Modifiable risk factors for poor health outcomes in multiple sclerosis: The urgent need for research to maximise smoking cessation success

Abstract

Tobacco smoking is a well-established risk factor for multiple sclerosis (MS) onset, progression and poor health outcomes in people with MS. Despite smoking being a modifiable risk factor, no research has been undertaken to understand how, or who is best placed, to assess or understand smoking behaviour in people with MS, or how healthcare professionals can best assist people with MS to quit. People with MS may have unique motivators to continue smoking, or unique barriers to smoking cessation, that are not addressed by existing cessation tools. Research is urgently needed in this area if the aim is to maximise health outcomes for all people with MS.

Keywords

Multiple sclerosis smoking tobacco review cessation

Introduction

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic neurological condition with no known cause, although evidence suggests it occurs due to genetic vulnerability coupled with environmental factors.¹ The manifestations of the disease are heterogeneous, although common symptoms include fatigue, sensory disturbances, muscle weakness and cognitive impairment. Following a diagnosis of MS, often early in adulthood, a person experiences uncertainty about the expected course of their disease and impact on their future. While there are more than a dozen disease modifying therapies for people with relapsing-remitting MS (RRMS), pharmacological treatment for people with progressive disease is limited with one approved therapy for primary progressive MS and none for secondary progressive MS (SPMS) without relapses. None of these therapies provide 100% efficacy.² Recent developments of new and repurposed drugs, and new biomarkers to monitor progression, show promising results for future treatment of MS.² However, few treatments specifically target neurodegeneration and none reverse damage in the central nervous system. Unfortunately, most people with MS still experience accumulation of disabling symptoms over the course of the disease.³

A recent topical review in the Multiple Sclerosis Journal highlighted the role of tobacco smoking as a key determinant of MS onset, increasing the risk by approximately 50%.⁴ Observational cross-sectional and cohort studies show that modifiable lifestyle or health risk factors, including tobacco smoking, but also sedentary behaviour, obesity and low serum vitamin D levels, are associated with disability worsening.⁵ This suggests the potential to modify risk factors and improve health outcomes for people with MS.⁶

Tobacco smoking and health outcomes

A meta-analysis of eight data sets showed that smokers had an increased hazard ratio of 1.55 (95% confidence interval (CI) = 1.1–2.2) for faster progression compared with non-smokers. The authors concluded that although the evidence was of moderate quality due to heterogeneity, smoking is an important modifiable risk factor for MS progression.⁵ Smoking is also associated with lower quality of life,⁷ increased depression and anxiety⁸ and higher premature mortality.⁹ A prospective study of more than 900 people with MS showed that the hazard ratio for death in smokers compared with never smokers was 2.7 (95% CI = 1.6–4.6). Furthermore, the standardised mortality ratio for smokers with MS was 1.8 (95% CI = 1.2–2.7) compared with smokers without MS, while there was no difference between non-smokers with or without MS.⁹ Smoking may also adversely effect the efficacy of disease modifying drugs.^10,11 Quitting smoking has significant benefits for people with MS. Persistent smokers reached the progressive stage of MS eight years earlier compared with those who quit at time of diagnosis, accelerating time from RRMS to SPMS by 4.7% (95% CI = 2.3–7.2) for each successive year smoked.¹² Another study showed that smoking cessation significantly reduces the risk of reaching disability milestones, and the earlier people with MS or clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) quit, the stronger this effect (risk reduction is approximately 30% per 10 years).¹³ Given that increased disability leads to exponentially higher economic costs in MS,¹⁴ lowering smoking rates may lead to substantial economic benefits, in addition to improvements to health outcomes and quality of life. Economic modelling for people with Crohn’s disease, another chronic immune relapsing-remitting disorder, shows cost effectiveness and improved health outcomes of all potential smoking cessation strategies over no strategy.¹⁵ Furthermore, smoking cessation could decrease the risk of MS in family members who may be genetically susceptible for developing MS, a risk further increased by being exposed to passive smoking.¹⁶ Indeed, the risk of childhood-onset MS is reduced in children whose parent stops smoking.¹⁷

