This article deals with the recent change of the global regime controlling ocean dumping of low-level radioactive waste. Why did this regime, which originally permitted ocean dumping of low-level radioactive waste, undergo a regime change that resulted in this activity being outlawed? It is concluded that the actions of a global environmental non-governmental organization (ENGO) were decisive in the regime change process, independent of state interests or epistemic communities. Four primary roles for ENGOs in environmental regimes are suggested — mobilizing international public opinion, transnational coalition building, monitoring of states' environmental commitments and advocating precaution and protection of the environment. It is concluded that regime studies should pay more attention to ENGOs and interaction between ENGOs, states and epistemic communities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aftenposten (1995) `Greenpeace must pay'. 15 March. (Author's translation.)
2.
Ardill, John
(1983) `Unions to Block Dumping of Nuclear Waste in Atlantic', The Guardian, 18 June.
3.
Berkhout, Frans
(1991) Radioactive Waste: Politics and Technology. London: Routledge.
4.
Berkovitz, Dan M.
(1987) `Waste Wars: Did Congress “Nuke” State Sovereignty in the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Policy Amendments Act of 1985?', Harvard Environmental Law Review11: 437-490.
5.
Bewers, J.M.
(1995) `The Declining Influence of Science on Marine Environmental Policy', Chemistry and Ecology10: 9-23.
6.
Bewers, J. Mike
and Chris J.R. Garrett (1987) `Analysis of the Issues Related to Sea Dumping of Radioactive Wastes', Marine Policy11: 105-124.
7.
Bishop, Kathrine
(1991) `US to Determine if Radioactive Waste in Pacific Presents Danger', New York Times, 20 January.
8.
Blowers, Andrew
, David Lowry and Barry D. Solomon (1991) The International Politics of Nuclear Waste. London: Macmillan.
9.
Boehmer-Christiansen, Sonja
(1990) `Environmental Quality Objectives versus Uniform Emission Standards', International Journal of Estuarine and Coastal Law: 139-149. Special Issue edited by D. Freestone and Tom Ijlstra.
10.
Boxer, Baruch
(1982) `Mediterranean Pollution: Problem and Response', Ocean Development and International Law Journal10 (3/4): 315-356.
11.
Brown, Paul
(1985a) `Britain Seeks Allies to Lift Nuclear Dumping Truce', The Guardian, 21 September.
12.
Brown, Paul
(1985b) `UK Threatens to Withdraw from Convention on Nuclear Dumping', The Guardian, 25 September.
13.
Brown, Paul
(1985c) `Open-Ended Nuclear Dumping Ban: Britain Loses Strong Rearguard Action as Vote Switches Burden of Proof', The Guardian, 27 September.
14.
Camplin, W.C.
and M.D. Hill (1986) `Sea Dumping of Solid Radioactive Waste: A New Assessment', Radioactive Waste Management and the Nuclear Fuel Cycle7 (3): 233-251.
15.
Carter, Luther J.
(1987) Nuclear Imperatives and Public Trust. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future.
16.
Castaing, Michel
(1993) `L'immersion de déchets radioactifs est définitivement interdite', Le Monde, 16 November: 14.
17.
Chayes, Abram
and Antonia Handler Chayes (1993) `On Compliance', International Organization47 (2): 175-205.
Curtis, Clifton E.
(1983b) `Radwaste Dumping Delayed. An International Moratorium Keeps Nuclear Wastes at Bay', Oceans16 (3): 22-23.
25.
Davidson, W. Philipps
(1968) `Public Opinion', in David L. Sills (ed.) International Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences (13), pp. 188-196. Washington, DC: Library of Congress.
26.
Dibblin, Jane
(1985) `Britain is in the Dock', New Statesman, 20 September.
27.
Dobrynin, Anatoly
(1995) In Confidence: Moscow's Ambassador to America's Six Cold War Presidents (1962-1986). New York: Time.
28.
Douglas, Mary
and Aaron Wildavsky (1982) Risk and Culture. Berkeley: University of California Press.
29.
Dyer, Robert S.
(1982) `Sea Disposal of Nuclear Waste: A Brief History' in Thomas C. Jackson (ed.) Nuclear Waste Management: The Ocean Alternative, pp. 9-16. New York: Pergamon Press.
