Limited research has addressed market structure and market power in the hospitality context. This study builds on the market structure literature by examining how market structure and power relate to and affect hotel properties’ price discrimination. We collected the published room rates of 583 hotels in Houston, Texas, in 2016 hotels.com. These dyadic price data captured booking windows with varied booking and check-in dates. Estimation results revealed two types of price discrimination, intertemporal and restriction-based, in the hotel industry. We confirmed that market structure and market power each played a role in such discrimination, with price discrimination being more intense in a more competitive market and among hotels with less market power. A sub-group analysis of hotels across different classes indicated heterogeneity in our results. Implications are provided for revenue managers and hotel investors to monitor market structure and power to design and manage proper pricing strategies.
AbrateGVigliaG (2016) Strategic and tactical price decisions in hotel revenue management. Tourism Management55: 123–132.
2.
AbrateGFraquelliGVigliaG (2012) Dynamic pricing strategies: evidence from European hotels. International Journal of Hospitality Management31: 160–168.
3.
AbrateGNicolauJLVigliaG (2019) The impact of dynamic price variability on revenue maximization. Tourism Management74: 224–233.
4.
AguilóEAlegreJSardM (2003) Examining the market structure of the German and UK Tour operating Industries through an analysis of Package holiday prices. Tourism Economics9: 255–278.
5.
AltinMChenC-CRiasiA, et al. (2022) Go moderate! How hotels' cancellation policies affect their financial performance. Tourism Economics29: 2165–2182.
6.
AngeliniFFiginiPLeoniV (2023) High tide, low price? Flooding alerts and hotel prices in Venice. Tourism Economics30: 876–899.
7.
Bárcena-MartínEBenítez-AuriolesBPérez-MorenoS (2022) Peer-to-peer accommodation prices: City listing concentration and host listing share. Tourism Economics29: 1499–1517.
8.
BergerAN (1995) The profit-structure relationship in banking--Tests of market-power and efficient-structure hypotheses. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking27: 404–431.
9.
BesbesOLobelI (2015) Intertemporal price discrimination: structure and computation of optimal policies. Management Science61: 92–110.
10.
BorgenNTHauptAWiborgØN (2023) Quantile regression estimands and models: revisiting the motherhood wage penalty debate. European Sociological Review39: 317–331.
11.
BrownJH (2002) Structure-conduct-perfonnance: a comment on Blaug's” is competition such a Good thing? Static efficiency versus dynamic efficiency. Review of Industrial Organization21: 103–105.
12.
CarltonDWPerloffJM (2005) Modern Industrial Organization. Boston, MA: Pearson/Addison Wesley.
13.
ChamberlinEH (1965) The Theory of Monopolistic Competition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
14.
ChangHHSokolDD (2022) How incumbents respond to competition from innovative disruptors in the sharing economy—the impact of Airbnb on hotel performance. Strategic Management Journal43: 425–446.
15.
ChenC-MChiuH-H (2014) Re-examining the market structure effects on hotel performance using market share inequality. International Journal of Hospitality Management41: 63–66.
16.
ChenC-FRothschildR (2010) An application of hedonic pricing analysis to the case of hotel rooms in Taipei. Tourism Economics16: 685–694.
17.
ChoiBPWeissMA (2005) An empirical investigation of market structure, efficiency, and performance in property‐liability insurance. Journal of Risk & Insurance72: 635–673.
18.
DaviesB (1999) Industrial organization the UK hotel sector. Annals of Tourism Research26: 294–311.
19.
DeLormeCDJrKleinPGKamerschenDR, et al. (2002) Structure, conduct and performance: a simultaneous equations approach. Applied Economics35: 13–20.
20.
DemsetzH (1973) Industry structure, market rivalry, and public policy. The Journal of Law and Economics16: 1–9.
21.
El-NemrNCanel-DepitreBTaghipourA (2020) The determinants of hotel room rates in Beirut: a hedonic pricing model. International Journal of Trade Economics and Finance12: 33–42.
22.
EllerbrockMJWellsGJ (1982) Tourist and commercial demand for hotel/motel services. The Review of Regional Studies12: 54–65.
23.
FalkMScaglioneM (2024) Effects of regulations on the Airbnb market in Geneva. Tourism Economics30: 615–632.
24.
FalkMVieruM (2019) Myth of early booking gains. Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management18: 52–64.
25.
FalkMTVieruM (2021) Short-term hotel room price effects of sporting events. Tourism Economics27: 569–588.
26.
FaulknerDOCampbellA (2006) The Oxford Handbook of Strategy: A Strategy Overview and Competitive Strategy. Oxford University Press.
27.
GémarGMonicheLMoralesAJ (2016) Survival analysis of the Spanish hotel industry. Tourism Management54: 428–438.
28.
HuXYangY (2021) Do lower costs necessarily induce higher value ratings? An analysis of online hotel reviews. Current Issues in Tourism24: 2357–2373.
29.
HuXYangYParkS (2019) A meta-regression on the effect of online ratings on hotel room rates. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management31: 4438–4461.
30.
JasjkoDHartmannMMiglavsA, et al. (1999) Industrial organisation of the food industry in Latvia: Results of an expert survey in the dairy and milling branches. Discussion paper No 22, Institute of agricultural development in Central and Eastern Europe.
31.
JiangY (2007) Price discrimination with opaque products. Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management6: 118–134.
32.
