Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Although digital radio broadcasting has undergone significant development over the last quarter-century, no single protocol is poised to break out as a bona fide replacement for traditional analogue radio services. This article illuminates the history and status of radio’s digital transition in an effort to understand its stagnancy. The current state of affairs is due to a variety of factors, including a lack of regulatory engagement with the transition, political and economic shifts in the balance of power between the various broadcaster constituencies involved, and the recalcitrance of receiver manufacturers and listeners to adopt any digital radio broadcast technology. The questions raised by the technologically agnostic nature of radio’s digital malaise beg for deeper scrutiny by media scholars, especially those involved in broadcast research as well as technology and policy studies.

Keywords

DAB Digital radio broadcasting Digital Radio Mondiale DRM Eureka 147 HD Radio media convergence media policy radio history radio studies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adelstein

(2007) Transcript of remarks delivered at the Media Policy Research Pre-Conference of the National Conference for Media Reform, 11 January. Available at: http://mediaresearchhub.ssrc.org/news/transcript-of-fcc-commissadelsteins-remarks-at-media-policy-research-pre-conference (accessed 5 February 2012).

Ala-Fossi

(2010a) Future scenarios for the radio industry. In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, pp. 153–172.

Ala-Fossi

(2010b) The technological landscape of radio. In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, pp. 43–66.

Ala-Fossi

Stavitsky

(2003) Understanding IBOC: Digital technology of analogue economics. Journal of Radio Studies 10(1): 63–79.

Anderson

(2006) Digital radio in the United States: Privatization of the public airwaves? Communication, Politics, and Culture (née Southern Review: Communication, Politics and Culture) 39(2): 5–25.

Anderson

(2009a) HD going global? Check the map. DIYmedia.net, 30 May. Available at: http://www.diymedia.net/archive/0509.htm#053009 (accessed 17 March 2011).

Anderson

(2009b) HD Radio increasing format diversity? DIYmedia.net, 25 August. Available at: http://www.diymedia.net/archive/0809.htm#082509 (accessed 2 February 2012).

Anderson

(2010a) Bring the noise redux: FCC okays FM-HD power increase. DIYmedia.net, 31 January. Available at: http://diymedia.net/archive/0110.htm#013110 (accessed 2 February 2012).

Anderson

(2010b) Translators: The back up plan to HD? DIYmedia.net, 20 June. Available at: http://diymedia.net/archive/0610.htm#062010 (accessed 2 February 2012).

10.

Anderson

(2011a) Radio’s digital dilemma: Broadcasting in the 21st century. Doctoral dissertation, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Available at: http://www.ideals.illinois.edu/handle/2142/26240 (accessed 5 February 2012).

11.

Anderson

(2011b) FM translator abuse creates ownership loophole. DIYmedia.net, 18 May. Available at: http://diymedia.net/archive/0511.htm#051811 (accessed 2 February 2012).

12.

Beezley

(2010) HD radio self-noise. Ham-radio.com, November. Available at: http://www.ham-radio.com/k6sti/hdrsn.htm (accessed 2 February 2012).

13.

Behrens

(1999) Field testing resumes for radio’s digital best hope. Current, 16 August, 19.

14.

Behrensdorf

(1998) Brazil DAB debate simmers slowly. Radio World, 2 September, 17.

15.

Behrensdorf

(2005) Brazil pushes ahead with HD Radio. Radio World, 23 November, 1, 16–17.

16.

Bg (2010) Brazil to opt for DRM? Comunica.org, 10 March. Available at: http://comunica.org/radio2.0/archives/220 (accessed 17 March 2011).

17.

Branigan

(2004) Irish DAB struggles to progress. Radio World, 1 February, 14.

18.

Calhoun

(2001) London DAB group complete. Radio World, 1 February, 7, 10.

19.

Careless

(1995a) DAB plan enrages Canadian broadcasters. Radio World, 12 July, 11.

20.

Careless

(1995b) Canada DAB on track. Radio World, 29 November, 1, 8.

21.

Careless

(1996a) Canadians have doubts about DAB roll out. Radio World, 20 March, 14.

22.

Careless

(1996b) Standardizing Eureka receivers. Radio World, 26 June, 11.

23.

Careless

(1996c) DAB allocation begins in Canada. Radio World, 4 September, 8, 15.

24.

Careless

(1996d) Ford pays attention to DAB in Canada. Radio World, 11 December, 3.

25.

Careless

(1998) DAB at the border line. Radio World, 7 January, 1, 3.

26.

Careless

(2002) Canada experiments with digital-only. Radio World, 10 April, 28.

27.

Careless

(2004) CBC enters year 2 for DRM tests. Radio World, 1 December, 6.

28.

Careless

(2006a) A Canadian call for IBOC support. Radio World, 18 January, 18, 21.

29.

Careless

(2006b) CAB: Digital radio needs help. Radio World, 13 September, 19.

30.

Careless

(2009) Radio submits its applications. Radio World, 15 July, 20.

31.

Careless

(2010a) Canadian lobby no more. Radio World, 8 June. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/101616 (accessed 17 March 2011).

32.

Careless

(2010b) Canada in digital radio limbo. Radio World, 28 October. Available at: http://www.radioworld.com/article/108522 (accessed 17 March 2011).

33.

Carera

(2008) DRM trial under way in Italy. Radio World, 24 September, 18, 20.

34.

Clark

(1996) Eureka–147 continues to spread. Radio World, 10 July, 1, 9.

35.

Clark

(1998) DAB systems are now a reality. Radio World, 13 May, 41–42.

36.

Cohen

(1995) Receivers key for DAB future. Radio World, 29 May, 14, 21.

37.

Cohen

(1998) European DAB data dispute settled. Radio World, 21 January, 1, 7.

38.

Cohen

(2005) More DRM radios due in 2005. Radio World, 19 January, 1, 6.

39.

Copps

(2002) Statement on Report and Order. FCC Media Bureau Docket 99 – 325, 10 October. Available at: http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-227261A3.pdf (accessed 6 August 2012).

40.

Corominas

Bonet

Guimerå

(2006) Digitalization and the concept of ‘local’: The case of radio in Spain. Journal of Radio Studies 13(1): 116–128.

41.

DRMNA – Digital Radio Mondiale North America (2010). Available at: http://drmna.bcdx.org/wp/ (accessed 17 March 2011).

42.

Dumiak

(2006) Europe dithers over digital radio. IEEE Spectrum, October, 20.

43.

Goddard

(2010a) D.A.B. Digital Radio: Licensed to Fail. London: Radio Books.

44.

Goddard

(2010b) Netherlands: Government forces DAB upon commercial radio. Grant Goddard: Radio Blog, 13 November. Available at: http://grantgoddardradioblog.blogspot.com/2010/11/netherlands-government-forces-dab-upon.html (accessed 17 March 2011).

45.

Hallett

(2003a) BBC confirms digital commitment. Radio World, 7 April, 14.

46.

Hallett

(2003b) DRM: What’s it about? Radio World, 22 October, 1, 8, 10.

47.

Hallett

(2005a) DRM expands into FM band. Radio World, 8 June, 8.

48.

Hallett

(2005b) Norway looks at DRM options. Radio World, 16 September, 16.

49.

Hallett

(2006) Norway strides down digital path. Radio World, 22 November, 14–15.

50.

Hedges

(2006) HD Radio gets alpine demo. Radio World, 16 August, 1, 3, 6.

51.

Hershberger

(2010a) Look before you leap. Radio World, 23 August. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/usercontrol/article/105256 (accessed 2 February 2012).

52.

Hershberger

(2010b) Elevated HD power, part II. Radio World, 19 October. Available at: http://www.radioworld.com/article/108074 (accessed 2 February 2012).

53.

iBiquity Digital Corporation (2007) Market status. Available at: http://www.ibiquity.com/i/january_%202007.pdf (accessed 2 February 2012).