30.
Earll, R.C.
(1992) `Commonsense and the Precautionary Principle — An Environmentalist's Perspective', Marine Pollution Bulletin24 (4): 182-186.
31.
Economist, The (1990) `The Greening of British Politics', 3 March.
32.
Edwards, Rob
(1983) `Wasting the Ocean', New Statesman, 1 July.
33.
Edwards, Michael
and David Hulme (eds) (1995) Non-Governmental Organisations — Performance and Accountability. Beyond the Magic Bullet. London: Earthscan.
34.
Environmental Policy and Law (1983) `London Dumping Convention — 7th Consultative Meeting', 10: 83-85.
35.
Evans, Peter B.
, Harold K. Jacobson and Robert D. Putnam (eds) (1993) Double-Edged Diplomacy: International Bargaining and Domestic Politics. Berkeley: University of California Press.
36.
Flavin, Christopher
(1994) `Storm Warnings: Climate Change Hits the Insurance Industry', World Watch7: 10-20.
37.
Fortner, Robert S.
(1994) Public Diplomacy and International Politics. Westport, CN: Praeger.
38.
Frye, Alton
(1962) The Hazards of Atomic Wastes: Perspectives and Proposals on Oceanic Disposal. Washington, DC: Public Affairs Press.
GESAMP
(1992) `Can there be a Common Framework for Managing Radioactive and Non-radioactive Substances to Protect the Marine Environment?', GESAMP Reports and Studies No. 45, Addendum 1. London: IMO.
41.
Gray, John S.
(1990a) `Statistics and the Precautionary Principle', Marine Pollution Bulletin21: 174-176.
42.
Gray, John S.
(1990b) (letter) Marine Pollution Bulletin21: 599-600.
43.
Greenpeace, `Greenpeace... for a cleaner, safer earth'. Pamphlet, Greenpeace Washington DC.
44.
Greenpeace
(1990) `Political and Social Impacts of a Resumption of Radioactive Waste Dumping at Sea'. Statement submitted by Greenpeace International to the Third Meeting of IGPRAD, October 1990.
45.
Haas, Peter M.
(1989) `Do Regimes Matter? Epistemic Communities and Mediterranean Pollution Control', International Organization43 (3): 377-403.
46.
Haas, Peter M.
(1990a) Saving the Mediterranean: The Politics of International Environmental Cooperation. New York: Columbia University Press.
47.
Haas, Peter M.
(1990b) `Obtaining International Environmental Protection through Epistemic Consensus', Millennium19 (3): 347-363.
48.
Haas, Peter M.
(1992a) `Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy Coordination', International Organization46 (1): 1-35.
49.
Haas, Peter M.
(1992b) `Banning Chlorofluorocarbons: Epistemic Community Efforts to Protect Stratospheric Ozone', International Organization46 (1): 187-224.
50.
Habermas, Jürgen
(1965) Strukturwandel der Offentlichkeit: Untersuchungen zu einer Kategorie der burgerlischen Gesellschaft. Neuwied am Rhein-Berlin: Politica.
51.
Hagen, Amelia A.
(1983) `History of Low-Level Radioactive Waste Disposal in the Sea', in P. Kilo Parket al. (eds) Wastes in the Ocean. Volume 3. Radioactive Wastes and the Ocean, pp. 47-64. New York: John Wiley.
52.
Hamilton, E.I.
(1986) `Science — A Time of Change?', Marine Pollution Bulletin17(7): 295-298.
53.
Hansen, Anders
(1993) `Greenpeace and Press Coverage of Environmental Issues', in A. Hansen (ed.) The Mass Media and Environmental Issues, pp. 150-178. Leicester: Leicester University Press.
54.
Harwood, Michael
(1971) `We Are Killing the Sea Around Us', The New York Times Magazine, 24 October.
55.
Haus, Leah
(1991) `The East European Countries and GATT: The Role of Realism, Mercantilism, and Regime Theory in Explaining East-West Trade Negotiations', International Organization45 (2): 163-182.
56.
Hiatt, Fred
(1993) `After Yeltsin Visit, Russia is Dumping A-Waste off Japan', International Herald Tribune, 18 October.
57.
Holcomb, W.F.