As smoking is a key risk factor for MS onset, it is not surprising that smoking rates are high at time of diagnosis. A UK study reported that 49% of 895 people smoked at time of MS diagnosis, with 22% still smoking 17 years later.¹⁸ Whether smoking remains more prevalent among people with MS compared with people with other chronic disease, or the general population is not well studied. However, some data from case-control studies suggests this is the case. An Australian case-control study of 282 people with first demyelinating event and 558 controls matched on age, sex and study region reported that 27.4% of people with MS smoked at time of enrolment versus 22.4% of controls,¹⁹ with 25.6% of people with MS still smoking five years later.²⁰ Data from a case-control study from Sweden also suggests that people with MS are more likely to smoke than controls matched for age, sex, and residential area: 36.5% of 902 people with MS versus 28.6% of 1855 controls.²¹ In addition, the increasing interest in cannabis to manage MS symptoms (one in five use cannabis regularly in the United Kingdom and Canada) may further increase the use of tobacco,²² as smoking a mix of tobacco and cannabis is common (although more evidence is needed in this area). It is a cause for considerable concern that around 20% of people with MS smoke cigarettes regularly, given the adverse consequences. We currently do not know what the barriers are to smoking cessation, what the motivators are to continue to smoke, whether people with MS are aware of the extent to which smoking contributes to their health outcomes, and what their needs are to receive smoking cessation assistance.

MS-specific motivators and barriers

It is possible that there are MS-specific motivators to continue smoking, as well as MS-specific barriers to smoking cessation, and that interventions designed for the general population are not meeting the needs of people with MS. Some motivators may be similar to those in other chronic disease populations (e.g. stress, boredom, coping, self-medication, perceived pain relief), while some may be unique to MS.^23,24 For people with acute health problems, the motivation to change behaviour should be higher, but if their health condition presents unique challenges that prevent them from quitting successfully,²⁵ many will find themselves unable to quit unless these challenges are adequately addressed. Several common symptoms such as cognitive dysfunction,²⁶ pain and depression²⁷ may be both motivators to continue smoking, and barriers to sustained smoking cessation. While smoking tobacco is harmful, nicotine may have actual and/or perceived benefits for symptoms,^21,28 as has been found in people with schizophrenia²⁹ and depression,³⁰ and in animal models for MS.³¹ Evidence from Swedish snuff users (smokeless tobacco) suggests that it is not the nicotine in tobacco that is responsible for an increased chance of MS onset, but other elements in the smoke.²¹ One key issue that is likely important with MS, and may be for some other conditions, is the role of nicotine. Nicotine may ameliorate deficits in cognitive function, such as inhibitory control, which can be impaired following abstinence.³² Similarly, depressive symptoms reduce cessation success²⁵ and there is a complex relationship between cognitive function, coping and depression in people with MS.^33,34 Finally, there is a clear association between smoking and pain,³⁵ which has been summarised as a positive feedback loop where smoking may be a risk factor for pain, while pain is a powerful motivator to continue smoking due to anti-nociceptive effects.³⁶ These feedback loops may be especially hard to break for people experiencing depression or anxiety who may have increased pain sensitivity (all common symptoms in MS) when attempting smoking cessation.³⁷ If indeed nicotine is actually or perceived to be helping with these issues, then this is likely to be one area where providing cessation assistance for those with MS may differ to the generic advice provided for all smokers. They also point to a potentially important role for nicotine replacement products. However, we have been unable to find any studies on the role of nicotine in ameliorating MS symptoms. In addition to the potential role of nicotine, there may be other disease-specific barriers, but this has not been investigated. We need to understand what additional or augmented resources people with MS may need (if any) on top of generic smoking cessation interventions if we are to maximise the likelihood of cessation programmes being successful.

