Perception of the barriers to women’s professional development in the cultural sector: A gender perspective study

Abstract

This study explores women’s and men’s perceptions of the specific barriers that prevent women from participating fully in the cultural labour market. To this end, an online questionnaire was administered to 375 cultural professionals in Catalonia (Spain) regarding their perceptions of the barriers faced by women in a range of areas. The results show similar views between genders regarding the difficulties associated with the work–life balance as the most important obstacle preventing women from entering specific cultural fields and from rising to decision-making positions. However, perceptions of the barriers impacting the recognition of women’s career achievements differed greatly between men and women. While men place more emphasis on issues of work–life balance, women more frequently mention the existence of a glass ceiling and their exclusion from networks of influence. Regarding the visibility of women’s artistic creations, although intersectionality is mentioned by both genders as the main limiting factor, there are marked differences between women’s and men’s perception of the other barriers. Men thus more frequently refer to the barriers of work–life balance and the association of creativity with maleness as the main factors limiting the visibility of women’s artistic creations. In short, this study provides evidence to stakeholders of the different perceptions that men and women have in relation to the main barriers that prevent women from climbing the career ladder; gaining recognition and visibility for their work; and, in some creative sectors, even from entering the labour market.

Keywords

Cultural labour markets cultural sector cultural work gender equality women

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acker

(2006) Inequality regimes: Gender, class, and race in organizations. Gender and Society 20(4): 441–464.

Banks

Milestone

(2011) Individualization, gender and cultural work. Gender, Work and Organization 18(1): 73–89.

Barrios

Villarroya

(2021) What is needed to promote gender equality in the cultural sector? Responses from cultural professionals in Catalonia. European Journal of Cultural Studies. Epub ahead of print 24 October. DOI: 10.1177/13675494211048903.

Baygual

Brugat

Cabré

MÀ

(2016) Exposicions de dones als centres d’art de Barcelona. Quart Informe de l’Observatori Cultural de Gènere, amb la col·laboració de MAV (Mujeres en las Artes Visuales) [Women at the Art Centers of Barcelona. Fourth report from the gender cultural observatory, with the collaboration of MAV (women in the visual arts)]. Available at: https://dones.gencat.cat/web/.content/03_ambits/docs/publicacions_OCG_informe4.pdf (accessed 9 April 2022).

Berridge

(2019) Mum’s the word: Public testimonials and gendered experiences of negotiating caring responsibilities with work in the film and television industries. European Journal of Cultural Studies 22(5–6): 646–664.

Bhavnani

(2007) Barriers to diversity in film: A research review. Report, Commissioned by the UK Film Council, London. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sites/bfi.org.uk/files/downloads/uk-film-council-barriers-to-diversity-in-film-2007-08-20.pdf (accessed 28 July 2020).

Bielby

(2009) Gender inequality in culture industries: Women and men writers in film and television. Sociologie Du Travail 51(2): 237–252.

Bohnet

(2016) What Works: Gender Equality by Design. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Bou

Cabré

MÀ

Porté

(2014) Directores, productores i guionistes al cinema català recent [Directors, producers and screenwriters in recent Catalan cinema]. Segon Informe de l’Observatori Cultural de Gènere [Second report of the gender cultural observatory]. Available at: https://dones.gencat.cat/web/.content/03_ambits/docs/publicacions_OCG_informe2.pdf (accessed 9 April 2022)

10.

Brook

(2010) Book review: Alan McKinlay and Chris Smith (eds) Creative Labour: Working in the Creative Industries. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009, £26.99 pbk (ISBN: 9780230222007), xi + 270 pp. Work, Employment and Society 24(2): 397–399.

11.

Bull

Scharff

(2021) Classical music as genre: Hierarchies of value within freelance classical musicians’ discourses. European Journal of Cultural Studies 24(3): 673–689.

12.

Cabré

(2017) Dones als festivals de música de Catalunya. Cinquè Informe de l’Observatori Cultural de Gènere, amb la col·laboració de MIM (Mujeres de la Industria de la Música) [Women at music festivals in Catalonia. Fifth report of the cultural gender observatory, with the collaboration of MIM (Women in the music industry)]. Available at: https://dones.gencat.cat/web/.content/03_ambits/docs/publicacions_OCG_informe5.pdf (accessed 9 April 2022).

13.

