This study addresses issues related to the productivity measurement of firms using intangible input to produce intangible output. It examines the difficulties associated with the productivity measurement of such firms and suggests a measure that takes account of the unique attributes of the factors used in their production. This issue is examined with application to a professional service industry—management consulting—in which all inputs and outputs are intangibles.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aharoni, Y.
(1997), “Management Consulting,” in Changing Role of State Intervention in Services in an Era of Open International Markets, Y. Aharoni, ed. Alberta: State University of New York Press, 153-179.
2.
“Assessing Brands: Broad, Deep, Long and Heavy” (1996), The Economist, November 16, 84-85.
3.
Banker, R. D.
, R. F. Conrad, and R. P. Strauss (1986), “A Comparative Application of Data Development Analysis and Translog Methods: An Illustrative Study of Hospital Production,”Management Science, 32 (1), 30-44.
4.
Berg, S. A. (1991), “Mergers, Efficiency and Productivity Growth in Norwegian Banking 1984-1989,” Norges Bank Research Paper 1991/3, Oslo.
5.
Berg, S. A., F. R. Forsund, and E. S. Jansen (1989), “Bank Output Measurement and the Construction of Best Practice Frontiers,” Norges Bank Research Paper 1989/6, Oslo.
6.
Berg, S. A.F. R. Forsund
, and E. S. Jansen (1992), “Malmquist Indices of Productivity Growth during the Deregulation of Norwegian Banking, 1980-1989,”proceedings of a symposium on productivity concepts and measurement problems, Uppsala, 1991 (Published as supplement to The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, Vol. 94, 1992, pp. 211-228).
7.
Berne, C.
and J. M. Mugica (1994), “The Measurement of Output in Retailing: Production and Demand Functions,” in Service Productivity: Current Research, Proceedings from the First International Research Workshop on Service Productivity, October, Brussels, Gummesson and I. Thoresson-Hallgren, eds. Stockholm: Stockholm University, 118-138.
8.
Bjurek, H.
, L. Hjalmarsson, and F. R. Forsund (1990), “Deterministic Parametric and Nonparametric Estimation of Efficiency in Service Production,”Journal of Econometrics, 46, 213-227.
9.
Bjurek, H.
, U. Kjulin, and B. Gustafsson (1992), “Efficiency, Productivity and Determinants of Inefficiency at Public Day Care Centres in Sweden,”proceedings of a symposium on productivity concepts and measurement problems, Uppsala, 1991, 173-187. Uppsala: Uppsala University.
10.
Bousofiane, A.
, R. G. Dyson, and E. Thanassoulis (1991), “Applied Data Envelopment Analysis,”European Journal of Operational Research, 52, 1-15.
11.
Colwell, R. J.
and E. P. Davis (1992), “Output and Productivity in Banking,”The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 94 (Supplement, 5-7), S111-S131.
12.
Dean, E. R.
and K. Kuntze (1992), “Bureau of Labour Statistics Productivity Measures for Service Industries,”International Productivity Journal, Fall-Winter, 69-91.
13.
Drucker, P. F.
(1991), “The New Productivity Challenge,”Harvard Business Review, November-December, 69-79.
14.
Fare, R., S. Grosskopf, B. Lindgren, and P. Roos (1989), “Productivity Development in Swedish Hospitals,” mimeo.
15.
Farrell, M. J.
(1957), “The Measurement of Productivity Efficiency,”Journal of Royal Statistical Society, Sec. A, 253-281.
16.
Gordon, R. J. (1996), “Problems in the Measurement and Performance of Service Sector Productivity in the United States,” NBER Working Paper No. 5519, NBER, Cambridge.
17.
Graves, S. B.
and N. S. Langowitz (1993), “Innovative Productivity and Returns to Scale in the Pharmaceutical Industry,”Strategic Management Journal, 14 (8), 593-606.
18.
Griliches, Z.
(1979), “Issues in Assessing the Contribution of Research and Development to Productivity Growth,”The Bell Journal of Economics, 10 (1), 92-116.
19.
Griliches, Z.
(1993), “Introduction,” in Output Measurement in the Service Sectors, