Anti-modernism has always been a part of the ideology of black metal and folk metal subcultures. In addition to Christianity, a common enemy in the field of modernity is the ‘social democratic’ welfare state. Although at least black metal can be considered as a counterculture, both black metal and folk metal subgenres reflect widely shared ideas from the mainstream. Based on interview material, this article examines how members of black metal and folk metal subcultures participate in the discussion about the welfare state. It gives voice to individuals rarely heard in music media or in the gatherings of the black metal and folk metal scenes. This article brings forward critical discourses about the apolitical tradition of heavy metal subcultures. It discusses ideologies and representations, and reception of ideas shared in metal communities.
AnderssonJ. (2009). Nordic nostalgia and Nordic light: The Swedish model as Utopia 1930–2007. Scandinavian Journal of History, 34(3), 229–245.
2.
BergerP. L.LuckmannT. (1967). The social construction of reality. A treatise in the sociology of knowledge. New York, NY: Doubleday.
3.
BlanningT. (2011). The romantic revolution: A history. New York, NY: Modern Library.
4.
BlombergH.KrollC. (2017). Hyvinvointivaltion kannatus [The backing of the welfare state]. In KananenJ. (Ed.), Kilpailuvaltion kyydissä. Suomen hyvinvointimallin tulevaisuus [In the competition state. The future of the Finnish model of welfare] (pp. 128–144). Helsinki: Gaudeamus.
5.
BorofskyR. (1987/1990). Making history: Pukapukan and anthropological construction of knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
ChakerS.SchermannJ.UrbanekN. (Eds.). (2018). Analyzing black metal. Transdiziplinäre Annäherungen an ein düsteres Phänomen der Musikkultur [Analyzing black metal. Transdisciplinary views on a dark phenomenon of the music culture]. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.
7.
ChristiansenN. F.MarkkolaP. (2006). Introduction. In ChristiansenN. F.PetersenK.EdlingN.HaaveP. (Eds.), The Nordic model of welfare: A historical reappraisal (pp. 9–30). Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press.
8.
DornbuschC.KillgussH. (2005). Unheilige Allianzen. Black Metal zwischen Satanismus, Heidentum und Neonazismus [The unholy alliance. Black metal between Satanism, Heathenism and Neo-Nazism]. Hamburg und Münster: Unrast-Verlag.
9.
EhrnroothJ. (2018). Hyvinvointivaltio on tullut tiensä päähän [The welfare state has run out of road]. Yle.fi. Retrieved from https://yle.fi/uutiset/3-10244313
10.
FalnesO. J. (1968). National romanticism in Norway. New York, NY: AMS Press.
GeertzC. (1973/1998). The interpretation of cultures. New York, NY: Basic Books.
13.
Goodrick-ClarkeN. (2003). Black sun: Aryan cults, esoteric Nazism and the politics of identity. New York, NY: New York University Press.
14.
GrünwaldJ. G. (2018). Männlichkeit, Räume und Wiederholung im Black Metal [Manhood, spaces and repetition in black metal]. In ChakerS.SchermannJ.UrbanekN. (Eds.), Analyzing Black Metal. Transdiziplinäre Annäherungen an ein düsteres Phänomen der Musikkultur (pp. 49–62). Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.
HeeschF. (2010). Metal for Nordic men? Amon Amarth’s representation of Vikings. In ScottN.von HeldenI. (Eds.), The metal void (pp. 71–80). Oxford: Inter-Disciplinary Press.
18.
HietalaV. (2007). Media ja suuret tunteet. Johdatusta 2000-luvun uusromantiikkaan [Media and great emotions. Introduction to the Neo-Romanticism in the 21th century]. Helsinki: BTJ Kustannus.
19.
HoadC.WhitingS. (2017). True Kvlt? The cultural capital of ‘Nordicness’ in extreme metal. M/C Journal, 20(6), 1–10.
20.
IkäheimonenT. (2016). Pirunkehto. Suomalaisen black metallin tarina [The cradle of the devil. The story of Finnish black metal]. S.l.: Svart Publishing.
21.
JensenH. (2002). The welfare state, the individual and the ‘revolution of rising expectations’. In JensenH. (Ed.) The welfare state. Past, present, future (pp. 1–12). Pisa: Edizioni Plus—Universita di Pisa.
22.
JohansenS. (1999). Between Hitler and Satan: Norwegian black metal as a spearhead for racial hatred. In BurghartD. (Ed.), Soundtracks to the white revolution: White supremacist assaults on youth music subcultures (pp. 65–67). Chicago, IL: Center for New Community.
23.
Kahn-HarrisK. (2007). Extreme metal. Music and culture on the edge. Oxford and New York: Berg Publishers.
24.
KantolaA.KananenJ. (2017). Johdanto: Suomen malli [Introduction. The Finnish model]. In KananenJ. (Ed.), Kilpailuvaltion kyydissä. Suomen hyvinvointimallin tulevaisuus (pp. 7–29). Helsinki: Gaudeamus.
25.
KatartziE. (2017). Unpacking young people’s national identities: The role of ethno-cultural and religious allegiances, history and ‘others’. Young, 26(3), 215–231.
26.
KertzerD. I. (1988). Ritual, politics and power. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
27.
KuismaM. (2017). Oscillating meanings of the Nordic model: Ideas and the welfare state in Finland and Sweden. Critical Policy Studies, 11(4), 433–454.
28.
KunnasT. (2013). Fasismin lumous. Eurooppalainen älymystö Mussolinin ja Hitlerin politiikan tukijana [The appeal of fascism. European intelligentsia supporting the politics of Mussolini and Hitler]. Jyväskylä: Atena.