54.

iBiquity Digital Corporation (2009a) HD Radio broadcaster licensing fact sheet. Available at: http://www.ibiquity.com/i/Licensing_%20Fact_%20Sheet_2009.pdf (accessed 2 February 2012).

55.

iBiquity Digital Corporation (2009b) 2009 station license agreement (for stations eligible for discount pricing) . Available at: http://www.ibiquity.com/i/2009%20Form%20SLA-A.pdf (accessed 2 February 2012).

56.

iBiquity Digital Corporation (2009c) Becoming an HD Radio IP licensee. Available at: http://www.ibiquity.com/manufacturers/receiver_manufacturers/license_agreement (accessed 2 February 2012).

57.

iBiquity Digital Corporation (2010) HD Radio broadcasting around the world. Available at: http://www.ibiquity.com/international (accessed 17 March 2011).

58.

Janssen

(2000) Technical merger may speed adoption of digital radio. Current, 17 July, 5.

59.

Janssen

(2004) With second channel, FM branches out. Current, 10 May, 1.

60.

Jauert

Lax

Shaw

(2010) DAB: The future of radio? The development of digital radio in Europe. In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

et al. (eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, pp. 99–120.

61.

Kassof

(2012) HD Radio: Zero progress in consumers’ knowledge. Kassof.com, 20 January. Available at: http://kassof.com/2012/hd-radio-zero-progress-in-consumers-knowledge-2/ (accessed 31 January 2012).

62.

Kellner

(2009) HD Radio aims to go global. Radio World, 14 January, 10, 12.

63.

Koerner

(2008) Israel prepares for DAB+ system. Radio World, 24 September, 11.

64.

Ladika

(1998) In Europe, DAB moves – slowly. Radio World, 28 October, 7, 12.

65.

Lasar

(2010) Are the likes of Pandora poised to kill AM/FM radio? Ars Technica, 2 November. Available at: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/11/are-the-likes-of-pandora-poised-to-kill-amfm-radio.ars (accessed 2 February 2012).

66.

Lawson

(2008) SWR tests digital radio future. Radio World, 7 May, 26.

67.

Lawton

(1996) Eureka debate in Germany. Radio World, 16 October, 1, 14.

68.

Lax

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(2008) DAB: The future of radio? The development of digital radio in four European countries. Media, Culture & Society 30(2): 151–166.

69.

Lee

(2006) DMB set for take off in Korea. Radio World, 15 March, 22.

70.

Limas-Villers

(2010) Seriously worried. Radio World, 1 February, 34.

71.

Mansergh

(2004) DRM, Eureka grow worldwide. Radio World, 1 July, 3, 8.

72.

Mansergh

(2006) DRM hopes for FM standard in 2007. Radio World, 13 September, 6, 8.

73.

Mansergh

(2007) DRM: ready for global deployment. Radio World, 18 July, 3.

74.

Maxson

(2000) Reply comments as tendered to the Federal Communications Commission. Media Bureau Docket 99 – 325. 23 February. Available at: http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=6010955386 (accessed 6 August 2012).

75.

Maxson

(2007) The IBOC Handbook: Understanding HD Radio Technology. Burlington, MA: Focal Press.

76.

McDonagh

(2000) Manufacturer: DAB needs hype. Radio World, 13 September, 14.

77.

McLane

(2009) Is it the best we can do? CBS rebroadcast strategy invites scrutiny. Radio World, 16 December, 34.

78.

McLane

(2010) From the editor: Digital radio cranks up the juice. Radio World, 10 February, 12.

79.

McLarnon

(2012) AM IBOC stations on the air. Topaz Designs. Available at: http://topazdesigns.com/iboc/station-list.html (accessed 2 February 2012).

80.

Meadows

(1995) AFCCE hears Eureka-147. Radio World, 26 July, 3.

81.

Mock

(2004) It’s all about the algorithm – but which one will win? IEEE Spectrum, September, 46.

