Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2025
Exploring biotite – a naturally occurring silicate as a sustainable additive in calcium hydroxide/castor oil eco-friendly grease for controlling friction,wear,and energy consumption
The environmental impact of non-biodegradable lubricants has increased interest in eco-friendly alternatives. This study investigates the tribological properties of a calcium-based grease with biotite, a naturally occurring anti-wear additive, compared to molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) which is not so environmentally friendly and commercial lithium grease. Biotite was added to calcium grease at various concentrations (0.2 wt.%, 0.4 wt.%, 0.6 wt.%, and 0.8 wt.%) along with castor oil and hydrogenated castor oil as other eco-friendly components. Thermogravimetric analysis showed that biotite-enhanced grease had superior thermal stability. Tribological testing revealed that 0.2 wt.% biotite and MoS2 reduced wear scar diameter by 28.67% and 39.13%, and the coefficient of friction reduced by 10% and 14% as compared to the base calcium grease. The commercial lithium grease exhibited 15% and 19% higher frictional properties than our proposed calcium grease. The addition of biotite also improved the load wear index by 15.69%, demonstrating its superior anti-wear and load-carrying properties compared to MoS2. Additionally, the biotite-enhanced grease showed 13.79% lower current consumption than commercial lithium grease. The results were also supported by the statistical analysis, which indicated higher influence of the anti-wear properties of biotite than its anti-friction properties and vice-versa in the case of molybdenum disulfide. These findings suggest that biotite can be a sustainable, cost-effective additive for improving the tribological properties of bio-based greases.
ParenagoOPSafievaRZAntonovSV, et al.State-of-the-Art and future prospects of production of biodegradable lubricating greases (review). PetChem2017; 57: 1144–1146.
2.
PrasannakumarPSankarannairSBoseC, et al.Influence of techniques on synthesizing cashew nut shell oil as a prospective biolubricant on its physicochemical, tribological, and thermal behaviors. J Cleaner Prod2023; 401: 136717.
3.
PrasannakumarPSanthakumariRThampiAD, et al.Epoxidation of Calophyllum inophyllum oil fatty acid methyl esters as a potential base-stock for green cutting fluid. Env Develop Sust2024
4.
ChoudhuryNDBhaumikSSahaN,et al.Investigating the tribological properties of TiO2 nanoparticles added Thevetia peruviana and Cucurbita pepo L. blend oils. Tribol Int2024; 197: 109769.
5.
BhaumikSMaggirwarRDattaS,et al.Analyses of anti-wear and extreme pressure properties of castor oil with zinc oxide nano friction modifiers. Appl Surf Sci2018; 449: 277–286.
6.
AhmedMNairKTirthV, et al.Tribological evaluation of date seed oil and castor oil blends with halloysite nanotube additives as environment friendly bio-lubricants. Biomass Conv Biorefinery2021.
7.
SrivastavaJNandiTTrivediRK. Experimental investigations on thermophysical, tribological and rheological properties of MoS2 and WS2 based nanolubricants with castor oil as base lubricant. Tribology - Industry2023; 45: 91.
8.
Martín-AlfonsoJEMartín-AlfonsoMJValenciaC,et al.Rheological and tribological approaches as a tool for the development of sustainable lubricating greases based on nano-montmorillonite and castor oil. Friction2021; 9: 415–428.
9.
NúñezNMartín-AlfonsoJEEugenioM, et al.Preparation and characterization of gel-like dispersions based on cellulosic pulps and castor oil for lubricant applications. Ind Eng Chem Res2011; 50: 5618–5627.
10.
KamelBMMohamedAGadMS. Tribological and rheological properties of calcium grease with hybrid nano additives. J Dispersion Sci Technol2024; 45: 559–568.
11.
NegiRSSinghRKDattaS,et al.Investigation of tribological performance of eco-friendly pentaerythritol tetraoleate ester based calcium Complex grease. Waste Biomass Valorization2024; 15: 2947–2960.
12.
RawatSSHarshaAP. The lubrication effect of different vegetable oil-based greases on steel-steel tribo-pair. Biomass Conversion and Biorefinery2024; 14: 1993–2005.
13.
DreselWH. Biologically degradable lubricating greases based on industrial crops. Ind Crops Prod1994; 2: 281–288.
14.
WatanabeKTanakaK. Study into structural impact of novel calcium Complex grease delivering high temperature performance. Tribology Online2016; 11: 639–645.
15.
RajKDasAP. Lead pollution: impact on environment and human health and approach for a sustainable solution. Env Chem Ecotoxicology2023; 5: 79–85.
16.
MadanhireIMbohwaCMadanhireI. Lubricant additive impacts on human health and the environment. In: Mitigating environmental impact of petroleum lubricants. Cham: Springer, 2016, pp.17–34.
17.
TroyETilburyMAPowerAM,et al.Nature-Based biomaterials and their application in biomedicine. Polymers (Basel)2021; 13: 3321.
