The concept of communities of practice has generated considerable debate among scholars of management. Attention has shifted from a concern with the transmission and reproduction of knowledge towards their utility for enhancing innovative potential. Questions of governance, power, collaboration and control have all entered the debate with different theorizations emerging from a wide mix of empirical research. We appraise these key findings through a critical review of the literature. From a divergent range of findings, we identify four main ways in which communities of practice enable and constrain innovative capabilities as (a) enablers of learning for innovation, (b) situated platforms for professional occupations, (c) dispersed collaborative environments and (d) governance structures designed for purpose. Our conclusion signals the way forward for further research that could be used to improve our understanding of different contextual forms and how they may align with organizations in enabling rather than constraining innovative capabilities.
AlleeVTaugJ (2006) Collaboration innovation and value creation in a global telecom. The Learning Organization13(6): 569–578.
2.
AlvessonM (2000) Social identity and the problem of loyalty in knowledge-intensive companies. Journal of Management Studies37(8): 1101–1123.
3.
AmidonDM (1998) The evolving community of knowledge practice: The ken awakening. International Journal of Technology Management16(1): 45–63.
4.
AminARobertsJ (2008) Knowing in action: Beyond communities of practice. Research Policy37(2): 353–369.
5.
AnandNGardnerHMorrisT (2007) Knowledge-based innovation: Emergence and embedding of new practice areas in management consulting firms. Academy of Management Journal50(2): 406–428.
6.
AnnandaleEHarveyJCaversD. (2007) Gender and access to healthcare in the UK: A critical interpretive synthesis of the literature. Evidence & Policy3(4): 463–486.
7.
AssimakopoulosD (2007) Technological Communities and Networks Triggers and Drivers for Innovation. London: Routledge.
8.
AubryMMüllerRGlücklerJ (2011) Exploring PMOs through communities of practice theory. Project Management Journal42(5): 42–56.
9.
AutioEKanninenSGustafssonR (2008) First- and second-order additionality and learning outcomes in collaborative R&D programs. Research Policy37(1): 59–76.
10.
BaldwinCHienerthCvon HippleE (2006) How user innovations become commercial products: A theoretical investigation and case study. Research Policy35(9): 1291–1313.
11.
BaumardP (1999) Tacit Knowledge in Organizations. London: SAGE.
12.
BertelsHMJKleinschmidtEJKoenPA (2011) Communities of practice versus organizational climate: Which one matters more to dispersed collaboration in the front end of innovation?Journal of Product Innovation Management28(5): 757–772.
13.
BorzilloS (2009) Top management sponsorship to guide communities of practice. Journal of Knowledge Management13(3): 60–72.
14.
BorzilloSKaminska-LabbéR (2011) Step-in or step-out: Supporting innovation through communities of practice. Journal of Business Strategy32(3): 29–36.
15.
BrownJSDuguidP (1991) Organizational learning and communities of practice: Towards a unified view of working learning and innovation. Organization Science2(1): 40–57.
16.
BrownJSDuguidP (2000) Balancing act: How to capture knowledge without killing it. Harvard Business Review78(3): 73–80.
17.
BrownJSDuguidP (2001) Knowledge and organization: A social practice perspective. Organization Science12(2): 198–213.
18.
BrownJSDuguidP (2002) Local knowledge innovation in the networked age. Management Learning33(4): 427–437.
19.
CaraC (2009) Creating a coherent culture: Building a culture that enables innovation and change. International Journal of Knowledge Culture and Change Management9(1): 15–33.
20.
ChenCTsengK (2011) Knowledge transfer and innovation performance of competitive knowledge communities: Case of a high-tech firm in Taiwan. African Journal of Business Management5(2): 9665–9675.
21.
ChesbroughH (2003) Open Innovation: The New Imperative for creating and Profiting from Technology. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
22.
CoakesESmithPAC (2007) Supporting innovation: Communities of practice and change. Journal of Knowledge Management Practice8(S1). Available at: http://www.tlainc.com/articlsi3.htm
23.
CohenWMLevinthalDA (1990) Absorptive capacity: A new perspective on learning and innovation. Administrative Science Quarterly35(1): 128–152.
24.
