The legal provisions of the United Nations Charter offer imprecise and insufficient
criteria for discriminating properly between legitimate vs illegitimate uses of
force. The conflation of the concept of the legitimacy of the use of force with what
is lawful, as agreed upon by a small number of major international actors, overlooks
those situations in which legal standards are rendered instruments of political
deception and manipulation in the hands of the most powerful actors. The solution
proposed to address this problem draws on Jürgen Habermas’s
theory of communicative action, and it is subsumed by the concept of
deliberative legitimacy, understood as the non-coerced commitment of an
actor to obey a norm adopted on the basis of the criteria and rules reached through
a process of communicative action. The analytical value of the concept of
deliberative legitimacy is examined empirically in two case studies — the
1999 NATO intervention in Kosovo, and the 2003 US-led war against Iraq.
9/11 Commission
(2004) ‘The 9/11 Commission
Report’,
National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States
, 21 July. <http://www.9-11commission.gov/>
(accessed 25 August 2004).
2.
Amstutz, Mark R.
(1999) International Ethics: Concepts, Theories, and Cases in
Global Politics.
Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield
.
3.
Arend, Anthony C.
and
Robert J. Beck
(1993) International Law and the Use of Force: Beyond the UN
Charter Paradigm.
London and New York: Routledge
.
4.
Art, Robert J.
and
Kenneth Neal Waltz
(1993) The Use of Force: Military Power and International
Politics, 4th edn.Lanham, MD: University Press of America
.
5.
Beaumont, Peter
,
David Roseand
and
Paul Beaver
(2003)
‘US to Punish German “Treachery”’
. Observer 16 February.
<http://observer.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,6903,896573,00.html>
(accessed 8 August 2004).
6.
Beetham, David
(1991) The Legitimation of Power.
Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press International
.
7.
Bennis, Phyllis
(2003)
‘Powell’s Dubious Case for War’
. Foreign Policy in Focus 5 February.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/attack/2003/0205powelldub.htm>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
8.
Bernstein, Steven
(2004) ‘The Elusive Basis of Legitimacy in Global
Governance: Three Conceptions.’Globalization and Autonomy Working Paper Series,
Institute for Globalization and the Human Condition, McMaster University
.
9.
Blair, Tony
(1999) ‘Prime Minister’s speech: Doctrine
of the International Community at the Economic Club, Chicago’,
24 April. <http://www.number-10.gov.uk/output/page1297.asp>
(accessed 25 August 2004).
10.
Buchanan, Allen
and
Robert O. Keohane
(2004)
‘The Preventive Use of Force: A Cosmopolitan Institutional Proposal’
. Ethics & International Affairs18(1):
1-23
.
11.
Bull, Hedley
(1966) ‘The Grotian Conception of International
Society’, in
M. Wright
(ed.) Diplomatic Investigations, pp. 51-73.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
12.
Buncombe, Andrew
(2003)
‘CIA “Sabotaged Inspections and Hid Weapons Details”’
. Independent 14 February.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/unmovic/2003/0214sabotaged.htm>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
13.
Bush, George W.
(2002a) ‘Remarks by the President at Signing of the
Joint Resolution’, 16 October,
<http://usinfo.state.gov/topical/pol/arms/02101603.htm>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
14.
Bush, George W.
(2002b) ‘Speech on Iraq made in Cincinnati,
Ohio’,
BBC
, 8 October.
<http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/2309049.stm>
(accessed 7 January 2004).
15.
Bush, George W.
(2003) ‘State of the Union
Address’,
White House
, 28 January.
<http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/01/20030128-19.html>
(accessed 18 August 2004).
16.
CBC
(2003) ‘Bush Twisted Facts on Iraq: Former
Intelligence Director’.
<http://www.cbc.ca/stories/2003/06/07/iraq_badintelligence>
(accessed 7 January 2004).
17.
Cirincione, Joseph
,
Jessica T. Mathews
,
George Perkovich
and
Alexis Orton
(2004) WMD in Iraq: Evidence and Implications.
New York: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
. <www.ceip.org/intel>
18.
Clark, Ian
(2003)
‘Legitimacy in a Global Order’
. Review of International Studies29:
75-95
.
19.
Clarke, Richard A.
(2004) Against All Enemies: Inside America’s War on
Terror.
New York: Free Press
.
20.
Clinton, Bill
(1998) ‘Presidential Statement on
Kosovo’,
White House
, 12 October.
