A man’s transition into the role of a father is a rewarding yet challenging experience for many men. This study explores how men navigate contradictory roles of fatherhood and the impact this has on their identities. Fifteen first-time fathers were interviewed, and their responses were analysed using thematic and discourse analysis tools. Findings revealed that fathers both adhered to and challenge masculine ideals of fatherhood. Men described both traditional and non-traditional roles in their becoming a father, being a father, and navigating fatherhood and manhood. The continuation and contestation of masculine discourses in the experiences of fatherhood was found to influence their involvement with raising children and employment, as well as their relationships. Overall, these findings highlight the uncertainty that shapes modern fathers’ roles and demonstrates how fathers move between both traditional and new fatherhood roles.
Australian Institute of Family Studies. 2015. Fatherhood and Mental Illness: A Review of Key Issues. CFCA Paper No.30 2015. Melbourne, Australia: Rhys Price-Robertson.
2.
BarclayL.LuptonD.1999. “The Experiences of new Fatherhood: A Socio-cultural Analysis.” Journal of Advanced Nursing29 (4), 1013–1020.
3.
BartlettE. E.2004. “The Effects of Fatherhood on the Health of Men: A Review of the Literature.” Journal of Men’s Health and Gender1 (2), 159–169.
4.
BaxterJ.BuchlerS.PeralesF.WesternM.2015. “A Life-changing Event: First Births and Men’s and Women’s Attitudes to Mothering and Gender Divisions of Labor.” Social Forces93 (3), 989–1014.
5.
BørveH. E.BungumB.2015. “Norwegian Working Fathers in Global Working Life.” Gender, Work & Organization22 (4), 309–323.
6.
BuchlerS.PeralesF.BaxterJ.2017.” Does Parenthood Change Attitudes to Fathering? Evidence from Australia and Britain.”Sex Roles, 77 (9–10), 1–13.
7.
CabreraN. J.Tamis-LeMondaC. S.BradleyR. H.HofferthS.LambM. E.2000. “Fatherhood in the Twenty-first Century.” Child Development71 (1), 127–136.
8.
CarlsonJ.KendallA.EdlesonJ. L.2015. “Becoming a Good Father: The Developmental Engine of First-time Fatherhood.” Fathering13 (3), 182–202.
9.
CarpenterC.2013. “Phenomenology and Rehabilitation Research.” In Research Methods in Health: Foundations for Evidence-based Practice, edited by LiamputtongP., 115–131. South Melbourne, Vic: Oxford University Press.
10.
ChinR.DaichesA.HallP.2011. “A Qualitative Exploration of First-time Fathers’ Experiences of Becoming a Father.”Community Practioner84(7), 19–23.
11.
ColesT.2009. “Negotiating the Field of Masculinity: The Production and Reproduction of Multiple Dominant Masculinities.” Men and Masculinities12, 30–44.
12.
ConnellR.W.1987. Gender and Power: Society, the Person, and Sexual Politics. Sydney, Australia: Allen & Unwin.
13.
ConnellR. W.1995. Masculinities. St Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin.
14.
ConnellR. W.MesserschmidtJ. W.2005. “Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept.” Gender and Society19 (6), 829–859.
15.
CookJ. L.JonesR. M.DickA. J.SinghA.2005. “Revisiting Men’s Role in Father Involvement: The Importance of Personal Expectations.” Fathering3(2), 165–178.
16.
CourtenayW. H.2000. “Constructions of Masculinity and Their Influence on Men’s Well-being: A Theory of Gender and Health.” Social Science & Medicine50 (10), 1385–1401.
17.
CraigL.MullanK.2014. “Australian Fathers’ Work and Family Time in Comparative and Temporal Perspective.” Journal of Family Studies18 (2), 165–174.
18.
CrespiI.RuspiniE.2015. “Transition to Fatherhood: New Perspectives in the Global Context of Changing Men’s Identities.” International. Review of Sociology25 (3), 353–358.
19.
CreswellJ.HansonW.Clark PlanoV.MoralesA.2007. “Qualitative Research Designs: Selection and Implementation.” The Counselling Psychologist, 35 (2), 236–264.
20.
CroweM.2005. “Discourse Analysis: Towards an Understanding of Its Place in Nursing.” Journal of Advanced Nursing, 51 (1), 55–63.
21.
DeaveT.JohnsonD.2008. “The Transition to Parenthood: What Does it Mean for Fathers?” Journal of Advanced Nursing63 (6), 626–633.
22.
DewK.2007. “A Health Researcher’s Guide to Qualitative Methodologies.” Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health31 (5), 433–437.
23.
DonaldsonM.1993. “What is Hegemonic Masculinity?” Theory and Society22 (5), 643–657.
24.
DoucetA.LeeR.2014. “Fathering, Feminism(s), Gender, and Sexualities: Connections, Tensions, and New Pathways.” Journal of Family Theory & Review6 (4), 355–373. doi:10.1111/jftr.12051
25.
DRAPERJ.2003. “Men’s Passage to Fatherhood: An Analysis of the Contemporary Relevance of Transition Theory.” Nursing Inquiry10 (1), 66–78.
26.
DuvanderA.2016. “Fathers on Leave Alone in Sweden: Toward more Equal Parenthood?”. In Comparative Perspectives on Work-Life Balance and Gender Equality, edited by O’BrienM.WallK., 125–145. Springer International Publishing.
27.
EakinJ.2005. “The Discourse of Abuse in Return-to-work: A Hidden Epidemic of Suffering.” In Occupational Health and Safety: International Influences and the “New” Epidemics, edited by PetersonC. L.MayhewC., 65). Amityville, NY: Baywood Publishing.
28.
