The process and outcome of clinical tasks in an acute psychiatric unit were compared using four different communication modes: face to face, telephone, hands-free telephone, and a low-cost videoconferencing system. Six doctors and six patients took part in the study. Four assessment measures were used. The videoconferencing system was positively received by both patients and doctors. Both doctors and patients preferred communication modes with visual cues. However, there were few significant differences between communication modes when using single measures; only multiple levels of analysis can adequately assess the differences between such modes of communication.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
HallamL. You've got a lot to answer for, Mr Bell. A review of the use of the telephone in primary care. Family Practice1989;6:47–57.
2.
BernheimH. Suggestive Therapeutics. A Treatise on the Nature and Use of Hypnosis. HerterCA, translator. London: GP Putmnam, 1889.
3.
McLarenPMWatsonJPSummerfieldABLipsedgeML. Interactive television in psychiatry. Psychiatric Bulletin1992;16:288–90.
4.
MichaelsE. Telemedicine: the best is yet to come. Canadian Medical Journal1989;141:612–14.
5.
ConrathDBuckinghamPDunnEVSwansonJN. An experimental evaluation of alternative communication systems as used for medical diagnosis. Behavioural Sciences1977;20:1119–26.
6.
MooreGTWillemainTRBonanmoR. Comparison of television and telephone for remote medical consultation. New England Journal of Medicine1975;729–32.
7.
SummerfieldABLawsJVWatsonJP. Nonverbal Behaviour in Human Computer Interactions: A Video Analysis Scheme. London: International Computers Ltd, 1987.
8.
StilesWB. Manual for the Taxonomy of Verbal Response. Chapel Hill, NC: Institute for Research in Social Science, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 1978.
9.
RoterD. Which facets of communication have strong effects upon outcome—A meta-analysis. In: StewartMRoterD, eds. Communicating with Medical Patients. London: Sage, 1989.
10.
MehrabianA. Methods and designs; some referents and measures of nonverbal behaviour. Behaviour, Research Methods and Instrumentation1969;1:203–7.
NollerP. Gaze in married couples. Journal of Nonverbal Behaviour1980;5(2):115–29.
14.
BallCJScottNMcLarenPMWatsonJP. Preliminary evaluation of a low cost videoconferencing system for remote cognitive testing of adult psychiatric patients. British Journal of Clinical Psychology1993;32:303–7.
15.
McLarenPMBallCJWatsonJP. Assessment for psychotherapy by interactive television suitable for transmission through telephone links. Psychiatric Bulletin1993;17:104–5.
16.
McLarenPMBallCJSummerfieldABLipsedgeMSWatsonJP. Preliminary evaluation of a low cost videoconferencing system for teaching in clinical psychiatry. Medical Teacher1992;14:43–7.
17.
McLarenPMBallCJ. A pilot study of the use of the telephone in an acute psychiatric service. Psychiatric Bulletin1992;16:531–2.
