Business schools have been accused of reproducing management practices that lead to global crises, sparking calls for greater sensitivity to critical management education. However, while there is much academic work on the need for critical pedagogy, documented practical experience of how this works in the classroom remains scarce. Drawing on our experience in designing and teaching a course that deconstructs naturalized “management commandments,” we reveal three interwoven tensions that help explain this limitation: institutional pressures, relational challenges, and personal vulnerabilities. Our analysis shows how integrating reflexivity with an exposure to experiences of alternative organizations helps to bridge these tensions, making critical management education both accessible and relevant. Our contributions are twofold. First, we illustrate how critical management can be practiced in the classroom by anchoring the scrutiny of mainstream naturalized practices in the emergence of alternative organizations. Second, we demonstrate that the tensions and contradictions of the neoliberal university are not merely obstacles, but generative forces that—when met with reflexivity—can foster deeper engagement and broaden the scope of management education.
AbdelnourSAbu MoghliM (2021) Researching violent contexts: A call for political reflexivity. Organization. Epub ahead of print 15 July. DOI: 10.1177/13505084211030646.
2.
AdlerPS (2016) 2015 presidential address: Our teaching mission. Academy of Management Review41(2): 185–195.
3.
AlajoutsijärviKJuusolaKSiltaojaM (2015) The legitimacy paradox of business schools: Losing by gaining?Academy of Management Learning & Education14(2): 277–291.
4.
AlakavuklarON (2024) Untangling alternative organising within and beyond capitalist relations: The case of a free food store. Human Relations77(11): 1596–1619.
5.
AlvessonMWillmottH (2011) Critical management studies. London: SAGE Library in Business and Management.
6.
AmisJMMairJMunirKA (2020) The organizational reproduction of inequality. Academy of Management Annals14(1): 195–230.
7.
AmisJMMunirKALawrenceTB, et al. (2018) Inequality, institutions and organizations. Organization Studies39(9): 1131–1152.
8.
AnthonyP (1998) Management education: Ethics versus morality. In: Ethics and Organization. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 269–281.
9.
BarkerJR (2005) Tightening the iron cage: Concertive control in self-managing teams. In: GreyCWillmottH (eds) Critical Management Studies: A Reader. Oxford: Oxford Management Readers, pp. 209–243.
10.
BaudoinLCarmineSNavaL, et al. (2022) Imagining a place for sustainability management: An early career call for action. Journal of Management Studies60(3): 754–760.
11.
BristowARobinsonSRatleO (2019) Academic arrhythmia: Disruption, dissonance, and conflict in the early-career rhythms of CMS academics. Academy of Management Learning & Education18(2): 241–260.
12.
BryerA (2020) Making organizations more inclusive: The work of belonging. Organization Studies41(5): 641–660.
13.
ChanlatJ-F (2013) Les études critiques en management: Un rappel historique. Communication31(1): 3840.
14.
ColomboLA (2023) Civilize the business school: For a civic management education. Academy of Management Learning & Education22(1): 132–149.
15.
ContuA (2020) Answering the crisis with intellectual activism: Making a difference as business schools scholars. Human Relations73(5): 737–757.
16.
CookeB (2003) The denial of slavery in management studies. Journal of Management Studies40(8): 1895–1918.
17.
CookeBKumarA (2020) U.S. philanthropy’s shaping of management education in the 20th century: Toward a periodization of history. Academy of Management Learning & Education19(1): 21–39.
18.
CunliffeALLinsteadSA (2009) Introduction: Teaching from critical perspectives. Management Learning40(1): 5–9.
19.
CurrieGKnightsD (2003) Reflecting on a critical pedagogy in MBA education. Management Learning34(1): 27–49.
20.
CzarniawskaB (2016) Reflexivity versus rigor. Management Learning47(5): 615–619.
21.
DahlmanSdu PlessisEMHustedE, et al. (2022) EXPRESS: Alternativity as freedom: Exploring tactics of emergence in alternative forms of organizing. Human Relations75(2): 10801.
22.
DarSFariaA (2024) Un/learning racism in the business school: Recovering embodiments of the hidden curriculum for re-humanising management education. Management Learning: 56(5): 842–862.
23.
DorionLPicardH (2024) Empowering the already powerful? A feminist intersectional analysis of critical management education in a business school. Management Learning: 56(3): 622–644.
24.
DyerSLHurdF (2016) “What’s going on?” Developing reflexivity in the management classroom: From surface to deep learning and everything in between. Academy of Management Learning & Education15(2): 287–303.
25.
ErgeneSBanerjeeSBHoffmanAJ (2021) (Un)Sustainability and Organization Studies: Towards a Radical Engagement. Organization Studies42(8): 1319–1335.
26.
FlemingP (2020) Dark academia: Despair in the neoliberal business school. Journal of Management Studies57(6): 1305–1311.
27.
FougèreMSolitanderN (2023) Homo responsabilis as an extension of the neoliberal hidden curriculum: The triple responsibilization of responsible management education. Management Learning54(3): 396–417.
28.
FraserNJaeggiR (2018) Capitalism: A Conversation in Critical Theory. Cambridge: Polity Press.
29.
FreireP (1987) Pedagogia Do Oprimido. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: Paz e Terra.
