The study of masculinities has not escaped the influence of Judith Butler’s writings on gender, performativity, and subversion. However, this article suggests that Butler’s formulations of performativity and subversion express a lack of clarity and engender a number of problems with respect to agency, action, interaction, and social change. This article argues for reformulating performativity and subversion in a more explicitly sociological frame to render the concepts more useful for examining agency and subjectivity in the study of masculinities. The writings of Erving Goffman suggest ways to reclaim the socially constructed agency of “performance” from the mire of “performativity,” with the latter’s apparent disappearance of subjective action. This article suggests reworking subversion away from parody and resignification toward a consideration of resources for subjectivity and challenges to prevailing social structures. In this way, performativity and subversion may be set more convincingly within a sociologically informed study of masculinity.
Allen, A.1998. Power trouble: Performativity as critical theory. Constellations5 (4): 456-471.
2.
Allen, L., and H. Worth.2002. The life of Brian: Masculinities, sexualities and health in New Zealand. Dunedin, New Zealand: Otago University Press.
3.
Althusser, L.1984. Essays on ideology. London: Verso.
4.
Austin, J.1962. How to do things with words. Oxford: Clarendon.
5.
Bordo, S.1993. Unbearable weight: Feminism, Western culture, and the body. Berkeley: University of California Press.
6.
Brickell, C.2000. Heroes and invaders: Gay and lesbian pride parades and the public/private distinction in New Zealand media accounts. Gender, Place and Culture7 (2): 163-178.
7.
Brickell, C.2002. Through the (new) looking glass: Gendered bodies, fashion and resistance in post-war New Zealand. Journal of Consumer Culture2 (2): 241-269.
8.
Brickell, C.2003. Performativity or performance? Clarifications in the sociology of gender. New Zealand Sociology18 (2): 158-178.
Butler, J.1988. Performative acts and gender constitution: An essay in phenomenology and feminist theory. Theatre Journal49 (1): 519-531.
11.
Butler, J.1990. Gender trouble: Feminism and the subversion of identity. New York: Routledge.
12.
Butler, J.1991. Imitation and gender insubordination. In Inside/out: Lesbian theories, gay theories, edited by D. Fuss, 13-31. London: Routledge.
13.
Butler, J.1993. Bodies that matter: On the discursive limits of “sex.”New York: Routledge.
14.
Butler, J.1996. Gender as performance. In A critical sense: Interviews with intellectuals, edited by P. Osborne, 109-125. London: Routledge.
15.
Butler, J.1997. The psychic life of power. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
16.
Butler, J.1998. How bodies come to matter: An interview with Judith Butler. Signs23 (2): 275-286.
17.
Cameron, D.1997. Performing gender identity: Young men’s talk and the construction of heterosexual masculinity. In Language and masculinity, edited by S. Johnson and U. Meinhof, 47-64. Oxford: Blackwell.
18.
Cameron, J.1997. Throwing a dishcloth into the works: Troubling theories of domestic labour. Rethinking Marxism9 (2): 24-44.
19.
Campbell, H.2000. The glass phallus: Pub(lic) masculinity and drinking in rural New Zealand. Rural Sociology65 (4): 562-581.
20.
Connell, R. W.1987. Gender and power. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
21.
Connell, R. W.1993. The big picture: Masculinities in recent world history. Theory and Society22: 597-623.
22.
Crespi, F.1989. Social action and power. Oxford: Blackwell.
23.
Deutscher, P.1997. Yielding gender: Feminism, deconstruction and the history of philosophy. London: Routledge.
24.
Edwards, T.1998. Queer fears: Against the cultural turn. Sexualities1 (4): 471-484.
25.
Garfinkel, H.1967. Studies in ethnomethodology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
26.
Gergen, K.1971. The concept of self. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
27.
Gerson, K.1993. No man’s land: Men’s changing commitment to family and work. New York: Basic Books.
28.
Giddens, A.1992. The transformation of intimacy. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
29.
Goffman, E.[1956] 1959. The presentation of self in everyday life. New York: Doubleday.
30.
Goffman, E.1963. Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
31.
Goffman, E.1974. Frame analysis. New York: Harper and Row.
32.
Goffman, E.1977. The arrangement between the sexes. Theory and Society4 (3): 301-331.
Goffman, E.1983. Felicity’s condition. American Journal of Sociology89 (1): 1-51.
35.
