The COVID-19 public health emergency led to an unprecedented rapid increase in telehealth use, but the role of telehealth in reducing disparities in access to care has been questioned. The objective of this study was to conduct a systematic review to summarize the available evidence on how telehealth during the COVID-19 pandemic was associated with telehealth utilization for minority groups and its role in health disparities.
Methods
We conducted a systematic review focused on health equity and access to care by searching for interventional and observational studies using the following four search domains: telehealth, COVID-19, health equity, and access to care. We searched PubMed, Embase, Cochrane CENTRAL, CINAHL, telehealth.hhs.gov, and the Rural Health Research Gateway, and included any study that reported quantitative results with a control group.
Results
Our initial search yielded 1970 studies, and we included 48 in our final review. The most common dimensions of health equity studied were race/ethnicity, rurality, insurance status, language, and socioeconomic status, and the telehealth applications studied were diverse. Included studies had a moderate risk of bias. In aggregate, most studies reported increased telehealth use during the pandemic, with the greatest increase in non-minority populations, including White, younger, English-speaking people from urban areas.
Discussion
We found that despite rapid adoption and increased telehealth use during the public health emergency, telehealth did not reduce existing disparities in access to care. We recommend that future work measuring the impact of telehealth focus on equity so that features of telehealth innovation can reduce disparities in health outcomes.
DoraiswamySAbrahamAMamtaniR, et al.Use of telehealth during the COVID-19 pandemic: scoping review. J Med Internet Res2020; 22: e24087.
2.
KooninLMHootsBTsangCA, et al.Trends in the use of telehealth during the emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic – United States, January-March 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep2020; 69: 1595–1599.
3.
KheraNKnoedlerMMeierSK, et al.Payment and coverage parity for virtual care and in-person care: How do we get there?Telemed Rep2023; 4: 100–108.
SamsonLWTaraziWTurriniG, et al.Medicare beneficiaries’ use of telehealth in 2020: trends by beneficiary characteristics and location. Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, Washington, DC, 2021.
10.
HatefEWilsonRFHannumSM, et al.Use of telehealth during the COVID-19 era. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US), 2023.
11.
CzeislerMMarynakKClarkeKEN, et al.Delay or avoidance of medical care because of COVID-19-related concerns - United States, June 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep2020; 69: 1250–1257.
12.
MageshSJohnDLiWT, et al.Disparities in COVID-19 outcomes by race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open2021; 4: e2134147–e2134147.
GarlingAChoSVogtC. Reducing health inequities through telehealth. US Pharm: Pharma Resour Clin Excellence2022; 47: 28–32.
15.
LauJKnudsenJ. Reducing disparities in telemedicine: an equity-focused, public health approach. Health Aff (Millwood)2022; 41: 647–650.
16.
Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation: Office of Healthy Policy. Medicare beneficiaries’ use of telehealth in 2020: trends by beneficiary characteristics and location.
17.
AlonsoWCrouchEThorellN. National Rural Health Association policy paper: telehealth in rural America. 2019.
18.
KarimiMLeeECCoutureSJ, et al.National survey trends in telehealth use in 2021: disparities in utilization and audio vs. video services. Research report no. HP-2022-04, 2022.
19.
LeeECGrigorescuVEnogieruI, et al.Updated national survey trends in telehealth utilization and modality (2021-2022). Research report no. HP-2023-09. Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, US Department of Health and Human Services, Washington DC, 2023.
20.
VakkalankaJPGadagKLavinL, et al.Telehealth use and health equity for mental health and substance use disorder during the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic review. Telemed J E Health2024. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1089/tmj.2023.0588.
21.
TierneyAAMosquedaMCesenaG, et al.Telemedicine implementation for safety net populations: a systematic review. Telemed e-Health2024; 30: 622–641.
22.
ZouCHarvardAQianJ, et al.A systematic review of digital health technologies for the care of older adults during COVID-19 pandemic. Digit Health2023; 9: 20552076231191050.
23.
CunhaASPedroARCordeiroJV. Facilitators of and barriers to accessing hospital medical specialty telemedicine consultations during the COVID-19 pandemic: systematic review. J Med Internet Res2023; 25: e44188.
24.
JacksonTNSreedharaMBosticM, et al.Telehealth use to address cardiovascular disease and hypertension in the United States: a systematic review and meta-analysis, 2011-2021. Telemed Rep2023; 4: 67–86.
25.
BediGVyasKSChungMT, et al.Telemedicine in international cleft care: a systematic review. Cleft Palate Craniofac J2021; 58: 1547–1555.
26.