KaimakoudiEPolymerosKKarelakisC (2009) An investigation of the supply chain of fisheries products in Greece. Paper prepared for presentation at the 113th EAAE Seminar: A Resilient European Food Industry and Food Chain in a Challenging World. Chania, Crete, Greece.
33.
KimEJKimELKimM, et al. (2023) Post-Pandemic hotel cancellation policy: Situational cues as perceived risk triggers. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management55: 153–160.
34.
LeeSKJangS (2011) Room rates of U.S. airport hotels: examining the dual effects of proximities. Journal of Travel Research50: 186–197.
35.
LewisMS (2021) Identifying airline price discrimination and the effect of competition. International Journal of Industrial Organization78: 102761.
36.
LinS (2017) Add-on policies under vertical differentiation: why do luxury hotels charge for Internet while economy hotels do not?Marketing Science36: 610–625.
37.
Lloyd-WilliamsDMMolyneuxPThorntonJ (1994) Market structure and performance in Spanish banking. Journal of Banking & Finance18: 433–443.
38.
LopezEJ (2000) New anti-merger theories: a critique. Cato Journal20: 359–378.
39.
MasieroLYoonjoung HeoCPanB (2015) Determining guests’ willingness to pay for hotel room attributes with a discrete choice model. International Journal of Hospitality Management49: 117–124.
40.
NaminAGauriDKKwortnikRJ (2020) Improving revenue performance with third-degree price discrimination in the cruise industry. International Journal of Hospitality Management89: 102597.
41.
PanC-M (2005) Market structure and profitability in the international tourist hotel industry. Tourism Management26: 845–850.
42.
PanagiotouG (2006) The impact of managerial cognitions on the structure‐conduct‐performance (SCP) paradigm: a strategic group perspective. Management Decision44: 423–441.
43.
PeypochN (2022) Market behavior of tourism firms and its effects on the boundaries of firm. In: CROESRYANGY (eds) A Modern Guide to Tourism Economics. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
44.
PopeNMaYL (2008) The market structure–performance relationship in the international insurance sector. Journal of Risk & Insurance75: 947–966.
45.
RayMA (1992) Economic education, experimental methods and the structure-conduct-performance paradigm. The American Economist36: 66–71.
46.
RhoadesSA (1985) Market share as a source of market power: implications and some evidence. Journal of Economics and Business37: 343–363.
47.
RhoadesSA (1997) Research on IO topics in banking: an introduction and Overview. Review of Industrial Organization12: 1–8.
48.
RiasiASchwartzZChenC-C (2019) A paradigm shift in revenue management? The new landscape of hotel cancellation policies. Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management18: 434–440.
49.
RobinsonJ (1933) The Economics of Imperfect Competition. London: Macmillan.
50.
Sánchez-LozanoGPereiraLNChávez-MirandaE (2021) Big data hedonic pricing: econometric insights into room rates’ determinants by hotel category. Tourism Management85: 104308.
SheelA (2016) SCP-relevance and class-effect in performance–A comparative analysis of restaurants and petroleum firms. International Journal of Hospitality Management52: 33–45.
54.
ShepherdWG (1983). Economies of scale and Monopoly profits. In: CravenJV (ed.) Industrial Organization, Antitrust, and Public Policy. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.
55.
SolerIPGemarGCorreiaMB, et al. (2019) Algarve hotel price determinants: a hedonic pricing model. Tourism Management70: 311–321.
56.
SongHDwyerLLiG, et al. (2012) Tourism economics research: a review and assessment. Annals of Tourism Research39: 1653–1682.
57.
StavinsJ (2001) Price discrimination in the airline market: the effect of market concentration. The Review of Economics and Statistics83: 200–202.
58.
StiglerGJ (1964) A theory of oligopoly. Journal of Political Economy72: 44–61.
59.
VivesAJacobM (2019) Dynamic pricing in different Spanish resort hotels. Tourism Economics27: 398–411.
60.
VivesAOstrovskayaL (2024) Exploring the impact of hotel attributes and services on price and revenue: a hedonic pricing model approach with a focus on internal and external segmentation and repeat customers. Tourism Economics30: 813–843.
61.
VivesAJacobMPayerasM (2018) Revenue management and price optimization techniques in the hotel sector: a critical literature review. Tourism Economics24: 720–752.
62.
WangDNicolauJL (2017) Price determinants of sharing economy based accommodation rental: a study of listings from 33 cities on Airbnb. com. International Journal of Hospitality Management62: 120–131.
63.
WebbTSchwartzZXiangZ, et al. (2022) Hotel revenue management forecasting accuracy: the hidden impact of booking windows. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Insights5: 950–965.
64.
WebsterAL (1996) The concentration-profitability relationship in American industry: a varying parameters model. Journal of Applied Business Research12: 44–52.
65.
YangYJiangL (2022) Who uses travel websites? A comparison of demand across websites. Journal of Smart Tourism2: 31–38.
66.
YangYLeungXY (2018) A better last-minute hotel deal via app? Cross-channel price disparities between HotelTonight and OTAs. Tourism Management68: 198–209.
67.
YangYMaoZ (2017) Do independent hotels benefit from the presence of branded ones?Journal of Business Research76: 108–117.
68.
YangYJiangLSchwartzZ (2019) Who’s hiding? Room rate discounts in opaque distribution channels. International Journal of Hospitality Management80: 113–122.
69.
YangYJiangLWangY (2023) Why do hotels go green? Understanding TripAdvisor GreenLeaders participation. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management35: 1670–1690.
