The agglomeration of the tourism industry has important effects on its efficiency. This article used panel data on the Chinese provincial tourism industry for the 2011–2016 period, applied the location quotient index and three-stage data envelopment analysis method to, respectively, measure the degree of agglomeration and efficiency, and explained the impact of agglomeration on tourism efficiency. The empirical results of this study indicate the following. (1) China’s tourism industry shows a trend towards agglomeration, revealing gradient differences where the highest degree of agglomeration is in the eastern region, followed by the western and central regions. (2) After eliminating random and environmental factors, the adjusted efficiencies are lower than the unadjusted efficiencies. The average overall tourism efficiency is higher in the eastern region than in the central and western regions. (3) From the national perspective, industrial agglomeration can significantly improve the overall efficiency (TE), pure technical efficiency (PTE), and scale efficiency of the tourism industry. (4) Based on regional analysis, the agglomeration of the eastern tourism industry can significantly enhance its TE and PTE. Agglomeration for the western area has a significant positive impact on PTE. There is no significant relationship between agglomeration and efficiency in the central region.
Alzua-SorzabalAZurutuzaMRebónF, et al. (2015) Obtaining the efficiency of tourism destination website based on data envelopment analysis. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences175: 58–65.
2.
Arbelo-PerezMArbeloAPerez-GomezP (2017) Impact of quality on estimations of hotel efficiency. Tourism Management61: 200–208.
3.
AssafAGJosiassenA (2012) European vs. U.S. airlines: performance comparison in a dynamic market. Tourism Management33: 317–326.
4.
BalaguerJPerníasJC (2013) Relationship between spatial agglomeration and hotel prices. Evidence from business and tourism consumers. Tourism Management36: 391–400.
5.
BannisterGJStolpC (2007) Regional concentration and efficiency in Mexican manufacturing. European Journal of Operational Research80: 672–690.
6.
BaoJMaX (2009) Evaluating the using efficiencies of Chinese national parks with DEA. Geographical Research28: 838–848.
7.
BarrosCP (2005) Evaluating the efficiency of a small hotel chain with a Malmquist productivity index. International Journal of Tourism Research7: 173–184.
8.
BarrosCPMatiasL (2010) Assessing the efficiency of travel agencies with a stochastic cost frontier: a Portuguese case study. International Journal of Tourism Research8: 367–379.
9.
BingDXiYBihuW (2004) Tourism industry cluster and its influential factors. Journal of Guilin Institute of Tourism15: 53–57.
10.
BoschmaR (2005) Proximity and innovation: a critical assessment. Regional Studies39: 61–74.
11.
BoschmaRATer WalAL (2007) Knowledge networks and innovative performance in an industrial district: the case of a footwear district in the South of Italy. Industry and Innovation14: 177–199.
12.
BreuschTSPaganAR (1980) The Lagrange multiplier test and its applications to model specification in econometrics. The Review of Economic Studies47: 239–253.
13.
BroersmaLOosterhavenJ (2010) Regional labor productivity in the Netherlands: evidence of agglomeration and congestion effects. Journal of Regional Science49: 483–511.
14.
CaoFHuangZXuM, et al. (2015) Spatial-temporal pattern and influencing factors of tourism efficiency and the decomposition efficiency in Chinese scenic areas: based on the Bootstrap-DEA method. Geographical Research34: 2395–2408.
15.
CaponeF (2015) Tourist Clusters, Destinations and Competitiveness: Theoretical issues and empirical evidences. Routledge.
16.
ChaabouniS (2018) China’s regional tourism efficiency: a two-stage double bootstrap data envelopment analysis. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management11: 183–191.
17.
ChaabouniS (2019) China’s regional tourism efficiency: a two-stage double bootstrap data envelopment analysis. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management11: 183–191.
18.
FangYWangF (2019) The Measurement and optimization of provincial tourism efficiency considering environment variables in Mainland China: from the perspective of regional economy and traffic location. Tourism and Hospitality Prospects3: 40–53.
19.
FengW (2009) An analysis on the motivation of the tourism industry agglomeration. On Economic Problems7: 114–116.
20.
FernandesEPachecoRR (2002) Efficient use of airport capacity. Transportation Research Part A36: 225–238.
21.
FriedHOLovellCKSchmidtSS, et al. (2002) Accounting for environmental effects and statistical noise in data envelopment analysis. Journal of Productivity Analysis17: 157–174.
22.
FriedHOSchmidtSSYaisawarngS (1999) Incorporating the operating environment into a nonparametric measure of technical efficiency. Journal of Productivity Analysis12: 249–267.
23.
García-VillaverdePMElcheDMartínez-PérezÁ (2020) Understanding pioneering orientation in tourism clusters: market dynamism and social capital. Tourism Management76: 103966.
24.
GongWZhaoY (2008) Analysis of the spatial agglomeration degree of China’s tourism industry. Jiangsu Commercial Forum 7: 70–72.
25.
GuoYTongLMeiL (2020) The effect of industrial agglomeration on green development efficiency in Northeast China since the revitalization. Journal of Cleaner Production258: 120584.
26.
