There is an ongoing debate on how political parties that form coalition governments keep tabs on each other during the drafting and negotiation of new bills. Our article complements existing studies focused on the parliamentary stage of law-making by enriching current knowledge with an analysis of the executive phase, where bills may be significantly changed before they are submitted to the legislature. Contrary to theoretical expectations, results based on unique data from the Czech Republic reveal that bills which are heavily altered during the executive phase are subsequently significantly changed in the parliament. Additional interaction models indicate the effect is stronger for bills that are highly significant for the proposing minister and are a greater distance from any coalition compromise. Our findings open the question of why the coalition parties leave the resolution of some controversial issues to the parliamentary phase: the outstanding conflict may be genuine, or the coalition MPs may just be playing out a prearranged and staged battle that enables the coalition partners to show their distinctive qualities to the voters.
AndewegRBTimmermansA (2008) Cabinets and Coalition Bargaining: The Democratic Life Cycle in Western Europe. In: StrømKMüllerWCBergmanT (eds), Conflict management in coalition government. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 269–300.
2.
AndréADepauwSMartinS (2016) “Trust is good, control is better”. Political Research Quarterly69(1): 108–120.
3.
BäckHDebusMDumontP (2011) Who gets what in coalition governments? Predictors of portfolio allocation in parliamentary democracies. European Journal of Political Research50(4): 441–478.
4.
BrunnerM (2013) Parliaments and Legislative Activity. Wiesbaden: Springer. VS
5.
BrunclíkMKubátM (2016) The Czech parliamentary regime after 1989: Origins, developments and challenges. Acta Politologica8(1): 5–29.
6.
BerryWDGolderMMiltonD (2012) Improving tests of theories positing interaction. The Journal of Politics74(3): 653–671.
7.
CarrollRCoxGW (2012) Shadowing ministers. Comparative Political Studies45(2): 220–236.
8.
De WildeP (2014) The operating logics of national parliaments and mass media in the politicisation of Europe. The Journal of Legislative Studies20(1): 46–61.
9.
DixonRMJonesJA (2019) Mapping mutations in legislation: a bioinformatics approach. Parliamentary Affairs72(1): 21–41.
10.
FishSMKroenigM (2009) The Handbook of National Legislatures: A Global Survey. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
FortunatoDMartinLWVanbergG (2019) Committee chairs and legislative review in parliamentary democracies. British Journal of Political Science49(2): 785–797.
12.
GavaRJaquetJMSciariniP (2021) Legislating or rubber‐stamping? Assessing parliament's influence on law‐making with text reuse. European Journal of Political Research60(1): 175–198.
13.
GelmanA (2008) Scaling regression inputs by dividing by two standard deviations. Statistics in Medicine (27): 2865–2873.
14.
GiannettiDPintoLPedrazzaniA (2015) Setting parliamentary calendars: how parties allocate time for plenary debates on bills. Political Studies64(4): 1016–1035.
15.
HallerbergM (2004) Patterns of Parliamentary Behavior. In: DöringHHallerbergM (eds), Electoral Laws, Government. Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 11–33.
16.
HöhmannDSiebererU (2020) Parliamentary questions as a control mechanism in coalition governments. West European Politics43(1): 225–249.
17.
IndridasonIHKristinssonGH (2013) Making words count: coalition agreements and cabinet management. European Journal of Political Research52(6): 822–846.
18.
IndridasonIHKristinssonGH (2018) The role of parliament under ministerial government. Icelandic Review of Politics and Administration14(1): 149–166.
19.
KimD-HLoewenbergG (2005) The role of parliamentary committees in coalition governments. Comparative Political Studies38(9): 1104–1129.
20.
KraussS (2018) Stability through control? The influence of coalition agreements on the stability of coalition cabinets. West European Politics41(6): 1282–1304.
21.
LaverMShepsleKA (1996) Making and Breaking Governments. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22.
LaverMSchofieldN (1998) Multiparty Government: The Politics of Coalitions in Europe. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
23.
LipsmeyerCSPierceHN (2011) The eyes that bind: junior ministers as oversight mechanisms in coalition governments. The Journal of Politics73: 1152–1164.
24.
