This article arises from a critical examination of the way the human sexual ity debate developed at national level within the United Reformed Church (URC) between 1997 and 2000. Documents that reflected the thinking of members of the Church were carefully examined in order to identify the issues that members of the URC considered fundamental to the debate. From this analysis three closely linked themes, which, it will be argued here form a circular argument, are reflected on theologically: homophobia, sexuality and changing traditional interpretations of the Bible. There can only be an end to the debate when the URC and other Churches are able to escape this circular argument. Taking the experience of South Africa after the apartheid years as a guide, the discussion concludes by exploring ways by which the Church might end the debate and move forward.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Armstrong, Karen2000The Battle For God (London: Harper Collins).
2.
Barclay, William1983The Daily Study Bible, The Gospel of Matthew Volume 1 (Edinburgh: St Andrews' Press ).
3.
Boswell, John1980Christianity, Social Tolerance and Homosexuality (Chicago : University of Chicago Press). 1994
4.
'Homosexuality and the Religious Life', in Nelson and Longfellow1994: 361-73.
5.
Carroll, Robert P.1997Wolf in the Sheepfold (London : SCM Press).
6.
Cornwell, John2001'Savage Messiahs', Sunday Times , section 4, p. 6.
7.
Cotter, Jim1977'The Gay Challenge to Traditional Notions of Spirituality' , in Macourt 1977: 63-86.
8.
Countryman, L. William1996Dirt, Greed and Sex (London: XPRESS Prints, SCM Press).
9.
Crew, L.1997'Changing the Church: Lessons to Be Learned in the Struggle to Reduce Institutional Sexism in the Episcopal Church', in Sears and Williams 1997: 341-53.
10.
France, R.T.2000A Slippery Slope? The Ordination of Women and Homosexual Practice: A Case Study in Biblical Interpretation (Cambridge : Grove Books).
11.
Furnish, Victor Paul1994'The Bible and Homosexuality: Reading the Texts in Context', in Jeffrey S. Siker (ed.), Homosexuality in the Church (Louisville: Westminster Press): 18-35.
12.
Goddard, Andrew2001God, Gentiles and Gay Christians: Acts 15 and Change in the Church (Cambridge: Grove Books).
13.
Goss, Robert1993Jesus ACTED Up (San Francisco : Harper).
14.
Hanks, Tom2000The Subversive Gospel (Cleveland : The Pilgrim Press).
15.
Hartman, Keith1996Congregations in Conflict: The Battle over Homosexuality (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press).
16.
Holloway, Richard2001Doubts and Loves: What Is Left of Christianity (Edinburgh: Canongate Books).
17.
Hopper, George S.E.2000Reluctant Journey: A Pilgrimage of Faith from Homophobia to Christian Love (Leeds: University Print Services).
18.
Houston, Walter1997'A Holy Life', unpublished paper delivered at a symposium at the National Training Centre, Windermere.
19.
Jordan, Mark D.1997The Invention of Sodomy in Christian Theology (Chicago : University of Chicago Press ).
20.
Koch, Timothy R.2001'A Homoerotic Approach to Scripture', T&S14:10-22.
21.
Macourt, Malcolm1977Towards a Theology of Gay Liberation ( London: SCM Press).
22.
McKelvey R.J.1997a 'Human Sexuality in Genesis 1-3', unpublished paper delivered at a symposium at the National Training Centre, Windermere.
23.
1997 b 'I Peter, Vocation and Holiness', unpublished paper delivered at a symposium at the National Training Centre, Windermere.
24.
McNeill, John J.1994The Church and the Homosexual ( Boston: Beacon Press, 4th edn).
25.
Mesner, Michael A.2002'Becoming 100% Straight', in Christine L. Williams and Arlene Stein (eds.), Sexuality and Gender (Oxford: Blackwell Publishers): 349-53.
26.
Moss, Rachel (ed.) 1981God's Yes to Sexuality ( Glasgow: William Collins).
27.
Nelson, James B.1978Embodiment: An Approach to Sexuality and Christian Theology (Minneapolis: Augsburg ).
28.
1992 a Body Theology (Louisville: Westminster Press).
29.
1992 b The Intimate Connection (London: SPCK).
30.
1994'Introduction', in Nelson and Longfellow 1994: xiii-xviii.
31.
1996'Rewriting Sexuality and Spirituality', in Thatcher and Stuart 1996: 213-19.
32.
Nelson, James B. and Sandra P. Longfellow1994Sexuality and the Sacred (Louisville: Westminster Press ).
33.
Norton, R.1977'The Biblical Roots of Homophobia', in Macourt 1977 : 39-46.
34.
Peel, David R.1997'Sola Scritpura Revisited: The Achilles Heel of Reformed Theology?', unpublished paper delivered at a symposium at the National Training Centre, Windermere.
35.
Proctor, John1997a 'The Holy Life: A Survey of Biblical Material' , unpublished paper delivered at a symposium at the National Training Centre, Windermere.
36.
1997 b 'Homosexuality and Redemption', unpublished paper delivered at a symposium at the National Training Centre, Windermere.
Webster, Alison1994'Eating the Fruit', in H. Walton and S. Durber (eds.), Silence in Heaven: A Book of Women's Preaching (London: SCM Press): 186-91.
58.
Wellings, Kaye, Julia Field, Anne M. Johnson and Jane Wadsworth1994Sexual Behaviour in Britain (t: Penguin Books).
59.
Williams, W.L.1997'Introduction', in Sears and Williams 1997: 1-10.
60.
Wilson, Nancy2000Our Tribe, Queer Folks, God, Jesus and the Bible (San Francisco: HarperCollins ).
61.
Yep, Gust A.1997'Changing Homophobic and Heterosexist Attitudes: An Overview of Persuasive Communication Approaches', in Sears and Williams 1997: 49-64.
62.
Yungblut, John R.1991The Gentle Art of Spiritual Guidance ( Shaftesbury: Longmead).