82.

n.a. (1995) Germany launches DAB in Bavaria. Radio World, 1 November, 1, 9.

83.

n.a. (1996a) DAB receivers delayed in Europe. Radio World, 20 March, 17.

84.

n.a. (1996b) EuroDAB expanding scope, focus. Radio World, 29 May, 12.

85.

n.a. (1996c) Will data services hurt Eureka audio? Radio World, 26 June, 9, 12.

86.

n.a. (2002) WorldDAB forum elects new leader. Radio World, 13 February, 5.

87.

n.a. (2003a) DRM launches big. Radio World, 16 July, 7.

88.

n.a. (2004) Greece DAB station plans for Olympics. Radio World, 14 July, 5.

89.

n.a. (2005a) Macedonian AM tries DRM. Radio World, 2 February, 3.

90.

n.a. (2005b) DRM tests begin in Mexico. Radio World, 30 March, 2, 7.

91.

n.a. (2005c) Australia DAB. Radio World, 23 November, 5.

92.

n.a. (2006a) BE installs HD-R in Paris. Radio World, 24 May, 10.

93.

n.a. (2006b) Radio broadcast to cell phones in U.K. Radio World, 16 August, 8.

94.

n.a. (2006c) Brazil HD-R alliance now formalized. Radio World, 6 November, 10.

95.

n.a. (2007a) DRM eyes India for MW test. Radio World, 6 June, 2.

96.

n.a. (2007b) Mexico to allow IBOC on border. Radio World, 20 June, 41.

97.

n.a. (2007c) Australia moves on DAB. Radio World, 20 June, 43.

98.

n.a. (2007d) Brazil could reduce tax on imported HD-R gear. Radio World, 1 August, 2–3.

99.

n.a. (2007e) Swiss HD Radio. Radio World, 1 August, 3.

100.

n.a. (2008a) Newswatch. Radio World, 18 June, 2.

101.

n.a. (2008b) Digital news. Radio World, 1 September, 18.

102.

n.a. (2008c) HD Radio in Latin America. Radio World, 24 September, 20.

103.

n.a. (2008d) Newswatch. Radio World, 8 October, 2.

104.

n.a. (2008e) Newswatch. Radio World, 22 October, 5.

105.

n.a. (2008f) Newswatch. Radio World, 17 December, 12.

106.

n.a. (2009) Panama says ‘yes’ to IBOC. Radio World, 19 May. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/81294 (accessed 17 March 2011).

107.

n.a. (2010a) News roundup: U.S./Mexico. Radio World, 1 January, 5.

108.

n.a. (2010b) News roundup: Swiss. Radio World, 1 March, 10.

109.

n.a. (2010c) KATY-FM files FCC petition against KTRH HD Radio interference. Radio Business Report, 20 May. Available at: http://www.rbr.com/radio/24360.html (accessed 2 February 2012).

110.

n.a. (2010d) Schweizer HD Radio offenbar vor dem aus. Infosat.de, 27 August. Available at: http://www.infosat.de/Meldungen/?msgID=59896 (accessed 17 March 2011).

111.

n.a. (2011a) Norway sets 2017 sunset for analog FM. Radio World, 4 February. Available at: http://www.radioworld.com/article/norway-sets–2017-sunset-for-analog-fm/23318 (accessed 12 January 2012).

112.

n.a. (2011b) HD Radio clears a big hurdle in Mexico. Radio World, 28 February. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/114392 (accessed 17 March 2011).

113.

n.a. (2011c) Doyle: HD Adoption Rate ‘Mixed’. Radio World, 13 April. Available at: http://radioworld.com/article/doyle-hd-adoption-rate-’mixed/23245 (accessed 2 February 2012).

114.

n.a. (2011d) Germany relaunches digital radio nationwide. Radio World, 4 August. Available at: http://www.radioworld.com/article/germany-relaunches-digital-radio-nationwide/24069 (accessed 12 January 2012).

115.