MistrySKShawMRaffanF, et al.Inequity in access and delivery of virtual care interventions: a scoping review. Int J Environ Res Public Health2022; 19: 9411.
27.
ChoukouMASanchez-RamirezDCPolM, et al.COVID-19 infodemic and digital health literacy in vulnerable populations: a scoping review. Digit Health2022; 8: 20552076221076927.
28.
ColburnDA. The impact of telehealth expansion on health care utilization, access, and outcomes during the pandemic: a systematic review. Telemed e-Health2023. EPub ahead of print. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1089/tmj.2023.0440.
29.
TruongMYeganehLCookO, et al.Using telehealth consultations for healthcare provision to patients from non-Indigenous racial/ethnic minorities: a systematic review. J Am Med Inform Assoc2022; 29: 970–982.
DownsSHBlackN. The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions. J Epidemiol Community Health1998; 52: 377–384.
35.
AckroydSKimJLeeN. Telemedicine utilization in gynecologic cancers: understanding the digital divide. Gynecol Oncol2021; 162: S286–S287.
36.
AnnapragadaAVMeshramPJenkinsSG, et al.Age and racial disparities in telemedicine utilization in an academic orthopedic surgery department. Telemed J E Health2022; 28: 970–975.
37.
BayudanAKamalFDaiSC, et al.Telemedicine and healthcare access in ambulatory gastroenterology visits during the COVID-19 pandemic: a single-center retrospective analysis. Gastroenterology2022; 162: S-475–S-476.
38.
BharadwajMLabbanMLangbeinB, et al.Patterns of tele-health usage after the COVID-19 pandemic among surgical specialties and urology. J Urol2022; 207: e221.
39.
BoseSDunCZhangGQ, et al.Medicare beneficiaries in disadvantaged neighborhoods increased telemedicine use during the COVID-19 pandemic. Health Aff (Millwood)2022; 41: 635–642.
40.
CahanEMMaturiJBaileyP, et al.The impact of telehealth adoption during COVID-19 pandemic on patterns of pediatric subspecialty care utilization. Acad Pediatr2022; 22: 1375–1383.
41.
CantorJHMcBainRKPeraMF, et al.Who is (and is not) receiving telemedicine care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Am J Prev Med2021; 61: 434–438.
42.
CaoYChenDLiuY, et al.Academyhealth Annual Research Meeting (ARM): a selection of abstracts accepted for oral presentation, 2021. Health Serv Res2021; 56: 5–91.
43.
ChakawaABelzerLTPerez-CrawfordT, et al.COVID-19, telehealth, and pediatric integrated primary care: disparities in service use. J Pediatr Psychol2021; 46: 1063–1075.
44.
ConnollySLStolzmannKLHeyworthL, et al.Patient and provider predictors of telemental health use prior to and during the COVID-19 pandemic within the Department of Veterans Affairs. Am Psychol2022; 77: 249–261.
45.
CousinsMMVan TilMSteppeE, et al.Age, race, insurance type, and digital divide index are associated with video visit completion for patients seen for oncologic care in a large hospital system during the COVID-19 pandemic. PLoS One2022; 17: e0277617.
46.
DattaPEilandLSamsonK, et al.Telemedicine and health access inequalities during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Glob Health2022; 12: 05051.
47.
FischerSHPredmoreZRothE, et al.Use of and willingness to use video telehealth through the COVID-19 pandemic. Health Aff2022; 41: 1645–1651.
48.
FriedmanEEDevlinSAGilsonSF, et al.Age and racial disparities in telehealth use among people with HIV during the COVID-19 pandemic. AIDS Behav2022; 26: 2686–2691.
49.
GeorgeMDDanilaMIWatrousD, et al.Disruptions in rheumatology care and the rise of telehealth in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in a community practice-based network. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken)2021; 73: 1153–1161.
50.
GrinbergASFentonBTWangK, et al.Telehealth perceptions and utilization for the delivery of headache care before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: a mixed-methods study. Headache2022; 62: 613–623.
51.
HoganJAmspokerABWalderA, et al.Differential impact of COVID-19 on the use of tele-mental health among veterans living in urban or rural areas. Psychiatr Serv2022; 73: 1393–1396.
52.
JaffeDHLeeLHuynhS, et al.Health inequalities in the use of telehealth in the United States in the lens of COVID-19. Popul Health Manag2020; 23: 368–377.
53.
JallowMEwuluAAjiloreP, et al.Analyzing disparities in access to teledermatology compared with dermatology clinic visits before, during, and after COVID-19 quarantine. Clin Dermatol2023; 41: 207–214.
