This article identifies pathways through which impacts from the 2014 Commonwealth Games might arise. It also assesses the likelihood of positive impacts and considers how best to evaluate the games. The pathways identified are: economic growth; increased sports participation; increased pride and sense of identity; volunteering; improved environment; and legacy programmes. There is little or no evidence from previous major multi-sports events to suggest that any of these pathways are likely to generate meaningful positive outcomes although there is an absence of evidence for some. The available evidence could be improved if the 2014 Games were to be evaluated using: retrospective cohort analysis for discrete interventions; theory-based comparative cohort analyses, which includes an assessment of opportunity costs for effects that are intrinsic to hosting the event; and a realist evaluation of ‘catalytic impacts’.
BurrowsM (2003) Volunteers are the name of the game (sport volunteering). Volunteering87: 12–14.
4.
CarlisleSHanlonP (2007) Well-being and consumer culture: a different kind of public health problem?Health Promotion International22(3): 261–8.
5.
CarlisleSHanlonPHannahM (2008) Status, taste and distinction in consumer culture: acknowledging the symbolic dimensions of inequality. Public Health122(6): 631–7.
6.
ChalipL (2000) Sydney ‘2000: volunteers and the organisation of the Olympic Games: economic and formative aspects. In: MoragasMMorenoABPuigN (eds), Volunteers, global society and the Olympic Movement: International Symposium Lausanne. 24th, 25th and 26th November 1999. Lausanne: International Olympic Committee, 205–14
7.
COHRE (2007) Fair Play for Housing Rights: Mega-Events, Olympic Games and Housing Rights: Opportunities for the Olympic Movement and Others. Geneva: Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions.
8.
CraigPDieppePMacintyreSMichieSNazarethIPetticrewM (2008a) Developing and Evaluating Complex Interventions: New Guidance. London: Medical Research Council.
9.
CraigPDieppePMacintyreSMichieSNazarethIPetticrewM (2008b) Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidance. British Medical Journal337: a1655.
10.
DevineTM (1999) The Scottish Nation. London: Penguin.
11.
DouglasMThomsonHJepsonR (2007) Health Impact Assessment of Transport Initiatives: A Guide. Edinburgh: NHS Health Scotland.
EisingerP (2000) The politics of bread and circuses: building the city for the visitor class. Urban Affairs Review35(3): 316–33.
14.
FogelRW (2004) The Escape from Hunger and Premature Death, 1700-2100: Europe, America, and the Third World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
15.
GarciaB (2005) De-constructing the City of Culture: the long term cultural legacies of Glasgow 1990. Urban Studies42(5−6): 1–28.
16.
GarciaB (2008) One hundred years of cultural programming within the Olympic Games (1912−2012): origins, evolution and projections. International Journal of Cultural Policy14(4): 361–6.
GrayN (2008) The Clyde Gateway: a new urban frontier. Variant33.
22.
HanlonPMcCartneyG (2008) Peak oil: will it be public health’s greatest challenge?Public Health122(7): 647–52.
23.
Hexagon Research and Consulting in association with Adrian Colwell Associates (2008) Glasgow 2014: delivering a lasting legacy for Scotland: analysis of consultation responses. URL (consulted 8 May 2009): http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/Doc/253682/0075174.pdf.
24.
HollandWW (2003) Fighting the regime: homeless activism and the 1996 Olympics. Southern Sociological Society, 2003.
25.
Homer-DixonT (2007) The Upside of Down: Catastrophe, Creativity and the Renewal of Civilisation. London: Souvenir Press.
26.
HorneJManzenreiterW (2006) Sports mega-events: social scientific analyses of a global phenomenon. The Sociological review monographs; Variation: Sociological review monograph. URL: http://www.loc.gov/catdir/toc/ecip0615/2006019738.html.
27.
HunterDJ (2009) Leading for health and wellbeing: the need for a new paradigm. Journal of Public Health31: 202–4.
28.
JacksonT (2009) Prosperity without Growth? The Transition to a Sustainable Economy. London: Sustainable Development Commission.
29.
KempS (2002) The hidden workforce: volunteers’ learning in the Olympics. Journal of European Industrial Training26: 109–16.
30.
LangenFGarciaB (2008) Measuring the impact of major cultural events: a literature review. Arts Research Digest44: 1–7.
31.
LinkBGPhelanJC (2002) McKeown and the idea that social conditions are fundamental causes of disease. Americal Journal of Public Health92(5): 730–2.
32.
LumsdonL (2003) An evaluation of the motivations, expectations and experiences of volunteers prior to and during the XVII Commonwealth Games, Manchester, UK, 25th July−4th August 2002. Manchester, Manchester Metropolitan University and UK Sport.
33.
LynchB (2005) Sydney’s Olympic volunteers: lessons and legacies. In: AdairDGuothN (eds), Beyond the Torch: Olympics and Australian Culture. Melbourne: Australian Society for Sports History, 95–100.
34.
