Standard Calculation of Outdoor Noise Propagation – Errors Due to Propagation Effect

Abstract

This paper looks at the common errors that may occur when applying existing standard methods of outdoor noise calculation to realistic environments. The two methods investigated are those described in the CONCAWE report 4/81 and the international standard ISO 9613 Part 2. These standard methods are based mainly on empirical developments and are therefore limited by the environmental conditions upon which the methods were derived. Based on comparisons obtained in real outdoor measurements, this paper shows that significant errors occur when the methods are applied to situations where the ground cover changes from the assumed types, when a finite length barrier is used on soft ground, or when the meteorological condition is significant. The error tends to increase with greater interactions between the ground, barrier and meteorological conditions. The result of this paper should provide a better understanding of the limitations of these standard methods and should therefore help to reduce the chance of these methods being used in inapplicable surroundings.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Gilbert

West

Sack

R.A.

, “A tutorial on the parabolic equation (PE) model used for long range sound propagation in the atmosphere”, Applied Acoustics, 37, 31–49 (1992).

Crombie

D.H.

Hothersall

D.C.

Chandler-Wilde

S.N.

, “Multiple-Edge Noise Barriers”, Applied Acoustics, 44, 353–368 (1995).

“The Propagation of Noise from Petroleum and Petrochemical Complexes to Neighbouring Communities”, CONCAWE Report no. 4/81, Madouplein 1, B-1030 Brussels, Belgium (1981).

ISO 9613–2, “Acoustics – Attenuation of Sound During Propagation Outdoors – Part 2: A General Method of Calculation”, Draft International Standard, ISO (1992).

Maekawa

, “Noise reduction by screens,” Applied Acoustics, 1, 157–173 (1968).

Calculation of Road Traffic Noise, Department of Transport, Welsh Office, HMSO, 1988.

Lam

Y.W.

, “Using Maekawa's chart to calculate finite length barrier insertion loss”, Applied Acoustics, 42(1), 29–40 (1994).

Lam

Y.W.

Roberts

S.C.

, “A Simple Method for Accurate Prediction of Finite Barrier Insertion Loss”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 93, 1445–1452 (1993).

Herzog

L'Espérance

Daigle

G. A.

Nicolas

J.R.

, “Heuristic model for outdoor sound propagation based on an extension of the geometrical ray theory in the case of linear sound speed profile”. Applied Acoustics, 37, 111–139 (1992).

10.

Daigle

G.A.

, “Diffraction of sound by a noise barrier in the presence of atmospheric turbulence”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 71. 847–854.

11.

Embleton

T.F.W.

Piercy

J.E.

Daigle

G.A.

, “Effective Flow Resistivity of Ground Surfaces Determined by Acoustical Measurements”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 74(4), 1239–1244 (1983).

12.

Parkin

P.H.

Scholes

W.E.

, “The Horizontal Propagation of Sound from a Jet Engine Close to the Ground at Hatfield”, J. Sound Vib., 2(4), 353–374 (1965).

13.

Edwards

N.J.

Lam

Y.W.

, “Investigating a simple method of including the effect of turbulence into short to medium range sound propagation prediction schemes”, Proc. of IOA, Vol. 16(2), 91–100 (1994).