30.
FreireP (2015) Sombra Desta Mangueira. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: Paz e Terra.
31.
GreyC (2003) The fetish of change. TAMARA: Journal of Critical Postmodern Organization Science2(2): 1–19.
32.
GreyC (2004) Reinventing business schools: The contribution of critical management education. Academy of Management Learning & Education3(2): 178–186.
33.
GrotherPNganMHanaokaK (2019) Face recognition vendor test part 3: Demographic effects. NIST IR 8280, December. Gaithersburg, MD: National Institute of Standards and Technology. Available at: https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ir/2019/NIST.IR.8280.pdf (accessed 15 February 2023).
34.
HibbertPCallagherLSiedlokF, et al. (2019) (Engaging or avoiding) change through reflexive practices. Journal of Management Inquiry28(2): 187–203.
35.
HietanenJMohammedS (2024) Is it all just melancholic pedagogy? Accelerationism and the future of critical management education. Management Learning55(4): 654–669.
36.
HockertsK (2018) The effect of experiential social entrepreneurship education on intention formation in students. Journal of Social Entrepreneurship9(3): 234–256.
37.
JenkinsSDelbridgeR (2017) Trusted to deceive: A case study of “strategic deception” and the normalization of lying at work. Organization Studies38(1): 53–76.
38.
JonesDRVisserMStokesP, et al. (2020) The performative university: “Targets,” ‘terror’ and “taking back freedom” in academia. Management Learning51(4): 363–377.
39.
KitchenerMDelbridgeR (2020) Lessons from creating a business school for public good: Obliquity, waysetting, and wayfinding in substantively rational change. Academy of Management Learning & Education19(3): 307–322.
40.
KnightsDHuberGLongmanR (2022) Critical management education: Selected auto-ethnographic vignettes on how attachment to identity may disrupt learning. Management Learning53(3): 605–616.
MailhotCLachapelleMD (2022) Teaching management in the context of Grand Challenges: A pragmatist approach. Management Learning55(2): 167–191.
43.
ManningJ (2024) A performative critical management studies: Developing a critical management pedagogy as intellectual activism praxis. Organization32(4): 607–622.
44.
MavinSJamesJPattersonN, et al. (2024) Flipping the normative: Developing and delivering a critical pedagogy for executive education in a UK business school. Management Learning55(4): 528–552.
45.
MazzucatoM (2019) The Value of Everything—Making and Taking in the Global Economy: An Allen Lane Book. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
46.
MingersJ (2000) What is it to be critical? Teaching a critical approach to management undergraduates. Management Learning31(2): 219–237.
47.
MorganG (2006) Interests, conflict and power: Organizations as political system. In: MorganG (ed.) Images of Organization. London: SAGE, 149–206.
48.
MorillasMRomaniL (2022) Ideology, doxa and critical reflexive learning: The possibilities and limits of thinking that “diversity is good.”Management Learning54(4): 511–530.
49.
MorrisSAguileraRVFisherG, et al. (2023) Theorizing from emerging markets: Challenges, opportunities, and publishing advice. Academy of Management Review48(1): 1–10.
50.
OngMCunninghamJLParmarBL (2023) Lay beliefs about homo economicus: How and why does economics education make us see honesty as effortful?Academy of Management Learning & Education: AMLE23(1): e0134.
51.
PacheA-CChowdhuryI (2012) Social entrepreneurs as institutionally embedded entrepreneurs: Toward a new model of social entrepreneurship education. Academy of Management Learning & Education11(3): 494–510.
PitesaMPillutlaMM (2019) Socioeconomic mobility and talent utilization of workers from poorer backgrounds: The overlooked importance of within-organization dynamics. Academy of Management Annals13(2): 737–769.
57.
SafatleV (2023) Alfabeto Das Colisões. São Paulo: Ubu Editora.
58.
ShanahanG (2025) Two routes to degeneration, two routes to utopia: The impure critical performativity of alternative organizing. Organization32(4): 489–507.
59.
Van HoutumHVan UdenA (2022) The autoimmunity of the modern university: How its managerialism is self-harming what it claims to protect. Organization29(1): 197–208.
60.
VieiraMMFCaldasMP (2006) Teoria crítica e pós-modernismo: principais alternativas à hegemonia funcionalista. Revista de Administração de Empresas46(1): 59–70.
61.
VijayDNairVG (2022) In the name of merit: Ethical violence and inequality at a business school. Journal of Business Ethics179(2): 315–337.
62.
VijayDBerkowitzHHuybrechtsB, et al. (2025) Another world is possible—It is already here: A review and research agenda on alternative organizing. Academy of Management Annals: Annals20(1): e0102.
63.
ZanoniP (2020) Prefiguring alternatives through the articulation of post- and anti-capitalistic politics: An introduction to three additional papers and a reflection. Organization27(1): 3–16.
64.
ZanoniPContuAHealyS, et al. (2017) Post-capitalistic politics in the making: The imaginary and praxis of alternative economies. Organization24(5): 575–588.
65.
ZulfiqarGPrasadA (2020) Challenging social inequality in the global south: Class, privilege, and consciousness-raising through critical management education. Academy of Management Learning & Education: AMLE20(2): 156–181.
