Videoconferencing psychotherapy (VCP) delivers treatment to individuals with limited access to face-to-face mental healthcare. VCP's effectiveness has been demonstrated for various disorders and therapeutic interventions. However, there is contradictory evidence regarding the therapeutic alliance in VCP as compared to psychotherapy in person (PIP). This meta-analysis examines whether therapeutic alliance differs by psychotherapy's delivery format, namely VCP versus PIP.
Methods
We searched five databases for trials comparing the therapeutic alliance in VCP and PIP, wherein the therapeutic alliance was rated by either patients or therapists or both. Eighteen publications were included, and the difference between VCP and PIP was assessed. Furthermore, we tested possible moderators of the difference in therapeutic alliance between VCP and PIP by meta-regression, and we assessed the risk of bias of this meta-analysis.
Results
The meta-analysis revealed no statistically significant difference in the therapeutic alliance between VCP and PIP for alliance ratings by patients (SMD = −0.09; 95% CI = −0.26; 0.07) as well as by therapists (SMD = 0.04; 95% CI = −0.17; 0.25). No significant moderators were found.
Discussion
In this meta-analysis, VCP and PIP did not differ with respect to the therapeutic alliance as rated by either patients or therapists. Further research is required into mechanisms driving the therapeutic alliance in VCP and PIP.
BackhausAAghaZMaglioneML, et al.Videoconferencing psychotherapy: A systematic review. Psychol Serv2012 May; 9: 111–131.
2.
SimpsonSReidCL. Therapeutic alliance in videoconferencing psychotherapy: A review. Aust J Rural Health2014 Dec; 22: 280–299.
3.
World Health Organization. The impact of COVID-19 on mental, neurological and substance use services: results of a rapid assessment. [Internet]. 2020 [cited 2020 Nov 26]. Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/335838.
4.
YuenEKHerbertJDFormanEM, et al.Acceptance based behavior therapy for social anxiety disorder through videoconferencing. J Anxiety Disord2013 May; 27: 389–397.
5.
MitchellJECrosbyRDWonderlichSA, et al.A randomized trial comparing the efficacy of cognitive–behavioral therapy for bulimia nervosa delivered via telemedicine versus face-to-face. Behav Res Ther2008 May; 46: 581–592.
6.
MorlandLAMackintoshMARosenCS, et al.Telemedicine versus in-person delivery of cognitive processing therapy for women with posttraumatic stress disorder: A randomized noninferiority trial. Depress Anxiety2015; 32: 811–820.
7.
YuenEKGrosDFPriceM, et al.Randomized controlled trial of home-based telehealth versus in-person prolonged exposure for combat-related PTSD in veterans: Preliminary results. J Clin Psychol2015; 71: 500–512.
8.
BouchardSPaquinBPayeurR, , et al.Delivering cognitive-behavior therapy for panic disorder with agoraphobia in videoconference. Telemed J E Health2004 Mar; 10: 13–25.
9.
HimleJAFischerDJMuroffJR, et al.Videoconferencing-based cognitive-behavioral therapy for obsessive-compulsive disorder. Behav Res Ther2006 Dec 1; 44: 1821–1829.
10.
SimpsonSGuerriniLRochfordS. Telepsychology in a university psychology clinic setting: A pilot project. Aust Psychol2015; 50: 285–291.
11.
ChavooshiBMohammadkhaniPDolatshaheeB. Telemedicine vs in-person delivery of intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy for patients with medically unexplained pain: A 12-month randomized, controlled trial. J Telemed Telecare2017 Jan; 23: 133–141.
12.
ArditoRBRabellinoD. Therapeutic alliance and outcome of psychotherapy: Historical excursus, measurements, and prospects for research. Front Psychol 2011; 2: 270
13.
FlückigerCDel ReACWampoldBE,et al.The alliance in adult psychotherapy: A meta-analytic synthesis. Psychotherapy2018; 55: 316–340.
14.
HorvathAODel ReACFlückigerC,et al.Alliance in individual psychotherapy. Psychotherapy2011; 48: 9–16.
15.
HorvathAOSymondsBD. Relation between working alliance and outcome in psychotherapy: A meta-analysis. J Couns Psychol1991; 38: 139–149.
16.
MartinDJGarskeJPDavisMK. Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: A meta-analytic review. J Consult Clin Psychol2000; 68: 438–450.
