This article is intended to be a tutorial on the subject of fatigue of foam and honeycomb core composite sandwich structures. First, several different analytical models for predicting the fatigue life of sandwich composites are presented. Then representative publications which have reported on the major failure modes in sandwich beams under dynamic fatigue loading are summarized, along with several related publications dealing with static and impact loading. Papers dealing with the effects of loading frequency, environmental factors, and block loading on the fatigue life of sandwich composites are discussed. Finally, recent research on different types of non-destruction evaluation (NDE) techniques employed for failure investigations during fatigue testing of sandwich structures is reviewed. Conclusions and generalizations that can be drawn from the literature are presented along with discussions of areas in which further research is needed.
Vinson, J.R. (1999). The Behavior of Sandwich Structures of Isotropic and Composite Materials, Technomic Pub. Co., Lancaster, PA .
2.
Degrieck, J. and van Paepegem, W. (2001). Fatigue Damage Modeling of Fibre-reinforced Composite Materials: Review , Applied Mechanics Review, 54(4): 279–299 .
3.
Kanny, K. and Mahfuz, H. (2005). Flexural Fatigue Characteristics of Sandwich Structures at Different Loading Frequencies , Composite Structures, 67(4): 403–410 . Figures [1] and [26] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
4.
Burman, M. and Zenkert, D. (1997). Fatigue of Foam Core Sandwich Beams – 1: Undamaged Specimens , Int. J. Fatigue, 19(7): 551–561 . Figure [2] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
5.
Burman, M. and Zenkert, D. (1997). Fatigue of Foam Core Sandwich Beams – 2: Effect of Initial Damage , Int. J. Fatigue, 19(7): 563–578 .
6.
Sendeckyj, G.P. (1990). Life Prediction for Resin-matrix Composite Materials, In: Reifsnider, K.L. (ed.), Fatigue of Composite Materials, 431–480.
7.
Dai, J. and Hahn, H.T. (2004). Fatigue Analysis of Sandwich Beams using a Wear-out Model , Journal of Composite Materials, 38(7): 581–589 .
8.
Mahi, El A. , Farooq, M.K. , Sahraoui, S. and Bezazi, A. (2004). Modeling the Flexural Behavior of Sandwich Composite Materials under Cyclic Fatigue , Materials & Design, 25(3): 199–208 . Figures [4], [5], [6] and [7] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
9.
Clark, S.D. , Shenoi, R.A. and Allen, H.G. (1999). Modeling the Fatigue Behavior of Sandwich Beams under Monotonic, 2-step and Block Loading Regimes , Composite Science and Technology, 59(4): 471–486 . Figures [8] and [9] and Table 5 reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
10.
ASTM Standard, C393-62. Standard Test Methods for the Flexural Properties of Flat Sandwich Constructions.
11.
Reifsnider, K.L. , Schulte, K. and Duke, J.C. (1983). Long Term Behavior of Composite Materials , In: Long Term Behavior of Composites, ASTM STP, 813: 136–159 .
12.
Wu, W.F. , Lee, L.J. and Choy, S.T. (1996) A Study of Fatigue Damage and Fatigue Life of Composite Laminates , Journal of Composite Materials, 30(1): 123–137 .
13.
Philippidis, T.P. and Vassilopoulos, A.P. (1999). Fatigue of Composite Laminates under Off-axis Loading , International Journal of Fatigue, 21(3): 253–262 .
14.
Whitworth, H.A. (1998). A Stiffness Degradation Model for Composite Laminates under Fatigue Loading , Composite Structures, 40(2): 95–101 .
15.
Miner, M.A. (1945). Cumulative Damage in Fatigue , Journal of Applied Mechanics, 12(3): 159–164 .
16.
Hashin, Z. and Rotem, A. (1978). A Cumulative Damage Theory of Fatigue Failure , Journal of Material Science Engineering, 34(2): 147–160 .
17.
Wang, A.S.D. , Chou, P.C. and Alper, J. (1981). Effect of Proof Test on the Strength and Fatigue Life of a Unidirectional Composite , Fatigue of Fibrous Composite Materials ASTM STP, 723, 116–132 .
18.