<http:%20//www.clintonpresidentialcenter.org/legacy/101298-presidential-statement-on-kosovo.htm>
(accessed 25 August 2004).
21.
CNN
(2002) ‘Interview with Condoleezza Rice Conducted
by Wolf Blitzer, CNN Late Edition’, 8 September.
<http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/bush/wolf.htm;>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
22.
Coates, A.J.
(1997) The Ethics of War.
Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press
.
23.
Coicaud, Jean-Marc
and
David Ames Curtis
(2002) Legitimacy and Politics: A Contribution to the Study
of Political Right and Political Responsibility.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
24.
Deen, Thalif
(2002) ‘US Dollars Yielded Unanimous UN Vote
Against Iraq’, Inter Press Service 11 November.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/attack/2002/1111dollars.htm>
(accessed 9 January 2004).
Evans, Gareth
and
Mohamed Sahnoun
(2001) The Responsibility to Protect.
International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty
, September. <http://www.idrc.ca
27.
Findlay, Trevor
(2002) The Use of Force in UN Peace Operations.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
,
28.
Fleischer, Ari
(2003) ‘Press Briefing.’White House
, 13 March.
<http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/03/20030313-13.html
(accessed 8 August 2004).
29.
Franck, Thomas M.
(1990) The Power of Legitimacy among Nations.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
30.
Franck, Thomas M.
(1992)
‘Editorial Comment: The “Powers of
Appreciation”: Who is the Ultimate Guardian of UN Legality?’
. American Journal of International Law86
.
31.
Gellman, Barton
(2004)
‘Iraq’s Arsenal Was Only on Paper: Since Gulf War,
Nonconventional Weapons Never Got Past the Planning Stage’
. Washington Post 7 January.
A01
.http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A60340-2004Jan6.html?referrer=email
32.
Global Policy Forum
(2003) ‘US Arm-Twisting.’<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/attack/armtwistindex.htm>
(accessed 9 January 2004).
33.
Global Policy Forum
(2004) ‘Changing Patterns in the Use of the Veto in
the Security Council.’ 2004.]
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/data/vetotab.htm>
(accessed 30 April 2004).
34.
Grafstein, Robert
(1981)
‘The Failure of Weber’s Conception of Legitimacy: Its
Causes and Implications’
. Journal of Politics43(2):
456-472
.
Habermas, Jürgen
(1979) Communication and the Evolution of Society.
Boston, MA: Beacon Press
.
37.
Habermas, Jürgen
(1984) The Theory of Communicative Action.
Boston, MA: Beacon Press
.
38.
Habermas, Jürgen
and
Maeve Cooke
(1998) On the Pragmatics of Communication.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
39.
Hall, Rodney Bruce
(1999) National Collective Identity: Social Constructs and
International Systems.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
40.
Hurd, Ian
(1999)
‘Legitimacy and Authority in International Politics’
. International Organization53(2):
379-408
.
41.
International Court of Justice
(2004) Case Summaries.
<http://212.153.43.18/icjwww/igeneralinformation/ibbook/Bbookframepage.htm>
(accessed 24 March 2004).
42.
Jehl, Douglas L.
(2004)
‘US Withdraws a Team of Weapons Hunters From Iraq’
. New York Times 8 January. http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/08/international/middleeast/08WEAP.html?position%20=%20&th%20=%20&pagewanted=print&position=
43.
Jehl, Douglas
and
David E. Sanger
(2004)
‘CIA Admits it Didn’t Give Weapon Data to the UN’
. New York Times 21 February p.
6
.
44.
Johnson, James Turner
(1981) Just War Tradition and the Restraint of War: A Moral
and Historical Inquiry.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
45.
Kessler, Glenn
(2003)
‘US Decision on Iraq has Puzzling Past’
. Washington Post 12 January p.
A01
. http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A43909-2003Jan11
46.
Kissinger, Henry
(1964) A World Restored (Universal Library
edn).
New York: Grosset & Dunlap
.
47.
Kratochwil, Friedrich V.
(1989) Rules, Norms, and Decisions on the Conditions of
Practical and Legal Reasoning in International Relations and Domestic
Affairs.
Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press
.
48.
Mroue, Bassem
(2003) ‘Iraq Says it’s Destroying More
Missiles’,
Associated Press
, 3 March.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/unmovic/2003/0303iraqsays.htm>
(accessed 11 January 2004).