Gutterman, D.2001. Postmodernism and the interrogation of masculinity. In The masculinities reader, edited by S. Whitehead and F. Barrett, 56-72. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
36.
Hekman, S.1992. The embodiment of the subject: Feminism and the communitarian critique of liberalism. The Journal of Politics54 (4): 1098-1119.
37.
Hollway, W.1996. Gender difference and the production of subjectivity. In Feminism and sexuality: A reader, edited by S. Jackson and S. Scott, 84-100. New York: Columbia University Press.
38.
Hutcheon, L.1994. Irony’s edge: The theory and politics of irony. London: Routledge.
39.
Jackson, S., and S. Scott.2001. Putting the body’s feet on the ground: Towards a sociological reconceptualization of gendered and sexual embodiment. In Constructing gendered bodies, edited by K. Backett-Milburn and L. McKie, 9-24. Houndmills, UK: Palgrave.
40.
Jones, D.2000. Gender trouble in the workplace: “Language and gender” meets “feminist organisational communication.” In Gendered speech in social context: Perspectives from town to gown, edited by J. Holmes, 192-210. Wellington, New Zealand: Victoria University Press.
41.
Kessler, S., and W. McKenna. 1978. Gender: An ethnomethodological approach. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
42.
Kimmel, M.2001. Becoming 100 percent straight. In Men’s lives, edited by M. Kimmel and M. Messner, 401-406. 5th ed.Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
43.
Lemert, C.1997. Goffman. In The Goffman reader, edited by C. Lemert and A. Branaman, ix-xliii. Oxford: Blackwell.
44.
Leonard, D., and L. Adkins.1996. Sex in question: French materialist feminism. London: Taylor and Francis.
45.
Livia, A., and K. Hall.1997. “It’s a girl!”: Bringing performativity back to linguistics. In Queerly phrased: Language, gender and sexuality, edited by A. Livia and K. Hall, 3-18. New York: Oxford University Press.
McIlvenny, P.2002. Critical reflections on performativity and the“un/doing”of gender and sexuality in talk. In Talking gender and sexuality, edited by P. McIlvenny, 111-149. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
48.
MacKinnon, C.1987. Feminism unmodified. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
49.
McNay, L.1999. Subject, psyche and agency: The work of Judith Butler. Theory, Culture and Society16 (2): 175-193.
50.
Morley, D.1996. Populism, revisionism, and the “new” audience research. In Cultural studies and communications, edited by J. Curran, D. Morley, and V. Walkerdine, 279-293. London: Arnold.
Rahman, M.2000. Sexuality and democracy: Identities and strategies in lesbian and gay politics. Edinburgh, UK: Edinburgh University Press.
53.
Redman, P.2001. The discipline of love: Negotiation and regulation in boys’performance of a romance-based heterosexual masculinity. Men and Masculinities4 (2): 186-200.
54.
Savran, D.1998. Taking it like a man: White masculinity, masochism and contemporary American culture. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
55.
Schacht, S.2001. Teaching about being an oppressor. Men and Masculinities4 (2): 201-208.
56.
Scott, S., and S. Jackson.2000. Sexuality. In Social divisions, edited by G. Payne, 168-183. London: MacMillan.
57.
Sedgwick, E. K.1994. Epistemology of the closet. London: Penguin.
58.
Segal, L.1990. Slow motion: Changing masculinities, changing men. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
59.
Sharpe, S.2002. “It’s just really hard to come to terms with”: Young people’s views on homosexuality. Sex Education2 (3): 263-277.
60.
Turner, R.1976. The real self: From institution to impulse. American Journal of Sociology81(5): 989-1016.
61.
van Dijk, T.1992. Discourse and the denial of racism. Discourse and Society3 (1): 87-118.
62.
Webster, F.2000. The politics of sex and gender: Benhabib and Butler debate subjectivity. Hypatia15 (1): 1-22.
63.
West, D., and C. Zimmerman.1991. Doing gender. In The social construction of gender, edited by J. Lorber and S. Farrell, 13-37. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
64.
Whitehead, S., and F. Barrett.2001. The sociology of masculinity. In The masculinities reader, edited by S. Whitehead and F. Barrett, 1-26. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
65.
Worth, H.2002. “Tits is just an accessory”: Masculinity and femininity in the lives of Maori and Pacific queens. In The life of Brian, edited by H. Worth, A. Paris, and L. Allen, 117-128. Dunedin, New Zealand: University of Otago Press.
