The author’s model of particle entrapment and thermoviscoplastic indentation built and experimentally validated in recent publications is utilised to calculate the contact forces on ductile, isolated interference particles passing through elastohydrodynamic, rolling–sliding, line contacts. The model is detailed and enriched by supplementary equations. A parametric study deals with the effects of particle size and cold hardness, kinetic friction coefficient, rolling velocity and slide-to-roll ratio of the contact on the particle contact forces, mean friction coefficient, temperature, plastic work and power required to deform a particle, as well as on dent volume and plastic strain rates of the indented contact surfaces. A factual selection of optimal conditions and parameter values that minimise the disruption of a contaminated contact is thus greatly facilitated.
MoonM. How clean are your lubricants?Trends Food Sci Technol2007; 18: S74–88.
2.
KjerT. Particles in new motor oils. Wear1981; 69: 395–396.
3.
LengJADaviesJE. Ferrographic examination of unused lubricants for Diesel engines. Wear1988; 122: 115–119.
4.
StachowiakGWKirkTBStachowiakGB. Ferrography and fractal analysis of contamination particles in unused lubricating oils. Tribol Int1991; 24: 329–334.
5.
NikasGKReview of studies on the detrimental effects of solid contaminants in lubricated machine element contacts. In: HayworthGI (ed). Reliability engineering advances, New York: Nova Science Publishers, 2009, pp. 1–44.
6.
NikasGK. A state-of-the-art review on the effects of particulate contamination and related topics in machine-element contacts. J Eng Tribol2010; 224: 453–479.
7.
McKeeSA. Effect of abrasive in lubricant. SAE Trans1927; 22: 73–77.
8.
RylanderHG. Effects of solid inclusions in sleeve-bearing oil supply. Mech Eng1952; 74: 963–966.
9.
RylanderHG. A theory of liquid-solid hydrodynamic film lubrication. ASLE Trans1966; 9: 264–271.
10.
BroederJJHeijnekampJW. Abrasive wear of journal bearings by particles in the oil. Proc Instn Mech Engrs1965–1966; 180: 21–31.
11.
RonenAMalkinSLoewyK. Wear of dynamically loaded hydrodynamic bearings by contaminant particles. ASME J Lubr Technol1980; 102: 452–458.
12.
RonenAMalkinS. Wear mechanism of statically loaded hydrodynamic bearings by contaminant abrasive particles. Wear1981; 68: 371–389.
13.
RonenAMalkinS. Investigation of friction and wear of dynamically loaded hydrodynamic bearings with abrasive contaminants. ASME J Lubr Technol1983; 105: 559–569.
14.
KhonsariMMWangSH. On the role of particulate contamination in scuffing failure. Wear1990; 137: 51–62.
15.
KhonsariMMPascoviciMDKucinschiBV. On the scuffing failure of hydrodynamic bearings in the presence of an abrasive contaminant. ASME J Tribol1999; 121: 90–96.
16.
PascoviciMDKhonsariMM. Scuffing failure of hydrodynamic bearings due to an abrasive contaminant partially penetrated in the bearing over-layer. ASME J Tribol2001; 123: 430–433.
17.
KhonsariMMBooserER. Effect of contamination on the performance of hydrodynamic bearings. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 419–428.
18.
SariMRVilleFHaiahemAet al.Effect of lubricant contamination on friction and wear in an EHL sliding contact. Mechanika2010; 82: 43–49.
19.
SariMRHaiahemAFlamandL. Effect of lubricant contamination on gear wear. Tribol Lett2007; 27: 119–126.
20.
Handschuh RF and Krantz TL. Engagement of metal debris into a gear nesh. Report No. NASA/TM 2010-216759, The National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, 2010.
21.
FodorJ. Improving utilisation of potential I.C. engine life by filtration. Tribol Int1979; 12: 127–129.
22.
KhorshidEANawwarAM. A review of the effect of sand dust and filtration on automobile engine wear. Wear1991; 141: 349–371.
23.
GreenDALewisR. The effects of soot-contaminated engine oil on wear and friction: A review. J Auto Engine2008; 222: 1669–1689.
24.
Sato H, Tokuoka N, Yamamoto H, et al. Study of wear mechanism by soot contaminated in engine oil. SAE paper 1999-01-3573, 1999.
25.
GreenDALewisRDwyer-JoyceRS. The wear effects and mechanisms of soot contaminated automotive lubricants. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 159–169.
26.
MasukoMSuzukiAUenoT. Influence of physical and chemical contaminants on the antiwear performance of model automotive engine oil. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 455–462.
27.
YamaguchiESUntermannMRobySHet al.Soot wear in Diesel engines. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 463–469.
28.
