Abstract
This ‘roundup’ review of evaluation blogs, podcasts and webinars covers the second half of 2024. The roundup is organised around key trends that emerged throughout the second half of the year: (1) multi-perspectival storytelling, (2) sustainability amid the polycrisis and (3) the promise and potential pitfalls of feminist evaluation. It then discusses two meta-trends related to the challenges of drawing evaluative boundaries and seeking parsimonious explanations. These cut across the trends mentioned in the three roundups so far. The article ends with a brief reflection on some potentially promising initiatives in the evaluation field to addressing some of the bigger challenges of the day.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Apgar
M
Aston
T
Snijder
M
, et al . (2024 ) Raising the bar: Improving how to assess evidence quality in evaluating systems-change efforts . Foundation Review 16 : 100–13.
2.
Bamberger
M
Podems
D
(2002 ) Feminist evaluation in the international development context . New Directions for Evaluation 96 : 83 –96 .
3.
Bernabè
S
(2024 ) What role should environmental considerations play in evaluation? Available at: https://ieg.worldbankgroup.org/blog/what-role-should-environmental-considerations-play-evaluation
4.
Bremner
L
Lee
L
(2023 ) Knowing place through story . Available at: https://www.betterevaluation.org/blog/knowing-place-through-story (accessed 29 July 2024 ).
5.
Broome
E
Burrows
L
Chadborn
N
, et al . (2024 ) Realist interviews with people with dementia . Available at: https://raid-er.com/blogs/ (accessed 22 November 2024 ).
6.
Brown
AM
(2024 ) How to run gender-inclusive focus groups . Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-run-gender-inclusive-focus-group-discussions-tips-brown–aunae/?trackingId=%2F0bAlRDqRgieSmSjF2kVHA%3D%3D (accessed 26 November 2024 ).
7.
Brown
ME
Dueñas
AN
(2020 ) A medical science educator’s guide to selecting a research paradigm: Building a basis for better research . Medical Science Educator 30 (1 ): 545–53.
8.
Bustelo
M
(2003 ) Evaluation of gender mainstreaming: Ideas from a meta-evaluation study1 . Evaluation 9 (4 ): 383 –403 .
9.Commonwealth Scholarships (2024 ) Development in Action webinar series: Using feminist evaluation to shift power dynamics in international cooperation initiatives . Available at: https://cscuk.fcdo.gov.uk/development-in-action-webinar-series-using-feminist-evaluation-to-shift-power-dynamics-in-international-cooperation-initiatives/ (accessed 13 January 2025 ).
10.
Criado-Perez
C
(2019 ) Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men . New York : Harry N. Abrams .
11.
de Nys
E
(2024 ) Accelerating climate impact for forested landscapes: 3 lessons from independent evaluations . Available at: https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/climatechange/accelerating-climate-impact-for-forested-landscapes—3-lessons- (accessed 20 August 2024 ).
12.
Denzin
N
(1970 ) The Research Act in Sociology . London : Butterworth & Co .
13.
Denzin
N
(2006 ) Sociological Methods: A Sourcebook . Piscataway, NJ : Aldine Transaction .
14.
Espinosa
J
(2013 ) Moving towards gender-sensitive evaluation? Practices and challenges in international-development evaluation . Evaluation 19 (2 ): 171–82.
15.European Evaluation Society (2023 ) Debate recording: Patton vs Jackson on systems concepts in evaluation . Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnyfpC8E4O8 (accessed 29 July 2024 ).
16.
Gates
E
Teasdale
R
Shim
C
, et al . (2024 ) Whose and what values? Advancing and illustrating explicit specification of evaluative criteria in education . Studies in Educational Evaluation 81 : 1 –11 .
17.Global Evaluation Initiative (2024 a) Evaluation and gender equality: Why we need more feminist evaluations . Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIj84WqueDE (accessed 25 November 2024 ).
18.Global Evaluation Initiative (2024 b) Leveraging evaluations for sustainable development: Opportunities, challenges and a way forward . Available at: https://www.globalevaluationinitiative.org/podcast/leveraging-evaluations-sustainable-development-opportunities-challenges-and-way-forward (accessed 20 August 2024 ).
19.Global Evaluation Initiative (2024 c) The gender lens: A necessary shift in perspective for development and evaluation . Available at: https://www.globalevaluationinitiative.org/podcast/gender-lens-necessary-shift-perspective-development-and-evaluation (accessed 25 November 2024 ).
20.Global Evaluation Initiative (2024 d) Webinar: Decolonising national evaluation systems in Africa . Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d48aK1jlJTo&list=WL&index=122 (accessed 28 December 2024 ).
21.
Hartford
T
(2024 ) ‘Known unknowns’, or how to plug the gaps in public research . Financial Times , 28 November . Available at: https://www.ft.com/content/97b40d39-003f-454f-9b0f-0187339f6adb (accessed 26 November 2024 ).
22.Inclusive Rigour Co-Lab (2024 ) Rethinking rigour: Shifting conversations on epistemologies, power, and participation . Available at: https://www.participatorymethods.org/2024/11/25/rethinking-rigour-shifting-conversations-on-epistemologies-power-and-participation/ (accessed 28 November 2024 ).
23.Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2023 ) Summary for policymakers . In: Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II, and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team,
Lee
H
Romeo
J
(eds)]. Geneva : IPPC , 1 –34 .
24.