MS management

Calls have been made for smoking cessation to be urgently advised to people with MS.^6,13,38,39 At present, we do not know to what extent people with MS receive assessment, advice and assistance by health professionals to quit smoking, but there is some evidence of an unmet need.⁴⁰ We currently do not know whether MS clinicians, or other health professionals are aware of the specific consequences of smoking on MS health outcomes, or if they feel able or willing to assist people with MS to quit smoking. The most effective method to offer smoking assessment and cessation intervention is also unclear (e.g. through a general practitioner, MS nurse, or neurologist). Anecdotally, time, resource or knowledge barriers may exist for health practitioners to assess smoking behaviour, refer to, or provide interventions. Furthermore, there may be a lack of confidence that existing smoking cessation interventions or tools available are effective for people with MS, which may be true to a degree if such interventions miss important MS-specific issues. Understanding current knowledge and practice, including gaps and barriers to assessing and addressing smoking from a healthcare provider perspective are essential in guideline or intervention development. Important aspects that need to be considered include: assessing smoking behaviour, referring for intervention, delivering the intervention and follow-up. For each of these aspects we need to consider what is the best method, which healthcare professional is best placed, and what is the best timing. From the perspective of the person with MS, there may be disease and sociodemographic considerations for smoking cessation management, such as whether people with specific symptoms, for example, cognitive impairment, depression or pain, require different levels of provider support. The answers to these questions may differ between countries depending on the structure of the healthcare system and/or access to generic smoking cessation programmes.

Tailored smoking cessation interventions

In many other areas of health, tailoring basic smoking cessation interventions to include a focus on comorbidities or problem-specific barriers are showing evidence of improving outcomes. Interventions that are tailored to specific groups, and take into account social determinants, may be more successful in promoting cessation, for example, tailoring to people with low literacy.⁴¹ For example, a customised intervention, including behavioural therapy and nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) is effective in people with cardiovascular disease⁴² and cancer.⁴³ For people with psychotic illness, eight sessions of intensive clinician-delivered therapies in combination with NRT were effective in a dose-response manner,⁴⁴ and in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, interventions with specific behaviour change techniques were found to be most efficacious.⁴⁵ It has been suggested that a combination of NRT and behavioural mood management should be considered for people with depression, although more evidence is needed to confirm efficacy.⁴⁶ It is troubling that nothing is happening to provide similar interventions tailored for our priority population, those with (or at risk of) MS.

Tailoring interventions to people with MS

Despite the known risks for health outcomes and premature mortality, not one study of an intervention for smoking cessation has been undertaken in people with MS or CIS.^42,45,47 One smoking cessation trial was designed in 2012,⁴⁸ but this was halted due to a combination of recruitment difficulties including lack of interest in quitting, and funding restrictions (personal communication, J Ciccolo 2017). The dearth of research into this key modifiable risk factor is in stark contrast to other modifiable risk factors such as physical inactivity and low vitamin D, where dozens of studies including meta-analyses are published.

Future research in this area needs to address the following questions:

Are people with MS more likely to smoke than people with other chronic disease or the general population?

Are people with MS, especially smokers, aware of the additional risks of smoking for their MS?

Are there MS/CIS-specific motivators for smoking behaviour? In particular, what is the role of nicotine?

Are there MS/CIS-specific barriers to smoking cessation? In particular, do specific MS symptoms impact cessation success?

To what extent is smoking behaviour routinely assessed and addressed in clinical practice?

What is the best method to assess smoking behaviour and refer people for smoking cessation?

To what extent is the MS health workforce aware of the importance of smoking cessation for people with MS?

Which healthcare provider is best placed to provide assessment and or cessation intervention?

When (and how often) is the best time to assess, refer or intervene?

To what extent are existing smoking cessation interventions effective in people with MS?

Should and can existing smoking cessation interventions be adapted to better meet the needs of people with MS and CIS?