GuoYZhongTAnY (2015) The effects of agglomeration on the total factor productivity of China’s tourism industry: an empirical study based on China’s provincial panel data. Tourism Tribune30: 14–22.
27.
HausmanJA (1978) Specification tests in econometrics. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society 46: 1251–1271.
28.
HooverEMHarrisSEHarrisCD. (1963) The Location of Economic Activity: New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
29.
IammarinoSMcCannP (2006) The structure and evolution of industrial clusters: transactions, technology and knowledge spillovers. Research Policy35: 1018–1036.
30.
JacksonJMurphyP (2002) Tourism destinations as clusters: analytical experiences from the New World. Tourism and Hospitality Research4: 36–52.
31.
JinCChenHSongG (2012) Research on the evaluation of China’s efficiency of regional tourism industry based on three-stage DEA model. Tourism Tribune 27: 56–65.
32.
KimNShimC. (2018) Social capital, knowledge sharing and innovation of small-and medium-sized enterprises in a tourism cluster. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management30(5): 2417–2437.
33.
KimYRWilliamsAMParkS, et al. (2020) Spatial spillovers of agglomeration economies and productivity in the tourism industry: the case of the UK. Tourism Management82: 104201.
34.
KonstantakisKNSoklisGMichaelidesPG (2017) Tourism expenditures and crisis transmission: a general equilibrium GVAR analysis with network theory. Annals of Tourism Research66: 74–94.
35.
LeeY-JAJangSKimJ (2020) Tourism clusters and peer-to-peer accommodation. Annals of Tourism Research83: 102960.
36.
LiRGuoQWuD, et al. (2014) Spatial characteristics of development efficiency for urban tourism in eastern China: a case study of six coastal urban agglomerations. Journal of Geographical Sciences24: 1175–1197.
37.
LiSXingFZhangL (2017) The influence of tourism industrial agglomeration on the regional tourism industry efficiency—a panel data analysis of provinces in China. World Regional Studies26: 134–146.
38.
LiuJLuJLiuN (2015) Space-time evolution, influencing factors and forming mechanisms of tourism industry’s efficiency in China’s coastal area of based on DEA-Malmquist model. Resources Science37: 2381–2393.
39.
LiuJZhangJFuZ (2017) Tourism eco-efficiency of Chinese coastal cities—analysis based on the DEA-Tobit model. Ocean & Coastal Management148: 164–170.
40.
LuoD (2012) Notes on inefficiency estimation of three-stage DEA model management. Statistical Research29: 104–107.
41.
MaXJinY (2015) The efficiency characteristics and evolution mode of Zhangjiajie Urban tourism development. Tourism Tribune30: 24–32.
42.
MajewskaJ (2017) GPS-based measurement of geographic spillovers in tourism—example of Polish districts. Tourism Geographies19: 612–643.
43.
MariottiSPiscitelloLEliaS (2010) Spatial agglomeration of multinational enterprises: the role of information externalities and knowledge spillovers. Journal of Economic Geography10: 519–538.
44.
MarshallA (1961) Principles of Economics: An Introductory Volume. London: Macmillan.
45.
MarshallA. (1992) The Principles of Economics. History of Economic Thought Books. London: Macmillan and Company.
46.
MontfortKVMasurelERijnIV (2000) Service satisfaction: an empirical analysis of consumer satisfaction in financial services. Service Industries Journal20: 80–94.
47.
NovelliMSchmitzBSpencerT (2006) Networks, clusters and innovation in tourism: a UK experience. Tourism Management27: 1141–1152.
48.
PengHZhangJLuL, et al. (2017) Eco-efficiency and its determinants at a tourism destination: a case study of Huangshan National Park, China. Tourism Management60: 201–211.
49.
PorterME. (1998) Clusters and the New Economics of Competition. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Review.
50.
QuCShaoJShiZ (2020) Does financial agglomeration promote the increase of energy efficiency in China?Energy Policy146: 111810.
51.
Ramírez-HurtadoJMContrerasI. (2017) Efficiency of travel agency franchises: a study in Spain. Service Business11: 717–739.
52.
RochaHO (2004) Entrepreneurship and development: the role of clusters. Small Business Economics23: 363–400.
53.
RosenfeldSA (1997) Bringing business clusters into the mainstream of economic development. European Planning Studies5: 3–23.
54.
RosenthalSSStrangeWC (2004) Evidence on the nature and sources of agglomeration economies. In Handbook of Regional and Urban Economic (Vol. 4, pp. 2119–2171). Elsevier.
55.
ScholochowCFuchsMHpkenW. (2010) ICT efficiency and effectiveness in the hotel sector—a three-stage DEA approach. Information & Communication Technologies in Tourism, Enter, International Conference in Lugano, Switzerland, 10–12 February.
56.
Sellers-RubioRCasado-DíazAB (2018) Analyzing hotel efficiency from a regional perspective: the role of environmental determinants. International Journal of Hospitality Management75: 75–85.
57.
ShiCZhangJShenZ, et al. (2005) Review of the studies on the tourism spatial competition and cooperation. Geography and Geo-Information Science21: 85–89.
58.
