Conflict Communication Management: Why Australians Didn't See Their Troops in Iraq

Abstract

As the first conflict to be viewed ‘in real time’, the Iraq war of 2003 was dominated by almost continuous footage delivered by technological and journalistic innovations. In contrast with the unprecedented coverage provided by British and American embedded journalists, little was reported of the role of Australian troops. The Australian media have been highly critical of the way the Australian Defence Force (ADF) restricted media access to Australian troops, claiming that the ADF obstructed the community's right to know with excessive secrecy and ‘strategic unhelpfulness’. The ADF says it was unable to provide media access because of operational and national security issues specific to this conflict. Research conducted amongst members of both the Australian media and the ADF's Military Public Affairs section suggests that the debate around access and secrecy is symptomatic of a much larger clash of cultures. The difficulties faced at the media/military interface are partially explained by the fact that current communication theory does little to enhance understanding of what is really happening in conflict situations.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

1996, ‘From Morse to Modem: Developments in Transmission Technologies and Their Impact upon the Military–Media Relationship’, in Stewart

Carruthers

S.L.

(eds), War, Culture and the Media: Representations of the Military in Twentieth Century Britain, Associated University Press, London.

Grunig

J.E.

Hon

1999, Guidelines for Measuring Relationships in Public Relations, The Institute for Public Relations, University of Florida, Miami.

Hess

Kalb

M.L.

2003, The Media and the War on Terrorism, Brookings Institution Press, Washington.

Hibbert

Z.A.

2004, ‘Managing Relationships between Australian Defence Force Military Public Affairs and the Australian Media During and After the War in Iraq’, confidential report presented to Military Public Affairs, Australian Defence Force at HMAS Penguin, Sydney, 30 March.

Kleinwachter

1991, ‘National Security versus Right to Know’, Media Development, October, pp. 5–7.

Military Public Affairs 2003, Post Operation Media Review; Post Activity Report, Australian Defence Force, Canberra.

Peters

2003, ‘Setting the Press Gang Straight’, The Australian, 26 March, p. 7.

Public Affairs & Corporate Communication 2001, Overarching Organisational Communication Strategy: Guiding Public Affairs and Corporate Communication Activities across Defence 2001–04, Australian Defence Force, Canberra.

Starr

A.J.

2004, ‘Australia's Involvement in the 2003 Conflict in Iraq’, BA Hons dissertation, Charles Sturt University, Bathurst.

10.

Stewart

Carruthers

S.L.

(eds) 1996, War, Culture and Media: Representations of the Military in Twentieth Century Britain, Associated University Press, London.

11.

Toledano

2003, ‘Embedding Strategy and Trust’, Australian Journal of Communication, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 43–51.

12.

Young

Jesser

1997, The Media and the Military: From the Crimea to Desert Strike, Macmillan, Basingstoke.