A mixed finite element and analytical method to predict load,mechanical power loss and improved efficiency in non-standard spur gear drives

Abstract

A reasonably accurate estimation of gear power loss is desirable to maximize gear performance. The load share by teeth pair, contact stress, sliding speed, elastohydrodynamic film thickness and coefficient of friction are some of the most important contributing factors which determine frictional power losses in gears. This paper presents an improvement concept to minimize the load-related power losses (sliding and rolling power losses), which will lead to an enhancement in gear efficiency by selection of non-standard gears. The tooth thickness at the pitch circle of the pinion and gear is different in non-standard gears (k_pπm > 0.5 πm and k_gπm < 0.5 πm), whereas it is equal in standard gears (k_pπm = k_gπm = 0.5 πm). In this work, the load share-based frictional power loss and the respective mechanical efficiency have been determined for comparative performance of standard and non-standard gears. Finally, the influence of various gear and drive parameters such as gear ratio, pressure angle pinion teeth number and addendum height factor on gear efficiency has also been investigated and the results of the parametric study are discussed.

Keywords

Contact stress fillet stress load share power loss efficiency

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Buckingham

. Efficiencies of gears. Analytical mechanics of gears, New York, NY, USA: Dover Publications, 1963, pp. 395–425.

Merritt

. Efficiency and testing, gear engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1972, pp. 345–357.

Shipley

Loaded gears in action. In: Dudley

(ed). Gear handbook, New York, USA: McGraw Hill Book Co., Inc., 1962, pp. 14–60.

Niemann . Maschine elementes, Berlin: Springer, 1965.

Pedrero J. Determination of the efficiency of cylindric gear sets. In: 4th World Congress on gearing and power transmission, Paris, France, 16–18 March 1999, pp.29–37.

Benedict

Kelley

. Instantaneous coefficients of gear tooth friction. Tribol Transact 1961; 4: 59–70.

ODonoghue

Cameron

. Friction and temperature in rolling sliding contacts. Tribol Transact 1966; 9: 186–194.

Kelley B and Lemanski A. Lubrication of involute gearing. In: Conference on lubrication and wear, proceedings of the institution of mechanical engineers, London, UK, 16 September 1967, pp.173–184.

Drozdov

Gavrikov

. Friction and scoring under the conditions of simultaneous rolling and sliding of bodies. Wear 1968; 11: 291–302.

10.

Kahraman

Anderson

et al.

Prediction of mechanical efficiency of parallel-axis gear pairs. ASME J Mech Des 2007; 129: 58–68.

11.

Anderson NE and Loewenthal. Part and full load spur gear efficiency, NASATP-1622, AVRADCOM, 1979.

12.

Simon V. Load capacity and efficiency of spur gears in regard to thermo-EHD lubrication. In: International symposium on gearing and power transmissions, Tokyo, Japan, 3 September 1981, pp.299–306.

13.

Simon V. Power losses in high speed spur and helical gears. In: Seventh World Congress on the theory of machines and mechanisms, Sevila, Spain, 17–22 September 1987, pp.1443–1446.

14.

Simon

. Thermo-EHD analysis of lubrication of helical gears. ASME J Mech Transm Automat Des 1988; 110: 330–336.

15.

Michlin

Myunster

. Determination of power losses in gear transmissions with rolling and sliding friction incorporated. Mech Mach Theor 2002; 37: 167–174.

16.

Luke

Olver

. A study of churning losses in dip lubricated spur gears. Proc Instn Mech Eng 1999; 213: 337–346.

17.

Kuria

Kihiu

. Prediction of overall efficiency in multistage gear trains. Int J Mech Indus Aerosp Eng 2010; 4: 25–31.

18.

Diab

Ville

Velex

. Investigations on power losses in high speed gears. Proc IMechE, Part J: J Engineering Tribology 2006; 220: 191–198.

19.

Diab

Ville

Velex

. Prediction of power losses due to tooth friction in gears. Tribol Transact 2006; 49: 260–270.

20.

Anderson NE and Loewenthal SH. Efficiency of non-standard and high contact ratio involute spur gear. NASATM-83725, USAAVSCM, 1984.

21.

Thirumurugan R and Muthuveerappan G. Study on mesh power losses in high contact ratio (HCR) gear drives. In: Proceedings of the 1st international conference on machines and mechanisms (iNaCoMM2013), Roorkee, India, 18–20 December 2013, pp.169–176.

22.

Marques

Martins

Seebra

. Power loss and load distribution models including frictional effects for spur and helical gears. Mech Mach Theor 2016; 96: 2016–2016.

23.

Prabhu Sekar

Muthuveerappan

. A balanced maximum fillet stresses on normal contact ratio spur gears to improve the load carrying capacity through non-standard gears. Mech Des Struct Mach 2015; 43: 150–163.

24.

Flodin

Andersson

. Simulation of mild wear in spur gears. Wear 1997; 207: 123–128.

25.

Hamrock

Dowson

. Isothermal elastohydrodynamic lubrication of point contacts, fully flooded results. J Lubricat Technol 1977; 99: 264–276.

26.

Cheng HS. Prediction of film thickness and sliding frictional coefficient in elastohydrodynamic contacts. In: Design engineering technology conference, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Evanston, USA, September 1974, pp.286–293.

27.

Prabhu Sekar

Muthuveerappan

. Load sharing based maximum fillet stress analysis of asymmetric helical gears designed through direct design – a parametric study. Mech Mach Theory 2014; 80: 84–102.

28.

Prabhu Sekar

Muthuveerappan

. Estimation of tooth form factor for normal contact ratio asymmetric spur gear tooth. Mech Mach Theory 2015; 90: 187–218.