The state monopoly on the legitimate use of violence in Europe and North America has
been central to the development of security as a collective good. Not only has it
institutionalized the state as the prime national and international security
provider, it has helped to reduce the threat from other actors by either prohibiting
or limiting their use of violence. The recent growth of the private security
industry appears to undermine this view. Not only are private security firms
proliferating at the national level; private military companies are also taking over
an increasing range of military functions in both national defence and international
interventions. This article seeks to provide an examination of the theoretical and
practical implications of the shift from states to markets in the provision of
security. Specifically, it discusses how the conceptualization of security as a
commodity rather than a collective good affects the meaning and implementation of
security in Western democracies.
Alexander, M.
and
T. Garden
(2001)
`The Arithmetic of Defence Policy'
, International Affairs77(3):
509-29.
2.
Altheide, David L.
and
R. Sam Michalowski
(1999)
`Fear in the News: A Discourse of Control'
, The Sociological Quarterly40(3):
475-503.
3.
Anderson, Warren M.
,
John J. McGuiness
and
John S. Spicer
(2001) From Chaos to Clarity: How Current Cost-Based
Strategies Are Undermining the Department of Defense.
Fort Belvoir, VA: Defense
Acquisitions University Press .
4.
Avant, Deborah
(2004)
`The Privatization of Security and Change in the Control of Force'
, International Studies Perspectives5(2):
153-7.
5.
Avant, Deborah
(2005) The Market for Force: The Consequences of Privatizing
Security. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
6.
Baldwin, David
(1997)
`The Concept of Security'
, Review of International Studies23(1):
5-26.
7.
Brauer, Jurgen
(2004) `Developing Peacemaking Institutions: An Economist's
Approach', in
Geoff Harris
(ed.) Achieving Security in Sub-Saharan Africa: Cost Effective
Alternatives to the Military, pp. 137-53.
Pretoria: Institute for Security
Studies.
8.
Briggs, Rachel
(2004)
`Perception Gap: Public Attitudes to Security and Impacts on Corporate
Decision-Making'
, Demos. Available from:
www.demos.co.uk/PerceptionGapEventReportFINAL_pdf_media_public.aspx
(last accessed 15 March 2007).
9.
Business Wire
(2005) ``L-3 Communications' Government Services, Inc.
Subsidiary Awarded Potential $426.5 Million US Army Intelligence Support
Services Contract',13 July.
10.
Buzan, Barry
(1991) People, States and Fear, 2nd edn.
Boulder, CO: Lynne
Rienner .
11.
Buzan, Barry
,
Ole Wæver
and
Japp de Wilde
(1998) Security: A New Framework for Analysis.
London: Lynne
Rienner.
12.
Cutler, Claire A.
(2005)
`Gramsci, Law, and the Culture of Global Capitalism'
, Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy8(4):
527-42.
13.
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform
( 2007)
`Iraqi Reconstruction: Reliance on Private Military Contractors'
, Hearing, 7 February, available from:
http://oversight.house.gov/story.asp?ID=1165.
14.
Dabelko, Geoffrey D.
and
David D. Dabelko
(1993)
`Environmental Security: Issues of Concept and Redefinition', Occasional
Paper No. 1
. Harrison Program on the Future Global Agenda. Available
from: http://www.bsos.umd.edu/harrison/papers/paper01.htm
.
15.
Edmonds, Martin
(1998)
`Defense Privatisation: From State Enterprise to Commercialism'
, Cambridge Review of International Affairs13(1):
114-29.
16.
Elbe, Stefan
(2005) `HIV/AIDS: The International Security
Dimensions' , in
Elke Krahmann
(ed.) New Threats and New Actors in International Security, pp.
111-30. New York:
Palgrave.
17.
Ericson, Richard V.
and
Kevin D. Haggerty
(1997) Policing the Risk Society .
Toronto: University of Toronto
Press.
18.
Financial Times
(2005) `London Businesses Told to Upgrade Security', 14
July.
19.
Foldvary, Fred
(1994) Public Goods and Private Communities.
Aldershot: Edward
Elgar.
20.
GAO (Government Accountability Office
) (2004 ) Military Operations: DOD's Extensive Use of
Logistics Support Contracts Requires Strengthened Oversight, GAO-04-854.
Washington, DC:
GAO.
21.
GAO
(2005) Rebuilding Iraq: Actions Needed to Improve Use of
Private Security Providers, GAO-05-737. Washington,
DC: GAO.