Given the paucity of evidence in the area currently, the priority would be to understand what MS/CIS-specific barriers to smoking cessation exist, and what barriers from healthcare professionals exist in assessing and referring for smoking cessation. This will enable learnings from smoking cessation research in other areas to be adapted and applied to the development of guidelines and interventions to be tested for efficacy in people with MS.

Challenges

There may be challenges in recruiting smokers for smoking cessation intervention studies, highlighting the importance of assessing the feasibility and acceptability of interventions, prior to phase III effectiveness trials. Smokers newly diagnosed with MS may be highly motivated to take action if made aware of the implications of the diagnosis and the evidence that smoking speeds progression. Combinations of the use of telephone Quitlines and online resources can help overcome challenges of accessing people with MS across a broad geographic region and in remote areas. Involvement of MS clinicians including neurologists, MS nurses and/or general practitioners are crucial to drive clinical change, depending on the healthcare setting. Models where MS clinicians work with smoking cessation experts to deliver high quality integrated services are possible, and these are increasingly being used by Quitlines to help support groups requiring more than standard levels of assistance.^49,50 Efforts to design and test smoking cessation interventions for priority groups are considered the last frontier in tobacco control in countries with low smoking rates such as Australia.⁵¹ The savings to economic and healthcare costs, improvements to health outcomes and quality of life could be substantial given people often live with MS for 3–5 decades following diagnosis. This would justify intense interventions, as in other chronic disease.¹⁵

Conclusion

Despite compelling evidence that smoking is a key risk factor for development, unfavourable health outcomes and premature mortality in people with MS, there is little focus in research or clinical practice on smoking cessation. There is an urgent need to understand whether there are MS-specific barriers for smoking cessation, whether there are real or perceived benefits from smoking or nicotine on MS symptoms, and what best practice is around assessing and addressing smoking in people with MS. We present this topical review to MS and smoking cessation researchers, as well as relevant funding bodies, to highlight that much needed research in this key modifiable lifestyle factor is required if we are to maximise health outcomes for all people with MS.

Footnotes

Declaration of Conflicting Interests

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: C.H.M. is funded by an Early Career Fellowship from the National Health and Medical Research Council (ID: 1120014).

ORCID iDs

Claudia H Marck

Roshan das Nair

References

Olsson

Barcellos

Alfredsson

Interactions between genetic, lifestyle and environmental risk factors for multiple sclerosis. Nature Rev Neurol 2016; 13: 25.

Ciccarelli

Multiple sclerosis in 2018: New therapies and biomarkers. Lancet Neurol 2019; 18(1): 10–12.

Cohen

Rae-Grant

Handbook of multiple sclerosis. 2nd ed. London: Springer Healthcare, 2012.

Hedstrom

AK.

Smoking and its interaction with genetics in MS etiology. Mult Scler 2019; 25(2): 180–186.

Hempel

Graham

, et al. A systematic review of modifiable risk factors in the progression of multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler 2017; 23: 525–533.

Amato

Derfuss

Hemmer

, et al. Environmental modifiable risk factors for multiple sclerosis: Report from the 2016 ECTRIMS focused workshop. Mult Scler 2017; 24(5): 590–603.

Briggs

Gunzler

Ontaneda

, et al. Smokers with MS have greater decrements in quality of life and disability than non-smokers. Mult Scler 2017; 23(13): 1772–1781.

McKay

Tremlett

Fisk

, et al. Adverse health behaviours are associated with depression and anxiety in multiple sclerosis: A prospective multisite study. Mult Scler 2016; 22(5): 685–693.

Manouchehrinia

Weston

Tench

, et al. Tobacco smoking and excess mortality in multiple sclerosis: A cohort study. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2014; 85(10): 1091–1095.

10.

Hedstrom

Alfredsson

Lundkvist Ryner

, et al. Smokers run increased risk of developing anti-natalizumab antibodies. Mult Scler 2014; 20(8): 1081–1085.

11.

Hedstrom

Ryner

Fink

, et al. Smoking and risk of treatment-induced neutralizing antibodies to interferon beta-1a. Mult Scler 2014; 20(4): 445–450.