EerolaP.MykkänenJ.2015. “Paternal Masculinities in Early Fatherhood: Dominant and Counter Narratives by Finnish First-time Fathers.” Journal of Family Issues36 (12), 1674–1701.
29.
ElliottKarla. 2016. “Caring Masculinities: Theorizing an Emerging Concept.” Men and Masculinities19 (3), 240–259.
30.
FaircloughN.2001. Language and Power (2nd ed.). Essex, England: Pearson Education Ltd.
31.
FaircloughN.2013. Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language (2nd ed.) [Pro Quest ebrary]. New York: Routledge.
32.
FägerskiöldA.2008. “A Change in Life as Experienced by First-time Fathers.” Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences22 (1), 64–71.
33.
GenesoniL.TallandiniM. A.2009. “Men’s Psychological transition to fatherhood: An analysis of the literature, 1989–2008.” Birth36 (4), 305–317.
34.
GoodmanJ. H.2005. “Becoming an Involved Father of an Infant.” Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, & Neonatal Nursing34 (2), 190–200.
35.
GrayE.2013. “Fatherhood and Men’s Involvement in Paid Work in Australia.” In Negotiating the Life Course: Stability and Change in Life Pathways, edited by EvansA.BaxterJ., 161–174. Dordrecht, NLD: Springer.
36.
GregoryA.MilnerS.2011. “What is ‘New’ about Fatherhood?: The social construction of fatherhood in France and the UK.” Men and Masculinities14 (5), 588–606.
37.
HabibC.2012. “The Transition to Fatherhood: A Literature Review Exploring Paternal Involvement with Identity Theory.” Journal of Family Studies18 (2), 103–120.
38.
HamiltonA.De JongeD.2010. “The Impact of Becoming a Father on Other Roles: An Ethnographic Study.” Journal of Occupational Science17 (1), 40–46.
39.
HanlonN.2012. Masculinities, Care and Equality: Identity and Nurture in Men’s Lives. Palgrave Macmillan UK, London.
40.
HenwoodK.ProcterJ.2003. “The ‘Good Father’: Reading Men’s Accounts of Paternal Involvement during the Transition to First-time Fatherhood.” British Journal of Social Psychology42 (3), 337–355.
41.
HodkinsonP.BrooksR.2018. “Interchangeable Parents? The Roles and Identities of Primary and Equal Carer Fathers of Young Children.” Current Sociology.
42.
HöfnerC.SchadlerC.RichterR.2011. “When Men become Fathers: Men’s Identity at the Transition to Parenthood.” Journal of Comparative Family Studies42 (5), 669–686.
43.
HollowayI.WheelerS.2010. Qualitative Research in Nursing and Healthcare (3rd ed.). Chichester, U.K.: Wiley-Blackwell.
44.
IwataH.2014. “Experiences of Japanese Men during the Transition to Fatherhood.” Journal of Transcultural Nursing25 (2), 159–166.
45.
JohanssonT.2011. “Fatherhood in Transition: Paternity Leave and Changing Masculinities.” Journal of Family Communication11 (3), 165–180.
46.
KowlessarO.FoxJ.WittkowskiA.2015. “First-time Fathers’ Experiences of Parenting during the First Year.” Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology33 (1), 4–14.
47.
LiamputtongP.2013. Qualitative Research Methods (4th ed.). South Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
48.
LiuK.GuoF.2016. “A Review on Critical Discourse Analysis.” Theory and Practice in Language Studies6 (5), 1076–1084.
49.
MachinA.2015. “Mind the Gap: The Expectation and Reality of Involved Fatherhood.” Fathering13 (1), 36–59.
50.
MagaraggiaS.2012. “Tensions between Fatherhood and the Social Construction of Masculinity in Italy.” Current Sociology61 (1), 76–92.
51.
McVeighC. A.BaafiM.WilliamsonM.2002. “Functional Status after Fatherhood: An Australian Study.” Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, & Neonatal Nursing31(2), 165–171.
NyströmK.ÖhrlingK.2004. “Parenthood Experiences during the Child’s First Year: Literature Review.” Journal of Advanced Nursing46 (3), 319–330.
54.
PitneyW.ParkerJ.2009. Qualitative Research in Physical Activity and the Health Professions. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
55.
PrembergÅ.HellströmA.BergM.2008. “Experiences of the First Year as Father.” Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences22 (1), 56–63.
56.
RussellG.1983. The Changing Role of Fathers. St. Lucia, Queensland: University of Queensland Press.
57.
SansiriphunN.KantaruksaK.KlunklinA.BaosuangC.LiamtriratS.2015. “The Journey into Fatherhood: A Grounded Theory Study.” Nursing & Health Sciences17 (4), 460–466.
58.
ScamborEBergmannN.WojnickaK.Belghiti-MahutS.HearnJ.Gullvåg HolterØ.GärtnerM.HrženjakM.ScamborC.WhiteA.2014. “Men and Gender Equality: European Insights.” Men and Masculinities17 (5), 552–577.
59.
ShiraniF.HenwoodK.ColtartC.2012. “‘Why Aren’t You at Work?’: Negotiating Economic Models of Fathering Identity.” Fathering10 (3), 274–290.
60.
St JohnW.CameronC.McVeighC.2005. “Meeting the Challenge of New Fatherhood during the Early Weeks.” Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, & Neonatal Nursing34 (2), 180–189.
61.
SuwadaK.2015. “Being a Traditional Dad or Being More Like a Mum? Clashing Models of Fatherhood according to Swedish and Polish Fathers.” Journal of Comparative Family Studies46 (4), 467–481.
62.
van ManenM.2017. “Phenomenology in Its Original Sense.” Qualitative Health Research27 (6), 810–825.