MackenzieMBlameyA (2005) The practice and the theory: lessons from the application of a theory of change approach. Evaluation11(2): 151–68.
35.
McCartneyG (2010) How will the 2014 Commonwealth Games impact on Glasgow’s health, and how will we know? Unpublished MD thesis, University of Glasgow.
36.
McCartneyGHanlonP (2008) Climate change and rising energy costs: a threat but also an opportunity for a healthier future?Public Health122(7): 653–7.
37.
McCartneyGHanlonPRomanesF (2008) Climate change and rising energy costs will change everything: a new mindset and action plan for 21st Century public health. Public Health122(7): 658–63.
38.
McCartneyGPalmerSWinterbottomJJonesRKendallRBookerD (2010a) A health impact assessment of the 2014 Commonwealth Games in Glasgow. Public Health124(8): 444–51.
39.
McCartneyGThomasSThomsonH. (2010b) The health and socio-economic impacts of major multi-sports events: a systematic review (1978-2008). British Medical Journal340: c2369.
40.
McKeownT (1976) The Modern Rise of Population. London: Edward Arnold.
41.
MurphyNMBaumanA (2007) Mass sporting and physical activity events: are they ‘bread and circuses’ or public health interventions to increase population levels of physical activity?Journal of Physical Activity & Health4(2): 193–202.
42.
NewmanHK (1999) Neighborhood impacts of Atlanta’s Olympic Games. Community Development Journal34(2): 151–9.
43.
NHS Health Scotland (2008) Health impact assessment of greenspace: a guide. Stirling, Greenspace Scotland.
PetticrewMTugwellPWelchV. (2009) Better evidence about wicked issues in tackling health inequities. Journal of Public Health31(3): 453–6.
46.
PreussH (1998) Problemizing arguments of the opponents of Olympic Games. In: BarneyRKWamsleyKGMartynSGMacDonaldGH (eds), Global and Cultural Critique: Problematizing the Olympic Games. London, Ontario: Centre for Olympic Studies, University of Western Ontario, 197–218.
47.
PreussH (2004) The Economics of Staging the Olympics: A Comparison of the Games 1972-2008. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
48.
PreussH (2007) The Impact and Evaluation of Major Sporting Events. London: Routledge.
49.
PreussHKebernikB (2000) Social structure, inducements and opinions of volunteers from Nagano 1998. In: De MoragasM (ed.), Volunteers, Global Society and the Olympic Movement. Lausanne: International Olympic Committee, 10.
50.
PrickettR (2000) Bread and circuses (economic impact of the Olympic Games). Financial Management: 24: 26–7.
51.
RaboyM (1978) Urban struggles and municipal politics: the Montreal citizens’ movement. Centro Sociale25(139−141): 145–64.
52.
RalstonRLumsdonLDownwardP (2004) An evaluation of volunteers’ reflections on the experience of volunteering at the XVII Commonwealth Games, Manchester, UK, 25th July−4th August 2002. Manchester, Manchester Metropolitan University and UK Sport.
53.
ReeserJCBergRLRheaDWillickS (2005) Motivation and satisfaction among polyclinic volunteers at the 2002 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games. British Journal of Sports Medicine39(4): e20.
54.
RuizJ (2004) A Literature Review of the Evidence Base for Culture, the Arts and Sport Policy. Edinburgh, Research and Economic Unit. Scottish Executive Education Department.
55.
Scottish Government (2008) Glasgow 2014: delivering a lasting legacy for Scotland. A consultation paper. Edinburgh, Scottish Government.
56.
Scottish Government (2009) On your marks: a games legacy for Scotland. Edinburgh, Scottish Government.
ShawMSmithGDDorlingD (2005) Health inequalities and New Labour: how the promises compare with real progress. British Medical Journal330(7498): 1016–21.
59.
TheodoreJ (2003) Sports development impact of the Commonwealth Games: study of volunteers (pre-games). Manchester, International Centre for Research & Consultancy for the Tourism and Hospitality Industries, Manchester Metropolitan University & UK Sport.
60.
ThomsonHAtkinsonRPetticrewMKearnsA (2006) Do urban regeneration programmes improve public health and reduce health inequalities? A synthesis of the evidence from UK policy and practice (1980–2004). Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health60(2): 108–15.
61.
ThomsonHPetticrewMMorrisonD (2001) Health effects of housing improvement: systematic review of intervention studies. British Medical Journal323(7306): 187–90.
62.
VilaGGavaldaJ (2006) The Barcelona model under scrutiny: social risks of urban transformation. International Sociological Association, Durban, South Africa.
63.
WeedMCorenEFioreJ (2009) A Systematic Review of the Evidence Base for Developing a Physical Activity and Health Legacy from the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games. London: Department of Health.
64.
WellingsKDattaJWilkinsonPPetticrewM (2011) The 2012 Olympics: assessing the public health effect. Lancet378: 1193–5.
65.
WilkinsonRPickettK (2009) The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better. London: Penguin.