12.

Ramanujam

Hedstrom

Manouchehrinia

, et al. Effect of smoking cessation on multiple sclerosis prognosis. JAMA Neurol 2015; 72(10): 1117–1123.

13.

Tanasescu

Constantinescu

Tench

, et al. Smoking cessation and the reduction of disability progression in Multiple Sclerosis: A cohort study. Nicotine Tob Res 2017; 20(5): 589–595.

14.

Patwardhan

Matchar

Samsa

, et al. Cost of multiple sclerosis by level of disability: A review of literature. Mult Scler 2005; 11(2): 232–239.

15.

Coward

Heitman

Clement

, et al. Funding a smoking cessation program for Crohn’s disease: An economic evaluation. Am J Gastroenterol 2015; 110(3): 368–377.

16.

Poorolajal

Bahrami

Karami

, et al. Effect of smoking on multiple sclerosis: A meta-analysis. J Public Health (Oxf) 2017; 39(2): 312–320.

17.

Mikaeloff

Caridade

Tardieu

, et al. Parental smoking at home and the risk of childhood-onset multiple sclerosis in children. Brain 2007; 130(Pt. 10): 2589–2595.

18.

Manouchehrinia

Tench

Maxted

, et al. Tobacco smoking and disability progression in multiple sclerosis: United Kingdom cohort study. Brain 2013; 136(Pt. 7): 2298–2304.

19.

Ponsonby

Lucas

Dear

, et al. The physical anthropometry, lifestyle habits and blood pressure of people presenting with a first clinical demyelinating event compared to controls: The Ausimmune study. Mult Scler 2013; 19(13): 1717–1725.

20.

Tao

Simpson

Jr Taylor

, et al. Onset symptoms, tobacco smoking, and progressive-onset phenotype are associated with a delayed onset of multiple sclerosis, and marijuana use with an earlier onset. Front Neurol 2018; 9: 418.

21.

Hedstrom

Baarnhielm

Olsson

, et al. Tobacco smoking, but not Swedish snuff use, increases the risk of multiple sclerosis. Neurology 2009; 73: 696–701.

22.

Banwell

Pavisian

Lee

, et al. Attitudes to cannabis and patterns of use among Canadians with multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler Relat Disord 2016; 10: 123–126.

23.

Newland

Flick

Xian

, et al. Symptom co-occurrences associated with smoking in individuals with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. Int J MS Care 2016; 18(4): 163–168.

24.

Friend

Mernoff

Block

, et al. Smoking rates and smoking cessation among individuals with multiple sclerosis. Disabil Rehabil 2006; 28(18): 1135–1141.

25.

Cooper

Borland

McKee

, et al. Depression motivates quit attempts but predicts relapse: Differential findings for gender from the International Tobacco Control Study. Addiction 2016; 111(8): 1438–1447.

26.

Drew

Tippett

Starkey

, et al. Executive dysfunction and cognitive impairment in a large community-based sample with multiple sclerosis from New Zealand: A descriptive study. Arch Clin Neuropsychol 2008; 23(1): 1–19.

27.

Feinstein

Multiple sclerosis and depression. Mult Scler 2011; 17: 1276–1281.

28.

Reale

Di Bari

Di Nicola

, et al. Nicotinic receptor activation negatively modulates pro-inflammatory cytokine production in multiple sclerosis patients. Int Immunopharmacol 2015; 29(1): 152–157.

29.

Quisenaerts

Morrens

Hulstijn

, et al. Acute nicotine improves social decision-making in non-smoking but not in smoking schizophrenia patients. Front Neurosci 2013; 7: 197.

30.

Salin-Pascual

RJ.

Relationship between mood improvement and sleep changes with acute nicotine administration in non-smoking major depressed patients. Rev Invest Clin 2002; 54(1): 36–40.

31.

Gomes

Watad

Shoenfeld

Nicotine and autoimmunity: The lotus’ flower in tobacco. Pharmacol Res 2018; 128: 101–109.