(1982) `A History of Ocean Disposal of Packaged Low-level Radioactive Waste', Nuclear Safety23(2): 183-197.
58.
IAEA
(1993) Risk Comparisons Relevant to the Sea Disposal of Low Level Radioactive Waste. Vienna: IAEA.
59.
IAEA
(1994) Nuclear Power, Nuclear Fuel Cycle and Waste Management: Status and Trends 1994. Part C of the IAEA Yearbook 1994. Vienna: IAEA.
60.
Johnston, P.
and M. Simmonds (1990) (letter) Marine Pollution Bulletin21: 598.
Kemp, Ray
(1992) The Politics of Radioactive Waste Disposal. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
63.
Keohane, Robert O.
(1980) `The Theory of Hegemonic Stability and Changes in International Economic Regimes, 1967-1977', in Ole R. Holstiet al. (eds) Changes in the International System, pp. 131-162. Boulder, CO: Westview.
64.
Keohane, Robert O.
(1984) After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
65.
Krasner, Stephen D.
(1983) `Structural Causes and Regime Consequences: Regimes as Intervening Variables', in Stephen D. Krasner (ed.) International Regimes, pp. 1-21. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
66.
Kremenyuk, Victor A.
(1991) `The Emerging System of International Negotiation', in Victor A. Kremenyuk (ed.) International Negotiation: Analysis, Approaches, Issues, pp. 22-39. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
67.
Lapp, Ralph E.
(1979) The Radiation Controversy. Greenwich, CN: Reddy Communications.
68.
Lawrence, John
and D. Taylor (1990) (letter) Marine Pollution Bulletin21: 598-599.
69.
Laws, David
(1990) `The Antarctic Minerals Regime Negotiations', in Lawrence E. Susskind, Esther Siskind and J. William Breslin (eds) Nine Case Studies in International Environmental Negotiation, pp. 121-149. Cambridge, MA: Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School.
70.
LC/IGPRAD 6/5
(31 August 1993) `Report of the Sixth Meeting of the Inter-Governmental Panel of Experts on Radioactive Waste Disposal at Sea'.
71.
LC 16/14
(15 December 1993) `Report of the Sixteenth Consultative Meeting'.
72.
LDC 3/12
(24 October 1978) `Report of the Third Consultative Meeting'.
73.
LDC 6/12
(10 November 1981) `Report of the Sixth Consultative Meeting'.
74.
LDC 7/12
(9 March 1983) `Report of the Seventh Consultative Meeting'.
75.
LDC 7/INF.2
(23 September 1982) `Evaluation of Oceanic Radioactive Dumping Programmes. Submitted jointly by Kiribati and Nauru'.
76.
LDC document 8/5
(9 December 1983) `Critical Studies and Comments to the Report “Evaluation of Oceanic Radioactive Dumping Programmes.” Submitted by France'. Annex 1.
77.
LDC 9/12
(18 October 1985) `Report of the Ninth Consultative Meeting'.
78.
LDC 9/4/1
(21 June 1985) `Report of Intersessional Activities Relating to the Disposal of Radioactive Wastes at Sea, Including the Final Report of the Scientific Review. Note by the Secretariat'.
79.
LDC 9/4
(24 June 1985) `Report of Intersessional Activities Relating to the Disposal of Radioactive Wastes at Sea, Including the Final Report of the Scientific Review. Report of Expanded Panel Meeting'.
80.
LDC 14/16
(30 December 1991) `Report of the 14th Consultative Meeting'. Annex 2.
81.
LDC/PRAD.1/2
(12 April 1985) `Introduction of Report Prepared by the Panel of Experts. Note by the Secretariat'.
82.
LDC/PRAD.1/2/Add.2
(1 May 1985) `Introduction of Report Prepared by the Panel of Experts. The Disposal of Low-Level Radioactive Waste at Sea. (Review of Scientific and Technical Considerations.) Note by the Secretariat'.
83.
Leitzell, Terry L.
(1973) `The Ocean Dumping Convention — A Hopeful Beginning', San Diego Law Review10 (3): 502-513.
84.
Le Monde (1993) `La France signe la convention de Londres sur l'interdiction de l'immersion des déchets nucléaires', 22 December, 12.
85.
Lettow, Charles F.
(1974) `The Control of Marine Pollution', in Erica L. Dolgin and Thomas G.P. Guilbert (eds) Federal Environmental Law, pp. 596-680. St Paul, MN: West Publishing Company.
86.
Levy, Marc A.
, Oran R. Young and Michael Zürn (1995) `The Study of International Regimes', European Journal of International Relations1 (3): 267-330.
87.
Lipschutz, Ronnie
(1992) `Restructuring World Politics: The Emergence of Global Civil Society', Millennium21 (3): 389-420.
88.
Litfin, Karen T.
(1994) Ozone Discourses. New York: Columbia University Press.
89.
McCormick, John
(1989) Reclaiming Paradise: The Global Environmental Movement. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
90.
Majone, Giandomenico
(1989) Evidence, Argument, and Persuasion in the Policy Process. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Mazuzan, George T.
and J. Samuel Walker (1985) Controlling the Atom: The Beginnings of Nuclear Regulation 1946-62. Berkeley: University of California Press.
93.
Milne, Alex
(1993) `The Perils of Green Pessimism', New Scientist138 (1877): 34-37.
94.
Mitchell, Ronald B.
(1994) `Regime Design Matters: Intentional Oil Pollution and Treaty Compliance', International Organization48 (3): 425-458.
95.
National Advisory Committee on Oceans and Atmosphere
(April 1984) `Nuclear Waste Management and the Use of the Sea: A Special Report to the President and the Congress'. Washington, DC.
96.
New York Times (1982a) `Dutch Ship Stops Dumping Nuclear Waste', 30 August.
97.
New York Times (1982b) `A Dutch Ship Resumes Dumping Nuclear Waste Off Northern Spain', 31 August.
98.
New York Times (1982c) `House Backs Moratorium on Ocean Dumping', 21 September.
99.
New York Times (1982d) `Dutch to Stop Dumping Nuclear Wastes at Sea', 23 September.
100.
Nuclear News (March 1983) `A Call for a Two-Year Halt on Ocean Disposal'.
101.
O'Riordan, Timothy
and James Cameron (eds) (1994) Interpreting the Precautionary Principle. London: Earthscan Publications.
102.
Oye, Kenneth A.
and James H. Maxwell (1995) `Self-interest and Environmental Management', in R. Keohane and E. Ostrom (eds) Local Commons and Global Interdependence, pp. 191-221. London: Sage.
103.
Park, P. Kiloet al.
(1983) `Radioactive Wastes and the Ocean: An Overview', in P. KiloParket al. (eds) Wastes in the Ocean. Volume 3. Radioactive Wastes and the Ocean, pp. 3-46. New York: John Wiley.
104.
Pearce, Fred
(1983) `Seamen Pull the Plug on Radioactive Dumping', New Scientist, 30 June.
105.
Pearce, Fred
(1991) Green Warriors: The People and the Politics Behind the Environmental Revolution. London: Bodley Head.
106.
Peterman, Randall M.
and M. M'Gonigle (1992) `Statistical Power Analysis and the Precautionary Principle', Marine Pollution Bulletin24 (5): 231-234.
107.
Peterson, M.J.
(1992) `Whalers, Cetologists, Environmentalists and the International Management of Whaling', International Organization46 (1): 147-186.
108.
Pitt, David E.
(1993a) `Pentagon Fights Wider Ocean-Dumping Ban', New York Times, 26 September.
109.
Pitt, David E.
(1993b) `US to Press for Ban on Nuclear Dumping at Sea', New York Times, 2 November.
110.
Potter, David (1996) (ed.) `NGOs and Environmental Policies: Asia and Africa', Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics34(1).
111.
Princen, Thomas
(1994) `NGOs: Creating A Niche in Environmental Diplomacy', in T. Princen and M. Finger (eds) Environmental NGOs in World Politics, pp. 29-47. London and New York: Routledge.
112.
Princen, Thomas
and Matthias Finger (1994) `Introduction', in T. Princen and M. Finger (eds) Environmental NGOs in World Politics. London and New York: Routledge.
113.
Princen, Thomas
, Matthias Finger and Jack Manno (1994) `Transnational Linkages', in T. Princen and M. Finger (eds) Environmental NGOs in World Politics. pp. 217-236. London and New York: Routledge.