ContuA (2014) On boundaries and difference: Communities of practice and power relations in creative work. Management Learning45(3): 289–316.
25.
ContuAWillmottH (2003) Re-embedding situatedness: The importance of power relations in learning theory. Organization Science14(3): 283–296.
26.
CorsoMMartiniABaloccoR (2008) Organizing for continuous innovation: The communities of practice approach. International Journal of Technology Management44(3): 441–460.
27.
CrossRPrusakL (2002) The people who make organizations go-or stop. Harvard Business Review80(6): 104–112.
28.
CunliffeAL (2002) Reflexive dialogical practice in management learning. Management Learning33(1): 35–61.
29.
DahlanderLFrederiksenL (2012) The core and cosmopolitans: A relational view of innovation in user communities. Organization Science23(4): 988–1007.
30.
DahlanderLWallinMW (2006) A man on the inside: Unlocking communities as complementary assets. Research Policy35(8): 1243–1259.
31.
DawsonPAndriopoulosC (2014) Managing Change Creativity and Innovation. London: SAGE.
32.
Dixon-WoodsMCaversDAgarwalS. (2006) Conducting a critical interpretive synthesis of the literature on access to healthcare by vulnerable groups. BMC Medical Research Methodology6(1): 35.
33.
DoughertyD (2001) Reimagining the differentiation and integration of work for sustained product innovation. Organization Science12(5): 612–631.
34.
Du PlessisM (2008) The strategic drivers and objectives of communities of practice as vehicles for knowledge management in small and medium enterprises. International Journal of Information Management28(1): 61–67.
35.
FerlieEFitzgeraldLWoodM. (2005) The nonspread of innovations: The mediating role of professionals. Academy of Management Journal48(1): 117–134.
36.
FieldJ (2008) Social Capital. London: Routledge.
37.
FoxS (2000) Communities of practice, Foucault and actor-network theory. Journal of Management Studies37(6): 853–867.
38.
GarretyKRobertsonPLBadhamR (2004) Integrating communities of practice in technology development projects. International Journal of Project Management22(5): 351–358.
39.
GishLClausenC (2013) The framing of product ideas in the making: A case study of the development of an energy saving pump. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management25(9): 1085–1101.
40.
HagedoornJDuystersG (2002) External sources of innovative capabilities: The preferences for strategic alliances or mergers and acquisitions. Journal of Management Studies39(2): 167–188.
41.
HamiltonE (2011) Entrepreneurial learning in family business. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development18(1): 8–26.
42.
HarveyJCohendetPSimonL. (2013) Another cog in the machine: Designing communities of practice in professional bureaucracies. European Management Journal31(1): 27–40.
43.
HasanHCrawfordK (2007) Knowledge mobilisation in communities through socio-technical systems. Knowledge Management Research and Practice5(4): 237–247.
44.
HayesN (2001) Boundless and bounded interactions in the knowledge work process: The role of groupware technologies. Information and Organization11(2): 79–101.
HildrumJ (2007) When is frequent face-to-face contact necessary in innovation? A comparative study of two distributed product development projects. Economics of Innovation and New Technology16(6): 467–484.
47.
HislopD (2003) The complex relations between communities of practice and the implementation of technological innovation. International Journal of Innovation Management7(2): 163–188.
48.
HothoJSaka-HelmhoutABecker-RitterspachF (2014) Bringing context and structure back into situated learning. Management Learning45(1): 57–80.
49.
HsiaoRTsaiSDLeeC (2006) The problems of embeddedness: Knowledge transfer coordination and reuse in information systems. Organization Studies27(9): 1289–1317.
50.
HydleKMKvålshaugenRBreunigKJ (2014) Transnational practices in communities of task and communities of learning. Management Learning45(5): 609–629.
51.
JeonSKimYKohJ (2011) An integrative model for knowledge sharing in communities-of-practice. Journal of Knowledge Management15(2): 251–269.
52.
JeppesenLBFrederiksenL (2006) Why do users contribute to firm-hosted user communities?The Case of Computer-Controlled Music Instruments Organization Science17(1): 45–63.
53.
