Do party primaries punish women? Revisiting the trade-off between the inclusion of party members and the selection of women as party leaders

Abstract

This paper examines the effect of party primaries on women’s chances of winning a leadership contest in eight Western parliamentary countries since 1985. By doing so, we revisit an ongoing debate about a possible trade-off between the democratic values of ‘inclusion’ of party members and ‘representation’ of excluded groups that this type of selection method may involve. Using an original data set consisting of 608 candidates who participated in 168 leadership mixed-gender contests at the national or regional level, we show that female candidates perform worse under party primaries. This finding holds even after controlling for the type of candidate competing. We therefore sustain the argument that this leadership selection mechanism, in its current format, involves a trade-off between ‘inclusion’ and ‘representation’.

Keywords

leadership selection mixed-gender contest party primaries women candidates

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Astudillo

Detterbeck

(2020) Why, sometimes, primaries? Intraparty democratization as a default selection mechanism in German and Spanish mainstream parties. Party Politics 26(5): 594–604.

Astudillo

Martínez-Cantó

(2020) Political professionalization, subnational style: political insiders and the selection of candidates for regional premiership in Spain. Regional & Federal Studies 30(4): 557–578.

Baitinger

(2015) Meet the press or meet the men? Examining women’s presence in American news media. Political Research Quarterly 68(3): 579–592.

Bashevkin

(2010) When do outsiders break in? Institutional circumstances of party leadership victories by women in Canada. Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 48(1): 72–90.

Cross

Katz

(2013) The Challenges of Intra-Party Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Cross

Kenig

Pruysers

, et al. (2016) The Promise and Challenge of Party Primary Elections: A Comparative Perspective. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

Cross

Pilet

J-B

(2015) The Politics of Party Leadership: A Cross-National Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Escobar-Lemmon

Funk

(2018) Women’s representation in subnational goverments. In: Schwind-Bayer

(ed), Gender and Representation in Latin America. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 99–118.

Fox

Oxley

(2003) Gender stereotyping in state executive elections: candidate selection and success. Journal of Politics 65(3): 833–850.

10.

Jalalzai

(2008) Women rule: shattering the executive glass ceiling. Politics and Gender 4(2): 205–231.

11.

Kenig

Rahat

Tuttnauer

(2015) Competitiveness of party leadership selection processes. In: Cross

Pilet

J-B

(eds) The Politics of Party Leadership: A Cross-National Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 50–72.

12.

Kittilson

(2006) Challenging Parties, Changing Parliaments: Women and Elected Office in Contemporary Western Europe. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press.

13.

Kittilson

Scarrow

(2003) Political parties and the rhetoric and realities of democratization. In: Cain

Dalton

Scarrow

(eds) Democracy Transformed? Expanding Political Opportunities in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 59–80.

14.

Lawless

Pearson

(2008) The primary reason for women’s underrepresentation? Reevaluating the conventional wisdom. Journal of Politics 70(1): 67–82.

15.

Lisi

Freire

Barberà

(2015) Leadership Selection Methods and Party Types. In: Cross

Pilet

J-B

(eds) The Politics of Party Leadership: A Cross-National Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 12–30.

16.

Mair

(1997) Party System Change: Approaches and Interpretations. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

17.

O’Brien

(2015) Rising to the top: gender, political performance, and party leadership in parliamentary democracies. American Journal of Political Science 59(4): 1022–1039.

18.

O’Neill

Pruysers

Stewart

(2019) Glass cliffs or partisan pressure? Examining gender and party leader tenures and exits. Political Studies. DOI: org/10.1177/0032321719880316.

19.

O’Neill

Stewart

(2009) Gender and political party leadership in Canada. Party Politics 15(6): 737–757.

20.

Pruysers

Cross

Gauja

, et al. (2017) Candidate selection rules and democratic outcomes: the impact of parties on women’s representation. In: Scarrow

Webb

Poguntke

(eds) Organizing Political Parties: Representation, Participation, and Power. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 208–233.

21.

Pruysers

Stewart

(2018) Federal-provincial variation in leadership selection: processes and participation. Journal of Canadian Studies 52(3): 742–764.

22.

Rahat

Hazan

Katz

(2008) Democracy and political parties: on the uneasy relationships between participation, competition and representation. Party Politics 14(6): 663–683.

23.

Samuels

Shugart

(2010) Presidents, Parties, and Prime Ministers: How the Separation of Powers Affects Party Organization and Behavior. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

24.

Sandri

Seddone

Venturino

(2015) Party Primaries in Comparative Perspective. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing Limited.

25.

Stambough

O’Regan

(2007) Republican lambs and the democratic pipeline: partisan differences in the nomination of female gubernatorial candidates. Politics and Gender 3(3): 349–368.

26.

Verge

Astudillo

(2019) The gender politics of executive candidate selection and reselection. European Journal of Political Research 58(2): 720–740.

27.

Von dem Berge

Poguntke

Obert

, et al. (2013) Measuring Intra-Party Democracy: A Guide for the Content Analysis of Party Statues. London: Springer.

28.

Wauters

Pilet

J-B

(2015) The selection of female party leaders. Does the selectorate make a difference? In: Cross

Pilet

J-B

(eds) The Politics of Party Leadership: A Cross-National Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 73–89.

29.

Young

Cross

(2002) The rise of plebiscitary democracy in Canadian political parties. Party Politics 8(6): 673–699.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.14 MB