Extending the Veil of Darkness Approach: An Examination of Racial Disproportionality in Traffic Stops in Durham,NC

Abstract

Developed in 2006, the veil of darkness approach is one of the most widely accepted methods for assessing the impact of driver race on traffic stops. Building on the original methodology, we innovate in three important ways to enhance the veil of darkness approach: (a) invoke generalized linear mixed models to account for the lack of independence among observations in traffic stop data sets, (b) decompose the relationship between daylight and driver race to consider the role of driver sex, and (c) assess variability in racial disproportionality across law enforcement units. Nearly 20,000 traffic stops are analyzed for the Durham (NC) Police Department. Results indicate that more than 10% of the variability in the rate of Black drivers stopped is accounted for by officer-level factors, racial disproportionality was only for male drivers, and evidence of disproportionality was found among some units, but no evidence was found among others.

Keywords

veil of darkness traffic stops racial disproportionality

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alpert

G. P.

Smith

M. R.

Dunham

R. G.

(2004) Toward a better benchmark: Assessing the utility of not-at-fault traffic crash data in racial profiling research. Justice Research and Policy 6: 43–69.

Barlow

M. H.

(1998) Race and the problem of crime in Time and Newsweek cover stories, 1946 to 1995. Social Justice 25: 149–183.

Baumgartner, F. R., & Epp, D. (2012a). North Carolina traffic stop analysis. Retrieved from http://www.unc.edu/∼fbaum/papers/Baumgartner-Traffic-Stops-Statistics-1-Feb-2012.pdf.

Baumgartner, F. R., & Epp, D. (2012b). North Carolina traffic stop statistics analysis. Final report to the North Carolina Advocates for Justice Task Force on Racial and Ethnic Bias. Retrieved from http://www.unc.edu/∼fbaum/papers/Baumgartner-Traffic-Stops-Statistics-1-Feb-2012.pdf.

Blalock

DeVaro

Leventhal

Simon

D. H.

(2011) Gender bias in power relationships: Evidence from police traffic stops. Applied Economics 43(29): 4469–4485.

Briggs, J. S. (2013). Routine justice: The intersection of race, gender, and police discretion in traffic stops (doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from http://krex.k-state.edu/dspace/handle/2097/16228.

Brown

Benedict

W. R.

(2002) Perceptions of the police: Past findings, methodological issues, conceptual issues and policy implications. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management 25: 543–580.

Brunson

R. K.

(2007) Police don’t like Black people: African-American young men’s accumulated police experiences. Criminology and Public Policy 6: 71–101.

Brunson

R. K.

Miller

(2006) Young Black men and urban policing in the United States. The British Journal of Criminology 46: 613–640.

10.

Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2016). Traffic stops. Retrieved from http://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=tp&tid=702.

11.

Chiricos

Eschholz

(2002) The racial and ethnic typification of crime and the criminal typification of race and ethnicity in local television news. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 39: 400–420.

12.

Chiricos

Welch

Gertz

(2004) The racial typification of crime and support for punitive measures. Criminology 42: 358–390.

13.

Cox

S. M.

Fitzgerald

J. D.

(1996) Police in community relations: Critical issues, 3rd ed. Dubuque, IA: Brown and Benchmark Publishers.

14.

Drummond

W. J.

(1990) About face: Blacks and the news media. American Enterprise 1: 23–29.

15.

Ene, M., Leighton, E., Blue, G., & Bell, B. (2014). Multilevel models for categorical data using SAS PROC GLIMMIX: The basics (Paper 134–2014). Retrieved from https://support.sas.com/resources/papers/proceedings15/3430-2015.pdf.

16.

Engel

R. S.

Calnon

J. M.

(2004) Examining the influence of drivers’ characteristics during traffic stops with police: Results from a national survey. Justice Quarterly 21: 49–90.

17.

Greenwald

H. P.

(2001) Final report: Police vehicle stops in Sacramento, California, Los Angeles, CA: University of Southern California.

18.

Grogger

Ridgeway

(2006) Testing for racial profiling in traffic stops from behind a veil of darkness. Journal of the American Statistical Association 101: 878–887. doi:10.1198/016214506000000168.

19.

Hawkins

D. F.

(1995) Ethnicity, race, and crime: A review of selected studies. In: Hawkins

(ed.) Ethnicity, race, and crime: Perspectives across time and place, Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, pp. 11–45.

20.

Hickman, M. J. (2005). Traffic stop data collection policies for state police, 2004. Bureau of Justice Statistics Fact Sheet. U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs. NCJ 209156. Retrieved from http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/tsdcp04.pdf.

21.

Horrace, W. C., & Rohlin, S. M. (2014, January). How dark is dark? Bright lights, big city, racial profiling (Unpublished manuscript). Retrieved from https://www.colgate.edu/docs/default-source/default-document-library/horracerohlindarkness-1-14-14.pdf?sfvrsn=0.

22.

Hurwitz, J., & Peffley, M. (Eds.). (1998). Perception and prejudice: Race and politics in the United States. New Haven, CT/London, England: Yale University Press.

23.

Kennedy

(1997) Race, crime and the law, New York, NY: Vintage.

24.

Kitwana

(2002) The hip hop generation: Young Blacks and the Crisis in African-American Culture, New York, NY: Basic Civitas Books.

25.

Klinger

D. A.

(1997) Negotiating order in patrol work: An ecological theory of police response to deviance. Criminology 35(2): 277–306.

26.

Knowles

Persico

Todd

(2001) Racial bias in motor vehicle searches: Theory and evidence. Journal of Political Economy 1(109): 203–229.