JuniperCMooreM (2002) Synergies and best practices of corporate partnerships for sustainability. Corporate Environmental Strategy9(3): 267–276.
54.
KäserPAWMilesRE (2002) Understanding knowledge activists’ successes and failures. Long Range Planning35(1): 9–28.
55.
KimL (1997) Imitation to Innovation: The Dynamics of Korea’s Technological Learning. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Press.
56.
KirkmanBCorderyJMathieuJ. (2013) Global organizational communities of practice: The effects of nationality diversity psychological safety and media richness on community performance. Human Relations66(3): 333–362.
57.
KivijãrviHPiirainenKTuominenM (2010) Sustaining organizational innovativeness: Advancing knowledge sharing during the scenario process. International Journal of Knowledge Management6(2): 22–39.
58.
KnoppenDSáenzMJJohnstonDA (2011) Innovations in a relational context: Mechanisms to connect learning processes of absorptive capacity. Management Learning42(4): 319–438.
59.
KodamaM (2005) Knowledge creation through networked strategic communities: Case studies on new product development in Japanese companies. Long Range Planning38(1): 27–49.
60.
KoenPABertelsHJKleinschmidtEJ (2014) Managing the front end of innovation – Part II. Research Technology Management57(1): 25–35.
61.
LampelJBhallaA (2007) Let’s get natural: The discourse of community and the problem of transferring practices in knowledge management. Management Decision45(7): 1069–1082.
62.
LandryRAmaraNLamariM (2002) Does social capital determine innovation? To what extent?Technological Forecasting and Social Change69(7): 681–701.
63.
LangeBKalandidesAStöberB. (2008) Berlin’s creative industries: Governing creativity?Industry and Innovation15(5): 531–548.
LeeSHWilliamsC (2007) Dispersed entrepreneurship within multinational corporations: A community perspective. Journal of World Business42(4): 505–519.
66.
LeonardDSensiperS (1998) The role of tacit knowledge in group innovation. California Management Review40(3): 112–132.
67.
LeseureMDriouchiT (2010) Exploitation versus exploration in multinational firms: Implications for the future of international business. Futures42(9): 937–951.
68.
LesserEStorckJ (2004) Communities of practice and organizational performance. In: LesserEPrusakL (eds) Creating Value with Knowledge: Insights from the IBM Institute for Business Value. New York: Oxford University Press, 831–841.
69.
McDermottRArchibaldD (2010) Harnessing your staff’s informal networks. Harvard Business Review88(3): 82–89.
70.
McGivernGDopsonS (2010) Inter-epistemic power and transforming knowledge objects in a biomedical network. Organization Studies31(12): 1667–1686.
71.
MarianoSCaseyA (2015) Is organizational innovation always a good thing?Management Learning46(5): 530–545.
72.
MeyerMAMarionTJ (2010) Innovating for effectiveness: Lessons from design firms. Research Technology Management53(5): 21–28.
73.
MoonGParkCYooDK. (2011) Effective implementation of Communities of practice in a knowledge habitat: A case study of Samsung electronics. International Journal of Services and Operations Management8(3): 335–346.
74.
MørkBEHoholmTAanestadM (2006) Constructing enacting and packaging innovations. European Journal of Innovation Management9(4): 444–465.
75.
MørkBEHoholmTEllingsenG. (2010) Challenging expertise: On power relations within and across communities of practice in medical innovation. Management Learning41(1): 575–592.
76.
MorrisonPDRobertsJHvon HippleE (2000) Determinants of user innovation and innovation sharing in a local market. Management Science46(12): 1513–1527.
77.
MudambiRSwiftT (2011) Leveraging knowledge and competencies across space: The next frontier in international business. Journal of International Management17(3): 186–189.
78.
NahapietJGhoshalS (1998) Social capital intellectual capital and the organizational advantage. Academy of Management Reviews23(2): 242–266.
79.
NooteboomB (2006) Innovation learning and cluster dynamics. In: MartinRAsheimBCookePH (eds) Clusters and Regional Development: Critical Reflections and Exploration. London: Routledge, 137–167.
80.
OrlikowskiWJ (2002) Knowing in practice: Enacting a collective capability in distributed organizing. Organization Science13(3): 249–273.
81.
