The purpose of this article is to describe the links between late nineteenth-century psychological research and the early musical aptitude research of Carl Emil Seashore (1866-1949). The primary link was the music-related research of the leader of the mental testing movement during the 1890s, Columbia University psychologist James McKeen Cattell (1860-1944). German psychologist Wilhelm Wundt instructed Cattell in the German scientific tradition, and English researcher Francis Galton encouraged Cattell's research on individual differences and introduced him to statistical methods. During the 1890s, Cattell conducted a longitudinal study, the hypothesis for which was that tests of sensory discrimination ability, including musical discrimination, would correlate with undergraduates' academic grades. After his study failed to produce the expected results, the mental testing movement followed Alfred Binet and Victor Henri of France, and Cattell turned to other activities. However, in the meantime, Cattell influenced many other important psychologists, including Edward W. Scripture, Carl Seashore's doctoral mentor at Yale University, and eventually Seashore himself. Despite the mental testing movement's shift to Binet and Henri's cognitive-type testing, Seashore continued his conservative, sensory approach to the testing of musical aptitude.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Binet, A., and V. Henri. "La psychologie individuelle." L'année psychologique2 (1895): 411-65. Excerpts translated by Mollie D. Boring. In A Source Book in the History of Psychology , ed. Richard J. Herrnstein and Edwin G. Boring, 428-33. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1965.
Boring, Edwin G.A History of Experimental Psychology. 2d ed. New York: Appleton Century-Crofts, 1950.
4.
Cattell, J. McKeen. "Early Psychological Laboratories." Science67 (May 1928): 543-48.
5.
—. "The First Year of the Psychological Corporation." Unpublished report to the Board of Directors, 1 December 1922. James McKeen Cattell Collection, Container #178, "Subject File, 1890-1936. Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC.
6.
—. James McKeen Cattell, 1860-1944: Man of Science. Vol. I (Lancaster, PA: The Science Press , 1947).
7.
—. Cambridge [England], to "Mama and Papa" [William and Elizabeth Cattell], Philadelphia, 23 November 1893, 25 July 1894 , 5 December 1894. Letters in the hand of James McKeen Cattell. James McKeen Cattell Collection, Container #55, " Family Correspondence," December 1888-March 1903 . Manuscript Division, Library of Congress , Washington, DC. (Two of these letters are misfiled in the Collection.)
8.
—. Leipzig [Germany], to Francis Galton, Cambridge [England], [n.d. given]. Quoted in Francis Galton. "On Recent Designs for Anthropometric Instruments." The Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland16 (1887): 2-9.
9.
—. "In Memory of Wilhelm Wundt." Psychological Review28 (May 1921): 155-59.
10.
—. "Mental Tests and Measurements." Mind15 (January 1890): 373-80.
11.
—. "The Psychological Laboratory at Leipsic [sic]." Mind13 (January 1888): 37-51.
12.
—. "Psychology at the University of Pennsylvania." American Journal of Psychology3 (April 1890): 281-83.
13.
—. "Ueber die Trägheit der Netzhaut und des Sehcentrums." Philosophische Studien3 (1885): 94-127. Reprinted as " The Inertia of the Eye and Brain." In (no translator) James McKeen Cattell. James McKeen Cattell, 1860-1944: Man of Science. Vol. I, 26-40. Lancaster, PA: The Science Press, 1947.
14.
—. "Ueber die Zeit der Erkennung und Benennung von Schriftzeichen, Bildem und Farben" Philosophische Studien2 (1885): 635-50. Excerpts translated by R. S. Woodworth in "On the Time Required for Recognizing and Naming Letters and Words, Pictures and Colors" In James McKeen Cattell. James McKeen Cattell, 1860-1944: Man of Science. Vol. I, 13-25. Lancaster, PA: The Science Press, 1947.
15.
Cattell, J. McKeen, and Livingston Farrand . "Physical and Mental Measurements of the Students of Columbia University. Psychological Review3 (1896): 618-48.
16.
Darwin, Charles.The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex, 2d ed. New York: American Publishers Corporation, 1874.
17.
Deary, Ian J. "Intelligence and Auditory Discrimination: Separating Processing Speed and Fidelity of Stimulus Representation." Intelligence18 (March 1994): 189-213.
18.
DuBois, Philip H.A History of Psychological Testing. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 1970.
19.
Esquirol, Jean-EtienneDominique. Des maladies mentales conside rées sous les rapports médical, hygienique, et médico-légal. Vols. I, II and Atlas. Paris: J. B. Bailliére, 1838.
20.
Galton, Francis. "On Recent Designs for Anthropometric Instruments." The Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland16 (1887): 2-9.
