This study investigates the drivers of profit inefficiency in the restaurant industry. Assuming that restaurants operate under monopolistic competition, we first present a characterization of the factors that explain restaurants’ departure from the profit frontier, focusing on the role of business experience, number of outlets, service model, restaurant typology, and COVID-19 shock. Based on Stochastic Frontier Analysis, we estimate how these factors explain the differences in profit inefficiency across firms using a panel dataset of 4128 restaurants in Sweden in the period 2017–2021. We find that the average level of profit efficiency is low (46%). Inefficiency increases with years in operation and is significantly higher among limited-service restaurants and single-outlet firms. Interestingly, no significant difference in profit inefficiency is detected during the COVID-19 pandemic. Our findings provide valuable insights for profit efficiency management.
AlbercaPParteL (2018) Operational efficiency evaluation of restaurant firms. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management30(3): 1959–1977.
2.
AngeliniFCastellaniMViciL (2024) Restaurant sector efficiency Frontiers: a meta-analysis. Journal of Foodservice Business Research27(2): 138–156.
3.
AngelovNWaldenströmD (2023) The economic effects of COVID-19 in Sweden: a report on income, taxes, distribution, and government support policies. IZA Policy Paper N0. 200.
4.
ArbeloAPérez-GómezPArbelo-PérezM (2017) Cost efficiency and its determinants in the hotel industry. Tourism Economics23(5): 1056–1068.
5.
ArbeloAPérez-GómezPArbelo-PérezM (2018) Estimating efficiency and its determinants in the hotel sector using a profit function. Current Issues in Tourism21(8): 863–876.
6.
ArbeloAArbelo-PérezMPérez-GómezP (2021) Heterogeneity of resources and performance in the hotel industry. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research45(1): 68–89.
7.
Arbelo-PérezMArbeloAPérez-GómezP (2017) Impact of quality on estimations of hotel efficiency. Tourism Management61: 200–208.
8.
Arbelo-PérezMPérez-GómezPArbeloA (2019) Impact of all-inclusive packages on hotel efficiency. Current Issues in Tourism22(8): 905–920.
9.
AssafAGDeeryMJagoL (2011) Evaluating the performance and scale characteristics of the Australian restaurant industry. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research35(4): 419–436.
10.
BahkBHGortM (1993) Decomposing learning by doing in new plants. Journal of Political Economy101(4): 561–583.
11.
BarronDNWestEHannanMT (1994) A time to grow and a time to die: growth and mortality of credit unions in New York city, 1914-1990. American Journal of Sociology100(2): 381–421.
12.
BatteseGECoelliTJ (1995) A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic Frontier production function for panel data. Empirical Economics20: 325–332.
13.
BFUF (2018) TILLVÄXTBRANSCH I FÖRÄNDRING Prognoser För Kompetensbehov Inom Hotell- Och Restaurangbranschen till År 2030. Sweden: BFUF.
BrownDM (1990) The restaurant and fast food race: who’s winning?Southern Economic Journal56(4): 984–995.
16.
CarlbäckM (2008) Are the chain operations simply with it? Five aspects meal model as a development tool for chain operations / franchise organizations. Journal of Foodservice19: 74–79.
17.
CarlbäckM (2022) The EA-approach; a customer-centered management system to produce, manage and assess relevant experiences for the hospitality and tourism industry. In: Contemporary Approaches Studying Customer Experience in Tourism Research. Leeds, UK: Emerald publishing, 131–144.
18.
CarlbäckMNygrenTHägglundP (2024) Human resource development in restaurants in Western Sweden–a human capital theory perspective. Journal of Human Resources in Hospitality & Tourism23(2): 289–314.
19.
Castillo-ManzanoJICastro-NuñoMLópez-ValpuestaL, et al. (2021) Quality versus quantity: an assessment of the impact of Michelin-starred restaurants on tourism in Spain. Tourism Economics27(5): 1166–1174.
20.
CoadASegarraATeruelM (2013) Like milk or wine: does firm performance improve with age?Structural Change and Economic Dynamics24: 173–189.
21.
CoadADaunfeldtSHalvarssonD (2018) Bursting into life: firm growth and growth persistence by age. Small Business Economics50: 55–75.
22.
DapengZJinghuaTLingxuZ, et al. (2020) Higher tourism specialization, better hotel industry efficiency?International Journal of Hospitality Management87: 102509.
