The purpose of the present study was to prospectively compare the predictive accuracy of static venous pressure (SVP); dynamic venous pressure (DVP) and access blood flow (ABF) in determining subsequent graft thrombosis and/or failure.
Methods
This study included 43 patients with functional arteriovenous grafts (AVG's) who underwent monthly serial measurements of SVP, DVP and ABF for 3 consecutive months. Patients were then followed for an additional 6 months. The primary end point was graft thrombosis.
Results
Six patients were excluded from the final analysis. Of the 37 patients completing the study, 7 episodes of graft thrombosis occurred within 6 months of follow up. Neither SVP nor DVP exhibited satisfactory sensitivity or specificity for graft thrombosis. Ten patients either began with or developed an ABF < 600 during the 3 months of measurements, but only 5 clotted. Δ ABF of >20% provided the best combination of sensitivity (86%) and specificity (90%) for graft thrombosis. In AVG's that have an ABF<600, it is those grafts with falling ABF that appear most likely to clot in the short term.
Conclusion
The study supports the concept that it is a falling level of access flow rather than the absolute level that is the most potent predictor of graft thrombosis.
SchwabS.J.. Vascular access for hemodialysis.Kidney Int1999; 55: 2078–990.
2.
TokarsJ.I., MillerE.R., AlterM.J., ArduinoM.J.. National surveillance of dialysis-associated diseases in the United States, 1997.Semin Dial2000; 13: 75–85.
3.
MillerP.E., CarltonD., DeierhoiM.H., ReddenD.T., AllonM.. Natural history of arteriovenous grafts in hemodialysis patients.Am J Kidney Dis2000; 36: 68–74.
4.
NKF-DOQI.Clinical Practice Guidelines for Vascular Access.Am J Kidney Dis1997; 30(suppl 3): S150–S191.
5.
NKF-DOQI.Clinical Practice Guidelines for Vascular Access. 2000 Update.Am J Kidney Dis2001; 37(suppl 1): S137–S181.
6.
PaulsonW.D.. Blood flow surveillance of hemodialysis grafts and the dysfunction hypothesis.Semin Dial2001; 14: 175–80.
7.
KrivitskiN.M., GantelaS.. Access flow measurement as a predictor of hemodialysis graft thrombosis: making clinical decisions.Semin Dial2001; 14: 181–5.
8.
LumsdenA.B., MacDonaldM.J., KikeriD., CotsonisG.A., HarkerL.A., MartinL.G.. Prophylactic balloon angioplasty fails to prolong the patency of expanded polytetrafluoroethylene arteriovenous grafts: Results of a prospective study.J Vasc Surg1997; 26: 382–92.
9.
MartinL.G., MacDonaldM.J., KirkeriD., CostonisG.A., HarkerL.A., LumsdenA.B.. Prophylactic angioplasty reduces thrombosis in virgin ePFTE arteriovenous dialysis grafts with greater than 50% stenosis: subset analysis of a prospectively randomized study.JVIR1999; 10: 389–96.
10.
SandsJ.J., JaybacP.A., MirandaC.L., KapsickB.J.. Intervention based on monthly monitoring decreases hemodialysis access thrombosis.ASAIO J1999; 45: 147–50.
11.
SmitsJ.H.M., Van der LindenJ., HagenE.C.Graft surveillance: venous pressure, access flow, or the combination?Kidney Int2001; 59: 1551–8.
12.
RamS., WorkJ., CalditoG.C., EasonJ.M., PervezA., PaulsonW.D.. A randomized controlled trial of blood flow and stenosis surveillance of hemodialysis grafts.Kidney Int2003; 64: 272–80.
13.
TessitoreN., MansuetoG., BedognaProspective controlled trial on effect of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty on functioning arteriovenous fistulae survival.J Am Soc Nephrol2003; 14: 1623–7.
14.
GarlandJ.S., MoistL.M., LindsayR.M.. Are hemodialysis access flow measurements by ultrasound dilution the standard of care for access surveillance?Advances in Renal Replacement Therapy2002; 9: 91–8.
15.
StrauchB.S., O'ConnellR.S., GeolyK.L., GrundlehnerM., YakubN., TietjenD.P.. Forecasting thrombosis of vascular access with Doppler color flow imaging.Am J Kidney Dis1992; 19: 554–7.
16.
SchwabS.J., RaymondJ.R., SaeedM., NewmanG.E., DennisP., BollingerR.R.. Prevention of hemodialysis fistula thrombosis. Early detection of venous stenoses.Kidney Int1989; 36: 707–11.
17.
BesarabA., MoritzM., SullivanK., DorrellS., PriceJ.J.. Venous access pressures and the detection of intra-access stenosis.ASAIO J1992; 38: M519–23.
18.
DemberL.M., HolmbergE.F., KaufmanJ.S.. Value of static venous pressure for predicting arteriovenous graft thrombosis.Kidney Int2002; 61: 1899–904.
19.
MayR.E., HimmelfarbJ., YenicesuM.Predictive measures of vascular access thrombosis: A prospective study.Kidney Int1997; 52: 1656–62.
20.
Roxana NeyraN., Alp IkizlerT., MayR.E.Change in access blood flow over time predicts vascular access thrombosis.Kidney Int1998; 54: 1714–9.
21.
BosmanP.J., BoereboomF.T.J., EikelboomB.C., KoomanH.A., BlankestijnP.J.. Graft flow as a predictor of thrombosis in hemodialysis grafts.Kidney Int1998; 54: 1726–30.
22.
PaulsonW.D., RamS.J., BirkC.G., WorkJ.. Does blood flow accurately predict thrombosis or failure of hemodialysis synthetic grafts? A meta-analysis.Am J Kidney Dis1999; 34: 478–85.
23.
PaulsonW.D., RamS.J., BirkC.G., ZapczynskiM., MartinS.R., WorkJ.. Accuracy of decrease in blood flow in predicting hemodialysis graft thrombosis.[see comment].Am J Kidney Dis2000; 35: 1089–95.
24.
KrivitskiN.M.. Theory and validation of access flow measurement by dilution technique during hemodialysis.Kidney Int1995; 48: 244–50.
25.
BesarabA., LubkowskiT., FrinakS.. A simple method for measuring intra-access pressure.J Am Soc Nephrol1999; 11: 202A.
26.
BayW.H., HenryM.L., LazarusJ.M., LewN.L., LimgJ., LowrieE.G.. Predicting hemodialysis access failure with color flow Doppler ultrasound.Am J Nephrol1998; 18: 296–304.
27.
BesarabA., LubkowskiT., FrinakS., RamanathanS., EscobarF.. Detection of access strictures and outlet stenoses in vascular accesses.Which test is best? ASAIO J1997; 43: M543–7.
28.
MurrayB.M., SuriS., HermanA., RajczakS., PaulsonW.D., PellM.. Prolongation of arteriovenous graft survival by access flow monitoring. In: HenryM.L., ed. Vascular Access for Hemodialysis VIII.Arlington Heights, Ill: Access Medical Press2002; 279–92.
29.
SpergelL.M., HollandJ.E., FademS.Z., McAllisterC.J., PeacockE.J.. Static intra-access pressure ratios does not correlate with access blood flow.Kidney Int2004; 66: 1512–6.
30.
FrinakS., ZasuwaG., DunfeeT., BesarabA., YeeJ.. Dynamic venous access pressure ratio test for hemodialysis monitoring.Am J Kidney Dis2002; 40: 760–8.