27.

Lamberth, J. (2003). Measuring the racial/ethnic makeup of traffic: The how, what and why. Paper presented at Confronting Racial Profiling in the 21st Century: Implications for Racial Justice, Boston, MA.

28.

Lange

J. E.

Johnson

M. B.

Voas

R. B.

(2005) Testing the racial profiling hypothesis for seemingly disparate traffic stops on the New Jersey Turnpike. Justice Quarterly 22(2): 193–223.

29.

Ludwig, J. (2003, May 13). Americans see racial profiling as widespread. Gallup. Retrieved from http://www.gallup.com/poll/8389/Americans-See-Racial-Profiling-Widespread.aspx.

30.

Lundman

R. J.

Kaufman

R. L.

(2003) Driving while black: Effects of race, ethnicity, and gender on citizen self-reports of traffic stops and police actions. Criminology 41(1): 195–220.

31.

Maas

C. J.

Hox

J. J.

(2004) Robustness issues in multilevel regression analysis. Statistica Neerlandica 52(2): 127–137.

32.

Maas

C. J.

Hox

J. J.

(2005) Sufficient sample size for multilevel modeling. Methodology 1(3): 86–92.

33.

Mauer

(1999) Race to incarcerate, New York, NY: New Press.

34.

McDevitt

Iwama

(2016) Vermont state police: An examination of traffic stop data. Report prepared for Institute on Race and Justice, Boston, MA: Northeastern University.

35.

Oakland Police Department (2004) Promoting cooperative strategies to reduce racial profiling: A technical guide, Oakland, CA: Author.

36.

Ridgeway

Schell

T. L.

Gifford

Saunders

Turner

Riley

K. J.

Dixon

T. L.

(2009) Police-community relations in Cincinnati, Santa Monica, CA: RAND Center on Quality PolicingRetrieved from http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/2009/RAND_MG853.pdf.

37.

Riksheim

Chermack

S. M.

(1993) Causes of Police behavior revisited. Journal of Criminal Justice 21: 353–382.

38.

Ritter, J. A., & Bael, D. (2009). Detecting racial profiling in Minneapolis traffic stops: A new approach. CURA Reporter, 11–17. Retrieved from http://hup.umn.edu/docs/DetectingRacialProfiling.pdf.

39.

Ross

Fazzalaro

Barone

Kalinowski

(2015) State of Connecticut: Traffic stop data analysis and findings, 2013–2014. Report prepared for Institute for Municipal and Regional Policy, New Britain, CT: Central Connecticut State University.

40.

Rushin, S., & Edwards, G. S. (2017). De-policing. Cornell Law Review. Retrieved from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Papers.cfm?abstract_id=2757809.

41.

Russell

K. K.

(2002) The racial hoax as crime: The law as affirmation. In: Gabbidon

S. L.

Greene

H. T.

Young

V. D.

(eds) African American classics in criminology and criminal justice, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, pp. 349–376.

42.

Sigelman

Tuch

S. A.

(1996) Metastereotypes: Blacks’ perceptions of Whites’ stereotypes of Blacks. Public Opinion Quarterly 61: 87–101.

43.

Smith

D. A.

Graham

Adams

(1991) Minorities and the police: Attitudinal and behavioral questions. In: Lynch

M. J.

Patterson

E. B.

(eds) Race and criminal justice, Albany, NY: Harrow and Heston Publishers, pp. 22–35.

44.

Smith

M. R.

Makarios

Alpert

G. P.

(2006) Differential suspicion: Theory specification and gender effects in the traffic stop context. Justice Quarterly 23(2): 271–295.

45.

Smith, W. R., Tomaskovic-Devey, D., Zingraff, M. T., Mason, H. M., Warren, P. Y., & Wright, C. P. (2004). The North Carolina highway traffic study. Final report to the National Institute of Justice, U.S. Department of Justice.

46.

Sniderman

Piazza

(1993) The scar of race, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

47.

Snijders

T. A. B.

(2005) Power and sample size in multilevel linear models. In: Everitt

B. S.

Howell

D. C.

(eds) Encyclopedia of statistics in behavioral science Vol. 3, Chicester, England: Wiley, pp. 1570–1573.

48.

Snijders

T. A. B.

Bosker

(1999) Multilevel analysis. An introduction to basic and advanced multilevel modeling, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

49.

Tillyer

Engel

R. S.

(2010) The impact of drivers’ race, gender, and age during traffic stops: Assessing interaction terms and the social conditioning model. Crime and Delinquency 59: 369–395.

50.

Tyler

T. R.

Fagan

(2008) Legitimacy and cooperation: Why do people help the police fight crime in their communities? Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 6: 231–275.

51.

Tyler

T. R.

Wakslak

C. J.

(2004) Profiling and police legitimacy: Procedural justice, attributions of motive, and acceptance of police authority. Criminology 42: 253–281.

52.

Weitzer

Tuch

(2002) Perceptions of racial profiling: Race, class, and personal experience. Criminology 40: 435–456.

53.

Welch

(2007) Black criminal stereotypes and racial profiling. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 23: 276–288.

54.

Welch, K., Chiricos, T., & Gertz, M. (2002). Racial typification of crime and punitive attitudes. Paper presented at annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Chicago, IL.

55.

Worden

R. E.

McLean

S. J.

Wheeler

(2012) Testing for racial profiling with the veil-of-darkness method. Police Quarterly 15: 92–111.

56.

Worrall

J. L.

(1999) Public perceptions of police efficacy and image: The ‘fuzziness’ of support for the police. American Journal of Criminal Justice 24: 47–66.