29.
22.
MattinsonJ.Mirrlees-BlackC.(2000) Attitudes to Crime and Criminal Justice: Findings from the 1998 British Crime Survey, Home Office Research Study, No. 200.
23.
News of the World, 23 July 2000.
24.
O'CarrollT.(1980) Paedophilia, the radical case, Peter Owen.
25.
RawlingsP.(1999) Crime and Power, Longmans.
26.
RyanM.(1999) ‘Penal policy making towards the Millenium: elites and populists: New Labour and the new criminology’Intl. Journal of Sociology and the Law, 27(1) 1–22.
27.
SimonJ.(1998) ‘Managing the Monstrous: Sex Offenders and the New Penology’Psychology, Public Policy and the Law, 4: 1, 1–16.
28.
SoothillK.WalbyS. (1991) Sex Crime in the News, Routledge.
29.
SoothillK.FrancisB.SandersonB. (1997) ‘A Cautionary Tale: The Sex Offenders Act 1997: the Police and the Courts’ (1997) Crim LR482.
30.
SoothillK.FrancisB.‘Reviewing the Pantheon of Sexual Offending’ [1999] Journal of the Society for Advanced Legal Studies, 17.
31.
ThomasT. (2000) Sex Crime, Sex Offending and SocietyWillan Publishing.
32.
TunbridgeV. (July, 2000) ‘OASys: Does it Exist or Is It Just a Mirage?’, Prison Research and Development Bulletin, 9, 7–10.
33.
WalkerN.(1999) Aggravation, Mitigation and Mercy in English Criminal Justice, London, Blackstone.
34.
WyreR.(1987) Working with Sex Offenders, Oxford, Perry Publications
35.
WyreR.(1992) ‘Pornography and sexual violence: working with sex offenders’, in ItzinC. (ed.) Pornography: Women, Violence and Civil Liberties, Oxford University Press, pp.236–247.
36.
WyreR.(1997)‘Paedophilia’, Report of the Conference on Child Sexual Exploitation, Pornography and Paedophilia, London, Michael Sieff Foundation.
