While the `security communities' literature has underscored the positive implications of collective identity for sustained peace and cooperation within the communities, it has overlooked the possible security implications of the discourses and practices of differentiation necessarily entailed in the construction of collective identity. Building on the case of Turkish-Greek relations, I argue that through these discourses and practices of differentiation, community-building can create and sustain discursive conditions conducive to conflict perpetuation, especially with and among states situated in liminal positions with respect to the community. Analyzing official and media discourse in Turkey and Greece between 1995 and 1999, I demonstrate, how by situating Turkey and Greece in different and also liminal/precarious positions with respect to `Europe', the community-building discourse of the EU reinforced and legitimized in the two states representations of their identities as different from and also as threatening to each other.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, Emanuel and Michael Barnett (eds) (1998) Security Communities. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
2.
Adler, Emanuel (1998) `Seeds of Peaceful Change: The OSCE's Security Community-Building Model', in Emanuel Adler and Michael Barnett (eds) Security Communities, pp. 119-160. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
3.
`Aegean Rivals Have A Lot To Gain', Financial Times ( London ), 3 November 2000, 10.
Translated in Dis Basinda Gumruk Birligi Anlasmasi I (Customs Union Agreement in Foreign Press I), p. 265. Ankara: Directorate General of Press and Information .
7.
Translated in Dis Basinda Gumruk Birligi Anlasmasi II (Customs Union Agreement in Foreign Press II), p. 99. Ankara: Directorate General of Press and Information .
Birand, Mehmet Ali (1997) `Atina'nin Ilginc Turkiye Politikasi (Athens' Interesting Turkey Policy)', Sabah ( Istanbul ), 20 March, URL: http://garildi.sabah.com.tr.
11.
Blot, Yvan (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
12.
Buzan, Barry and Thomas Diez (1999) `The European Union and Turkey' , Survival41(1): 41-57 .
13.
Campbell, David (1992) Writing Security. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .
14.
Carnero-Gonzales, Carlos (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
15.
Cem, Ismail (1994) `Bu Sevdanin Sonu Boyle mi Gelmeliydi? (Is it Going to End This Way?)', Sabah ( Istanbul ), 18 December: 8.
16.
Cemal, Hasan (1997) `Dugumleri Cozmek (Untying the Knots)', Sabah ( Istanbul ), 31 October, URL: http://garildi.sabah.com.tr.
17.
Clogg, Richard (1991) `Greek-Turkish relations in the Post-1974 Period', in Dimitris Costas (ed.) The Greek-Turkish Conflict in the 1990s: Domestic and External Influences, pp. 12-25. London: Macmillan .
18.
Connolly, William E. (1991) Identity/Difference: Democratic Negotiations of Political Paradox. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
19.
Cronin, Bruce (1999) `From Balance to Community: Transnational Identity and Political Integration' , Security Studies8(2/3): 270-301 .
20.
De Vries, Gijs (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
21.
Diez, Thomas (2001) `Europe as a Discursive Battleground: Discourse Analysis and European Integration Studies' , Cooperation and Conflict36(1): 5-38 .
22.
Translated in Dis Basinda Gumruk Birligi Antlasmasi, I (Customs Union Agreement in Foreign Press), p. 174. Ankara: Directorate General of Press and Information .
23.
Esche, Martin (1990) `A History of Greek-Turkish Relations', in Ahmet Evin and Geoffrey Denton (eds) Turkey and the European Community, pp. 101-116. Opladen: Leske and Budrich .
24.
Fabre-Aubrespy, Herve (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
25.
Featherstone, Kevin (1996) `Introduction', in Kevin Featherstone and Kostas Ifantis (eds) Greece in a Changing Europe: Between European Integration and Balkan Disintegration?' pp. 3-16. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press .
26.
`Greece, Turkey Dash Latest Hopes For Thaw', The Washington Post ( Washington, DC ), 26 October 2000: A28.
27.
Gundogdu, Ayten (2001) `Identities in Question: Greek-Turkish Relations in a Period of Transformation?' , Middle East Review of International Affairs5(1): 106-117 .
28.
Gunugur, Haluk (1994) `Bir Diplomatik Hatanin Affedilmez Haffifligi (The Unforgiveable Lightness of a Diplomatic Error)', Cumhuriyet ( Istanbul ), 18 December: 6.
29.
Guvenc, Serhat (1998/1999) `Turkey's Changing Perception of Greece's Membership in the European Union,' Turkish Review of Balkan Studies4: 103-130 .
30.
Juncker, Jean-Claude (1997) `European Council in Luxembourg — Six Months of the Luxembourg Presidency' , sitting of 17 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament, URL: http://www3.europarl.eu.int.
31.
Kahl, Colin, H. (1998) `Constructing a Separate Peace: Constructivism, Collective Liberal Identity, and Democratic Peace' , Security Studies8(2/3): 94-144 .
32.
Kentel, Ferhat (1995a) `Perception of Balkan Neighbors in the Turkish Press (April-September 1995)', Balkan Neighbors Newsletter 1995/3. Sofia: Association for Contacts and Cooperation — East European Self Support , URL: http://www.access.online.bg/bn/newsletter/default.htm.
33.
Kentel, Ferhat (1995b) `Perception of Balkan Neighbors in the Turkish Press (October 1994-March 1995)', Balkan Neighbors Newsletter 1995/2. Sofia: Association for Contacts and Cooperation — East European Self Support , URL: http://www.access.online.bg/bn/newsletter/default.htm.
34.