MartinLWVanbergG (2004) Policing the Bargain: coalition government and parliamentary scrutiny. American Journal of Political Science48(1): 13–27.
25.
MartinLWVanbergG (2005) Coalition policymaking and legislative review. American Political Science Review99(1): 93–106.
26.
MartinLWVanbergG (2011) Parliaments and Coalitions: The Role of Legislative Institutions in Multiparty Governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
27.
MartinLWVanbergG (2014) Parties and policymaking in multiparty governments: the legislative median, ministerial autonomy, and the coalition compromise. American Journal of Political Science58(4): 979–996.
28.
MartinLWVanbergG (2020) Coalition government, legislative institutions, and public policy in parliamentary democracies. American Journal of Political Science64: 325–340.
29.
McDonaldMBudgeI (2005) Elections, Parties, Democracy: Conferring the Median Mandate. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
30.
MüllerWCMeyerTM (2010) Meeting the challenges of representation and accountability in multi-party governments. West European Politics33(5): 1065–1092.
31.
MüllerWCPhilippWGerlichP (1993) Governing together. In: BlondelJMüller-RommelF (eds), Prime Ministers and Cabinet Decision-Making Processes. New York: St. Martin’s Press, pp. 223–256.
32.
MüllerWCStrømK (eds), (2000) Coalition governments in Western Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
MüllerWCStrømK (2008). Cabinets and Coalition Bargaining: The Democratic Life Cycle in Western Europe. In: StrømKMüllerWCTorbjörnB (eds), Coalition Agreements and Cabinet Governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 159–199.
34.
OlsonDMNortonP (1996) Legislatures in democratic transition. The Journal of Legislative Studies2(1): 1–15.
35.
PedrazzaniAZucchiniF (2013) Horses and hippos: Why Italian government bills change in the legislative arena, 1987–2006. European Journal of Political Research52(5): 687–714.
36.
PoguntkeTWebbP (2005) The Presidentialization of Politics: A Comparative Study of Modern Democracies. In: PoguntkeTWebbP (eds), The Presidentialization of Contemporary Democratic Politics: Evidence, causes, consequences. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 336–356.
37.
PolkJRovnyJBakkerR, et al (2017) Explaining the salience of anti-elitism and reducing political corruption for political parties in Europe with the 2014 Chapel Hill Expert Survey data.Research & Politics: 1–9.
38.
ProkschS-OSlapinJB (2012) Institutional foundations of legislative speech. American Journal of Political Science56: 520–537.
39.
RauhC (2015) Communicating supranational governance? The salience of EU affairs in the German Bundestag, 1991-2013. European Union Politics16(1): 116–138.
40.
ShepsleKA (2010) Analyzing Politics. New York: Norton.
41.
SiebererUHöhmannD (2017) Shadow chairs as monitoring device? A comparative analysis of committee chair powers in Western European parliaments. The Journal of Legislative Studies23(3): 301–325.
42.
StromKMüllerCMSmithDM (2010) Parliamentary control of coalition governments. Annual Review of Political Science13: 517–535.
43.
ThiesMF (2001) Keeping tabs on partners: the logic of delegation in coalition governments. American Journal of Political Science45(3): 580–598.
44.
TsebelisG (1995) Decision making in political systems: veto players in presidentialism, parliamentarism, multicameralism and multipartyism. British Journal of Political Science25(3): 289–325.
45.
ZbíralR (2015) Changing investiture rules in the Czech Republic. In: RaschBEMartinSCheibuJA (eds), Parliaments and Government Formation: Unpacking Investiture Rules. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 182–196.
46.
ZbíralR (2020a). Legislation in the Czech Republic. In: XanthakiHKarpenU (eds) Legislation in Europe: A Country by Country Guide, Oxford: Hart Publishing, pp. 119–136.
47.
ZbíralR (ed), (2020b). The Cradle of Laws: Drafting and Negotiating Bills within the Executives in Central Europe. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
48.
ZbíralR (2017) Comparing the intensity of scrutiny for “domestic” and implementing bills: does transposition of EU law reduce political contestation in national parliaments?Journal of European Public Policy24(7): 969–988.
49.
ZubekRKlüverH (2015) Legislative pledges and coalition government. Party Politics21(4): 603–614.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