54.
JudyWMougeyEVenkateshR, et al.Pediatric gastroenterology telehealth during the COVID-19 public health emergency: access to care, socioeconomic disparities and geo-mapping. JPGN2021; 73: S362–S363.
55.
KhoslaKSureshSMuellerA, et al.Elimination of racial disparities in postpartum hypertension follow-up after incorporation of telehealth into a quality bundle. Am J of Obstet Gynecology MFM2022; 4: 100580.
56.
LarsonAEZahndWEDavisMM, et al.Before and during pandemic telemedicine use: an analysis of rural and urban safety-net clinics. Am J Prev Med2022; 63: 1031–1036.
57.
LattimoreCMKaneWJFlemingMA2nd, et al.Disparities in telemedicine utilization among surgical patients during COVID-19. PLoS One2021; 16: e0258452..
58.
LeeMSGuoLNWangW, et al.Differences in utilization of nonvideo telemedicine visits for dermatologic concerns in underserved populations during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Telemed Telecare2021; 27: 827–834.
59.
LeungLBYooCChuK. Widening rural-urban divide in telehealth use during the COVID-19 pandemic: a national observational study of primary care delivery in the veterans’ health administration. J Gen Intern Med2022; 37: S346–S347.
60.
LupezELBaylyJXuanZ, et al.Primary care and telemedicine utilization in patients with type 2 diabetes at a safety-net hospital before and after onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. J Gen Intern Med2022; 37: S160–S161.
61.
MuellerBRLawrenceSBennE, et al.Disparities in telehealth utilization in patients with pain during COVID-19. Pain Rep2022; 7: e1001.
62.
PatelSYMehrotraAHuskampHA, et al.Variation in telemedicine use and outpatient care during the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States. Health Aff (Millwood)2021; 40: 349–358.
63.
PritchardAENorthrupRAPetersonR, et al.Can we expand the pool of youth who receive telehealth assessments for ADHD? Covariates of service utilization. J Atten Disord2023; 27: 159–168.
64.
PritchettJBorahBJDholakiaR, et al.Patient- and provider-level factors associated with telehealth utilization across a multisite, multiregional cancer practice. J Clin Oncol2022; 40: 1512–1512.
65.
QianASSchiaffinoMKNalawadeV, et al.Disparities in telemedicine during COVID-19. Cancer Med2022; 11: 1192–1201.
66.
QianLSyLSHongV, et al.Disparities in outpatient and telehealth visits during the COVID-19 pandemic in a large integrated health care organization: retrospective cohort study. J Med Internet Res2021; 23: e29959.
67.
RodriguezNJOkwaraNCShenL, et al.Telemedicine in the COVID-19 era: impact on disparities in access to ambulatory care. Gastroenterology2021; 160: S-29.
68.
RubertoRASchweppeEAAhmedR, et al.Disparities in telemedicine utilization during COVID-19 pandemic analysis of demographic data from a large academic orthopaedic practice. JBJS Open Access2022; 7. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2106/JBJS.OA.21.00116.
69.
SachsJWGravenPGoldJA, et al.Disparities in telephone and video telehealth engagement during the COVID-19 pandemic. JAMIA Open2021; 4. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jamiaopen/ooab056.
70.
SanakaHGargRPatelV, et al.Impact of COVID-19 pandemic and social determinants of health on utilization of telehealth services. Gastroenterology2022; 162: S-472–S-473.
71.
SenBPSharmaPBrisendineA, et al.Disparities in telehealth utilization in a population of publicly insured children during the COVID-19 pandemic. Popul Health Manag2022; 25: 178–185.
72.
ShehanJNAgarwalPO'Neil DanisD, et al.Effects of COVID-19 on telemedicine practice patterns in outpatient otolaryngology. Am J Otolaryngol2021; 42: 103044.
73.
StevensJPMechanicOMarksonL, et al.Telehealth use by age and race at a single academic medical center during the COVID-19 pandemic: retrospective cohort study. J Med Internet Res2021; 23: e23905.
74.
TewariSCoyneKDWeinermanRS, et al.Racial disparities in presentation to infertility consultations and telehealth use during the COVID-19 pandemic. Fertil Steril2022; 118: e201.
75.
ThomasonJMantillaBBaysA, et al.Socioeconomic characteristics associated with electronic health care utilization in an urban rheumatology clinic during the COVID-19 pandemic. Arthritis Rheumatol2021; 73: 1252–1255.
76.
TildenDRDatyeKAMooreDJ, et al.The rapid transition to telemedicine and its effect on access to care for patients with type 1 diabetes during the COVID-19 pandemic. Diabetes Care2021; 44: 1447–1450.