49.
NATO
(1999a) ‘NATO’s Role in Relation to the
Conflict in Kosovo.’ 15 July.
<http://www.nato.int/kosovo/history.htm> (accessed 31
December 2003).
50.
NATO
(1999b) Statement issued at the Extraordinary Ministerial Meeting of
the North Atlantic Council (M-NAC-1(99)51), 12
April.
<http://www.nato.int/docu/pr/1999/p99-051e.htm> (accessed
30 December 2003).
51.
O’Brien, William Vincent
(1981) The Conduct of Just and Limited War.
New York: Praeger
.
52.
Onuf, Nicholas Greenwood
(1989) World of Our Making: Rules and Rule in Social Theory
and International Relations.
Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press
.
53.
Peel, Quentin
,
Robert Graham
,
James Harding
and
Judy Dempsey
(2003)
‘How the US Set a Course for War with Iraq’
. Financial Times 26 May. http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/attack/2003/0526course.htm
54.
hillips, Mark
(2004)
‘Inspectors Call US Tips “Garbage”’
, CBS News, 20 February. (accessed 7 August 2004).
55.
Powell, Colin L.
(2003) ‘Remarks to the United Nations Security
Council’,
US Department of State
, 5 February.
<http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2003/17300.htm>
(accessed 13 January 2004).
56.
Preston, Julia
and
Steven R. Weisman
(2003)
France Offering Plan to Expand Iraq Arms Hunt’
. New York Times 12 February.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/unmovic/2003/0212franceoff.htm>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
57.
Price, Niko
(2003) ‘Experts Say Iraq Doing Best to Disarm.’Associated Press
, 27 February.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/unmovic/2003/0227expertsay.htm>
(accessed 11 January 2004).
58.
Ramsey, Paul
(1968) The Just War: Force and Political
Responsibility.
New York: Scribner
.
59.
Rangwala, Glen (2003) ‘Blix and ElBaradei vs Powell.’
<http://middleeastreference.org.uk/un030214.html> (accessed
7 August 2004).
60.
Reisman, Michael W.
(1984)
‘Coercion and Self-Determination: Construing Charter Article 2(4)’
. American Journal of International Law78(3):
642-645
.
61.
Reisman, W. Michael
and
Chris T. Antoniou
(1994) The Laws of War: A Comprehensive Collection of Primary
Documents on International Laws Governing Armed Conflict, 1st edn.New York: Vintage Books
.
62.
Reynolds, Paul
(2003) ‘What Have We Learned about the
Dossier?’,
BBC
, 11 September.
<http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3090586.stm>
(accessed 7 January 2004).
63.
Risse, Thomas
(2000)
‘“Let’s Argue!” Communicative
Action in World Politics’
. International Organization54(1):
1-39
.
64.
Roberts, Adam
and
Richard Guelff
(2000) Documents on the Laws of War, 3rd edn.Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press
.
65.
Ronzitti, Natalino
(2002) ‘The Current Status of the Principles
Prohibiting the Use of Force and Legal Justifications of the Use of
Force’,
Instituto Affari Internazionali
, 8 June. <http://www.ciaonet.org/wps/ron01/>
(accessed 6 March 2003).
66.
Ruggie, John Gerard
(1993)
‘Territoriality and Beyond’
. International Organization47(1):
139-174
.
67.
Ruggie, John
(1998) ‘UN Forces: Whither — or
Whether?’, in
J. Ruggie
(ed.) Constructing the World Polity, pp.
240-255.
London: Routledge
.
68.
Rumsfeld, Donald H.
(2002) Statement of Donald H.
Rumsfeld before the House Armed Services Committee on Iraq
, 18 September.
<http://www.house.gov/hasc/openingstatementsandpressreleases/107thcongress/02-09-18rumsfeld.html>
accessed 7 August 2004).
69.
Sato, Tetsuo
(2001) ‘The Legitimacy of Security Council
Activities under Chapter VII of the UN Charter after the End of the Cold
War’, in
J.-M. Coicaud
and
V. Heiskanen
(eds) The Legitimacy of International Organizations, pp.
309-352.
Tokyo and New York: United Nations University Press
.
70.
Schabert, Tilo
(1986) ‘Power, Legitimacy and Truth: Reflections
on the Impossibility to Legitimise Legitimations of Political
Orders’, in
A. Moulakis
(ed.) Legitimacy/Lâegitimitâe, pp.