MengFMZhangYYHuYZet al.Numerical study of influences of hard particles in lubricant on tribological performances of the piston ring. J Mech Eng Sci2007; 221: 361–372.
29.
GrieveDGDwyer-JoyceRSBeynonJH. Abrasive wear of railway track by solid contaminants. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit2001; 215: 193–205.
30.
KhalladiAElleuchK. Tribological behavior of wheel-rail contact under different contaminants using pin-on-disc methodology. ASME J Tribol2017; 139: 011102–011102-9.
31.
ShenX. and Bogy DB. Contact force and frictional heating due to “large” particles in the head disk interface. ASME J Tribol2008; 130: 011015–011015-7.
32.
OkamotoJFujitaKToshiokaT. Effects of solid particles in oil on the life of ball bearings. J Mech Eng Lab (Tokyo)1972; 26: 228–238. NASA Technical Translation, NASA TT F-15, 653, June 1974).
33.
TallianTE. Prediction of rolling contact fatigue life in contaminated lubricant: Part II – experimental. ASME J Lubr Technol1976; 98: 384–392.
LoewenthalSHMoyerDW. Filtration effects on ball bearing life and condition in a contaminated lubricant. ASME J Lubr Technol1979; 101: 171–176.
36.
BhachuRSaylesRSMacphersonPB. The influence of filtration on rolling element bearing life. In: TR Shives and WA Willard (eds) Innovation for maintenance technology improvements. NBS-SP-640. Washington: NASA CR 172821, The National Aeronautics and Space Administration, 1981, pp.326–347.
37.
LoewenthalSHMoyerDWNeedelmanWM. Effects of ultra-clean and centrifugal filtration on rolling-element bearing life. ASME J Lubr Technol1982; 104: 283–291.
38.
Dwyer-JoyceRS. Predicting the abrasive wear of ball bearings by lubricant debris. Wear1999; 233–235: 692–701.
39.
Needelman WM and Zaretsky EV. Quantifying oil filtration effects on bearing life. Report NASA TM 104350, The National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, 1991.
40.
Hamer JC and Hutchinson J. Denting of rolling element bearings by third body particles. PCS report No. 33/92, Tribology Group, Imperial College, London, 1992.
41.
Dwyer-Joyce RS. The effects of lubricant contamination on rolling bearing performance. PhD Thesis, Imperial College London, UK, 1993.
42.
ChaoKKSabaCSCentersPW. Effects of lubricant borne solid debris in rolling surface contacts. Tribol Trans1996; 39: 13–22.
43.
KahlmanLHutchingsIM. Effect of particulate contamination in grease-lubricated hybrid rolling bearings. Tribol Trans1999; 42: 842–850.
44.
AiX. Effect of debris contamination on the fatigue life of roller bearings. J Eng Tribol2001; 215: 563–575.
45.
NilssonROlofssonUSundvallK. Filtration and coating effects on self-generated particle wear in boundary lubricated roller bearings. Tribol Int2005; 38: 145–150.
46.
NilssonRDwyer-JoyceRSOlofssonU. Abrasive wear of rolling bearings by lubricant borne particles. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 429–439.
47.
Underwood RJ. The tribological effects of contamination in rolling element bearings. PhD Thesis, Imperial College London, UK, 2008.
48.
NeedelmanWMZaretskyEV. Recalibrated equations for determining effect of oil filtration on rolling bearing life. Tribol Trans2015; 58: 786–800.
49.
CoulonSJubaultILubrechtAAet al.Pressure profiles measured within lubricated contacts in presence of dented surfaces: Comparison with numerical models. Tribol Int2004; 37: 111–117.
50.
BibouletNLubrechtAAHoupertL. Contact pressure in indented elastohydrodynamic lubrication contacts. J Eng Tribol2008; 222: 415–421.
51.
NikasGK. Debris particle indentation and abrasion of machine-element contacts: An experimentally validated, thermoelastoplastic numerical model with micro-hardness and frictional heating effects. J Eng Tribol2013; 227: 579–617.
52.
Nikas GK. Theoretical modelling of the entrainment and thermomechanical effects of contamination particles in elastohydrodynamic contacts. PhD Thesis, Imperial College London, UK, 1999.
53.
NikasGK. Particle entrainment in elastohydrodynamic point contacts and related risks of oil starvation and surface indentation. ASME J Tribol2002; 124: 461–467.
54.
NikasGKIoannidesESaylesRS. Thermal modeling and effects from debris particles in sliding/rolling EHD line contacts – a possible local scuffing mode. ASME J Tribol1999; 121: 272–281.
55.
NikasGKSaylesRSIoannidesE. Thermoelastic distortion of EHD line contacts during the passage of soft debris particles. ASME J Tribol1999; 121: 265–271.
