The conceptualisation of satisfaction and quality in tourism consumption has
always been the object of an unresolved debate questioning whether satisfaction
should be evaluated upon the achievement of psychological/emotional needs or on
its utilitarian/quality components. The paper details a study which combines
both these approaches with the aim of clarifying how an understanding of
tourists’ motivations can provide a better appreciation of their
quality evaluations. Results show that when subdividing consumers along their
motivational profiles, a clearer evaluation of quality perception is achieved:
each segment displays different quality perceptions of the service offered and
the relative importance attached to various quality dimensions also differs. The
study concludes that an understanding of quality evaluations can be greatly
enhanced by segmenting consumers rather than assuming that all consumers have
similar quality perceptions and prioritisation. It also confirms that
consumers’ quality perceptions are influenced by both utilitarian and
psychological components, thereby justifying the necessity for a
multidisciplinary approach to tourist quality conceptualisation and measurement.
Bowen, D.
and
Clarke, J.
(2002)
‘Reflections on tourist satisfaction research: Past, present and future’
, Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 8, No.
4, pp.
297-308
.
2.
Baker, D. A.
and
Crompton, J. L.
(2000)
‘Quality, satisfaction and behavioral intentions’
, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 27, No.
3, pp.
785-804
.
3.
Cronin, J. J.
and
Taylor, S. A.
(1992)
‘Measuring service quality: A re-examination and extension’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 56, July,
pp.
55-68
.
4.
Hunt, H. K.
(1977) ‘Conceptualisation and Measurement of
Consumer Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction’,
Marketing Science Institute, Cambridge, MA
.
5.
Oliver, R. L.
(1980)
‘A cognitive model of the antecedents and consequences of
customer satisfaction’
, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 17,
November, pp.
460-469
.
6.
Parasuraman A.
,
Zeithaml, V. A.
and
Berry, L.
(1988)
‘SERVQUAL: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer
perceptions of service quality’
, Journal of Retailing, Vol. 64, No. 1,
pp.
12-37
.
7.
Parasuraman, A.
,
Zeithaml, V. A.
and
Berry, L.
(1991)
‘Refinement and reassessment of the SERVQUAL scale’
, Journal of Retailing, Vol. 67, No. 4,
pp.
420-449
.
8.
Parasuraman, A.
,
Zeithaml, V. A.
and
Berry, L.
(1994)
‘Reassessment of expectations as a comparison standard in
measuring service quality: Implications for future research’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 58, January,
pp.
111-124
.
9.
Holbrook, M. B.
and
Hirschman, E. C.
(1982)
‘The experiential aspects of consumption: Consumer fantasies,
feelings, and fun’
, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 9,
September, pp.
132-140
.
10.
Holbrook, M. B.
and
Hirschman, E. C.
(1982)
‘Hedonic consumption: Emerging concepts, methods and proposition’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 46, Summer,
pp.
92-101
.
11.
Oliver, R. L.
(1981)
‘Measurement and evaluation of satisfaction processes in retail settings’
, Journal of Retailing, Vol. 57, Fall,
pp.
25-48
.
12.
Westbrook, R. A.
(1987)
‘Product/consumption-based affective responses and post-purchase processes’
, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 24,
August, pp.
258-270
.
13.
Beard, J. G.
and
Ragheb, M. G.
(1980)
‘Measuring leisure satisfaction’
, Journal of Leisure Research, Vol. 12, No.
1, pp.
20-33
.
14.
Lounsbury, J. W.
and
Hoopes, L. L.
(1985)
‘An investigation of the factors associated with vacation satisfaction’
, Journal of Leisure Research, Vol. 17, No.
1, pp.
1-13
.
15.
Manning, R. E.
(1986) ‘Studies in Outdoor
Recreation’,
Oregon State University Press, Corvallis
.
16.
Otto, J. E.
and
Ritchie, J. R. B.
(1996)
‘The service experience in tourism’
, Tourism Management, Vol. 17, No. 3, pp.