SongMLiH (2019) Estimating the efficiency of a sustainable Chinese tourism industry using bootstrap technology rectification. Technological Forecasting and Social Change143: 45–54.
59.
SurugiuCLeitãoNCSurugiuMR (2011) A panel data modelling of international tourism demand: evidences for Romania. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja24: 134–145.
60.
TanakaKManagiS. (2017) Analysis of energy use efficiency in Japanese factories: industry agglomeration effect for energy efficiency. Working Papers. https://ideas.repec.org/p/kch/wpaper/sdes-2017-3.html.
61.
UNWTO. (2019) International Tourism Highlights 2019 Edition. Madrid, Spain: UNWTO.
62.
UrtasunAGutiérrezI (2006) Tourism agglomeration and its impact on social welfare: an empirical approach to the Spanish case. Tourism Management27: 901–912.
63.
WangKHuangZCaoF, et al. (2016a) Spatial pattern evolution of urban tourism performance and its influence factors in Pan-Yangtze River Delta. Journal of Natural Resources31: 1149–1163.
64.
WangKYiJXiaoY, et al. (2016b) The correlation between tourism agglomeration and industrial efficiency in China. Human Geography31: 120–127.
65.
WangMLiuYLiT (2019a) The differential impact of tourism industrial agglomeration on environmental pollution: empirical evidence from 287 cities. Reform 2: 102–114.
66.
WangXZhuWLuX, et al. (2019b) Spatial-temporal evolution and relationship between tourism industrial agglomeration and efficiency in China’s coastal provinces: an analysis based on 114 cities with PVAR model. Journal of Ocean University of China(Social Sciences)5: 81–95.
67.
WangYSunCJiangJ (2016c) Research on efficiency and empirical of cultural tourism in Gansu province—based on three stage data envelopment analysis model. Resource Development & Market32: 125–128.
68.
WangZHuoF (2018) Measurement of the relationship between tourism industrial cluster and regional economic development in Wuling mountain area. Areal Research and Development37: 94–98.
69.
WangZLiuQXuJ, et al. (2020) Evolution characteristics of the spatial network structure of tourism efficiency in China: a province-level analysis. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management18: 100509.
70.
XieM (2019) Research on tourism efficiency of south Anhui international cultural tourism demonstration zone based on DEA-MI model. Journal of Anqing Normal University(Natural Science Edition)25: 25–29.
71.
XuDHuangZHuX, et al. (2018) The spatial pattern evolution and its influencing factors of county-scale tourism efficiency in Zhejiang province. Economic Geography38: 197–207.
72.
YangY (2011) Specialization, diversification and tourism development: an empirical research based on Chinese current statistical data. Economic Review168: 119–128.
73.
YangY (2012) Agglomeration density and tourism development in China: an empirical research based on dynamic panel data model. Tourism Management33: 1347–1359.
74.
YangR (2013) Industrial Agglomeration and Regional Wage Gap: An Empirical Study Based on 269 Cities in my country. Management World8: 41–52.
75.
YangY (2016) Agglomeration density and labor productivity in China’s tourism industry. International Journal of Tourism Research18: 434–446.
76.
YuanHFengYLeeC-C, et al. (2020) How does manufacturing agglomeration affect green economic efficiency?Energy Economics92: 104944.
77.
ZhangCXiaoHGursoyD, et al. (2015) Tacit knowledge spillover and sustainability in destination development. Journal of Sustainable Tourism23: 1029–1048.
78.
ZhangG (2005) Evaluation of the operational efficiency of tourism in Jiangxi province: enlightenment from comparison. Statistics & Decision 5: 81–84.
79.
ZhangLQuBYangY (2006) A new way to upgrade the competence of hospitality industry: cluster development. Tourism Tribune21: 55–59.
80.
ZhangLWuY-Q (2013) The evolution and formation mechanism of mice tourism cluster in Guangzhou. Human Geography2: 111–116+153.
81.
ZhaoHLinB (2019) Will agglomeration improve the energy efficiency in China’s textile industry: evidence and policy implications. Applied Energy237: 326–337.
82.
ZhaoL (2013) Can tourism industry agglomeration affect regional income gap? Based on threshold regression analysis of provincial panel data in China. Tourism Science3: 22–41.
83.
ZhaoLDongY (2017) Tourism agglomeration and urbanization: empirical evidence from China. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research22: 512–523.
84.
ZhengQLinB. (2018) Impact of industrial agglomeration on energy efficiency in China’s paper industry. Journal of Cleaner Production184: 1072–1080.
85.
ZhouBQuHLiN (2016) How tourist attraction agglomeration affects a regional tourism economy. Tourism Analysis21: 603–616.
86.
ZhouBXuYLeeSK (2019a) Tourism development and regional production efficiency: evidence from southwestern China. Tourism Economics25: 800–818.
87.
ZhouJJiangZLiF (2019b) The impact of tourism industry agglomeration on the efficiency of green economy: an empirical research based on provincial panel data. Ecological Economy35: 122–128.
88.
ZuoBBaoJ (2008) Tourism total factor productivity and its regional variation in China from 1992 to 2005. Acta Geographica Sinica63(4): 417–427.