32.

Charles-Walsh

Furlong

Munro

, et al. Inhibitory control dysfunction in nicotine dependence and the influence of short-term abstinence. Drug Alcohol Depend 2014; 143: 81–86.

33.

Grech

Kiropoulos

Kirby

, et al. Coping mediates and moderates the relationship between executive functions and psychological adjustment in multiple sclerosis. Neuropsychology 2016; 30(3): 361–376.

34.

Mathew

Hogarth

Leventhal

, et al. Cigarette smoking and depression comorbidity: Systematic review and proposed theoretical model. Addiction 2017; 112(3): 401–412.

35.

Marck

De Livera

Weiland

, et al. Pain in people with multiple sclerosis: Associations with modifiable lifestyle factors, fatigue, depression, anxiety, and mental health quality of life. Front Neurol 2017; 8: 461.

36.

Ditre

Brandon

Zale

, et al. Pain, nicotine, and smoking: Research findings and mechanistic considerations. Psychol Bull 2011; 137(6): 1065–1093.

37.

Zale

Maisto

Ditre

JW.

Anxiety and depression in bidirectional relations between pain and smoking: Implications for smoking cessation. Behav Modif 2016; 40(1–2): 7–28.

38.

Newland

Flick

Salter

, et al. The link between smoking status and co-morbid conditions in individuals with multiple sclerosis (MS). Disabil Health J 2017; 10: 587–591.

39.

Hempel

Graham

, et al. A systematic review of the effects of modifiable risk factor interventions on the progression of multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler 2017; 23(4): 513–524.

40.

Turner

Kivlahan

Kazis

, et al. Smoking among veterans with multiple sclerosis: Prevalence correlates, quit attempts, and unmet need for services. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2007; 88(11): 1394–1399.

41.

Bennett

Gilbert

Sutton

Computer-tailored smoking cessation advice matched to reading ability: Perceptions of participants from the ESCAPE trial. Patient Educ Couns 2015; 98: 1577–1584.

42.

Suissa

Lariviere

Eisenberg

, et al. Efficacy and safety of smoking cessation interventions in patients with cardiovascular disease: A network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2017; 10(1): e002458.

43.

Klemp

Steffenssen

Bakholdt

, et al. Counseling is effective for smoking cessation in head and neck cancer patients-a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2016; 74(8): 1687–1694.

44.

Baker

Richmond

Haile

, et al. A randomized controlled trial of a smoking cessation intervention among people with a psychotic disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2006; 163(11): 1934–1942.

45.

Bartlett

Sheeran

Hawley

MS.

Effective behaviour change techniques in smoking cessation interventions for people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A meta-analysis. Br J Health Psychol 2014; 19(1): 181–203.

46.

Gierisch

Bastian

Calhoun

, et al. Smoking cessation interventions for patients with depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Gen Intern Med 2012; 27(3): 351–360.

47.

Huttunen-Lenz

Song

Poland

Are psychoeducational smoking cessation interventions for coronary heart disease patients effective? Meta-analysis of interventions. Br J Health Psychol 2010; 15(Pt. 4): 749–777.

48.

Ciccolo

Jennings

, et al. Rationale and design of a clinical trial investigating resistance training as an aid to smoking cessation in persons with multiple sclerosis. Contemp Clin Trials 2012; 33(4): 848–852.

49.

Segan

Baker

Turner

, et al. Nicotine withdrawal, relapse of mental illness, or medication side-effect? Implementing a monitoring tool for people with mental illness into Quitline counseling. J Dual Diagn 2017; 13(1): 60–66.

50.

Segan

Borland

Wilhelm

, et al. Helping smokers with depression to quit smoking: Collaborative care with Quitline. Med J Aust 2011; 195(3): S7–S11.

51.

Bonevski

Borland

Paul

, et al. No smoker left behind: It’s time to tackle tobacco in Australian priority populations. Med J Aust 2017; 207: 141–142.