18.
YuHLWangHMYinYL, et al.Tribological behaviors of natural attapulgite nanofibers as an additive for mineral oil investigated by orthogonal test method. Tribol Int2021; 153: 106562.
19.
MantovaniACGChendynskiLTGalvanD, et al.Thermal-oxidation study of biodiesel by proton nuclear magnetic resonance (1H NMR). Fuel2020; 274: 117833.
20.
YuanKWangCBYueW, et al.The study on tribological properties of muscovite a mineral lubricating oil additive. Lubr Eng2008; 33: 61–65.
21.
DuPChenGSongS, et al.Tribological properties of muscovite, CeO2 and their composite particles as lubricant additives. Tribol Lett2016; 62: –9.
22.
DuPChenGXSongS, et al.Effect of thermal activation on the tribological behaviors of muscovite particles as lubricant additives in lithium grease. Industrial Lubrication Tribol2018; 70: 538–543.
23.
DuPChenGSongS, et al.Preparation and tribological properties of Ni-doped muscovite composite particles as a lubricant additive in for lithium grease. Tribol2017; 37: 19–26.
24.
ZhangZYinYLYuHL, et al.Tribological behaviors and mechanisms of surface-modified sepiolite powders as lubricating oil additives. Tribol Int2022; 173: 107637.
25.
WangFGaoPLiangJ, et al.Surface-modified sepiolite nanofibers as a novel lubricant additive. Clays Clay Miner2019; 67: 283–290.
26.
YuHXuYShiP, et al.Microstructure, mechanical properties and tribological behavior of tribo film generated from natural serpentine mineral powders as lubricant additive. Wear2013; 297: 802–810.
27.
YuHLXuYShiPJ, et al.Tribological behaviors of surface-coated serpentine ultrafine powders as lubricant additive. Tribol Int2010; 43: 667–675.
28.
ZhangBXuYGaoF, et al.Sliding friction and wear behaviors of surface-coated natural serpentine mineral powders as lubricant additive. Appl Surf Sci2011; 257: 2540–2549.
29.
QiXJiaZYangY,et al.Characterization and auto-restoration mechanism of nanoscale serpentine powder as lubricating oil additive under high temperature. Tribol Int2011; 44: 805–810.
30.
YinYLYuHLWangHM, et al.Friction and wear behaviors of steel/bronze tribo pairs lubricated by oil with serpentine natural mineral additive. Wear2020; 456-457: 203387.
31.
NanFWangD. Tribological properties of attapulgite nanofiber as lubricant additive for electric-brush plated Ni coating. Lubricants2023; 11: 04.
32.
VasićBCzibulaCKratzerM, et al.Two-dimensional talc as a van der waals material for solid lubrication at the nanoscale. Nanotechnology2021; 32: 265701.
33.
RaadnuiS. Plain bearing used grease debris analysis. Int J Appl Mech Eng2002; 7: 273–276.
34.
OliveiraRDYoshidaABBRabahiC, et al.Ultrathin natural biotite crystals as a dielectric layer for van der waals heterostructure applications. Nanotechnol2024; 35: 505703.
35.
GurbanovGRGasimzadeAAbbasovaL. Study of the properties of depressor additive “Difron-3970” and the new composition. Azerbaijan: Nafta-Gaz, 2024, pp.759–766.
FleischerG. Zum Energetischen Niveau von Reibpaarungen. In: Schmierungstechnik 16. Germany: VEB Verlag Technik, 1985, pp.358–363.
38.
FleischerGGrögerHThumH. Verschleiß und Zuverlässigkeit. Germany: VEB Verlag Technik, 1980.
39.
AcarNFrancoJMKuhnE, et al.Tribological investigation on the friction and wear behaviors of biogenic lubricating greases in steel–steel contact. Appl Sci2020; 10: 1477.
40.
PennestrìERossiVSalviniP,et al.Review and comparison of dry friction force models. Nonlinear Dyn2016; 83: 1785–1801.
41.
FengIM. A new approach in interpreting the four-ball wear results. Wear1962; 5: 275–288.
42.
KragelskiIPDobitsinMNKombalovVS. Reibung und Verschleiß. Technik: Verl, 1982.
43.
BhaumikSDattaSPathakSD. Analyses of tribological properties of castor oil with various carbonaceous micro- and nano-friction modifiers. J Tribol2017; 139: 061802.
44.
YanZG. Technical manual for lubricant performance testing. Beijing, China: Petroleum Industry Press, 2000.
45.
GeethanjaliGPadmajaK. Synthesis, characterization, and evaluation of castor oil-based acylated derivatives as potential lubricant base stocks. Ind Eng Chem Res2016; 55: 5801–5808.
46.
BhaumikSMaggirwarRDattaS,et al.Analyses of anti-wear and extreme pressure properties of castor oil with zinc oxide nano friction modifiers. Appl Surf Sci2018; 449: 277–286.