O’Neill

(2007) Digital audio broadcasting in Canada: Technology and policy in the transition to digital radio. Canadian Journal of Communication 32(1): 71–90.

116.

O’Neill

(2010a) Beyond Europe: Launching digital radio in Canada and Australia.’ In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, 135–152.

117.

O’Neill

(2010b) Sounding the future: Digital radio and CD-quality audio. In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, 85–98.

118.

O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(2010) Introduction. In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

et al. (eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, 17–26.

119.

O’Neill

Shaw

(2010) Radio broadcasting in Europe: The search for a common digital future. In: O’Neill

Ala-Fossi

Jauert

(eds) Digital Radio in Europe: Technologies, Industries and Cultures. Bristol: Intellect, 27–42.

120.

Ory

(2000) How to open the global DAB market. Radio World, 13 September, 14–15.

121.

Pizzi

(2002a) IBOC raises eyebrows. Radio World, 27 March, 67.

122.

Pizzi

(2002b) At IBC, new directions for DAB. Radio World, 9 October, 16, 20.

123.

Pizzi

(2004a) Rethinking DAB north of the border. Radio World, 1 August, 17–18.

124.

Pizzi

(2004b) Digital radio’s sweet spot. Radio World, 24 September, 20–21.

125.

Pizzi

(2004c) Around the world in 80 DABs. Radio World, 3 November, 27–28.

126.

Pizzi

(2008) DAB on the up and down track. Radio World, 26 March, 64, 68.

127.

Pizzi

(2009a) Is the perfect storm approaching? Radio World, 14 January, 18.

128.

Pizzi

(2009b) Ponder this post-broadcast paradigm. Radio World, 3 June, 24.

129.

Pizzi

(2009c) Radio applies the Pogo principle. Radio World, 23 September, 18.

130.

Plata

(1995) Mexico DAB: Waiting for results. Radio World, 19 April, 6.

131.

Plata

(2004) Mexico plans a digital choice. Radio World, 1 December, 5.

132.

Plata

(2007) Mexico steps toward digital standard. Radio World, 12 September, 18–19.

133.

Plata

(2009) Mexican AM–M transition sought. Radio World, 24 April, 5.

134.

Plata

(2010) Mexico is set to elect IBOC. Radio World, 7 April, 13, 16, 18.

135.

Pohlmann

(2005) Principles of Digital Audio (5th edn). New York: McGraw-Hill.

136.

Robertiello

(1991a) The competition. Current, 21 January, 8.

137.

Robertiello

(1991b) The competition. Current, 4 March, 7.

138.

Robertiello

(1991c) The competition. Current, 29 April, 16.

139.

Ross

(1996) DAB transmitters from around the world. Radio World, 29 May, 28.

140.

Rudin

(2006) The development of DAB digital radio in the UK: The battle for control of a new technology in an old medium. Convergence: The International Journal of Research Into New Media Technologies 12(2): 163–178.

141.

Ruoss

(2008) Radio Sunshine HD tests successful. Radio World Engineering Extra, 20 February, 1, 14, 16, 18, 20.

142.

Sedman

(1997) Radio transmission. In: Seel

Grant

(eds) Broadcast Technology Update: Production and Transmission. Boston, MA: Focal Press, pp. 157–164.

143.

Seidler

(1995) Poland is an early DAB proponent. Radio World, 8 February, 14.

144.

Senger

(1998) DRM takes aim at digital AM. Radio World, 10 June, 10.

145.

Siew

(2011) MediaCorp to cut digital radio programmes on Dec 1. Techgoondu, 2 November. Available at: http://www.techgoondu.com/2011/11/02/mediacorp-to-cut-digital-radio-programmes-on-dec-1/ (accessed 12 January 2012).

146.

Signorelli

(2003) ‘Open’ source? Up for interpretation. Radio World, 10 September, 15.

147.

Stacey

(2007) Canada eyes IBOC additions to DAB. Radio World, 17 January, 23, 26.

148.

