Monitoring,evaluation and performance management in South Asia: The challenge of building capacity

Abstract

The article reviews the state of M&E in South Asia, and makes a case for building capacity in the field, without which the discipline will remain underdeveloped, and accountability for government spending not improve. We suggest that almost none of the South Asian countries have yet managed to develop an M&E ‘system’, though all have mechanisms in place. The article discusses the MIS and evaluation systems, tools in use by governments in South Asia, budgets for evaluation, and the role of civil society organizations. It highlights two cases in South Asia (India and Sri Lanka) where the concept of Performance Management has gathered momentum, even though outcome budgeting has barely taken off in any country of the sub-region. It examines plans for improving implementation of evaluation, but finds many areas suffering from capacity weaknesses. The article closes by recommending ways to address the capacity weaknesses.

Keywords

capacity building M&E outcome budgets performance management South Asia

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asian Development Bank (2008) Managing for Development Results in Action: Results-Based Monitoring and Evaluation for the Health Sector in Sri Lanka. Manila: Asian Development Bank.

Canadian International Development Agency (2004) Evaluation Guide. Ottawa, Canada: CIDA and Chris Stanley Oakron Consultants International.

Comptroller and Auditor General of India (2003) Development evaluation in India: contemporary issues and approaches. Government of India, New Delhi.

Institute of Applied Manpower Research (2011) India Human Development Report 2011. Towards Social Inclusion. New Delhi, India: Oxford University Press.

Mehrotra

(forthcoming) Monitoring and evaluation in India: commensurate with the needs of an emerging market economy? Independent Evaluation Group, World Bank, Washington, DC, Occasional paper.

Mehrotra

Kumar

Saxena

(2012) Management Information Systems in India: assessing the MIS of central government programmes, IAMR Occasional Paper No. 5/2012.

Pal

(2011) Policy impact of evaluation studies: the Indian experience. Website of the Development Evaluation Society of India. URL (consulted 25 October 2012): http://www.desindia.org.

Ratnala

(2009) Evaluation in South Asia: a community of evaluation perspective. Paper prepared for the first Community of Evaluation of South Asia first seminar, Delhi, 11–13 December 2008.

Sivagnanasothy

(2010) The monitoring and evaluation system in Sri Lanka: experiences, challenges, and the way forward. Paper presented in the fifth conference of The Latin America and the Caribbean Monitoring and Evaluation Network, mimeo.

10.

Sridharan

(2009) Making evaluations matter: ten concepts that will help you become a better evaluator. Paper presented to the Sri Lanka Evaluators Association.

11.

Sri Lanka Evaluation Association (2003) Sri Lanka’s national evaluation policy. Sri Lanka Evaluation Association and Ministry of Public Development and Implementation Strategic Plan (2008–13), Colombo.

12.

Waissi

(2007) Integrated results-based management in the case of Afghanistan, Afghanistan National Development Strategy. Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, Kabul.

13.

Williams

Sankar

(2008) Evaluation South Asia. Kathmandu, Nepal: UNICEF South Asia.