Broutman, L.J. and Sahu, S.A. (1972). New Theory to Predict Cumulative Fatigue Damage , In: Fiberglass Reinforced Plastics, Composite Materials: Testing and Design (Second Conference), ASTM STP, Vol. 497, pp. 170–188 .
19.
Epaarachchi, J.A. and Clausen, P.D. (2005). A New Cumulative Fatigue Damage Model for Fiber Reinforced Plastic Composites under Step/Discrete Loading , Composites: Part A, 36(9): 1236–1245 .
20.
Allen, H.G. (1969). Analysis and Design of Structural Sandwich Panels, Paragon Press, London .
21.
Zenkert, D. (1995). An Introduction to Sandwich Construction, Chameleon, London .
22.
Daniel, I.M. , Gdoutos, E.E. , Wang, K.A. and Abbot, J.L. (2002). Failure Modes of Composite Sandwich Beams , International Journal of Damage Mechanics, 11(4): 309–334 .
23.
Gdoutos, E.E. , Daniel, I.M. and Wang, K.A. (2002). Indentation Failure in Composite Sandwich Structures , Experimental Mechanics, 42(4): 426–431 .
24.
Gdoutos, E.E. , Daniel, I.M. and Wang, K.A. (2003). Compression Facing Wrinkling of Composite Sandwich Structures , Mechanics of Materials, 35(6): 511–522 .
25.
Steeves, C.A. and Fleck, N.A. (2004). Collapse Mechanisms of Sandwich Beams with Composite Faces and a Foam Core, Loaded in Three-point Bending. Part I: Analytical Models and Minimum Weight Design , International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 46(4): 561–583 .
26.
Steeves, C.A. and Fleck, N.A. (2004). Collapse Mechanisms of Sandwich Beams with Composite Faces and a Foam Core, Loaded in Three-point Bending. Part II: Experimental Investigation and Numerical Modeling , International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 46(4): 585–608 . Figures [10], [11] and [12] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
27.
Konsta–Gdoutos , M.S., Konsta and Gdoutos, E.E. (2005). Load and Geometry Effect on the Failure of Sandwich Structures , In: Proc. Society for Experimental Mechanics Conference on Experimental and Applied Mechanics, Portland, Oregon, Paper No. 34 (on CD ROM). Figures [13] and [14] and Tables 1 and 2, reprinted with the permission of the Society for Experimental Mechanics, Inc., copyright 2005.
28.
Lee, S.M. and Tsotsis, T.K. (2000). Indentation Failure Behavior of Honeycomb Sandwich Panels , Composites Science and Technology, 60(8): 1147–1159 .
29.
Pan, S.D. , Wu, L.Z. , Sun, Y.G. , Zhou, Z.G. and Qu, J.L. (2004). Longitudinal Shear Strength and Failure Process of Honeycomb Cores , Composite Structures, 72(1): 42–46 .
30.
Petras, A. and Sutcliffe, M.P.F. (1999). Failure Mode Maps for Honeycomb Sandwich Panels , Composite Structures, 44(4): 237–252 . Figures [15] and [16] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
31.
Abrate, S. (1998). Impact on Composite Structures, Cambridge University Press .
32.
Abrate, S. (1997). Localized Impact on Sandwich Structures with Laminated Facing , Applied Mechanics Reviews, 50(2): 83–96 .
33.
Lim, T.S. , Lee, C.S. and Lee, D.G. (2004). Failure Modes of Foam Core Sandwich Beams under Static and Impact Loads , Journal of Composite Materials, 38(18): 1639–1662 .
34.
ASTM D 5942 (1999). Determining Charpy Impact Strength of Plastics, American Society of Testing and Materials.
35.
Harte, A.M. , Fleck, N.A. and Ashby, M.F. (2001). The Fatigue Strength of Sandwich Beams with an Aluminum Alloy Foam Core , International Journal of Fatigue, 23(6): 499–507 .
36.
Kulkarni, N. , Mahfuz, H. , Melanie, S. and Carlson, L.A. (2004). Fatigue Failure Mechanism and Crack Growth in Foam Core Sandwich Composites under Flexural Loading , Journal of Reinforced Plastics & Composites, 23(1): 83–94 .
37.