Cabré

Alvarado

(2015) El gènere als nostres premis literaris: Tercer Informe de l’Observatori Cultural de Gènere [The genre in our literary awards: Third report of the cultural gender observatory]. Available at: https://dones.gencat.cat/web/.content/03_ambits/docs/publicacions_OCG_informe3.pdf (accessed 9 April 2022)

14.

Christopherson

(2009) Working in the creative economy: Risk, adaptation, and the persistence of exclusionary networks. In: McKinlay

Smith

(eds) Creative Labour: Working in the Creative Industries. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 72–90.

15.

Conor

(2021) Gender & Creativity: Progress on the Precipice. Special Edition. 2005 Convention Global Report Series. Paris: UNESCO Publishing. Available at: https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000375706 (accessed 28 August 2021).

16.

Conor

Gill

Taylor

(2015) Gender and creative labour. Sociological Review 63(S1): 1–22.

17.

Consalvo

(2008) Crunched by passion: Women game developers and workplace challenges. In: Kafai

Heeter

Denner

, et al. (eds) Beyond Barbie & Mortal Kombat: New Perspectives on Gender and Gaming. Cambridge; London: MIT Press, pp. 177–191.

18.

Corbat

González

(2019) Wom@rts. State of the Arts Report about the situation of women artists and professionals in the Cultural and Creative Industries sector in Europe. Available at: http://www.womarts.eu/upload/01-LI-WOMART-1-20-6.pdf (accessed 28 July 2020).

19.

Creative Scotland (2016) Equalities, diversity and inclusion in the screen sector: A report on the findings of the screen equalities survey. Available at: https://www.creativescotland.com/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/35020/ScreenEqualitiesSurveyMay2016.pdf

20.

Crenshaw

(1989) Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, pp. 139–167. Available at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1052&context=uclf

21.

De Vuyst

Raeymaeckers

(2019) Gender as a multi-layered issue in journalism: A multi-method approach to studying barriers sustaining gender inequality in Belgian newsrooms. European Journal of Women’s Studies 26(1): 23–38.

22.

Eikhof

Warhurst

(2013) The promised land? Why social inequalities are systemic in the creative industries. Employee Relations 35(5): 495–508.

23.

Eikhof

Newsinger

Luchinskaya

, et al. (2019) And … action? Gender, knowledge and inequalities in the UK screen industries. Gender, Work and Organization 26(6): 840–859.

24.

Erkut

Ceder

(2016) Women’s leadership in resident theaters. Final report, Wellesley Centers for Women, Wellesley, MA.

25.

European Commission (2009) Gender in research: Toolkit and training – Gender in research as a mark of excellence on behalf of the Directorate-General for Research. Report, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg.

26.

European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE) (2016) Gender in Culture. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

27.

European Parliament (2019) Employment in the cultural and creative sectors. Available at: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2019/642264/EPRS_BRI(2019)642264_EN.pdf (accessed 3 October 2021).

28.

European Union (2019) Culture Statistics. Statistical Books, Eurostat, 2019 edn. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

29.

Follows

Kreager

Gomes

(2016) Cut out of the picture: A study of gender inequality amongst film directors in the UK film industry. Report, Directors UK, London. Available at: https://directors.uk.com/news/cut-out-of-the-picture (accessed 3 October 2021).

30.

Gruber

(2019) Challenges and opportunities for decent work in the culture and media sectors work in the culture and media sectors. Working paper 324. Geneva: International Labour Office.

31.

Harvey

Shepherd

(2016) When passion isn’t enough: Gender, affect and credibility in digital games design. International Journal of Cultural Studies 20(5): 492–508.

32.

Hennekam

Bennett

(2017) Sexual harassment in the creative industries: Tolerance, culture and the need for change. Gender, Work and Organization 24(4): 418–434.

33.

Hesmondhalgh

Baker

(2015) Sex, gender and work segregation in the cultural industries. Sociological Review 63(S1): 23–36.

34.

Ibos

(2013) La place des femmes dans la musique et le cinéma en Europe. Paris: Laboratoire de l’egalité, Vivendi.

35.

Instituto de la Mujer (2013) Formación Profesional de las Mujeres y Nuevos Yacimientos de Empleo [Vocational Training for Women and New Sources of Employment]. Madrid: Ministerio De Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad.

36.

Jansson

(2019) The quality of gender equality: Gender quotas and Swedish film governance. International Journal of Cultural Policy 25(2): 218–231.

37.