47.
YadavGTiwariSJainM. Tribological analysis of extreme pressure and anti-wear properties of engine lubricating oil using four ball tester. Mater Today Proc2018; 5: 22129–22135.
48.
IgeOOAriboSObadeleBA, et al.A facile and effective method to improve the dispersibility of WS2 nanosheets in PAO8 for the tribological performances. Tribol Int2017; 118: 60–70.
49.
ProlicTCLepusicA. Effect of foaming on the antiwear properties of lubricating oils. Goriva iMaziva2012; 51: 38.
50.
ChatziADoodyO. The one-way ANOVA test explained. Nurse Res2023; 31: 8–14.
51.
KimTK. T test as a parametric statistic. Korean J Anesthesiol2015; 68: 540–546.
52.
JoysulaSKDubeAPatroD,et al.On the fictitious grease lubrication performance in a four-ball tester. Lubricants2021; 9: 33.
53.
OettingFLHolleyCE. The specific heat capacity of biotite. J Chem Thermodyn1982; 14: 1029–1034.
54.
KhairuldeanAKIngTCChe KobMS, et al.Extreme pressure properties investigation of palm olein using four ball tribotester. AIP Conf Proc2012; 1440: 920–927.
55.
RobertsonECHemingwayBS. Estimating heat capacity and heat content of rocks. U.S. Geological Surv1995; 95–622.
KwonTYFujishimaTImaiY. FT-Raman spectroscopy of calcium hydroxide medicament in root canals. Int Endod J2004; 37: 489–493.
58.
ShekadeSVShirolkarSDeshkarS,et al.Phytochemical, pharmacognostic and pharmacological aspects of Ricinus communis seed oil: an overview. Natural Product J2023; 13: 31–47.
59.
BhaumikSPathakSDDeyS,et al.AI-based design of multiple friction modifiers dispersed castor oil and evaluating its tribological properties. Tribol Int2019; 140: 105813.
60.
ZengQDongGMartinJM. Green lubricity of nitinol 60 alloy against steel in presence of castor oil. Sci Rep2016; 6: 29992–30001.
61.
BhaumikSKamarajM. Artificial neural network and multi-criteria decision-making approach of designing a blend of biodegradable lubricants and investigating its tribological properties. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part J2021; 235: 1575–1589.
62.
JolayemiOSAlagbeCI. Influence of seed variety and extraction technique on fatty acid distribution and quality parameters of tropical castor (Ricinus communis L.) oils. J Oleo Sci2022; 71: 1565–1575.
63.
YinYLYuHLWangHM, et al.Friction and wear behaviors of steel/bronze tribo pairs lubricated by oil with serpentine natural mineral additive. Wear2020; 456-457: 203387.
64.
ShiYZhouWLuAY, et al.Van der Waals epitaxy of MoS2 layers using graphene as growth templates. Nano Lett2012; 12: 2784–2791.
65.
NiPDiengMVanelJC, et al.Liquid shear exfoliation of MoS2: preparation, characterization, and NO2-sensing properties. Nanomaterials2023; 13: 2502.
66.
BowerWHeadWDroopGT, et al.High-resolution imaging of biotite using focal series exit wavefunction restoration and the graphene mechanical exfoliation method. Mineral Mag2015; 79: 337–344.
67.
MahapatraPLTromerRPandeyP, et al.Synthesis and characterization of biotene: a new 2D natural oxide from biotite. Small2022; 18: e2201667.
68.
ZhangBXuYGaoF, et al.Sliding friction and wear behaviors of surface-coated natural serpentine mineral powders as lubricant additive. Appl Surf Sci2011; 257: 2540–2549.
69.
WamplerJ. Misconceptions: a column about errors in geoscience textbooks. J Geosci Educ2000; 48: 92–94.
70.
SaediBMohammadiSShahbaziH. Application of fuzzy inference system to predict uniaxial compressive strength and elastic modulus of migmatites. Env Earth Sci2019; 78: 21.
71.
AslinJMarianiEDawsonK,et al.Ripplocations provide a new mechanism for the deformation of phyllosilicates in the lithosphere. Nat Commun2019; 10: 86.
72.
SinghaMSinghL.Vibrational spectroscopic study of muscovite and biotite layered phyllosilicates. Indian J Pure Appl Phys2016; 54: 116–122.
73.
KloproggeJT. Raman Spectroscopy of clay minerals. In: Developments in clay science. Unites States: Elsevier, 2017, pp.150–199.
74.
ChenWThummavichaiKChenX, et al.Design and evaluation the anti-wear property of inorganic fullerene tungsten disulfide as additive in PAO6 oil. Crystals (Basel)2021; 11: 70.
75.
WuNHuNZhouG,et al.Tribological properties of lubricating oil with micro/nano-scale WS2 particles. J Exp Nanosci2018; 13: 1–12.