Shenoi, R.A. , Clark, S.D. and Allen, H.G. (1995). Fatigue Behaviour of Polymer Composite Sandwich Beams , Journal of Composite Materials, 29(18): 2423–2446 .
38.
Challis, K.E. , Hall, D.J. and Paul, D.B. (1986). A Novel Method for Determining the Temperature Dependence of Shear Properties of Structural Foams , Cellular Polymers, 5(1): 91–101 .
39.
Sharma, S.C. , Murthy, H.N.N. and Krishna, M. (2004). Interfacial Studies in Fatigue Behavior of Polyurethane Sandwich Structures , Journal of Reinforced Plastics & Composites, 23(8): 893–903 .
40.
Berkowitz, C.K. and Johnson, W.S. (2005). Fracture and Fatigue Tests and Analysis of Composite Sandwich Structure , Journal of Composite Materials, 39(16): 1417–1431 .
41.
Erickson, M.D. , Kallmeyer, A.R. and Kellogg, K.G. (2005). Effect of Temperature on the Low-velocity Impact Behavior of Composite Sandwich Panels , Journal of Sandwich Structures and Materials, 7(3): 245–264 .
42.
Kanny, K. , Mahfuz, H. , Thomas, T. and Jeelani, S. (2004). Temperature Effects on the Fatigue Behavior of Foam Core Sandwich Structures , Polymers and Polymer Composites, 12(7): 551–559 . Figures [28] and [29] reprinted with permission from the journal of Polymers and Polymer Composites.
43.
Thomas, T. , Mahfiz, H. , Kanny, K. and Jeelani, S. (2004). Dynamic Compression of Sandwich Composites at Sub-ambient Temperatures , Journal of Composite Materials, 38(8): 641–653 .
44.
Smith, L.V. and Weitsman, Y.J. (1996). The Immersed Fatigue Response of Polymer Composites , International Journal of Fracture, 82(1): 31–42 .
45.
Weitsman, Y.J. and Elahi, M. (2000). Effects of Fluids on Deformation, Strength and Durability of Polymeric Composites , Mechanics of Time-Dependent Materials, 4(2): 107–126 .
46.
Scudamore, R.J. and Cantwell, W.J. (2002). The Effect of Moisture and Loading Rate on the Interfacial Fracture Properties of Sandwich Structures , Polymer Composites, 23(3): 406–417 .
47.
Li, X. and Weitsman, Y.J. (2004). Sea-water Effects on Foam-cored Composite Sandwich Lay-ups , Composites: Part B, 35(6–8): 451–459 . Table 4 reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
48.
ASTM D 5045-99 (1999). Standard Test Methods for Plane-strain Fracture Toughness and Strain Energy Release Rate of Plastic Materials, American Society for Testing and Materials
49.
Ishai, O. , Hiel, C. and Luft, M. (1995). Long-term Hygrothermal Effects on Damage Tolerance of Hybrid Composite Sandwich Panels , Composites, 26(1): 47–55 .
50.
Ishiaku, U.S. , Hamada, H. , Mizoguchi, M. , Chow, W.S. and Ishak, Z.A. (2005). The Effect of Ambient Moisture and Temperature Conditions on the Mechanical Properties of Glass Fiber/Carbon Fiber/Nylon 6 Sandwich Hybrid Composites Consisting of Skin-core Morphologies , Polymer Composites, 26(1): 52–59 .
51.
Harris, B. , Gathercole, N. , Reiter, H. and Adam, T. (1997). Fatigue of Carbon-fibrereinforced Plastics under Block-loading Conditions , Composites Part A, 28(4): 327–337 .
52.
Gamstedt, E.K. and Sjogren, B.A. (2002). An Experimental Investigation of the Sequence Effect in Block Amplitude Loading of Cross-ply Composite Laminates , International Journal of Fatigue, 24(2–4): 437–446 .
53.
Bertelsen, W.D. (1992). The Hydromat System: An Experimental Technique for the Static and Fatigue Testing of Sandwich Panels , In: Proceedings Second International Conference on Sandwich Construction, Gainesville, Florida.
54.
Bertelsen, W.D. (2000). Development and Certification of the ASTM D 6416-99 Plate Flexure Test and its Implications for the Future of Composite Panel Design and Construction , In: Proceedings MACM 2000, 8th International Conference on Marine Applications of Composite Materials, Melbourne, Florida.