Joseph

(2015) Women as creators: Gender equality. In: UNESCO (ed.) Re/shaping Cultural Policies: A Decade Promoting the Diversity of Cultural Expressions for Development. Paris: UNESCO Publishing, pp. 173–187.

38.

Loist

Prommer

(2019) Gendered production culture in the German film industry. Media Industries 6(1): 96–115.

39.

Martin

Jerrard

Wright

(2019) Identity work in female-led creative businesses. Gender, Work and Organization 27: 310–326.

40.

Mennel

(2002) Local funding and global movement: Minority women’s filmmaking and the German film landscape of the late 1990s. Women in German Yearbook: Feminist Studies in German Literature & Culture 18(1): 45–66.

41.

Miller

(2016) Gender and the artist archetype: Understanding gender inequality in artistic careers. Sociology Compass 10(2): 119–131.

42.

Mujeres en las Artes Visuales (2018) Informe MAV #18: Presencia de mujeres artistas en Arco Madrid, Art Madrid, Hybrid y Justmad 2018 [MAV Report # 18: Presence of women artists at Arco Madrid, Art Madrid, Hybrid and Justmad 2018]. Madrid: Mujeres De Las Artes Visuales.

43.

O’Brien

Laurison

Miles

, et al. (2016) Are the creative industries meritocratic? An analysis of the 2014 British Labour Force Survey. Cultural Trends 25(2): 116–131.

44.

Perrons

(2003) The new economy and the work-life balance: A case study of new media in Brighton and Hove. Gender, Work and Organization 10(1): 65–93.

45.

Pinoncely

Washington-Ihieme

(2019) Culture Club: Social Mobility in the Creative and Cultural Industries. London: Centre for London.

46.

Pujar

(2016) Gender Inequalities in the Cultural Sector. Brussels: Culture Action Europe.

47.

Ross

(2014) Women in media industries in Europe: What’s wrong with this picture? Feminist Media Studies 14(2): 326–330.

48.

Scharff

(2018) The Classical Music Industry (eds Dromey

Haferkorn

). London: Routledge, pp. 96–111.

49.

Scharff

(2020) Explaining inequalities in the classical music profession. Oncurating 47: 16.

50.

Skillset (2008) Balancing children and work in the audio visual industries. Available at: https://www.screenskills.com/media/1404/balancing_children_and_work_in_the_audio_visual_industries_2008.pdf (accessed 3 October 2021).

51.

Smith

Pieper

Choueiti

, et al. (2021) Inclusion in the Recording Studio? Gender and Race/Ethnicity of Artists, Songwriters & Producers across 900 Popular Songs from 2012-2020. Los Angeles, CA: USC Annenberg.

52.

TBR (2008) Women in leadership in the creative and cultural sector. Cultural Leadership Programme. Available at: https://dones.gencat.cat/web/.content/03_ambits/docs/publicacions_OCG_informe3.pdf (accessed 9 April 2022)

53.

Thanki

Jeffreys

(2007) Who are the fairest? Ethnic segmentation in London’s media production. Work Organisation, Labour and Globalisation 1(1): 108–118.

54.

Uğur Tanrıöver

(2017) Women as film directors in Turkish cinema. European Journal of Women’s Studies 24(4): 321–335.

55.

UNESCO (2014) Gender Equality – Heritage and Creativity. Paris: UNESCO Publishing.

56.

van Liemt

(2014) Employment relationships in arts and culture. Working paper no. 301. Geneva: International Labour Office.

57.

Villarroya

(2012) Cultural policies and national identity in Catalonia. International Journal of Cultural Policy 18(1): 31–45.

58.

Villarroya

(2017) L’ocupació en el sector de la cultura des d’una perspectiva de gènere [Employment in the cultural sector from a gender perspective]. DeCultura 50: 1–59.

59.

Wing-Fai

Gill

Randle

(2015) Getting in, getting on, getting out? Women as career scramblers in the UK film and television industries. Sociological Review 63(S1): 50–65.

60.

Wittel

(2001) Toward a network sociality. Theory, Culture and Society 18(6): 51–76.

61.

Wreyford

(2013) The real cost of childcare: Motherhood and flexible creative labour in the UK film industry – Review essay. Studies in the Maternal 5(2): 1–22.

62.

Wreyford

(2015) Birds of a feather: Informal recruitment practices and gendered outcomes for screenwriting work in the UK film industry. Sociological Review 63(S1): 84–96.