Frozen children and despairing embryos in the ‘new’ post-communist state: The debate on IVF in the context of Poland’s transition

Abstract

In vitro fertilization (IVF) technology has been in use in Poland for over 25 years with success and social approval, but it is still not regulated under Polish law. The current debate over different non-medical aspects of reproductive technologies in Poland is extremely heated and highly politicized. Politicians on the right, Catholic clergy and some journalists use very radical language and criticize IVF as a technique that plays with the lives and deaths of thousands and thousands of children. The aim of this article is to follow the Polish debate on IVF in the context of Poland’s transition, which is marked primarily by two events: the collapse of communism in 1989 and access to the European Union in 2004. The article shows that the IVF debate concerns not only moral choices or legal regulation, but also citizenship, nation, state, and the role of the Catholic Church within. Moreover, it creates new citizens: frozen embryos, which being independent persons, have the right to life, ‘dignity’ and care. The history of IVF in Poland reveals the different tensions in the Polish transition to liberal democracy and it can be used to view a ‘big’ history of the Polish transition. It is one of the micro-histories which make this big story about Poland after 1989. Analyses of both the abortion debate and the IVF debate in Poland show that the process of democratization is very much connected with limiting women’s reproductive rights, including the right to choose infertility treatment.

Keywords

Catholic Church embryo in vitro fertilization Poland post-socialist democratization

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albanese

(n.d.) Abortion and reproductive rights under nationalist regimes in twentieth century Europe. Available at: tspace.library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/1055/2/Womens_Health_Abortion_reproductive_rights.pdf (accessed 20 August 2013).

Anderson

(1983) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.

Bednarczuk

(1997) Stworzyć dziecko to nie grzech [Creating a child – it is not a sin]. Express Wieczorny 30 January, 7.

CBOS (2012) Postawy wobec stosowania zapłodnienia in vitro [Attitudes to in vitro fertilization]. Warsaw: Fundacja Centrum Badania Opinii Społecznej. Available at: www.cbos.pl/SPISKOM.POL/2012/K_121_12.PDF (accessed 20 August 2013).

Chełstowska

(2011) Stigmatisation and commercialization of abortion services in Poland: Turning sin into gold. Reproductive Health Matters 19(37): 98–106.

Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (2008) Instruction Dignitas Personae on Certain Bioethical Questions. Available at: www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20081208_dignitas-personae_en.html (accessed 20 August 2013).

Dubow

(2011) Ourselves Unborn: A History of the Fetus in Modern America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dunin

(2002) Czarny ford i dwugłowe cielę, czyli Polak idzie do Unii [The black ford and the two-headed calf: Poland is going to the EU]. ResPublica Nowa 165 (XV): 29–36.

Einhorn

(2006) Insiders and outsiders: Within and beyond the gendered nation. In: Davis

Evans

Lorber

(eds) Handbook of Gender and Women’s Studies. London, Thousand Oaks, CA and New Delhi: Sage, pp. 196–213.

10.

Franklin

Roberts

(2006) Born and Made: An Ethnography of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

11.

Fuszara

(2000) New gender relations in Poland in the 1990s. In: Gal

Kligman

(eds) Reproducing Gender: Politics, Publics, and Everyday Life after Socialism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 259–285.

12.

Gal

Kligman (2000) Introduction. In: Gal

Kligman

(eds) Reproducing Gender: Politics, Publics, and Everyday Life after Socialism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 3–19.

13.

Gawlicz

(2005) Płeć i naród. Dyskurs dotyczący aborcji w ‘Naszym Dzienniku’ a konstruowanie tożsamości narodowej [Gender and nation: Abortion discourse in NaszDziennik and constructing identity of nation]. In: Ziarkiewicz

Kowalczyk

(eds) Kobiety. Feminizm. Media [Women. Feminism. Media]. Poznań: Konsola, pp. 99–115.

14.

Gee

(1999) An Introduction to Discourse Analysis: Theory and Method. London and New York: Routledge.

15.

Gowin

(2008) Ten spór nie może zamienić się w zimną wojnę religijną [This conflict cannot change into religion cold war] (interview conducted by B Łoziński). Dziennik, 1 December, 6.

