In this article, we explore the electoral dynamics of multi-level political systems for the case of the United Kingdom (Scotland and Wales) through a comparison with multi-level voting behaviour in Germany, Spain and Canada. The analysis suggests that sub-state elections can be `second order' in relation to state-wide elections, but that this `second orderness' is reduced when more powers are decentralized to the sub-state level (and, thus, more is at stake in sub-state elections), and if sub-state identities and parties are stronger. Consequently, elections in Scotland and Wales are unlikely to be or become only `second order' to Westminster elections, and British state-wide parties will continue to face challenges and pressures to adapt their organizations and programmes to the devolution of the British state.
Anderson, Christopher J. and Daniel S. Ward (1996) `Barometer Elections in Comparative Perspective' , Electoral Studies15: 447-60.
2.
Benoit, Kenneth (2006) `Duverger's Law and the Study of Electoral Systems' , French Politics4: 69-83.
3.
Bohrer, Robert E. and Glen S. Krutz (2004) `Duverger and Devolution: A Note on the Effects of New Electoral Rules in the UK', Electoral Studies23: 315-27.
4.
Bradbury, Jonathan (2006) `British Political Parties and Devolution: Adapting to Multi-Level Politics in Scotland and Wales', in Dan Hough and Charlie Jeffery (eds) Devolution and Electoral Politics, pp. 214-47. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
5.
Bromley, Catherine (2006) `Devolution and Electoral Politics in Scotland' , in Dan Hough and Charlie Jeffery (eds) Devolution and Electoral Politics , pp. 192-213. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
6.
Caramani, Daniele (2004) The Nationalization of Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
7.
Chhibber, Pradeep and Kollman, Ken (2004) The Formation of National Party Systems. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
8.
Curtice, John (2004) `Proportional Representation in Scotland: Public Reaction and Voter Behaviour', Representation40: 329-41.
9.
De Winter, Lieven and Huri Türsan (1998) (eds) Regionalist Parties in Western Europe. London: Routledge .
10.
Dinkel, Rainer (1977) `Der Zusammenhang zwischen Bundes- und Landtagswahlergebnissen' , Politische Vierteljahresschrift18: 348-60.
11.
Duverger, Maurice (1959) Political Parties: Their Organisation and Activity in the Modern State. London: Methuen .
12.
Elkins, David J. and Richard Simeon (1980) (eds) Small Worlds: Provinces and Parties in Canadian Political Life. Toronto: Methuen.
13.
Erikson, Robert S. (1988) `The Puzzle of Midterm Loss', Journal of Politics50: 1011-29.
14.
Erikson, Robert S. and Mikhail G. Filippov (2001) `Electoral Balancing in Federal and Sub-national Elections: The Case of Canada', Constitutional Political Economy12: 313-32.
15.
Finer, Herman (1949) The Theory and Practice of Modern Government. New York: Henry Holt.
16.
Flora, Peter, Stein Kuhnle and Derek Urwin (1999) State Formation, Nation-Building and Mass Politics in Europe: The Theory of Stein Rokkan. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
17.
Hearl, Derek, Ian Budge and Bernard Peterson (1996) `Distinctiveness of Regional Voting: A Comparative Analysis across the European Community Countries (1979-1993)' , Electoral Studies15: 167-82.
18.
Heath, Anthony, Iain McLean, Bridget Taylor and John Curtice (1999) `Between First and Second Order: A Comparison of Voting Behaviour in European and Local Elections in Britain', European Journal of Political Research35: 389-414.
19.
Hooghe, Liesbet and Gary Marks (2001) Multi-Level Government and European Integration . Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
20.
Hough, Dan (2002) The Fall and Rise of the PDS in Eastern Germany, 1989-2000. Birmingham: Birmingham University Press.
21.
Hough, Dan and Charlie Jeffery (2003) `Landtagswahlen: Bundestestwahlen oder Regionalwahlen?' Zeitschrift für Parlamentsfragen34: 79-94.
22.
Hough, Dan and Charlie Jeffery (eds) (2006) Devolution and Electoral Politics . Manchester: Manchester University Press.
23.
Hough, Dan, Charlie Jeffery and Michael Keating ( 2003) (eds) `Multi-Level Electoral Competition: Regional Elections and Party Systems in Decentralised States', special issue of Journal of European Urban and Regional Studies10.
24.