165-174
.
17.
Crompton, J. L.
(1979)
‘Motivations for pleasure vacation’
, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 6, No.
4, pp.
408-424
.
18.
Mackay, K. J.
and
Crompton, J. L.
(1990)
‘Measuring the quality of recreation services’
, Journal of Park and Recreation Administration, Vol.
8, No. 3, pp.
47-56
.
19.
Knutson, B.
,
Stevens, P.
,
Wullaert, C.
and
Patton, M.
(1991)
‘LODGSERV: A service quality index for the lodging industry’
, Hospitality Research Journal, Vol. 14, No.
7, pp.
277-284
.
20.
Ryan, C.
and
Cliff, A.
(1997)
‘Do travel agencies measure up to customer expectations? An
empirical investigation of travel agencies’ service quality as
measured by SERVQUAL’
, Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, Vol. 6,
No. 2, pp.
1-31
.
21.
Kozak, M.
and
Rimmington, M.
(2000)
‘Tourist satisfaction with Mallorca, Spain as an off-season
holiday destination’
, Journal of Travel Research, Vol. 38,
February, pp.
260-269
.
22.
Tribe, J.
and
Snaith, T.
(1998)
‘From SERVQUAL to HOLSTAT: Holiday satisfaction in Varadero, Cuba’
, Tourism Management, Vol. 19, No. 1, pp.
25-34
.
23.
Otto and Ritchie, ref. 16 above.
24.
Ryan, C.
(2000) ‘From the psychometrics of SERVQUAL to
sex: Measurements of tourist satisfaction’, in
Pizam, A.
and
Mansfeld, Y.
(eds) ‘Consumer Behavior in Travel and
Tourism’,
Haworth Hospitality Press, Binghamton
, pp. 267-286.
25.
Childress, R. D.
and
Crompton, J. L.
(1997)
‘A comparison of alternative direct and discrepancy approaches to
measuring quality of performance at a festival’
, Journal of Travel Research, Vol. 36, No.
2, pp.
43-57
.
26.
Moutinho, L.
(1987)
‘Consumer behaviour in tourism’
, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 21, No.
10, pp.
3-44
.
27.
Urry, J.
(1991)
‘The sociology of tourism’
, Progress in Tourism Recreation and Hospitality Management,
Vol. 3, pp.
48-57
.
28.
Baker and Crompton, ref. 2 above.
29.
Manning, ref. 15 above.
30.
Thrane, C.
(1997)
‘Values as segmentation criteria in tourism research: The
Norwegian Monitor approach’
, Tourism Management, Vol. 18, No. 2, pp.
111-113
.
31.
Pizam, A.
and
Calantone, R.
(1987)
‘Beyond psychographics — Values as determinants of
tourist behavior’
, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.
6, No. 3, pp.
177-181
.
32.
Muller, T. E.
(1991)
‘Using personal values to define segments in an international
tourism market’
, International Marketing Review, Vol. 8, No.
1, pp.
57-70
.
33.
Knopf, R. C.
and
Barnes, J. D.
(1980) ‘Determinants of satisfaction with a
tourism resource: A case study of visitors to Gettysburg national military
park’, in
Hawkins, D.
,
Shafer, E.
and
Rovelstad, J.
(eds) ‘Tourism Marketing and Management
Issues’,
George Washington University, Washington, DC
, pp. 217-237.
34.
Pizam, A.
and
Milman, A.
(1993)
‘Predicting satisfaction among the first time visitors to a
destination by using the expectancy disconfirmation theory’
, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.
12, No. 2, pp.
197-209
.
35.
McCool, S. F.
and
Reilly, M.
(1993)
‘Benefit segmentation analysis of state park visitor setting
preferences and behavior’
, Journal of Park and Recreation Administration, Vol.
11, No. 4, pp.
1-14
.
36.
Luk, S. T. K.
,
De Leon, C.