Stimson

(2000a) Robert Struble steers new IBOC DAB race. Radio World, 13 September, 6–7.

149.

Stimson

(2000b) Dutch DAB pilot ends. Radio World, 20 December, 3, 5.

150.

Stimson

(2001) Mobile DRM DAB system unveiled at IFA show. Radio World, 24 October, 6.

151.

Stimson

(2002a) IBOC fees stir reaction. Radio World, 10 September, 15

152.

Stimson

(2002b) DAB developments in Germany, Taiwan. Radio World, 25 September, 7.

153.

Stimson

(2002c) DRM demos receiver at IBC. Radio World, 9 October, 8.

154.

Stimson

(2002d) ITU endorses DRM. Radio World, 4 December, 8.

155.

Stimson

(2003a) DRM reaches for launch. Radio World, 21 May, 2.

156.

Stimson

(2003b) DRM: Shortwave wants to sound better, too. Radio World, 18 June, 3, 5.

157.

Stimson

(2003c) Eureka: Niche or volume player? Radio World, 18 June, 3, 10.

158.

Stimson

(2003d) Group targets Latin America for Eureka-147. Radio World, 3 December, 5.

159.

Stimson

(2004a) Australia launches DAB. Radio World, 1 February, 2–3.

160.

Stimson

(2004b) Russia chooses DRM for digital pilot. Radio World, 1 February, 3.

161.

Stimson

(2004c) Chinese radio supports DRM. Radio World, 5 May, 8.

162.

Stimson

(2005a) iBiquity gets specific with fees. Radio World, 16 March, 1, 16.

163.

Stimson

(2005b) DRM to expand to FM, combine efforts with DAB. Radio World, 12 April, 7.

164.

Stimson

(2005c) Messer leaves IBB for DRM. Radio World, 3 August, 2, 6.

165.

Stimson

(2007a) Canada allows IBOC. Radio World, 1 August, 8.

166.

Stimson

(2007b) Mexico wants FCC ‘do-over’ on IBOC. Radio World, 12 September, 18.

167.

Stimson

(2010a) How many HD FMs will raise power? Radio World, 24 March, 10.

168.

Stimson

(2010b) Canadian broadcasters start turning off DAB transmitters. Radio World, 24 June. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/102542 (accessed 17 March 2011).

169.

Stimson

(2010c) Second SoCal class A IBOC interference complaint surfaces. Radio World, 27 May. Available at: http://www.radioworld.com/article/101240 (accessed 2 February 2012).

170.

Stimson

(2010d) CBS Radio disputes KATY’s IBOC interference claim. Radio World, 15 July. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/103510 (accessed 2 February 2012).

171.

Stimson

(2010e) AM HD Radio has stalled. Now what? Radio World, 31 August. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/105898 (accessed 2 February 2012).

172.

Stimson

(2011) Effort to get HD chips in phones progressing. Radio World, 21 October. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/effort-to-get-hd-radio-chips-in-phones-progressing/24655 (accessed 31 January 2012).

173.

Stine

(2010) Among AM HD users, opinions vary. Radio World, 2 September. Available at: http://www.rwonline.com/article/105924 (accessed 2 February 2012).

174.

Vernon

(2009) Here’s what’s on their minds. Radio World, 25 March, 18, 20.

175.

Wagoner

(2010) KMLA want FCC to run interference with KRTH, KOST. Los Angeles Daily News, 28 May. Available at: http://www.dailynews.com/lalife/ci_15177216 (accessed 2 February 2012).

176.

Webster

(2010) Broadcast media’s failure to communicate. The Infinite Dial, 18 November. Available at: http://www.infinitedial.com/2010/11/broadcast_medias_failure_to_co.php (accessed 2 February 2012).

177.

White

(2007) Shortwave awaits DRM in United States. Radio World, 18 July, 5–6.

178.

Zametica

(2010) Sweden resumed DAB interest. Radio World, 13 January, 10, 12.

Radio broadcasting’s digital dilemma

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References