Jeffery, Charlie (2004) `Judgements on Devolution? The 2003 Elections in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland', Representation40: 302-15.
25.
Jeffery, Charlie (2005) `Federalism: The New Territorialism', in Simon Green and William Paterson (eds) Governance in Contemporary Germany: The Semi-Sovereign State Revisited, pp. 78-93. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
26.
Jeffery, Charlie (2007) `Balancing Territorial Politics and Social Citizenship in Germany and Britain: Constraints in Public Opinion', German Politics16(1): 58-78.
27.
Jeffery, Charlie and Dan Hough (2003) `Regional Elections in Multi-Level Systems', Journal of European Urban and Regional Studies10: 199-212.
28.
Jeffery, Charlie and Dan Hough (2006) `Devolution and Electoral Politics: Where Does the UK Fit in?', in Dan Hough and Charlie Jeffery (eds) Devolution and Electoral Politics, pp. 248-56. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
29.
Johnston, Richard (1980) `Federal and Provincial Voting: Contemporary Patterns and Historical Evolution', in David J. Elkins and Richard Simeon (eds) Small Worlds: Provinces and Parties in Canadian Political Life, pp. 131-78. Agincourt , ON: Methuen.
30.
Lipset, Seymour Martin and Stein Rokkan (eds) (1967) Party Systems and Voter Alignments: Cross-National Perspectives. New York : Free Press.
31.
McLean, Iain, Anthony Heath and Bridget Taylor (1996) `Were the 1994 Euro- and Local Elections in Britain Really Second-Order? Evidence from the British Election Panel Study', in David M. Farrell, David Broughton, David Denver and Justin Fisher (eds) British Elections and Parties Yearbook 1996, pp. 1-20. London: Frank Cass.
32.
Müller-Rommel, Ferdinand (1998) `Ethnoregionalist Parties in Western Europe: Theoretical Considerations and Framework of Analysis', in Lieven De Winter and Huri Türsan (eds) Regionalist Parties in Western Europe, pp. 17-27. London : Routledge.
33.
Pallarées, Francesc and Michael Keating (2006) `Multi-Level Electoral Competition: Sub-State Elections and Party Systems in Spain', in Dan Hough and Charlie Jeffery (eds) Devolution and Electoral Politics, pp. 96-118. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
34.
Paterson, Lindsay, Alice Brown, John Curtice, Kerstin Hinds, David McCrone, Alison Park, Kerry Sproston and Paula Surridge (2001) New Scotland, New Politics?Edinburgh: Polygon.
35.
Rallings, Colin and Michael Thrasher (2005) `Not All "Second Order" Contests Are the Same: Turnout and Party Change at the Concurrent 2004 Local and European Parliament Elections in England', British Journal of Politics and International Relations7: 584-97.
36.
Reif, Karlheinz (1985) `Ten Second-Order Elections', in Karlheinz Reif (ed.) Ten Second-Order Elections , pp. 1-36. Aldershot: Gower.
37.
Reif, Karlheinz and Hermann Schmitt (1980) `Nine Second-Order National Elections: A Conceptual Framework for the Analysis of European Election Results' , European Journal of Political Research8: 3-44.
38.
Rokkan, Stein and Derek Urwin (1982) `Introduction: Centres and Peripheries in Western Europe', in Stein Rokkan and Derek Urwin (eds) The Politics of Territorial Identity, pp. 1-18. London: Sage.
39.
Rokkan, Stein et al. (1987) Centre-Periphery Structures in Europe. Frankfurt: Campus.
40.
Schmitt, Hermann (2004) `The European Parliament Elections of 2004: Still Second Order?', West European Politics28: 650-79.
41.
Thorlakson, Lori (2006) `Party Systems in Multi-Level Contexts', in Dan Hough and Charlie Jeffery (eds) Devolution and Electoral Politics , pp. 37-53. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
42.
van Biezen, Ingrid and Jonathan Hopkin (2006) `Party Organisation in Multi-Level Contexts', in Dan Hough and Charlie Jeffery (eds) Devolution and Electoral Politics, pp. 14-36. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
43.
van Houten, Pieter (2009) `Multi-Level Relations in Political Parties: A Delegation Approach', Party Politics15(2): 137-56.
44.
Wyn Jones, Richard and Roger Scully (2006) `Devolution and Electoral Politics in Wales and Scotland', Publius: The Journal of Federalism36: 115-34.