21.
Gilbert, J.A. "Experiments on the Musical Sensitiveness of School Children." In Studies from the Yale Psychological Laboratory. Vol. I, ed. E. W. Scripture, 80-87. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1893.
22.
—. "Researches on Mental and Physical Development of School-Children." Studies from the Yale Psychological Laboratory. Vol. II, ed. E. W. Scripture, 40-100. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1894.
23.
—. "Researches upon School Children and College Students." University of Iowa Studies in Psychology. Vol. I, ed. G. T. W. Patrick and J. Allen Gilbert, 1-39. Iowa City: State University of Iowa, 1897.
24.
Goodenough, Florence L. MentalTesting: Its History, Principles, and Applications . New York: Rinehart and Company , 1949.
Herrnstein, Richard J.I.Q. in the Meritocracy. Boston: Little, Brown, 1973.
27.
Herrnstein, Richard J., and Edwin G. Boring, eds. A Source Book in the History of Psychology . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1965.
28.
Humphreys, Jere T. "Applications of Science: The Age of Standardization and Efficiency in Music Education." The Bulletin of Historical Research in MusicEducation9 (January 1988): 1-21.
29.
—. "The Child-Study Movement and Public School Music Education." Journal of Research in Music Education33 (Summer 1985): 79-86.
30.
—. "Precursors of Musical Aptitude Testing: From the Greeks through the Work of Francis Galton."Journal of Research in Music Education41 (Winter 1993): 315-27.
31.
Humphreys, Jere T., William V. May, and David J. Nelson . "Research on Music Ensembles." In Handbook of Research on Music Teaching and Learning, ed. Richard Colwell, 651-68. New York: Schirmer Books, 1992.
32.
Jastrow, Joseph. "Joseph Jastrow." In A History of Psychology in Autobiography . Vol. I, ed. Carl Murchison, 135-62. Worcester, MA: Clark University Press, 1930; reprint, New York : Russell & Russell, 1961.
33.
—. "Some Anthropometric and Psychologic [sic] Tests on College Students ." American Journal of Psychology4 (April 1892): 420-28.
34.
Linden, Katherine W., and James D. Linden .Modern Mental Measurement: A Historical Perspective . Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company , 1968.
35.
Münsterberg, Hugo. "Zur individual Psychologie," Centralblatt f. Nervenheilkunde und Psychiatrie14 (1891): 196-98.
36.
Mursell, James L.The Psychology of School Music Teaching. New York: Silver, Burdett and Company, 1931.
37.
Pearson, Karl.The Life, Letters and Labours of Francis Galton. Vol. IIIA. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1930.
38.
Scripture, [Edward Wheeler], New Haven, CT, to [James McKeen] Cattell, New York, NY, 7 August 1901. Letter in the hand of Edward Wheeler Scripture. James McKeen Cattell Collection, Container #38, "General Correspondence," 1884-1944. Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington, DC.
39.
—. "The Method of Regular Variation," in "Psychological Notes" American Journal of Psychology4 (August 1892): 577-84.
40.
__. The New Psychology. New York: Scribner's , 1897.
41.
Seashore, Carl Emil. "Carl Emil Seashore." In A History of Psychology in Autobiography. Vol. I, ed. Carl Murchison, 225-97. Worcester, MA: Clark University Press, 1930; reprint, New York : Russell & Russell, 1961.
42.
—. " Hearing-ability and Discriminative Sensibility for Pitch." University of Iowa Studies in Psychology. Vol. II, ed. G. T. W. Patrick, 163-78. Iowa City: State University of Iowa, 1899.
43.
—. "Measurements of Illusions and Hallucinations in Normal Life." Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 1895; published in Studies from the Yale Psychological Laboratory. Vol. III, ed. E. W. Scripture, 1-67. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1895.
44.
Seashore, CarlE. Seashore Measures ofMusical Talent. New York: The Psychological Corporation, 1919.
45.
Sokal, Michael M. "Biographical Approach: The Psychological Career of Edward Wheeler Scripture." In Historiography of Modern Psychology: Aims, Resources, Approaches, ed. Josef Brozek and Ludwig J. Pongratz, 255-78. Toronto: C.J. Hogrefe, Inc., 1980.
46.
__. ed. An Education in Psychology: James McKeen Cattell's Journal and Letters from Germany and England, 1880-1888. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 1981.
47.
—." The Unpublished Autobiography of James McKeen Cattell." American Psychologist26 (July 1971): 626-35.
48.
Wissler, Clark. "The Correlation of Mental and Physical Tests." Psychological Review Monograph Supplements3 (Whole No. 16) (June 1901): 1-62.