OrrJ (1990) Talking about machines: An ethnography of a modern job. PhD Thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
82.
OrrJ (1996) Talking About Machines: An Ethnography of a Modern Job. New York: Cornell University Press.
83.
OxmanAD (1994) Systematic reviews – Checklists for review articles. British Medical Journal309: 648–651.
84.
PattinsonSPreeceD (2014) Communities of practice, knowledge acquisition and innovation: A case-study of science-based SMEs. Journal of Knowledge Management18(1): 107–120.
85.
PittawayLRobertsonMMunirK. (2004) Networking and innovation: A systematic review of the evidence. International Journal of Management Reviews5(3–4): 137–168.
86.
ProbstGBorzilloS (2008) Why communities of practice succeed and why they fail. European Management Journal26(5): 335–347.
87.
RetnaKSNgPT (2011) Communities of practice: Dynamics and success factors. Leadership and Organization Development Journal32(1): 41–59.
88.
RobertsJ (2006) Limits to communities of practice. Journal of Management Studies43(3): 623–639.
89.
RoySSivakumarK (2011) Managing intellectual property in global outsourcing for innovation generation. Journal of Product Innovation Management28(1): 48–62.
90.
SakkabNY (2002) Connect and develop complements research and develop at Proctor and Gamble. Research Technology Management45(2): 38–45.
91.
ScarbroughHSwanJLaurentS. (2004) Project-based learning and the role of learning boundaries. Organization Studies25(9): 1579–1600.
92.
SenseSJClementsMDJ (2006) Ever consider a supply chain as a ‘Communities of practice’? Embracing a learning perspective to build supply chain integration. Development and Learning in Organizations: an International Journal20(5): 6–8.
93.
SmedsRAlvesaloJ (2003) Global business process development in a virtual communities of practice. Production Planning & Control14(4): 361–371.
94.
SnowCCFjeldstadODLettlC. (2011) Organizing continuous product development and commercialization: The collaborative community of firms’ model. Journal of Product Innovation Management28(1): 3–16.
95.
SoekijadMVeldMAHEnserinkB (2004) Learning and knowledge processes in inter-organizational communities of practice. Knowledge and Process Management11(2): 3–12.
96.
StarbuckWMillikenF (1988) Challenger: Fine tuning the odds until something breaks. Journal of Management Studies25(4): 319–340.
97.
StrangKD (2010) Comparing learning and knowledge management theories in an Australian telecommunications practice. Asian Journal of Management Cases7(1): 33–54.
98.
SubramaniamMYoundtMA (2005) The influence of intellectual capital on the types of innovative capabilities. Academy of Management Journal48(3): 450–463.
99.
SwanJAScarbroughHRobertsonMJ (2002) The construction of communities of practice in the management of innovation. Management Learning33(4): 477–496.
100.
SwartJKinnieN (2007) Simultaneity of learning orientations in a marketing agency. Management Learning38(3): 337–357.
101.
TagliaventiMRBertolottiFMacrìDM (2010) A perspective on practice in interunit knowledge sharing. European Management Journal28(5): 331–345.
102.
TempestS (2003) Intergenerational learning: A reciprocal knowledge development process that challenges the language of learning. Management Learning34(2): 181–200.
103.
TerwieschCYiX (2008) Innovation contests open innovation and multiagent problem solving. Management Science54(9): 1529–1543.
104.
Van de VenAH (1986) Central problems in the management of innovation. Management Science32(5): 590–607.
105.
VeenswijkMVan MarrewijkABoersmaK (2010) Developing new knowledge in collaborative relationships in megaproject alliances: Organizing reflection in the Dutch construction sector. International Journal of Knowledge Management Studies4(2): 216–232.
106.
WengerEC (1998) Communities of Practice: Learning Meaning and Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
107.
WengerECSnyderWM (2000) Communities of practice: The organizational frontier. Harvard Business Review78(1): 139–145.
108.
WengerECMcDermottRSnyderW (2002) Cultivating Communities of Practice. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
109.
WolfPSpäthSHaefligerS (2011) Participation in intra-firm communities of practice: A case study from the automotive industry. Journal of Knowledge Management15(1): 22–39.
