Economic impact of low-cost carrier in a saturated transport market: Net benefits or zero-sum game?

Abstract

The introduction of low-cost carriers (LCCs) can improve the accessibility of destinations, stimulate suppressed demand, and offer transportation attractive to lower income residents. This present study estimates the economic contribution of the entry of an additional LCC into a mature transport market. Both primary and secondary data are used to estimate both direct and indirect economic impacts to the host economy. This research framework captures both displacement effects and the demand for an additional LCC among domestic travelers leaving the destination. Taking these effects into account, there is limited net economic contribution to the host economy with a mature transport market. Based on these findings, local governments as well as aviation policymakers are advised to consider all the economic injections and leakages created by the potential LCC in assessing the economic feasibility of new entrants, especially considering the development stage of a transport market.

Keywords

displacement growth saturation hub airport input–output model leisure tourism low-cost carrier mature market

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ACI Europe (1998) Creating Employment and Prosperity in Europe. A Study of the Social and Economic Impacts of Airports. Brussels: Airport Council International Europe.

ACI Europe (2004) The Social and Economic Impact of Airports in Europe. Brussels: Airport Council International Europe.

Aguiar

Narayanan

McDougall

(2016) An overview of the GTAP 9 data base. Journal of Global Economic Analysis 1(1): 181–208.

Aguiló

Rey

Rosselló

. (2007) The impact of the post-liberalisation growth of LCCs on the tourism trends in Spain. Rivista di Politica Economica 97(1/2): 39–60.

Allroggen

Wittman

Malina

(2015) How air transport connects the world–A new metric of air connectivity and its evolution between 1990 and 2012. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review 80: 184–201.

Barrett

(2004) How do the demands for airport services differ between full-service carriers and low-cost carriers? Journal of Air Transport Management 10(1): 33–39.

Bieger

Wittmer

(2006) Air transport and tourism—Perspectives and challenges for destinations, airlines and governments. Journal of Air Transport Management 12(1): 40–46.

Blume

(2006) Business Airlines Take Off in Asia. Voice of America. Available at: https://www.voanews.com/a/a-13-2006-02-19-voa12/326801.html (accessed 28 January 2007).

Bowen

(2000) Airline hubs in Southeast Asia: National economic development and nodal accessibility. Journal of Transport Geography 8(1): 25–41.

10.

Brueckner

(2003) Airline traffic and urban economic development. Urban Studies 40(8): 1455–1469.

11.

Button

Lall

Stough

. (1999) High-technology employment and hub airports. Journal of Air Transport Management 5(1): 53–59.

12.

Button

Taylor

(2000) International air transportation and economic development. Journal of Air Transport Management 6(4): 209–222.

13.

Cho

Jeong

(2006) Measuring the potentials of low-fare airlines in Korea via price elasticity of air demand. The Korean Transport Policy Review 13(1): 185–199.

14.

Chung

Whang

(2011) The impact of low cost carriers on Korean Island tourism. Journal of Transport Geography 19(6): 1335–1340.

15.

Civil Aviation Authority (UK) (2006) No-Frills Carriers: Revolution or Evolution, CAP770. London: CAA.

16.

Clavé

Saladié

Cortés-Jiménez

. (2015) How different are tourists who decide to travel to a mature destination because of the existence of a low-cost carrier route? Journal of Air Transport Management 42: 213–218.

17.

Cooper

(1990) Airports and economic development: An overview. Transportation Research Record 1274: 125–133.

18.

Cracolici

Nijkamp

(2009) The attractiveness and competitiveness of tourist destinations: A study of Southern Italian regions. Tourism Management 30(3): 336–344.

19.

Dobruszkes

(2013) The geography of European low-cost airline networks: A contemporary analysis. Journal of Transport Geography 28: 75–88.

20.

Dobruszkes

Mondou

(2013) Aviation liberalization as a means to promote international tourism: The EU–Morocco case. Journal of Air Transport Management 29: 23–34.

21.

Doganis

(2001) The Airline Business in the 21st Century. London: Routledge.

22.

Donzelli

(2010) The effect of low-cost air transportation on the local economy: Evidence from Southern Italy. Journal of Air Transport Management 16(3): 121–126.

23.

Dresner

Lin

JSC

Windle

(1996) The impact of low-cost carriers on airport and route competition. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 30: 309–328.

24.

Dunleavy

Westermann

(2005) Future of airline revenue management. Journal of Revenue & Pricing Management 3(4): 380–383.

25.

Duval

(2008) Regulation, competition and the politics of air access across the Pacific. Journal of Air Transport Management 14(5): 237–242.

26.

Forsyth

(2003) Low-cost carriers in Australia: Experiences and impacts. Journal of Air Transport Management 9(5): 277–284.

27.

Francis

Fidato

Humphreys

(2003) Airport–airline interaction: The impact of low-cost carriers on two European airports. Journal of Air Transport Management 9(4): 267–273.

28.

Francis

Humphreys

Ison

. (2006) Where next for low cost airlines? A spatial and temporal comparative study. Journal of Transport Geography 14(2): 83–94.

29.

Franke

(2004) Competition between network carriers and low-cost carriers—retreat battle or breakthrough to a new level of efficiency? Journal of Air Transport Management 10(1): 15–21.

30.

Graham

(2003) Managing Airports: An International Perspective. Oxford: Elsevier.

31.

Graham

Dennis

(2010) The impact of low cost airline operations to Malta. Journal of Air Transport Management 16(3): 127–136.

32.