16.

Gowin

(2009) Aborcja zarodka to zabicie dziecka [An abortion of the embryo is killing the child] (interview conducted by P Nowosielska-Kucharska). Available at: ekai.pl/wydarzenia/wywiad/x17960/polska-aborcja-zarodka-to-zabiciedziecka (accessed 20 August 2013).

17.

Graff

(2001) Świat bez kobiet: płeć w polskim życiu publicznym [World without women]. Warsaw: W.A.B. Publisher.

18.

Graff

(2003) Lost between the waves? The paradoxes of feminist chronology and activism in contemporary Poland. Journal of International Women’s Studies 4(2 April): 100–116.

19.

Graff

(2007) The land of real men and women: Gender and E.U. accession in three Polish weeklies. The Journal of International Institute 1 (15). Available at: quod.lib.umich.edu/j/jii/4750978.0015.107?rgn=main;view=fulltext (accessed 20 August 2013).

20.

Graff

(2008) Rykoszetem: rzecz o płci, seksualności i narodzie [Stray bullets: Essays on gender, sexuality and the nation]. Warsaw: W.A.B. Publisher.

21.

Hall

(2012) Questioning secularization? Church and religion in Poland. In: Pollack

Müller

Pickel

(eds) The Social Significance of Religion in the Enlarged Europe: Secularization, Individualization and Pluralization. Farnham and Burlington, VA: Ashgate, pp. 121–141.

22.

Hauser

(1995) Traditions of patriotism, questions of gender: The case of Poland. In: Ellen

Berry

(eds) Postcommunism and the Body Politic, GENDERS 22. New York: New York University Press, pp. 78–101.

23.

Hennelowa

(1978) Niepokoje nad ‘dobrą nowiną’ [Concerns over ‘good news’]. Tygodnik Powszechny, 6 August, 1–3.

24.

Herzfeld

(1997) Cultural Intimacy: Social Poetics in the Nation-state. New York: Routledge.

25.

Holc

(2004) The purest democrat: Foetal citizenship and subjectivity in the construction of democracy in Poland. Signs 3(29): 755–782.

26.

Konarska

(1991) Szatańskie probówki [Diabolic test tubes]. Polityka 27: 10.

27.

Konarska

(2004) Szczęście z in vitro [Happiness from in vitro]. Przegląd 5. Available at: www.przeglad-godnik.pl/pl/artykul/szczescievitro (accessed 20 August 2013).

28.

Korolczuk

(2012) Między rynkiem a Kościołem. Kontrowersje wokół nowych technologii reprodukcyjnych w Polsce [Between marketplace and the Church: Controversy about new reproductive technologies in Poland]. In: Macierzyństwo i polityka – niebezpieczne związki [Motherhood and politics: dangerous associations], conference, Warsaw, 28–29 September, unpublished.

29.

Krupa

(2003) Statement during Parliamentary session. 13 March. Available at: orka2.sejm.gov.pl/Debata4.nsf/main/042F8751 (accessed 20 August 2013).

30.

Krzyszkowska

(2003) Etyka z probówki [Ethics from test tube]. Przewodnik Katolicki 35. Available at: www.przewodnik-katolicki.pl/nr/aktualnosci/etyka_z_probowki.html (accessed 20 August 2013).

31.

Kulawik

(2009) Science policy and public accountability in Poland: The case of embryonic stem-cell research. Science and Public Policy 36(6): 469–482.

32.

Longchamp

Bérier

(2013) In vitro niczego nie załatwia (interview conducted by T Krzyżak). Uważam Rze, 11–17 February, 82–84.

33.

Mayer

(1999) Gender ironies of nationalism. Setting the stage. In: Mayer

(ed.) Gender Ironies of Nationalism: Sexing the Nation. London, New York: Routledge, 1–24.

34.

McClintock

(1993) Family feuds: Gender, nationalism and the family. Feminist Review 44: 61–80.

35.