55.
ASTM D 6416-99 (1999). Standard Test Method for Two-dimensional Flexural Properties of Simply supported Sandwich Composite Plates Subjected to Distributed Load, American Society for Testing and Materials.
56.
Ahtonen, P.J. and Sikarskie, D.L. (1998). An Analytical and Experimental Comparison of Orthotropic Sandwich Panels using the Hydromat Test System , Composites Part B, 29(6): 705–714 . Figure [31] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
57.
Ayorinde, E.O. (1995). Elastic Constants of Thick Orthotropic Composite Plates , Journal of Composite Materials, 28(8): 1025–1039 .
58.
Gibson, R.F. (2000). Modal Vibration Response Measurements for Characterization of Composite Materials and Structures , Composite Science and Technology, 60(15): 2769–2780 .
59.
Liew, K.M. , Xiang, Y. and Kitiponchai, S. (1995). Research on Thick Plate Vibration: A Literature Survey , Journal of Sound and Vibration, 180(1): 163–176 .
60.
Salawu, O.S. (1997). Detection of Structural Damage through Changes in Frequency: A Review , Engineering Structures, 19(9): 718–723 .
61.
Palozotto, A.N. , Gummadi, L.N.B. , Vaidya, U.K. and Herrup, F.J. (1995). Low Velocity Impact Damage Characteristics of Z-fiber Reinforced Sandwich Panels – An Experimental Study , Composites Structures, 43(4): 275–288 .
62.
Zheng, Z. , Ayorinde, E.O. and Gibson, R.F. (2001). A Thick Beam Library Solution Method for Vibration-Based Characterization of Thick Composite Plates , Journal of Vibrations and Acoustics, 123(1): 76–83 . Figure [32] reprinted with permission from ASME.
63.
Zou, Y. , Tong, L. and Steven, G.P. (2000). Vibration-based Model-dependent Damage (delamination) Identification and Health Monitoring for Composite Structures — A Review , Journal of Sound and Vibration, 230(2): 357–378 .
64.
Liu, G.R. and Chen, S.C. (2001). Flaw Detection in Sandwich Plates based on Timeharmonic Response using Genetic Algorithm , Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 190(42): 5505–5514 .
65.
Kim, H. and Hwang, W. (2002). Effect of Debonding on Natural Frequencies and Frequency Response Functions of Honeycomb Sandwich Beams , Composite Structures, 55(1): 51–62 .
66.
Akay, M. and Hanna, R. (1990). A Comparison of Honeycomb-core and Foam-core Carbon-fibre/Epoxy Sandwich Panels , Composites, 21(4): 325–331 .
67.
Sachse, W. , Castagnede, B. , Grabec, I. , Kim, K.Y. and Weaver, R.I. (1990). Recent Developments in Quantitative Ultrasonic NDE of Composites , Ultrasonics, 28(2): 97–104 .
68.
Gupta, N. and Sankaran, S. (1999). On the Characterization of Syntactic Foam Core Sandwich Composites for Compressive Properties , Journal of Reinforced Plastics & Composites, 18(14): 1347–1357 .
69.
Legendre, S. , Goyette, J. and Massicott, D. (2001). Ultrasonic NDE of Composite Material Structures using Wavelet Coefficients , NDT & E International, 34(1): 31–37 .
70.
Gur, C.H. (2003). Investigation of Microstructure–Ultrasonic Velocity Relationship in SiCp-reinforced Aluminium Metal Matrix Composites , Materials Science and Engineering A, 361(1–2): 29–35 .
71.
Hosur, M.V. , Vaidya, U.K. , Myers, D. and Jeelani, S. (2003). Studies on the Repair of Ballistic Impact Damaged S2-glass/Vinylester Laminates , Composite Structures, 61(4): 281–290 .
72.
Roth, D.J. (1997). Using a Single Transducer Ultrasonic Imaging Method to Eliminate the Effect of Thickness Variation in the Images of Ceramic and Composite Plates , Journal of Nondestructive Evaluation, 16(2): 101–120 . Figure [33] reprinted with permission from Springer Science and Business Media.
73.