23.
DemydyukGVShawkyHARestJV, et al. (2015) Key operating indicators to lever financial performance of publicly traded restaurant companies: a market’s perspective from 2007-2011. International Journal of Revenue Management8(2): 165–192.
24.
DengYVeigaHWiperMP (2019) Efficiency evaluation of hotel chains: a Spanish case study. SERIEs10: 115–139.
25.
DixitAKStiglitzJE (1977) Monopolistic competition and optimum product diversity. The American Economic Review67(3): 297–308.
26.
EnzCAPeiró-SignesASegarra-OñaM (2014) How fast do new hotels ramp up performance?Cornell Hospitality Quarterly55(2): 141–151.
27.
FangCHsuFS (2014) An efficiency-based metafrontier approach to menu analysis. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research38(2): 199–221.
FosterLHaltiwangerJSyversonC (2008) Reallocation, firm turnover, and efficiency: selection on productivity of profitability?The American Economic Review98(1): 394–425.
30.
FosterLHaltiwangerJSyversonC (2016) The slow growth of new plants: learning about demand?Economica83: 91–129.
31.
GiokasDEriotisNDokasI (2015) Efficiency and productivity of the food and beverage listed firms in the pre-recession and recessionary periods in Greece. Applied Economics47(19): 1927–1941.
32.
GreeneW (2005) Reconsidering heterogeneity in panel data estimators of the stochastic Frontier model. Journal of Econometrics126(2): 269–303.
33.
HottmanCJReddingSJWeinsteinDE (2016) Quantifying the sources of firm heterogeneity. Quarterly Journal of Economics131(3): 1291–1364.
34.
HumphreyDBPulleyLB (1997) Banks' responses to deregulation: profits, technology, and efficiency. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking29(1): 73–93.
35.
JohnsonJPMyattDP (2006) On the simple economics of advertising, marketing and product design. The American Economic Review96(3): 756–784.
36.
JondrowJKnox LovellCMaterovIS, et al. (1982) On the estimation of technical inefficiency in the stochastic Frontier production function model. Journal of Econometrics19: 233–238.
37.
KhanMA (2020) Technological disruptions in restaurant services: impact of innovations and delivery services. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research44(5): 715–732.
38.
KimJKimJWangY (2021) Uncertainty risks and strategic reaction of restaurant firms amid COVID-19: evidence from China. International Journal of Hospitality Management92: 102752.
39.
KivelaJCrottsJC (2006) Tourism and gastronomy: gastronomy's influence on how tourists experience a destination. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research30(3): 354–377.
40.
KohYRhouYLeeS, et al. (2018) Does franchising alleviate restaurants' vulnerability to economic conditions?Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research42(4): 627–648.
41.
KonishiH (2005) Concentration of competing retail stores. Journal of Urban Economics58: 488–512.
42.
KruegerAB (1991) Ownership, agency, and wages: an examination of franchising in the fast food industry. Quarterly Journal of Economics106(1): 75–101.
43.
KumbhakarSCLovellCAK (2003) Stochastic Frontier Analysis. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
44.
KumbhakarSCSunK (2013) Derivation of marginal effects of determinants of technical inefficiency. Economics Letters120: 249–253.
45.
KumbhakarSCWangHJHorncastleAP (2015) A Practitioner's Guide to Stochastic Frontier Analysis Using Stata. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
46.
LeeSHamSYeonJ, et al. (2024) ESG themes of the restaurant industry: a comparison between full-service and limited-service restaurants. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing41(1): 20–34.
47.
LiuHTsaiH (2021) A stochastic Frontier approach to assessing total factor productivity change in China's star-rated hotel industry. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research45(1): 109–132.
48.
MhlangaO (2018a) Drivers of restaurant efficiency in South África: a stochastic Frontier approach. International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research12(4): 407–419.
49.
MhlangaO (2018b) Factors impacting restaurant efficiency: a data envelopment analysis. Tourism Review73(1): 82–93.
50.
MohsinALenglerJ (2015) Exploring the antecedents of staff turnover within the fast-food industry: the case of Hamilton, New Zealand. Journal of Human Resources in Hospitality & Tourism14(1): 1–24.
51.
MunSGJangS (2015) Working capital, cash holding, and profitability of restaurant firms. International Journal of Hospitality Management48: 1–11.
