Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

In this paper, we examine the controversy surrounding Freudian theories, which the Indian psychoanalyst Sudhir Kakar was aware of, namely, the abandonment of the seduction theory and the construction of the Oedipus Complex. Jeffrey Masson, the disillusioned psychoanalyst, who was in communication with Kakar in the 1980s, called Freud’s abandonment of seduction theory “the assault on truth”. Both Kakar and Masson also wrote about India but from divergent viewpoints; Kakar adopted “a cultural interpretation” of the Oedipus Complex, while Masson claimed Freud “suppressed” the truth about sexual abuse and trauma in Viennese families. Both authors knew Kakar personally and professionally, worked with him over many years, and decided to examine this recent history, going back to the 1890s. We suggest that Masson developed a highly critical interpretation of Freud based on access to the Freud archives. John Ross, a friend of Kakar’s, similarly offered a critique of Freud from within psychoanalysis, calling it “the Laius Complex”, where the father sets in motion the intergenerational Oedipal rivalry. Kakar developed a cultural adaptationist view, “the maternal enthrallment theory,” where Freud’s abandonment of the seduction theory and the issues of child sexual abuse are completely avoided.

Keywords

Freud India Kakar Masson Culture Oedipus complex Psychoanalysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bandyopadhyay

(2012). Child-sex tourism, HIV/AIDS, and social justice in India. Peace Review: A Journal of Social Justice, 24(2), 143–146. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402659.2012.677320

Basu

Kumar

(2022). Bride price, dowry, and young men with time to kill: A commentary on men’s marriage postponement in India. Population Studies, 76(3), 515–534. https://doi.org/10.1080/00324728.2022.2080858

Brown

L. M.

Gilligan

(1992). Meeting at the crossroads. Harvard University Press.

Cecil

C. A. M.

Zhang

Nolte

(2020). Childhood maltreatment and DNA methylation: A systematic review. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 112(May), 392–409. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2020.02.019

Childlight Global Child Safety Institute . (2025). Into the light Index 2025: Global child sexual exploitation and abuse data. University of Edinburgh & University of New South Wales.

Choudhry

Dayal

Pillai

Kalokhe

A. S.

Beier

Patel

(2018). Child sexual abuse in India: A systematic review. PLoS One, 13(10), Article e0205086. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0205086

Connell

Wilson

(1974). Rape: The first sourcebook for women by New York radical feminists (p. 65). New American Library.

Crews

(1996). The verdict on Freud. Psychological Science, 7(2), 63–68. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.1996.tb00331.x

Crews

(2017). Freud: The making of an illusion. Metropolitan Books.

10.

Doi

(1981). The Anatomy of Dependence: The Key Analysis of Japanese Behavior. English trans. John Bester (2nd ed.). Tokyo: Kodansha.

11.

Ellenberger

H. F.

(1970). The discovery of the unconscious: The history and evolution of dynamic psychiatry. Basic Books.

12.

Erikson

E. H.

(1958). Young man luther. Norton.

13.

Eysenck

H. J.

(1952). The effects of psychotherapy: An evaluation. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 16(5), 319–324. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0063633

14.

Fanon

(1952). Black skin, white masks. Éditions du Seuil.

15.

Felitti

V. J.

Anda

R. F.

Nordenberg

Williamson

D. F.

Spitz

A. M.

Edwards

Koss

M. P.

Marks

J. S.

(1998). Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to leading causes of death in adults. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 14(4), 245–258. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0749-3797(98)00017-8

16.

Ferenczi

(1932/1984). Confusion of tongues between adults and the child. In Masson

J. M.

(ed.) The assault on truth: Freud’s suppression of the seduction theory (pp. 283–295). Faber and Faber.

17.

Fliess

(1956). Erogeneity and libido: Addenda to the theory of the psychosexual development of the human – Psychoanalytic series (Vol. 1). International Universities Press.

18.

Fonagy

Gergely

Elliot

L. J.

Mary

(2002). Affect regulation, mentalization, and the development of the self. Other Press.

19.

Foucault

(1976). The history of sexuality (Vol. 1). Pantheon.

20.

Freud

(1896). In Strachey

(Ed.), The aetiology of hysteria (Vol. 3, pp. 187–222). Vintage.

21.

Freud

(1897). Letter to wilhelm fliess. Sept 21.

22.

Fuller

E. T.

(2017). The death of Freud. National Review. Sep 11. https://www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2017/09/11/frederick-crews-freud-death/

23.

Garcia

E. C.

Vieira

P. S. C.

de Andrade Viana

R. C.

Mariano

F. C.

de Brito

M. I. B.

de Araújo Feitosa Neto

Lima

N. N. R.

Neto

M. L. R.

(2022). Domestic violence and suicide in India. Child Abuse & Neglect, 127(May), 1–3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2022.105573

24.