Favro, L.D. , Jin, H.J. , Wang, Y.X. , Ahmed, T. , Wang, X. , Kuo, P.K. and Thomas, R.L. (1993). IR Thermal Wave Tomographic Studies of Structural Composites, In: Thompson, D.O. and Chimenti, D.E. , (eds), Review of Progress in Quantitative Nondestructive Evaluation, NDT & E International, 28 Jul.–2 Aug. 1991; Vol. 26(2), p. 99-99, Plenum Press, Brunswick, Maine (United States) 11A: 447–451.
74.
Favro, L.D. , Thomas, R.L. , Han, X. , Ouyang, Z. , Newaz, R.L. and Gentile, G.D. (2001). Sonic Infrared Imaging of Fatigue Cracks , International Journal of Fatigue, 23(Supplement 1): S471–S476 . Figure [34] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
75.
Guazzone, L.J.-P. and Danjoux, R. (1996). Inspection of New Aeroengine Components by Thermal Wave , NDT & E International, 29(6): 392-392 .
76.
Dattoma, V. , Marcuccio, R. , Pappalettere, C. and Smith, G.M. (2001). Thermographic Investigation of Sandwich Structure made of Composite Material , NDT AND E International, 34(8): 515–520 .
77.
Mandelis, A. (2001). Diffusion-wave Laser Radiometric Diagnostic Quality-control Technologies for Materials , NDE/NDT, NDT & E International, 34(4): 277–287 .
78.
Mandelis, A. , Munidasa, M. and Nicolaides, L. (1999). Laser Infrared Photothermal Radiometric Depth Profilometry of Steels and its Potential in Rail Track Evaluation , NDT & E International, 32(8): 437–443 .
79.
Wendler, L. and Grigoryan, V.G. (1988). Acoustic Interface Waves in Sandwich Structures , Surface Science, 206(1–2): 203–224 .
80.
Osmont, D. , Devillers, D. and Taillade, F. (2001). Health Monitoring of Sandwich Plates based on the Analysis of the Interaction of Lamb Waves with Damages , In: Proceedings of SPIE – The International Society for Optical Engineering, 432(7): 290–301 .
81.
Lee, J. (1999). Plate Waves in Multi-directional Composite Laminates , Composite Structures, 46(3): 289–297 . Figure [35] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
82.
Chen, W.H. , Lee, F.C. and Chiang, D.M. (2000). On the Acoustic Absorption of Porous Materials with Different Surface Shapes and Perforated Plates , Journal of sound and Vibration, 237(2): 337–355 . Figure [36] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
83.
Forest, L. , Gibiat, V. and Hooley, A. (2001). Impedance Matching and Acoustic Absorption in Granular Layers of Silica Aerogels , Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 285(1–3): 230–235 .
84.
Yamaguchi, K. , Oyaizu, H. , Johkaji, J. and Kobayashi, Y. (1991). In: Sachse, W. , Roquet, J. and Yamaguchi, K. (eds), Acoustic Emission: Current Practice and Future Directions, ASTM STP 1077, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, PA , p. 123-123.
85.
Hamstad, A. (1996). A Review: Acoustic Emission, a Tool for Composite Material Studies , Experimental Mechanics, 26(1): 7–13 .
86.
Dzenis, Y.A. and Qian, J. (2001). Analysis of Microdamage Evolution Histories in Composites , International Journal of Solids and Structures, 38(10–13): 1831–1854 . Figure [37] reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
87.
Aberg, M. (2001). Numerical Modeling of Acoustic Emission in Laminated Tensile Test Specimens , International Journal of Solids and Structures, 38(36–37): 6643–6663 .
88.
Ma, X.Q. and Takemoto, M. (2001). Quantitative Acoustic Emission Analysis of Plasma Sprayed Thermal Barrier Coatings subjected to Thermal Shock Tests , Material Science and Engineering A, 308(1–2): 101–110 .
89.
Kim, B. and Weiss, J. (2003). Using Acoustic Emission to Quantify Damage in Restrained Fiber-reinforced Cement Mortars , Cement and Concrete Research, 33(2): 207–214 .
90.
Paul, H. and Fowler, T. (2003). Fiber Reinforced Vessel Design with a Damage Criterion Approach , Composite Structures, 61(4): 395–411 .