Kentel, Ferhat (1997) `Perception of Balkan Neighbors in the Turkish Press (April-September 1997)', Balkan Neighbors Newsletter 1997/6. Sofia: Association for Contacts and Cooperation — East European Self Support , URL: http://www.access.online.bg/bn/newsletter/default.htm.
35.
Kentel, Ferhat (2000) `Perception of Balkan Countries and Local Minorities in the Turkish Press (April-December 1999)', Balkan Neighbors Newsletter 1997/6. Sofia: Association for Contacts and Cooperation — East European Self Support , URL: http://www.access.online.bg/bn/newsletter/default.htm.
36.
Kollias, Christos G. (1996) `The Greek-Turkish Conflict and Greek Military Expenditure 1960-1992' , Journal of Peace Research33(2): 217-228 .
37.
Kourvetaris, George A. (1988) `The Southern Flank of NATO: Political Dimensions of the Greco-Turkish Conflict Since 1974' , East European Quarterly21(4): 431-446 .
38.
Krebs, Ron (1999) `Perverse Institutionalism: NATO and the Greco-Turkish Conflict' , International Organization53(2): 343-377 .
39.
Krickus, Richard (2002) The Kaliningrad Question. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
40.
Lenkova, Mariana (1997) `Positive and Negative Stereotypes of Internal Minorities and Neighboring Peoples in the Greek Press', Balkan Neighbors Newsletter 1997/6. Sofia: Association for Contacts and Cooperation — East European Self Support , URL: http://www.access.online.bg/bn/newsletter/bn-6/6.htm.
41.
Lenkova, Mariana (ed) (1998) `Hate Speech' in the Balkans. Vienna: The International Helsinki Federation for Human Rights .
Martinez-Martinez, Miguel A. (1999) `State of Relations between Turkey and the EU' , sitting of 6 October, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament, URL: http://www3.europarl.eu.int/.
44.
Mengi, Gungor (1997) `Bahar Guzel Ama... (It is a Nice Spring, But...)', Sabah ( Istanbul ), 19 April, URL: http://garildi.sabah.com.tr/.
45.
Milliken, Jennifer (1999) `The Study of Discourse in International Relations: A Critique of Research and Methods' , European Journal of International Relations5(2): 225-254 .
46.
Muftuler-Bac, Meltem (1997) Turkey's Relations with a Changing Europe. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press .
47.
Neumann, Iver B. (1996) `Self and Other in International Relations' , European Journal of International Relations, 2(2): 139-174 .
48.
Neumann, Iver B. (1998) `European Identity, EU Expansion, and the Integration/Exclusion Nexus' , Alternatives23(3): 397-416 .
49.
Neumann, Iver B. (1999) Uses of the Other: The East in European Identity Formation. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .
50.
Neumann, Iver B. and Jennifer M. Welsh (1991) `The Other in European Self-Definition: An Addendum to the Literature on International Society' , Review of International Studies17(4): 327-348 .
51.
Norton, Anne (1988) Reflections on Political Identity. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press .
52.
Onis, Ziya (2000) `Luxembourg, Helsinki and Beyond: Turkey-EU Relations' , Government and Opposition35(4): 463-483 .
53.
Pettifer, James (1996) `Greek Political Culture and Foreign Policy', in Kevin Featherstone and Kostas Ifantis (eds) Greece in a Changing Europe: Between European Integration and Balkan Disintegration?, pp. 17-23. Manchester and New York: Manchester University Press .
`Rapprochement Comes Out of its Critical Test With Success', Turkish Probe ( Istanbul ), 6 November 2000.
56.
Risse-Kappen, Thomas (1996) `Collective Identity in a Democratic Community: The Case of NATO', in Peter Katzenstein (ed.) The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics, pp. 357-399. New York: Columbia University Press .
57.
Rocard, Michel (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
58.
Roth, Claudia (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
59.
Roth, Claudia (1997) `European Council in Luxembourg — Six Months of the Luxembourg Presidency' , sitting of 17 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament, URL: http://www3.europarl.eu.int.
60.
Rougheri, Christina (1998) `Positive and Negative Stereotypes of Internal Minorities and Neighboring Peoples in the Greek Press', Balkan Neighbors Newsletter 1998/7, Sofia: Association for Contacts and Cooperation — East European Self Support , URL: http://www.access.online.bg/bn/newsletter/bn-7/4.htm.
61.
Schulz, Martin (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
62.
Translated in Dis Basinda Gumruk Birligi II (Customs Union in Foreign Press II), pp. 163-165. Ankara: Directorate General of Press and Information .
Theonas, Ioannis (1995) `EC-Turkey Relations and Human Rights in Turkey', sitting of 13 December, Official Journal of the European Communities: Debates of the European Parliament (no. 4-472). Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities .
65.
Turenc, Tufan (1999) `Kuzey Kibris Oldugu Yerde Kalacak (Northern Cyprus Will Stay Where it is)', Hurriyet ( Istanbul ), 15 December, URL: http://arsiv.hurriyetim.com.tr/.
Translated in Dis Basinda Gumruk Birligi Anlasmasi II (Customs Union Agreement in Foreign Press II), p. 85. Ankara: Directorate General of Press and Information .
68.
Turner, Victor ([1969] 1995) The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure, 2nd edn. New York: Aldine De Gruyter .
69.
Vasquez, John A. (1995) `Why do Neighbors Fight? Proximity, Interaction or Territoriality' , Journal of Peace Research32(3): 277-293 .
70.
Wendt, Alex (1994) `Collective Identity Formation and the International State' , American Political Science Review88(2): 384-396 .
71.
Wood, Pia C. (1999) `Europe and Turkey: A Relationship under Fire' , Mediterranean Quarterly10(1): 95-115 .