77.
TisdaleRLFergusonJMVan CampenJ, et al.Disparities in virtual cardiology visits among veterans’ health administration patients during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Gen Intern Med2021; 36: S168.
78.
WegermannKWilderJParishA, et al.Black, older, unmarried, and Medicaid patients were less likely to complete hepatology video visits during COVID-19. Hepatology2020; 72: 382A–383A.
79.
WegermannKWilderJMParishA, et al.Racial and socioeconomic disparities in utilization of telehealth in patients with liver disease during COVID-19. Dig Dis Sci2022; 67: 93–99.
80.
WhaleyCMPeraMFCantorJ, et al.Changes in health services use among commercially insured US populations during the COVID-19 pandemic. JAMA Netw Open2020; 3: e2024984–e2024984.
81.
White-WilliamsCLiuXShangD, et al.Use of telehealth among racial and ethnic minority groups in the United States before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. Public Health Rep2023; 138: 149–156.
82.
XuPHudnallMZhaoS, et al.Pandemic-triggered adoption of telehealth in underserved communities: Descriptive study of pre- and postshutdown trends. J Med Internet Res2022; 24: e38602.
83.
CaoYJChenDLiuY, et al.Disparities in the use of in-person and telehealth outpatient visits among medicare beneficiaries in an accountable care organization during COVID-19. Health Serv Res2021; 56: 5.
84.
SanakaHGargRPatelV, et al.Temporal trends and disparities in gastroenterology care use before, during, and after COVID-19 lockdown. J Investig Med2022; 70: 1704–1712.
85.
WegermannKPatelYWilderJ. Health equity and telemedicine in gastroenterology and hepatology. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol2021; 19: 1516–1519.
86.
LeeMSKassamaliBShahN, et al.281 Racial and language disparities in teledermatology visits for acne during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Investig Dermatol2021; 141: S50.
87.
ChangJELaiAYGuptaA, et al.Rapid transition to telehealth and the digital divide: implications for primary care access and equity in a post-COVID era. Milbank Q2021; 99: 340–368.
88.
KuziemskyCHunterIUdayasankaranJG, et al.Telehealth as a means of enabling health equity. Yearb Med Inform2022; 31: 60–66.
89.
Gallegos-RejasVMThomasEEKellyJT, et al.A multi-stakeholder approach is needed to reduce the digital divide and encourage equitable access to telehealth. J Telemed Telecare2022; 29: 73–78.
90.
Gallegos-RejasVMKellyJTSnoswellCL, et al.Does the requirement for an interpreter impact experience with telehealth modalities, acceptability and trust in telehealth? Results from a national survey including people requiring interpreter services. J Telemed Telecare2023; 29: 24S–29S.
91.
SmithACThomasESnoswellCL, et al.Telehealth for global emergencies: implications for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). J Telemed Telecare2020; 26: 309–313.
92.
HillLArtigaSDamicoA. Health coverage by race and ethnicity, 2010-2021. The independent source for health policy and research, polling, and news. 2022.
93.
KimSJPetersonCEWarneckeR, et al.The uneven distribution of medically underserved areas in Chicago. Health Equity2020; 4: 556–564.
94.
GrumbachKHartLGMertzE, et al.Who is caring for the underserved? A comparison of primary care physicians and nonphysician clinicians in California and Washington. Ann of Fam Med2003; 1: 97–104.
95.
BowerKMThorpeRJJrRohdeC, et al.The intersection of neighborhood racial segregation, poverty, and urbanicity and its impact on food store availability in the United States. Prev Med2014; 58: 33–39.
96.
BarajasJM. Biking where Black: connecting transportation planning and infrastructure to disproportionate policing. Transp Res D2021; 99: 103027.
Dalva-BairdNPAlobuiaWMBendavidE, et al.Racial and ethnic inequities in the early distribution of U.S. COVID-19 testing sites and mortality. Eur J Clin Invest2021; 51: e13669.
99.
AlthouseBMBakerCSmitsPD, et al.Racial inequality in COVID-treatment and in-hospital length of stay in the US over time. Front Public Health2022; 10: 1074775.
100.
GottliebERZieglerJMorleyK, et al.Assessment of racial and ethnic differences in oxygen supplementation among patients in the intensive care unit. JAMA Intern Med2022; 182: 849–858.
101.
BressmanEWernerRMChildsC, et al.Association of telemedicine with primary care appointment access after hospital discharge. J Gen Intern Med2022; 37: 2879–2881.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
