The Cutler-Beard flap for upper eyelid reconstruction: Surgical indications revisited

Abstract

Purpose

To present the long-term outcome of the Cutler-Beard two-stage technique in patients with large full-thickness upper eyelid defects after tumor excision.

Methods

The medical records of 24 patients with large full-thickness upper eyelid defects reconstructed with the Cutler-Beard technique from January 2000 to January 2021 were retrospectively reviewed. All the defects involved ≥ 60% of the horizontal length of the upper eyelid and extended vertically for at least 15 mm from the eyelid margin. Patients with follow-up < 24 months were excluded. Long-term postoperative complications, functional outcome, and patient's satisfaction at the end of the follow-up were evaluated.

Results

Patients’ age ranged from 36 to 88 (mean 66.0  ±  10.7 years) and 58.3% were females. Seven patients (29.2%) had had previous eyelid surgeries. The most common diagnosis was basal cell carcinoma (62.5%), followed by sebaceous gland carcinoma (12.5%), squamous cell carcinoma (8.3%), and Merkel cell carcinoma (8.3%). The mean duration of follow-up was 53.0  ±  16.9 months. Eleven patients (45.8%) developed upper eyelid entropion: 9 were treated conservatively with a therapeutic contact lens, 2 patients required a third operating stage. Most patients achieved a satisfactory functional and aesthetical outcome at the end of the follow-up.

Conclusions

Although non-bridging techniques are usually favored to reconstruct large upper eyelid defects, the Cutler-Beard bridge flap is a valuable technique in case of large horizontal defects where the vertical gap is greater than 15 mm. Further surgical steps are rarely necessary; however, alternative techniques should be considered following excision of highly malignant tumors.