22.
GAO
(2006) Contract Management: DOD Vulnerabilities to
Contracting Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, GAO-06-838R.
Washington, DC:
GAO.
23.
Gleick, Peter H.
(1993)
`Water and Conflict'
, International Security18(1):
79-112.
24.
Hartley, Keith
(nd)
`The UK's Major Defence Projects: A Cause for Concern?'
, Research Paper, Centre for Defence Economics, at:
http://www.york.ac.uk/depts/econ/research/documents/GovtOppsArticle.pdf
. (accessed 7 September 2005).
25.
Homer-Dixon, Thomas
(1994)
`Environmental Scarcities and Violent Conflict: Evidence from Cases'
, International Security19(1):
5-40.
26.
Huysmans, Jef
(1998)
`Security! What Do You Mean? From Concept to Thick Signifier'
, European Journal of International Relations4(2):
226-55.
27.
Johnston, Les
(1992) The Rebirth of Private Policing.
London:
Routledge.
28.
Johnston, Les
(1999) `Private Policing: Uniformity and Diversity', in
R.I. Mawby
(ed.) Policing Across the World: Issues for the Twenty-first
Century, pp. 226-38.
London : UCL
Press.
29.
Johnston, Les
(2000) `Transnational Private Policing: The Impact of Global
Commercial Security', in
J.W.E. Sheptycki
(ed.) Issues in Transnational Policing, pp.
21-42. London :
Routledge.
30.
Jones, Trevor
and
Tim Newburn
(1998) Private Security and Public Policing.
Oxford:
Clarendon.
31.
Kaufmann, Chaim
(2004)
`Threat Inflation and the Failure of the Marketplace of Ideas'
, International Security29(1):
5-48.
32.
Kaul, Inge
,
Isabelle Grunberg
and
Marc A.
Stern (1999) `Defining Global Public Goods', in
Inge Kaul
,
Isabelle Grunberg
and
Marc A. Stern
(eds) Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st
Century, pp. 2-17. New
York: Oxford University
Press.
33.
Kirchner, Emil
and
James Sperling
(eds) (2007a) Global Security Governance .
London:
Routledge.
34.
Kirchner, Emil
and
James Sperling
(eds) (2007b) `Global Threat Perception: Elite Survey Results
from Canada, China, the European Union, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia,
the United Kingdom and the United States', Garnet Working Paper 18/07, May
2007, available from:
http://www.garnet-eu.org/fileadmin/documents/working_papers/1807/5.3.2%20contents.pdf
.
35.
Kinsey, Christopher
(2006) Corporate Soldier and International Security: The Rise
of Private Military Companies. London:
Routledge.
36.
Krahmann, Elke
(2005a)
`Security Governance and the Private Military Industry in Europe and North
America'
, Conflict, Security and Development5(2):
247-68.
37.
Krahmann, Elke
(2005b)
`Controlling Private Military Companies in Europe: Between Partnership and
Regulation'
, European Security13(2):
277-95.
38.
Krause, Keith
and
Michael C. Williams
(eds) (1997) Critical Security Studies: Concepts and
Cases. Minneapolis, MN: University
of Minnesota Press.
39.
Leander, Anna
(2003) `The Commodification of Violence: Private Military
Companies and African States', in
Mammo Muchi
(ed.) The Making of the African Nation: Pan-Africanism and the African
Renaissance, pp. 264-80.
London:
Adonis-Abbey.
40.
Leander, Anna
(2005)
`The Power to Construct International Security: On the Significance of
Private Military Companies'
, Millennium33(3):
803-26.
41.
Lee, Dwight R.
(1990) `Public Goods, Politics and Two Cheers for the
Military- Industrial Complex', in
Robert Higgs
(ed.) Arms, Politics and the Economy: Historical and Contemporary
Perspectives, pp. 22-36. New
York: Holmes &
Meier.
42.
Lilly, Damian
(2000) The Privatization of Security and Peacekeeping .
London: International
Alert.
43.
Lipschutz, Ronnie
(ed.) (1995) On Security. New
York: Columbia University
Press.
44.
Loader, Ian
(1999)
`Consumer Culture and the Commodification of Policing and Security'
, Sociology33(2):
373-92.
45.
McCarthy, Ellen
(2004) `CACI Contract: From Supplies to Interrogation'
. Washington Post 17 May.
46.