114.
Princen, Thomas
, Matthias Finger and Jack Manno (1995) `Nongovernmental Organizations in World Environmental Politics', International Environmental Affairs7 (1): 42-58.
115.
Rapoport, Anatol
(1968) `Introduction', in Carl von Clausewitz, On War. London: Penguin.
116.
Raustiala, Kal
(1995) `The New Role of NGOs in International Environmental Regimes', mimeo, Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
117.
Ringius, Lasse (1992) `Radwaste Disposal and the Global Ocean Dumping Convention: The Politics of International Environmental Regimes', PhD thesis, the European University Institute, Florence, Italy.
118.
Ringius, Lasse
(1996) `The Environmental Action Plan Approach: A Milestone in Pollution Control in the Baltic Sea', in Ronnie Hjorth (ed.) Baltic Environmental Cooperation: A Regime in Transition, pp. 23-38. Linköping: Water and Environmental Studies, Report no. 23, Linköping University.
119.
Rippon, Simon
(1983) `Ocean Disposal', Nuclear News, March: 76-79.
120.
Rochlin, Gene I.
(1979) Plutonium, Power, and Politics: International Arrangements for the Disposition of the Spent Nuclear Fuel. Berkeley: University of California Press.
121.
Samstag, Tony
(1983) `Unions Act to Block Nuclear Dumping', The Times, 7 April.
122.
Samstag, Tony
(1985) `Talks on Radioactive Dumping', The Times, 23 September.
123.
Schoon, Nicholas
(1994) `UK bows to ban on dumping N-waste at sea', The Guardian, 18 February.
124.
Sielen, Alan B.
(1988) `Sea Changes? Ocean Dumping and International Regulation', Georgetown International Law Review1 (1): 1-32.
125.
Stairs, Kevin
and Peter Taylor (1992) `Non-Governmental Organizations and the Legal Protection of the Oceans: A Case Study', in Andrew Hurrell and Benedict Kingsbury (eds) The International Politics of the Environment, pp. 110-141. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
126.
Stebbing, A.R.D.
(1992) `Environmental Capacity and the Precautionary Principle', Marine Pollution Bulletin24 (6): 287-295.
127.
Susskind, Lawrence E.
(1994) Environmental Diplomacy: Negotiating More Effective Global Agreements. New York: Oxford University Press.
128.
Third World Quarterly (1995) `Special Issue: Non-Governmental Organizations, The United Nations and Global Governance', 16 (3).
129.
Thomas, Jo
(1984) `Greenpeace Aims at Headlines First', International Herald Tribune, 4 September.
130.
Times, The (1983) `Boycott of Nuclear Dumping at Sea', 10 September.
131.
Tönnies, Ferdinand
(1957) Community and Society, trans. and ed. by Charles P. Loomis. New York: Harper and Row.
132.
Van Dyke, Jon M.
(1988) `Ocean Disposal of Nuclear Wastes', Marine Policy12: 82-95.
133.
Walker, Charles A.
, Leroy C. Gould and Edward J. Woodhouse (eds) (1983) Too Hot To Handle? Social and Policy Issues in the Management of Radioactive Wastes. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
134.
Waltz, Kenneth N.
(1986) `Theory of International Politics', in Robert O. Keohane (ed.) Realism and Its Critics, pp. 27-130. New York: Columbia University Press.
135.
Wapner, Paul
(1995) `Politics Beyond the State: Environmental Activism and World Civic Politics', World Politics47 (3): 311-340.
136.
Wassermann, Ursula
(1985) `Disposal of Radioactive Waste', Journal of World Trade Law19 (4): 178-181.
137.
Weart, Spencer R.
(1988) Nuclear Fear: A History of Images. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
138.
Wenk, Edward Jr
(1972) The Politics of the Ocean. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
139.
Wood-Thomas, Bryan C. (1991) environmental scientist, Marine Policy Programs, Office of International Activities, US EPA. Interview 29 August, Washington, DC.
140.
Wright, Pearce
(1983) `Britain Defies Ban on Dumping Waste', The Times, 18 February.
141.
Young, Oran R.
(1989) `The Politics of International Regime Formation: Managing Natural Resources and the Environment', International Organization43 (3): 349-375.