Kohlweg
K
Novakova
P
(2021 ) Time is up: Let’s increase efforts to mainstream gender in evaluations! Available at: https://europeanevaluation.org/2021/03/08/time-is-up-lets-increase-efforts-to-mainstream-gender-in-evaluations/ (accessed 26 November 2024 ).
25.
Lehrner
K
Novakova
P
(2024 ) Breaking boundaries: The beginning of a conversation on the intersections between Gender-Transformative Evaluation , Decolonisation, and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI). Intrigued? Then join the conversation! Available at: https://europeanevaluation.org/2024/03/11/breaking-boundaries-the-beginning-of-a-conversation-on-the-intersections-between-gender-transformative-evaluation-decolonisation-and-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-dei-intrigued-then-join-the/ (accessed 26 November 2024 ).
26.
Lincoln
Y
Guba
E
(1989 ) Fourth Generation Evaluation . Beverly Hills, CA : Sage .
27.
Macfarlan
A
(2022 ) Footprint evaluation initiative: Incorporating environmental sustainability into all evaluations . Global Evaluation Initiative . Available at: https://www.globalevaluationinitiative.org/blog/footprint-evaluation-initiative-incorporating-environmental-sustainability-all-evaluations
28.
Macfarlan
A
(2023 ) Knowing the place: Key methods and processes for evaluator engagement in environmental sustainability evaluations . Available at: https://www.betterevaluation.org/blog/knowing-place-key-methods-processes-for-evaluator-engagement-environmental-sustainability (accessed 20 August 2024 ).
29.
Mertens
D
(2005 ) Feminism . In:
Mathison
S
(ed.) Encyclopedia of Evaluation . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage , 154 .
30.
Montrosse-Moorhead
B
Bitar
K
(2024 ) Amending the architectural blueprints for evaluation . In:
Wingate
LA
Boyce
A
Becho
LW
, et al . (eds) Core Concepts in Evaluation: Contemporary Commentary on Classic Writings . Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage , 41–60.
31.
Nanthikesan
S
(2024 ) Evaluating sustainable pathways to climate-resilient agriculture: Recent experiences from an IFAD evaluation . Available at: https://ioe.ifad.org/en/w/evaluating-sustainable-pathways-to-climate-resilient-agriculture-recent-experiences-from-an-ifad-evaluation (accessed 20 August 2024 ).
32.
Patton
MQ
(2019 ) Blue Marble Evaluation: Premises and Principles . New York : Guilford Press .
33.
Patton
MQ
(2024 ) Evaluation earth day declaration 2024 . Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHJ_pbY-e60&list=WL&index=81 (accessed 20 August 2024 ).
34.
Pereverza
K
(2024 ) Review of Current System & Portfolio Practices in the Development Sector: Organizational Perspectives and Collaborative Experiments . San Francisco, CA : Medium . Available at: https://medium.com/@undp.innovation/review-of-current-system-portfolio-practices-in-the-development-sector-organizational-236088b699d9 (accessed 13 January 2025 ).
35.
Podems
D
(2010 ) Feminist evaluation and gender approaches: There’s a difference? Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evaluation 6 (14 ): 1 –17 .
36.
Podems
D
(2023 ) Behind the Scenes of a Feminist Principles Evaluation: CGIAR’s Gender Platform . Montpellier : CGIAR . Available at: https://iaes.cgiar.org/evaluation/news/behind-scenes-feminist-principles-evaluation-cgiars-gender-platform (accessed 13 January 2025 ).
37.
Pritchett
L
(2019 ) A review essay – The politics and governance of basic education: A tale of two South African provinces . Available at: https://riseprogramme.org/publications/book-review-politics-governance-basic-education-south-african-provinces.html (accessed 26 November 2024 ).
38.
Rogers
P
(2023 ) Risky Behaviour: Three Predictable Problems with the Australian Center for Evaluation . San Francisco, CA : Medium . Available at: https://medium.com/@patriciarogers_5608/risky-behaviour-three-predictable-problems-with-the-australian-centre-for-evaluation-e952622f52cc (accessed 17 November 2023 ).
39.
Rowe
A
(2023 ) Knowing the Place . Better Evaluation. Available at: https://www.betterevaluation.org/blog/knowing-place (accessed 20 August 2024 ).
40.
Shadish
WR
(1993 ) Critical multiplism: A research strategy and its attendant tactics . New Directions for Program Evaluation 1993 : 13 –57 .
41.
Tapella
E
Menese
A
(2024 ) Dime Cómo Miras y te Diré cómo Evalúa: Reflexiones sobre el rigor en la práctica y formación en Evaluación Participativa . Available at: https://evalparticipativa.net/2024/08/14/dime-como-miras-y-te-dire-como-evaluas/ (accessed 27 January 2025 ).
42.
Tolmer
Z
(2024 ) Decolonizing M&E: What does African monitoring and evaluation look like? Medium. Available at: https://medium.com/@undp.innovation/decolonizing-m-e-what-does-african-monitoring-and-evaluation-look-like-926d97d6f8d1 (accessed 29 July 2024 ).
43.World Bank Group (2024 ) World Bank Group Gender Strategy 2024–2030: Accelerating gender equality to end poverty on a liveable planet . Washington D.C. : World Bank . Available at: https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099061124182033630/pdf/BOSIB17e6952570c51b49812a89c05be6a4.pdf