17.
BergerT. The therapeutic alliance in internet interventions: A narrative review and suggestions for future research. Psychother Res2017 Sep 3; 27: 511–524.
18.
BordinES. The generalizability of the psychoanalytic concept of the working alliance. Psychotherapy: Theory, ResPract1979; 16: 252–260.
19.
HorvathAOGreenbergLS. Development and validation of the working alliance inventory. J Couns Psychol1989; 36: 223–233.
20.
GlueckaufRLFritzSPEcklund-JohnsonEP,et al.Videoconferencing-based family counseling for rural teenagers with epilepsy: Phase 1 findings. Rehabil Psychol2002 Feb; 47: 49–72.
21.
GreeneCJMorlandLAMacdonaldA,et al.How does tele-mental health affect group therapy process? Secondary analysis of a noninferiority trial. J Consult Clin Psychol2010; 78: 746–750.
22.
ReesCSStoneS. Therapeutic alliance in face-to-face versus videoconferenced psychotherapy. Prof Psychol: Res Pract2005 Dec; 36: 649–653.
23.
GermainVMarchandABouchardS,et al.Assessment of the therapeutic alliance in face-to-face or videoconference treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Networking2010 Feb; 13: 29–35.
24.
WehmannEKöhnenMHärterM,et al.Therapeutic alliance in technology-based interventions for the treatment of depression: Systematic review. J Med Internet Res2020; 22: e17195–e17195.
25.
SimpsonSDeansGBrebnerE. The delivery of a tele-psychology service to shetland. Clin Psychol Psychother2001; 8: 130–135.
26.
SimpsonSBellLKnoxJ,et al.Therapy via videoconferencing: A route to client empowerment?Clin Psychol Psychother2005; 12: 156–165.
27.
WattsSMarchandABouchardS, et al.Telepsychotherapy for generalized anxiety disorder: Impact on the working alliance. J Psychother Integr2020 Jun; 30: 208–225.
28.
NorwoodCMoghaddamNGMalinsS,et al.Working alliance and outcome effectiveness in videoconferencing psychotherapy: A systematic review and noninferiority meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Psychother2018 Nov; 25: 797–808.
ConnollySLMillerCJLindsayJA,et al.A systematic review of providers’ attitudes toward telemental health via videoconferencing. Clin Psychol: Sci Pract2020; 27: e12311.
31.
HorowitzMSA. An exploratory study of therapist perceptions of the differences in therapeutic alliance between videoconference therapy and face-to-face therapy. 74. US: Fielding Graduate University, 2014.
32.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ,et al.Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. J Clin Epidemiol2009 Oct; 62: 1006–1012.
33.
OuzzaniMHammadyHFedorowiczZ,et al.Rayyan—a web and mobile app for systematic reviews. Syst Rev2016 Dec; 5: 210.
ThomasBHCiliskaDDobbinsM,et al.A process for systematically reviewing the literature: Providing the research evidence for public health nursing interventions. Worldviews Evid Based Nurs2004; 1: 176–184.
36.
DöringNBortzJ. Forschungsmethoden und Evaluation in den Sozial- und Humanwissenschaften [Internet]. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2016 [cited 2022 May 13], Available from: http://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-3-642-41089-5.
37.
R Development Core Team. a language and environment for statistical computing: reference index [Internet]. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing; 2010 [cited 2021 Mar 11]. Available from: http://www.polsci.wvu.edu/duval/PS603/Notes/R/fullrefman.pdf
38.
R Studio Team. RStudio: Integrated Development for R [Internet]. Boston, MA, USA: RStudio Inc, 2020. Available from: http://www.rstudio.com/
39.
ViechtbauerW. Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. J Stat Softw2010; 36: 1–48.
40.
BalduzziSRückerGSchwarzerG. How to perform a meta-analysis with R: A practical tutorial. Evid Based Mental Health2019; 22: 153–160.
41.
JelfsARichardsonJTE. The use of digital technologies across the adult life span in distance education. Br J Educ Technol2013; 44: 338–351.
42.
ZickuhrK. Who’s not online and why. Pew Internet Am Life Project2013 Sep. Available from: https://apo.org.au/node/35848
43.
GuyattGHOxmanADVistGE, et al.GRADE: An emerging consensus on rating quality of evidence and strength of recommendations. Br Med J2008 Apr 26; 336: 924–926.