97-104.
Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter
.
71.
Schimmelfenning, Frank
(2001)
‘The Community Trap: Liberal Norms, Rhetorical Action, and
Eastern Enlargement of the European Union’
. International Organization55(1):
47-80
.
72.
Select Committee on Intelligence
(2004) Report of the US Intelligence Community’s
Prewar Intelligence Assessments on Iraq — Conclusions, 7 July. <http://intelligence.senate.gov/conclusions.pdf>
73.
Smith, Helena
(2003)
‘Blix: I Was Smeared by the Pentagon’
. Guardian 11 June.
<http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/unmovic/2003/0611blix.htm>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
74.
Steffek, Jens
(2003)
‘The Legitimation of International Governance: A Discourse Approach’
. European Journal of International Relations9(2):
249-275
.
75.
Suskind, Ron
(2004) The Price of Loyalty: George W. Bush, the White House,
and the Education of Paul O’Neill.
New York: Simon & Schuster
.
76.
UN General Assembly
(1974) Definition of Aggression. 29th session, 3314 (XXIX).
77.
United Nations
(1945) Charter of the United Nations.
<http://www.un.org/aboutun/charter/> (accessed 5 March 2003).
78.
UN News Centre
(2003) ‘Annan Names High-level Panel to Propose Collective
Action to Meet New Global Challenges.’<http://www.un.org/apps/news/infocusRel.asp?infocusID=84&Body=xxxxx&Body1=
(accessed 13 January 2004).
79.
UN Security Council
(1998) Resolution 1160. 3868, S/RES/1160.
80.
UN Security Council
(1998) Resolution 1199. 3930, S/RES/1199.
81.
UN Security Council
(1998) Resolution 1203. 3937, S/RES/1203.
82.
UN Security Council
(1998) Report of the Secretary-General prepared pursuant to
Resolutions 1160 (1998), 1199 (1998), and 1203 (1998) of the Security
Council.
New York
. 24 December. <http://ods-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N98/404/20/PDF/N9840420.pdf?OpenElement>
83.
UN Security Council
(1999a) UN Speech. 3988, S/PV 3988.
84.
UN Security Council
(1999b) UN Speech. 3989, S/PV 3989.
85.
UN Security Council
(2002) Resolution 1441. 4644, S/RES/1441.
86.
UN Security Council
(2003) Draft Resolution. S/2003/215.
87.
US Agency for International_Development
(1997) ‘Former Yugoslavia — Complex
Emergency.’ 31 July.
<http://www.cidi.org/humanitarian/hsr/97b/0013.html>
(accessed 13 January 2004).
88.
Walzer, Michael
(1992) Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical
Illustrations, 2nd edn.New York: Basic Books
.
89.
Walzer, Michael
(2004) Arguing about War.
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
.
90.
Washington Post (2002)
‘Mr Cheney on Iraq’
, 27 August.
<http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A125-2002Aug26?language=printer>
(accessed 7 August 2004).
91.
Wedgwood, Ruth
(2000)
‘Unilateral Action in the UN System’
. European Journal of International Law11(2):
349-359
.
92.
Weisburd, A. Mark
(1997) Use of Force: The Practice of States Since World War
II.
University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State
University Press
.
93.
Wendt, Alexander
(1999) Social Theory of International Politics.
Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press
.
94.
Wendt, Alexander
(2003)
‘Why a World State is Inevitable’
. European Journal of International Relations9(4):
491-542
.
95.
Wheeler, Nicholas J.
(2000) Saving Strangers: Humanitarian Intervention in
International Society.
Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press
.
96.
White House
(2002) ‘The National Security of the United States
of America’. PDF file. September.
<http://www.whitehouse.gov/nsc/nss.html> (accessed 10
October 2002).
97.
Wight, Martin
(1966) ‘Why is There No International
Theory?’, in
H. Butterfield
,
M. Wight
and
H. Bull
(eds) Diplomatic Investigations: Essays in the Theory of International
Politics, pp. 17-34.
London: Allen & Unwin
.
98.
Woodward, Bob
(2004) Plan of Attack.
New York: Simon & Schuster
.
99.
Wurst, Jim
(2003) ‘Annan Names Panel to Study Security
Threats, UN Reform. UN Wire, 4 November.
<http://www.unwire.org/UNWire/20031104/449_10084.asp>
(accessed 13 January 2004).