Gay

(1998). Freud: A life for our times. Norton.

25.

Gilligan

(1982). In a different voice. Harvard University Press.

26.

Grünbaum

(1984). The foundations of psychoanalysis: A philosophical critique. University of California Press.

27.

Herman

J. L.

(1992). Trauma and recovery. Basic Books.

28.

Horney

(1926). The Flight from Womanhood: The Masculinity-Complex in Women, as Viewed by Men and by Women. The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 7, 324–339.

29.

Hughes

Bellis

M. A.

Hardcastle

K. A.

Sethi

Butchart

Mikton

Jones

Dunne

M. P.

(2017). The effect of multiple adverse childhood experiences on health. The Lancet Public Health, 2(8), e356–e366. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2468-2667(17)30118-4

30.

International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) . (2021). National family health survey (NFHS-5), 2019–21: India. IIPS.

31.

International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) & ICF . (2017). National family health survey (NFHS-4), 2015–16: India. IIPS.

32.

Johri

(2018). Social and psychological implications of death penalty, India-seminar. Nov 18. https://www.india-seminar.com/2018/711.htm

33.

Jones

E. E.

(1953). The life and work of Sigmund Freud (Vol. 1). Basic Books.

34.

Kacker

Varadan

Kumar

(2007). Study on child abuse: India 2007. Last accessed on mar 9, 2025.https://resourcecentre.savethechildren.net/document/study-child-abuse-india-2007/

35.

Kakar

(1982). Reflections on psychoanalysis, Indian culture, and mysticism. Journal of Indian Philosophy, 10(3), 289–297. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00240668

36.

Kakar

(2008a). Maternal enthrallment: Two case histories. In Culture and psyche: Selected essays (pp. 86–99). Oxford University Press. OUP Academic.

37.

Kakar

(2008b). The maternal–feminine in Indian psychoanalysis. In Culture and psyche: Selected essays (pp. 72–85). Oxford University Press.

38.

Kakar

(2018). Interview with Sudhir Kakar, death for child rape, India-seminar. Nov 18. Last accessed on Mar 11, 2025.https://www.india-seminar.com/2018/711.htm

39.

Lasch

(1979). The culture of narcissism. Norton.

40.

Lebra

(1985). Japanese women. University of Hawaii Press.

41.

LeVine

R. A.

(1973). Culture, behavior, and personality. Aldine.

42.

LeVine

R. A.

(2021a). Freud and anthropology. In Sharma

(Ed.), The cultural psyche (pp. 117–131). Information Age Press.

43.

LeVine

R. A.

(2021b). Asian explorers of psyche and culture. In Sharma

(Ed.), The cultural psyche (pp. 159–166). Information Age Press.

44.

Lothane

H. Z.

(2024). Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson revisited: The seduction controversies about reality versus fantasy. In Middleton

Dorahy

M. J.

(Eds.), Contemporary perspectives on Freud’s seduction theory and psychotherapy (pp. 81–96). Routledge.

45.

Love

B. J.

Cott

N. F.

(2008). Feminists who changed America, 1963—1975 (p. 399). University of Illinois Press.

46.

Makari

(2008). Revolution in mind. Harper.

47.

Masson

J. M.

(1980). Review of the inner world. Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 49(2), 333–334.

48.

Masson

J. M.

(1984). The assault on truth. Farrar Straus and Giroux.

49.

Masson

J. M.

(1985). The complete letters of Sigmund Freud to Wilhelm Fliess, 1887-1904. Harvard University Press.

50.

McGowan

P. O.

Sasaki

D'Alessio

A. C.

Dymov

Labonté

Szyf

Turecki

Meaney

M. J.

(2009). Epigenetic regulation of the glucocorticoid receptor in human brain associates with childhood abuse. Nature Neuroscience, 12(3), 342–348. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn.2270

51.

Ministry of Women and Child Development (MWCD) . (2007). Study on child abuse: India 2007. Government of India.

52.

Mitchell

(1974). Psychoanalysis and feminism. Pantheon.

53.

Murphy

(1952). In the Minds of Men: The Study of Human Behavior and Social Tensions in India. Basic Books.

54.

Nair

(2024). Interview with Mira Nair. In Three iconic directors: Meera Nair, Gurinder Chaddha, Deepa Mehta. Sep 29 at Asia Society, NYC. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-n6mKhngOSQ

55.

Obeyskere

(1990). The work of culture. University of Chicago Press.

56.

Popper

K. R.

(1959). The logic of scientific discovery. Routledge.

57.