44.
PenskaKMichaelRMesserSC,et al.Therapeutic alliance building during the child psychiatric intake: Does VTC make a difference?Mil Med2012 May; 177: 541–545.
45.
ReeseRJMechamMRVasiljI, , et al.The effects of telepsychology format on empathic accuracy and the therapeutic alliance: An analogue counselling session. Couns Psychother Res2016 Dec; 16: 256–265.
46.
ŞtefanSDavidD. Face-to-face counseling versus high definition holographic projection system efficacy and therapeutic alliance A brief research report. J Cogn Behav Psychother2013 Sep; 13: 299–307.
47.
StevensAVooreP. Pilot study of televideo psychiatric assessments in an underserviced community. Am J Psychiatry 1999; 156: 783–785
48.
ErteltTWCrosbyRDMarinoJM,et al.Therapeutic factors affecting the cognitive behavioral treatment of bulimia nervosa via telemedicine versus face-to-face delivery. Int J Eat Disord2011 Dec; 44: 687–691.
49.
KingVLBroonerRKPeirceJM,et al.A randomized trial of web-based videoconferencing for substance abuse counseling. J Subst Abuse Treat2014 Jan; 46: 36–42.
50.
LevyFLeboucherPRautureauG,et al.E-virtual reality exposure therapy in acrophobia: A pilot study. J Telemed Telecare2016 Jun; 22: 215–220.
51.
StubbingsDRReesCSRobertsLD,et al.Comparing in-person to videoconference-based cognitive behavioral therapy for mood and anxiety disorders: Randomized controlled trial. J Med Internet Res2013; 15: 169–184.
52.
WylerHLiebrenzMAjdacic-GrossV, et al.Treatment provision for adults with ADHD during the COVID-19 pandemic: An exploratory study on patient and therapist experience with on-site sessions using face masks vs. telepsychiatric sessions. BMC Psychiatry2021 Dec; 21: 237.
53.
FarabeeDCalhounSVelizR. An experimental comparison of telepsychiatry and conventional psychiatry for parolees. Psychiatr Serv2016; 67: 562–565.
54.
HungerbuehlerIValiengoLLochAA,et al.Home-based psychiatric outpatient care through videoconferencing for depression: A randomized controlled follow-up trial. JMIR Ment Health2016; 3: e36.
55.
AllardMBouchardSMarchandA, L’efficacité de la psychothérapie pour le trouble panique en vidéoconférence: Réplication, et alliance thérapeutique = the efficacy of psychotherapy for panic disorders in videoconference: Replication and therapeutic alliance. Rev Qué Psychol2007; 28: 43–64.
56.
BouchardSAllardMRobillardG, et al.Videoconferencing psychotherapy for panic disorder and agoraphobia: Outcome and treatment processes from a non-randomized non-inferiority trial. Front Psychol2020; 11: 2164.
57.
NetterALHesslerJBPfeufferS, et al.Usability and naturalness of videoconference-based exposure and response prevention for obsessive–compulsive disorder at the patients’ homes: A pilot study. J Cogn Psychother2018 Oct; 32: 303–314.
58.
MorganRDPatrickARMagalettaPR. Does the use of telemental health alter the treatment experience? Inmates’ perceptions of telemental health versus face-to-face treatment modalities. J Consult Clin Psychol2008 Feb; 76: 158–162.
59.
BouchardSDugasMJBellevilleG, et al.A multisite non-inferiority randomized controlled trial of the efficacy of cognitive-behavior therapy for generalized anxiety disorder delivered by videoconference. JCM2022 Oct 7; 11: 5924.
60.
LopezASchwenkSSchneckCD,et al.Technology-based mental health treatment and the impact on the therapeutic alliance. Curr Psychiatry Rep2019 Jul 8; 21: 76.
61.
CataldoFChangSMendozaA,et al.A perspective on client-psychologist relationships in videoconferencing psychotherapy: Literature review. JMIR Ment Health2021 Feb 19; 8: e19004.
62.
TaylorT. Video conferencing us talking face-to-face: Is video suitable for supportive dialogue?Int J Ther Rehabil2011; 18: 392–402.
63.
ThorpSRFidlerJMorenoL,et al.Lessons learned from studies of psychotherapy for posttraumatic stress disorder via video teleconferencing. Psychol Serv2012; 9: 197–199.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