,
Foo-Weng, L.
and
Esther, L.
(1993)
‘Value segmentation of tourists’ expectations of
service quality’
, Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, Vol. 2,
No. 4, pp.
23-37
.
37.
Naylor, G.
and
Kleisser, S. B.
(2002)
‘Exploring the differences in perceptions of satisfaction across
lifestyle segments’
, Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 8, No.
4, pp.
343-351
.
38.
Gutman, J.
(1982)
‘A means-end chain model based on consumer categorization processes’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 46, Spring,
pp.
60-72
.
39.
Rokeach, M.
(1973) ‘The Nature of Human
Values’,
Free Press, New York
.
40.
Gutman, ref. 38 above.
41.
Vinson, D. E.
,
Lamont, J. E.
and
Lamont, L. M.
(1977)
‘The role of personal values in marketing and consumer behavior’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 41, April,
pp.
44-50
.
42.
Peter, J. P.
and
Olson, J. C.
(1987) ‘Consumer Behaviour: Marketing Strategy
Perspectives’,
Irwin, Homewood, IL
.
43.
Lai, A. W.
(1993)
‘Consumer values, product benefits and customer value: A
consumption behavior approach’
, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 22, pp.
381-389
.
44.
Westbrook, R. A.
and
Reilly, M. D.
(1983) ‘Value-percept disparity: An alternative
to the disconfirmation of expectations theory of consumer
satisfaction’, in
Bagozzi, R. P.
and
Tybout, A.
(eds) ‘Advances in Consumer Research’, Vol.
10,
Association for Consumer Research, Ann Arbor, MI
.
45.
Peter and Olson, ref. 42 above.
46.
Spreng, R. A.
and
Olshavsky, R. W.
(1993)
‘A desires congruency model of consumer satisfaction’
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol.
21, No. 3, pp.
169-177
.
47.
Spreng, R. A.
,
Mackenzie, S. B.
and
Olshavsky, R. W.
(1996)
‘A reexamination of the determinants of consumer satisfaction’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 60, July,
pp.
15-32
.
48.
Haley, R. I.
(1968)
‘Benefit segmentation: A decision orientated research tool’
, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 32, July,
pp.
30-35
.
49.
Frochot, I.
and
Hughes, H.
(2000)
‘HISTOQUAL: The development of a historic houses assessment scale’
, Tourism Management, Vol. 21, No. 2, pp.
157-167
.
50.
Baker and Crompton, ref. 2 above.
51.
Cronin and Taylor, ref. 3 above.
52.
Armstrong, R. W.
,
Mok, C.
,
Go, F. M.
and
Chan, F. M.
(1997)
‘The importance of cross-cultural expectations in the measurement
of service quality perceptions in the hotel industry’
, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Vol.
16, No. 2, pp.
181-190
.
53.
Crompton, J. L.
and
Love, L.
(1995)
‘The predictive validity of alternative approaches to evaluating
the quality of a festival’
, Journal of Travel Research, Vol. 34, No.
3, pp.
11-24
.
54.
Dorfman, P. W.
(1979)
‘Measurement and meaning of recreation satisfaction’
, Environment and Behaviour, Vol. 11, No.
4, pp.
483-510
.
55.
Suh, S. H.
,
Lee, Y. H.
,
Park, Y.
and
Shin, G. C.
(1997)
‘The impact of consumer involvement on the consumers’
perception of service quality — Focusing on the Korean hotel industry’
, Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, Vol. 6,
No. 2, pp.
33-52
.
56.
Norusis, M. J.
and
SPSS Inc.
(1994) ‘SPSS Advanced Statistics
6.1’,
SPSS Inc., Chicago
.
57.
Klockars, A. J.
and
Sax, G.
(1986) ‘Multiple Comparisons’,
Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences Series,
Sage, London
.
58.
Norusis, ref. 56 above.
59.
Cramer, D.
(1997) ‘Basic Statistics for Social
Research’,
Routledge, London