Green

(2007) Airports and economic development. Real Estate Economics 35(1): 91–112.

33.

Gutschi

(2007) Air Canada fliers buy the extras. Wall Street Journal. Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB117513422473552799 (accessed 21 August 2007).

34.

Goetz

Graham

(2004) Air transport globalization, liberalization and sustainability: Post-2001 policy dynamics in the United States and Europe. Journal of Transport Geography 12(4): 265–276.

35.

Hong Kong Tourism Board (2013) A statistical review of Hong Kong tourism 2012. Available at: http://securepartnernet.hktb.com/filemanager/intranet/ir/ResearchStatistics/paper/Stat-Review/Stat_Review2012/stat_review_2012_2.pdf (accessed 25 September2013).

36.

Hong Kong Tourism Board (2017) A statistical review of Hong Kong tourism 2016. Available at: http://securepartnernet.hktb.com/filemanager/intranet/ir/ResearchStatistics/paper/Stat-Review/StatReview2016/Stat%20Review%202016.pdf (accessed 21 August2017).

37.

Hooper

(1997) Liberalising competition in domestic airline markets in Asia—The problematic interface between domestic and international regulatory policies. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review 33(3): 197–209.

38.

Hooper

(1998) Airline competition and deregulation in developed and developing country contexts—Australia and India. Journal of Transport Geography 6(2): 105–116.

39.

Jiang

(2016) Hong Kong has an aviation labor shortage because companies don’t pay enough – except for pilots. China Aviation Daily, 08 July, 2018.

40.

Klophaus

Conrady

Fichert

(2012) Low cost carriers going hybrid: Evidence from Europe. Journal of Air Transport Management 23: 54–58.

41.

Lawton

Solomko

(2005) When being the lowest cost is not enough: Building a successful low-fare airline business model in Asia. Journal of Air Transport Management 11(6): 355–362.

42.

Lei

Papatheodorou

(2010) Measuring the effect of low-cost carriers on regional airports’ commercial revenue. Research in Transportation Economics 26(1): 37–43.

43.

Lian

Denstadli

(2010) Booming leisure air travel to Norway–the role of airline competition. Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism 10(1): 1–15.

44.

Mason

Alamdari

(2007) EU network carriers, low cost carriers and consumer behaviour: A Delphi study of future trends. Journal of Air Transport Management 13(5): 299–310.

45.

Miller

Blair

(2009) Input-Output Analysis: Foundations and Extensions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

46.

Morrell

(2005) Airlines within airlines: An analysis of US network airline responses to low cost carriers. Journal of Air Transport Management 11(5): 303–312.

47.

NFO (2002) Monitor Group Analysis, Hapag Lloyd. In: The Future of Air Travel Conference, London, 2002.

48.

O’Connell

Williams

(2005) Passengers’ perceptions of low cost airlines and full service carriers: A case study involving Ryanair, Aer Lingus, Air Asia and Malaysia Airlines. Journal of Air Transport Management 11(4): 259–272.

49.

Pantazis

Liefner

(2006) The impact of low-cost carriers on catchment areas of established international airports: The case of Hanover Airport, Germany. Journal of Transport Geography 14(4): 265–272.

50.

Page

Connell

(2009) Tourism: A Modern Synthesis. Andover: Cengage Learning EMEA.

51.

Papatheodorou

Lei

(2006) Leisure travel in Europe and airline business models: A study of regional airports in Great Britain. Journal of Air Transport Management 12(1): 47–52.

52.

Percoco

(2010) Airport activity and local development: Evidence from Italy. Urban Studies 47(11): 2427–2443.

53.

Pratt

McCabe

Cortes-Jimenez

. (2009) Measuring the effectiveness of destination marketing campaigns: Comparative analysis of conversion studies. Journal of Travel Research 49(2): 179–190.

54.

Prideaux

Whyte

(2014) Implications for destinations when low-cost carrier operations are disrupted: The case of tiger Airlines Australia. In: Joseph

(ed) Advances in Hospitality and Leisure. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp. 99–118.

55.

Rey

Myro

Galera

(2011) Effect of low-cost airlines on tourism in Spain. A dynamic panel data model. Journal of Air Transport Management 17(3): 163–167.

56.

Robertson

(1995) Airports and economic regeneration. Journal of Air Transport Management 2(2): 81–88.

57.

Ryan

Birks

(2006) Passengers and low cost flights: Evidence from the Trans-Tasman routes. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing 19(1): 15–27.

58.

Samonte

Amojelar

(2006) Government welcomes more budget airlines to meet tourism targets. The Manila Times, 27 January, 2007.

59.

Sarker

MAR

Hossan

Zaman

(2012) Sustainability and growth of low cost airlines: An industry analysis in global perspective. American Journal of Business and Management 1(3): 162–171.

60.

Skeels

(2005) Is airport growth a necessity or a luxury? Overall view of market growth. Munich: Report Presented to ACI Annual Congress.

61.

Taneja

(2017) Simpli-Flying: Optimizing the Airline Business Model. Abingdon: Routledge.

62.

Tretheway

(2004) Distortions of airline revenues: Why the network airline business model is broken. Journal of Air Transport Management 10(1): 3–14.

63.

Tsui

KWH

(2017) Does a low-cost carrier lead the domestic tourism demand and growth of New Zealand? Tourism Management 60: 390–403.

64.

Vuthisopon

Srinuan

(2017) Low-cost carrier passenger repurchase intention: A structural equation model analysis. Asia-Pacific Social Science Review 17(2): 249–266.