56.
NikasGK. An advanced model to study the possible thermomechanical damage of lubricated sliding-rolling line contacts from soft particles. ASME J Tribol2001; 123: 828–841.
57.
NikasGK. Mathematical analysis of the entrapment of solid spherical particles in non-conformal contacts. ASME J Tribol2001; 123: 83–93.
58.
NikasGK. A mechanistic model of spherical particle entrapment in elliptical contacts. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 507–522.
59.
NikasGK. Effects of operating conditions and friction on the entrapment of spherical debris particles in elliptical contacts. J Eng Tribol2007; 221: 727–741.
60.
NikasGK. An experimentally validated numerical model of indentation and abrasion by debris particles in machine-element contacts considering micro-hardness effects. J Eng Tribol2012; 226: 406–438.
61.
NikasGK. Strain-rate effects on the plastic indentation and abrasion of elastohydrodynamic contacts by debris particles. J Eng Tribol2014; 228: 22–45.
62.
NikasGK. Modeling dark and white layer formation on elastohydrodynamically lubricated steel surfaces by thermomechanical indentation or abrasion by metallic particles. ASME J Tribol2015; 137: 031504–031504-20.
63.
NikasGK. Algebraic equations for the pile-up geometry in debris particle indentation of rolling elastohydrodynamic contacts. ASME J Tribol2016; 138: 021503–021503-14.
64.
MizuharaKTomimotoMYamamotoT. Effect of particles on lubricated friction. Tribol Trans2000; 43: 51–56.
65.
TomimotoMMizuharaKYamamotoT. Effect of particles on lubricated friction – theoretical analysis of friction caused by particles in journal bearing. Tribol Trans2002; 45: 47–54.
66.
TomimotoMMizuharaKYamamotoT. Effect of particles on lubricated friction – verification of dead time phenomenon and friction theory. Tribol Trans2002; 45: 94–102.
67.
TomimotoM. Experimental verification of a particle induced friction model in journal bearings. Wear2003; 254: 749–762.
68.
RoachAE. Performance of oil-film bearings with abrasive containing lubrication. ASME Trans1951; 73: 677–686.
69.
MiettinenJAnderssonP. Acoustic emission of rolling bearings lubricated with contaminated grease. Tribol Int2000; 33: 777–787.
70.
PengZKessissoglouNJCoxM. A study of the effect of contaminant particles in lubricants using wear debris and vibration condition monitoring techniques. Wear2005; 258: 1651–1662.
71.
AkagakiTNakamuraMMonzenTet al.Analysis of the behaviour of rolling bearings in contaminated oil using some condition monitoring techniques. J Eng Tribol2006; 220: 447–453.
72.
Aoki H and Nakahara T. Friction characteristics of fluid film bearings with MoS2 containing lubricant. In: JSLE international tribology conference, Tokyo, Japan, 8–10 July 1985, pp.1127–1132.
73.
HaberSShapiraMEtsionI. The effect of two-phase lubricant on bearing performances. ASLE Trans1987; 30: 34–40.
74.
WanGTYSpikesHA. The behavior of suspended solid particles in rolling and sliding elastohydrodynamic contacts. Tribol Trans1987; 31: 12–21.
75.
CusanoCSlineyHE. Dynamics of solid dispersions in oil during the lubrication of point contacts, part I – graphite. ASLE Trans1982; 25: 183–189.
76.
Chiñas-CastilloFSpikesHA. Mechanism of action of colloidal solid dispersions. ASME J. Tribol2003; 125: 552–557.
MatthewsJR. Indentation hardness and hot pressing. Acta Metall1980; 28: 311–318.
79.
HillRStorakersBZdunekAB. A theoretical study of the Brinell hardness test. Proc R Soc Lond A1989; 423: 301–330.
80.
EttlesCMDincOSCalabreseSJ. The effect of frictionally generated heat on lubricant transition. Tribol Trans1994; 37: 420–424.
81.
GaoX-L. An expanding cavity model incorporating strain-hardening and indentation size effects. Int J Solids Struct2006; 43: 6615–6629.
82.
Johnson GR and Cook WH. A constitutive model and data for metals subjected to large strains, high strain rates and high temperatures. In: 7th international symposium on ballistics, The Hague, The Netherlands, April 1983, pp.541–547.
83.
HamrockBJSchmidSRJacobsonBO. Fundamentals of fluid film lubrication, 2nd ed. New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc, 2004.
84.
Hebrard Y. Bearing, housing including a set of bearing, associated method and computer program. United States Patent Application, US 2014/0169715 A1, 19 June 2014.
85.
NikasGK. Fatigue life and traction modeling of Continuously Variable Transmissions. ASME J Tribol2002; 124: 689–698.