52.
MunSGJangS (2018) Restaurant operating expenses and their effects on profitability enhancement. International Journal of Hospitality Management71: 68–76.
53.
MuziSJolevskiFUedaK, et al. (2023) Productivity and firm exit during the COVID-19 crisis: cross-country evidence. Small Business Economics60: 1719–1760.
54.
OliveiraRPedroMIMarquesRC (2013) Efficiency performance of the Algarve hotels using a revenue function. International Journal of Hospitality Management35: 59–67.
55.
PengHZhangJZhongS, et al. (2021) Corporate governance, technical efficiency and financial performance: evidence from Chinese listed tourism firms. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management48: 163–173.
56.
Pérez-RodríguezJVAcosta-GonzálezE (2007) Cost efficiency of the lodging industry in the tourist destination of Gran Canaria (Spain). Tourism Management28: 993–1005.
57.
PorettiCHeoCY (2022) COVID-19 and firm value drivers in the tourism industry. Annals of Tourism Research95: 103433.
58.
PorterME (1974) Consumer behavior, retailer power and market performance in consumer goods industries. The Review of Economics and Statistics56(4): 419–436.
59.
PrattSMcCabeSCortes-JimenezI, et al. (2010) Measuring the effectiveness of destination marketing campaigns: comparative analysis of conversion studies. Journal of Travel Research49(2): 179–190.
Restrepo-TobónDAKumbhakarSC (2017) A new method to decompose profit efficiency: an application to US commercial banks. Journal of Productivity Analysis48: 117–132.
62.
ReynoldsDThompsonGM (2007) Multiunit restaurant productivity assessment using three-phase data envelopment analysis. International Journal of Hospitality Management26: 20–32.
63.
RodgersSAssafA (2007) Quantitative methods in measuring productivity of foodservice systems. Journal of Foodservice Business Research9(1): 39–54.
64.
SanjeevGM (2007) Measuring efficiency of the hotel and restaurant sector: the case of India. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management19(5): 378–387.
SchiffN (2015) Cities and product variety: evidence from restaurants. Journal of Economic Geography15: 1085–1123.
67.
SongHYeonJLeeS (2021) Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic: evidence from the U.S. restaurant industry. International Journal of Hospitality Management92: 102702.
68.
SparksBBowenJKlagS (2003) Restaurants and the tourist market. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management15(1): 6–13.
69.
StelderD (2012) Spatial monopoly of multi-establishment firms: an empirical study for supermarkets in The Netherlands. Papers in Regional Science91(1): 181–193.
70.
SusskingAWillageBCawleyJ (2024) The impact of restaurant menu calorie labels on restaurant revenue and profit: evidence from a randomized controlled trial. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly65(2): 227–239.
71.
SveumMSykutaM (2019) The effect of franchising on establishment performance in the U.S. restaurant industry. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly60(2): 104–115.
72.
TürkcanKErkus-ÖztürkH (2020) The impact of economic and political crises on the survival of tourism-related firms: evidence from Antalya. Tourism Economics26(7): 1152–1174.
73.
UC (2023) Upplysningscentralen.
74.
VivasAL (1997) Profit efficiency for Spanish savings banks. European Journal of Operational Research98: 381–394.
75.
WangBWilliamsMDuarteF, et al. (2022) Demand for social interactions: evidence from the restaurant industry during the COVID-19 pandemic. Papers in Regional Science62: 830–857.
76.
WatermanD (1996) Local monopsony and free riders. Information Economics and Policy8(4): 337–355.
77.
WebbTMaJChengA (2023) Variable pricing in restaurant revenue management: a priority mixed bundle strategy. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly64(1): 22–33.
78.
YanBZhangXWuL, et al. (2020) Why do countries respond differently to COVID-19? A comparative study of Sweden, China, France, and Japan. The American Review of Public Administration50(6-7): 762–769.
79.
YangYCaoYYangLT (2017) Product diversification and property performance in the urban lodging market: the relationship and its moderators. Tourism Management59: 363–375.
80.
YangYLiuHChenX (2020) COVID-19 and restaurant demand: early effects of the pandemic and stay-at-home orders. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management32(12): 3809–3834.
81.
YostEKizildagMRidderstaatJ (2021) Financial recovery strategies for restaurants during COVID-19: evidence from the US restaurant industry. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management47: 408–412.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