Michalik

(2009) Egzamin z dekalogu. Kościół o metodzie in vitro [Exam from Decalogue: Church about in vitro fertilization]. Bioetyka katolicka (bezpłatny dodatek), 13 December, 2.

36.

Mishtal

(2009) Matters of ‘conscience’: The politics of reproductive healthcare in Poland. Medical Anthropology Quarterly 23(2): 161–183.

37.

Mishtal

(2012) Irrational non-reproduction? The ‘dying nation’ and the post socialist logics of declining motherhood in Poland. Anthropology and Medicine 2(19): 153–169.

38.

Morgan

(2009) Icons of Life: A Cultural History of Human Embryos. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.

39.

Nowicka

(2007) The struggle for abortion rights in Poland. In: Parker

Petchesky

Sember

(eds) Sex Politics: Reports from the Front Lines (e-book). Columbia University, pp. 167–196.

40.

Papież

(2003) Speech during Parliamentary session. 26 February. Available at: orka2.sejm.gov.pl/Debata4.nsf/main/0F6E6D0B (accessed 20 August 2013).

41.

Petchesky

(1987) Fetal images: The power of visual culture in the politics of reproduction. Feminist Studies 2(13): 263–292.

42.

Radkowska-Walkowicz

(2012a) Who is afraid of Frankenstein? Polish debate on in-vitro fertilization. Ethnologia Europea. Journal of European Ethnology 42(2): 68–83.

43.

Radkowska-Walkowicz

(2012b) The creation of ‘monsters’: The discourse of opposition to in vitro fertilization in Poland. Reproductive Health Matters 20(40): 30–37.

44.

Radkowska-Walkowicz M(2013) Doświadczenie in vitro. Niepłodność i nowe technologie reprodukcyjne w perspektywie antropologicznej [Experience of in vitro: Infertility and new reproductive technologies in anthropological perspective]. Warsaw: Warsaw University Press.

45.

Ragoné

(2004) Surrogate motherhood and American kinship. In: Parkin

Stone

(eds) Kinship and Family: An Anthropological Reader. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 342–361.

46.

Sanocka

Kurpisz

(2003) Infertility in Poland: Present status, reasons and prognosis as a reflection of Central and Eastern Europe problems with reproduction. Medical Science Monitor 9(3): 16–20.

47.

Sierakowski

(2014) The Polish Church’s gender problem. New York Times. Available at: www.nytimes.com/2014/01/27/opinion/sierakowski-the-polish-churchs-gender-problem.html?_r=0 (accessed 20 March 2014).

48.

Stopler

(2005) The liberal bind: The conflict between women’s rights and patriarchal religion in the liberal state. Social Theory and Practice 31(2): 191–231.

49.

Terlecka

(2011) Zagrożenia i koszty procedury in vitro [Dangers and costs of in vitro procedures]. Tygodnik Niedziela 49: 38–39.

50.

Throsby

(2004) When IVF Fails: Feminism, Infertility and Negotiation of Normality. London: Palgrave.

51.

Watson

(1993) The rise of masculinism in Eastern Europe. New Left Review I/198: 71–82.

52.

Woźniak

(2012) Interpelacja nr 5308 do prezesa Rady Ministrów w sprawie przeciwdziałania dopuszczalności zabijania dzieci w Polsce [Intervention no. 5308 to Prime Minister concerning the counter measure of admissibility of killing children in Poland]. Available at: orka2.sejm.gov.pl/StenoInter7.nsf/0/4D36D7452E0C228FC1257A37003EA054/%24File/16_aneks_ksiazka_cz1.pdf (accessed 20 August 2013).

53.

Yuval-Davis

(1996) Women and the biological reproduction of the nation. Women’s Studies International Forum 19(1–2): 17–24.

54.

Zawisza

(2006) Speech during Parliamentary session. 20 July. Available at: orka2.sejm.gov.pl/Debata5.nsf/main/1969744B (accessed 20 August 2013).

55.

Zielińska

(2000) Between ideology, politics and common sense: The discourse about reproductive rights in Poland. In: Gal

Kligman

(eds) Reproducing Gender: Politics, Publics, and Everyday Life after Socialism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 23–58.