McDermott, Rose
(2004)
`Prospect Theory in Political Science: Gains and Losses from the First
Decade'
, Political Psychology25(2):
289-312.
47.
Mandel, Robert
(2002) Armies without States: The Privatization of
Security . Boulder, CO: Lynne
Rienner.
48.
Mendez, Ruben P.
(1999) `Peace as a Global Public Good,' in
Inge Kaul
,
Isabelle Grunberg
and
Marc A. Stern
(eds) Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st
Century, pp. 382-417. New
York: Oxford University
Press.
49.
Merle, Renae
(2006)
`Census Counts 100,000 Contractors in Iraq,'Washington Post 5 December.
50.
NATO
(1949) The North Atlantic Treaty.
Washington, DC
. Available from:
http://www.nato.int/docu/basictxt/treaty.htm.
51.
Parfomak, Paul W.
(2004)
`Guarding America: Security Guards and US Critical Infrastructure
Protection'
, CRS Report for Congress . November 12.
52.
Paris, Roland
(2001)
`Human Security: Paradigm Shift or Hot Air?'
, International Security26(2):
87-102.
53.
Reuters
(2004)
`Halliburton's Role in Iraq - from Meals to Oil'
, New York Times 12 April.
54.
Rothschild, Emma
(1995)
`What is Security?'
, Daedalus124(3):
53-98.
55.
Sandler, Todd
(1993)
`The Economic Theory of Alliances'
, Journal of Conflict Resolution37(3):
446-83.
56.
Sandler, Todd
(2001) `On Financing Global and International Public Goods',
Policy Research Working Paper 2638. Washington,
DC: World Bank.
57.
Singer, Peter W.
(2003) Corporate Warriors: The Rise of the Privatized
Military Industry. Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press.
58.
Smoke, Richard
(1991) `A Theory of Mutual Security', in
Richard Smoke
and
Andrei Kortunov
(eds) Mutual Security: A New Approach to Soviet-American
Relations, pp. 59-111.
Basingstoke:
Macmillan .
59.
South, Nigel
(1988) Policing for Profit: The Private Security Sector
. London:
Sage.
60.
Spearin, Christopher
(2005) `Humanitarians and Mercenaries: Partners in Security
Governance?', in
Elke Krahmann
(ed.) New Threats and New Actors in International Security, pp.
45-65. New York:
Palgrave.
61.
Spinner, Jackie
(2004a)
`Army May Allow Bids for some KBR work'
, Washington Post 19 March.
62.
Spinner, Jackie
(2004b)
'Pentagon Faults Supervision of Contracts'
, Washington Post 25 March.
63.
Spinner, Jackie
and
Mary Pat Flaherty
(2004)
`US Auditors Criticize Halliburton Subsidiary'
, Washington Post 12 March.
64.
Stretton, Hugh
and
Lionel Orchard
(1994) Public Goods, Public Enterprise, Public Choice .
New York: St Martin's
Press.
65.
The Associated Press
(2004)
`Halliburton Passes $10B Mark in Iraq Work'
, New York Times 9 December.
US Department of State
(2002) Patterns of Global Terrorism 2002. Available
from: http://www.state.gov/s/ct/rls/pgtrpt/2002/pdf/.
68.
US Department of State
(2003) Patterns of Global Terrorism 2003. Available
from: http://www.state.gov/s/ct/rls/pgtrpt/2003/c12153.htm.
69.
Ullman, Richard H.
(1983)
`Redefining Security'
, International Security8(1):
129-53.
70.
United Nations
(2003) `The Eighth United Nations Survey on Crime Trends and
the Operations of Criminal Justice Systems (2001-2002)'; Available from:
http://www.unodc.org/pdf/crime/eighthsurvey/5678svr.pdf .
71.
Wæver, Ole
(1995) `Securitization and Desecuritization', in
Ronnie D.
Lipschutz (ed.) On Security, pp. 46-86.
New York: Columbia University
Press.
72.
Walt, Stephen M.
(1991)
`The Renaissance of Security Studies'
, International Studies Quarterly35(2):
211-39.
73.
Weiner, Tim
(2004)
`Lockheed and the Future of Warfare'
, New York Times 28 November.
74.
White House
(1991) National Security Strategy of the United States.
Washington, DC
, August.
75.
White House
(1998) A National Security Strategy for a New CenturyWashington, DC
, October.
76.
Witter, Willis
(2006)
`Private Firms Eye Darfur'
, Washington Times 2 October.