Rachman

A. W. M.

(2024). Child sexual abuse and psychoanalytic theory: Sigmund Freud and Sandor Ferenczi’s childhood seduction. In Middleton

Dorahy

M. J.

(Eds.), Contemporary perspectives on Freud’s seduction theory and psychotherapy (p. 248). Routledge.

58.

Rich

G. J.

(2026). Erik Erikson. In Teo

(Ed.), The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology (pp. 1–5). Cham: Palgrave: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-70581-6_382-1

59.

Rich

G. J.

Gielen

U. P.

(2018). Pathfinders in psychology. Emrald.

60.

Rogers

C. R.

(1961). On Becoming a Person: A Therapist’s View of Psychotherapy. Houghton Mifflin.

61.

Ross

J. M.

(1982). Oedipus revisited: Laius and the “Laius complex”. Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, 37(1), 169–200. https://doi.org/10.1080/00797308.1982.11823362

62.

Ross

J. M.

(2007). Trauma and abuse in the case of little Hans: A contemporary perspective. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 55(3), 852–862. https://doi.org/10.1177/00030651070550031601

63.

Rush

(1977/1996). The Freudian cover-up. Feminism & Psychology, May 1. Last accessed on Mar 3, 2024. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0959353596062015

64.

Said

E. W.

(1978). Orientalism. Pantheon.

65.

Sarin

(2019). Sexual abuse, sexuality and desire of daughters: A reflection on the changing familial relationships. IAHRW International Journal of Social Sciences Review, 7(5), 837–841.

66.

Sharma

(1998). The discursive voice of psychoanalysis: A case for culturally constituted defenses. Culture & Psychology, 4(1), 49–64. https://doi.org/10.1177/1354067X9800400103

67.

Sharma

(2003). Childhood, Family, and Sociocultural Change in India: Reinterpreting the Inner World. Oxford.

68.

Sharma

(2013). Rape of Draupadi: Why Indian democracy has failed women. Al Jazeera English. Jun 18. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2013/6/18/rape-of-draupadi-why-indian-democracy-has-failed-women/

69.

Sharma

Fischer

(1998). Socioemotional development across cultures: Context, complexity, and pathways. In New directions for child and adolescent development (pp. 3–20). Jossey Bass.

70.

Sharma

LeVine

R. A.

(2021). Child care in India: A comparative developmental view of infant social environments. In Sharma

(Ed.), The cultural psyche: Selected papers of Robert A. LeVine on psychosocial science (pp. 289–312). Emerald.

71.

Skinner

B. F.

(1954). Critique of psychoanalytic concepts and theories. Scientific Monthly, 79(5), 300–305.

72.

Swales

P. J.

(1982). Freud, Minna Bernays, and the conquest of Rome: New light on the origins of psychoanalysis. New American Review, 1, 1–23.

73.

Swales

P. J.

(1995). Once a cigar, always a cigar. Nature, (378), 107–108. (review of Webster, Richard, Why Freud Was Wrong: Sin, Science and Psychoanalysis, HarperCollins/Basic Books, 1995). https://doi.org/10.1038/378107a0

74.

Tagore

Rabindranath

(1905). Ekla Chalo Re. Gitabitan. https://www.geetabitan.com/lyrics/J/jodi-tor-daak-shune-lyric.html

75.

Times of India . (2018). Nobel laureate Kailash Satyarthi: In India, two children are…. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/in-india-two-children-are-raped-four-are-sexually-abused-and-eight-go-missing-every-hour-isnt-this-a-national-emergency/articleshow/64321969.cms

76.

Tumbe

(2020). Who is Kamla Chowdhury? https://fiftytwo.in/story/kamla/. Fifty-Two Weeks, December 16(1).

77.

Tyagi

Karande

(2021). Child sexual abuse in India: A wake-up call. Journal of Postgraduate Medicine, 67(3), 125–129. https://doi.org/10.4103/jpgm.JPGM_264_21

78.

Verma

Chowdhury

(2024). Child marriage and intimate partner violence in India: A national study. Journal of Loss & Trauma, 29(3), 331–348. https://doi.org/10.1080/15325024.2023.2259292

79.

Westen

(1998). The scientific legacy of Sigmund Freud. Psychological Bulletin, 124(3), 333–371. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.124.3.333

80.

Yadav

(2021). Scripting bollywood: Candid conversations with women who write Hindi cinema. Women Unlimited. https://www.amazon.com/Scripting-Bollywood-Candid-Conversations-Cinema/dp/9385606336

81.

Young

R. J. C.

(1990). White mythologies. Routledge.

Death by Silence ( Totschweigen ) in Indian Psychoanalysis: Kakar,Masson,and Freud’s Abandonment of the Seduction Theory

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References