29.
LinK.CarrollE. (2006). Theoretical visions versus policymaking realities? Searching for the logical grounds of expansion and retrenchment arguments in studies on Nordic social policy models from the 1960s to the 2000s. Comparative Sociology, 5(1), 65–86.
30.
MarkkolaP. (2011). The Lutheran Nordic welfare states. In KettunenP.PetersenK. (Eds.), Beyond welfare state models: Transnational historical perspectives on social policy (pp. 102–118). Cheltenham/Northampton: Edward Elgar.
31.
MassaJ. (1999). Unholy alliance: The national socialist black metal underground. In BurghartD. (Ed.), Soundtracks to the white revolution: White supremacist assaults on youth music subcultures (pp. 49–64). Chicago, IL: Center for New Community.
32.
MørkG. B. (2002). Drømmer om fortiden—minner for fremtiden. Norsk black metals norrøne orientering 1990–1995 [Dreams of the past : Memories for the future. The Norse orientation of the Norwegian black metal 1990–1995]. (Unpublished Master’s thesis). University of Tromsø.
33.
MustamoA. (2016a). ‘Yö, metsä, aika ennen kristinuskoa’. Kotimaan ja kansakunnan representaatiot black metalissa ja folk metalissa Suomessa ja Norjassa [‘Night, forest, time before Christianity’. Representations of Homeland and Nation in Black Metal and Folk Metal in Finland and Norway] (Acta Universitatis Ouluensis B: 140). Oulu: University of Oulu.
34.
MustamoA. (2016b). ‘En pidä siitäkään, että norjalaiset matkustavat etelään’. Maahanmuuttoasenteet black metal- ja folk metal -alakulttuureissa Suomessa ja Norjassa. [‘I like neither that Norwegians travel to the south’. Attitudes to immigration in Black Metal and Folk Metal subcultures in Finland and Norway] Musiikin suunta, 38(1).
35.
NiskakangasT. (2018). Vihattu aktiivimalli voi pelastaa hyvinvointivaltion [The hated active model can save the welfare state]. Helsingin Sanomat. Retrieved from https://www.hs.fi/politiikka/art-2000005720776.html
36.
OlsonB. H. (2013). Voice of our blood: National socialist discourses in black metal. In HjelmT.Kahn-HarrisK.LeVineM. (Eds.), Heavy metal: Controversies and countercultures (pp. 136–151). Sheffield/Bristol: Equinoz.
37.
PattisonR. (1987). The triumph of vulgarity: Rock music in the mirror of romanticism. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
38.
PerhoS. (2010). Rasistisuus nuorten yhteisöissä. Tutkimus vuosituhannen vaihteen Joensuusta [Racism in youth communities. A study from Joensuu at the millenium shift]. Helsinki: Nuorisotutkimusseura/Nuorisotutkimusverkosto.
39.
PetersenJ. H. (2011). Marketization and free choice in the provision of social services. Normative shifts 1982–2008. Social democrat lip service as a response to problems of legitimacy. In KettunenP.PetersenK. (Eds.), Beyond welfare state models: Transnational historical perspectives on social policy (pp. 170–198). Cheltenham/Northampton: Edward Elgar.
40.
PyrhönenN. (2015). The true colors of Finnish welfare nationalism. Consolidation of Neo-populist advocacy as a resonant collective identity through mobilization of exclusionary narratives of blue-and-white solidarity (SSKH Skrifter 38). Helsinki: Swedish School of Social Science, University of Helsinki.
41.
RossiL.-M. (2010). Esityksiä, edustamisia ja eroja: Representaatio on politiikkaa [Representations, representings and differences. Representations are political]. In KnuuttilaT.LehtinenA. P. (Eds.), Representaatio. Tiedon kivijalasta tieteen työkaluksi [Representation. From the foundation of knowledge to a tool of science] (pp. 261–275). Helsinki: Gaudeamus.
42.
ScottN. (2013). Heavy metal and the defeating threat of the apolitical. In HjelmT.Kahn-HarrisK.LeVineM. (Eds.), Heavy metal: Controversies and countercultures (pp. 228–243). Sheffield/Bristol: Equinoz.
43.
SpracklenK. (2010). True Aryan black metal: The meaning of leisure, belonging and the construction of whiteness in black metal music. In ScottN.von HeldenI. (Eds.), Metal void: First gatherings (pp. 81–92). Oxford: Inter-Disciplinary Press.
44.
SpracklenK. (2015). ‘To Holmgard… and beyond’: Folk metal fantasies and hegemonic white masculinities. Metal Music Studies, 1(3), 354–377.
45.
TamminenT. (2004). Pahan viehätys. Natsismin ja terrorin lähteillä [The appeal of evil. At the sources of Nazism and terror]. Helsinki: Otava.
46.
Turner-GrahamE. (2014). ‘Breivik is my hero’: The Dystopian world of extreme right youth on the internet. Australian Journal of Politics and History, 60(3), 416–430.
47.
Von HeldenI. (2010). Scandinavian metal attack: The power of Northern Europe in extreme metal. In HillR.SpracklenK. (Eds.), Heavy fundamentalisms: Music, metal and politics (pp. 33–41). Oxford: Inter-Disciplinary Press.
48.
Von HeldenI. (2017). Norwegian native art: Cultural identity in Norwegian metal music. Zürich: Lit.
49.
WagnerR. (1981). The invention of culture. Revised and expanded edition. Chicago/London: The University of Chicago Press.
50.
WolfeA.KlausenJ. (1997). Identity politics and the welfare state. Social Philosophy and Policy, 14(2), 231–255.
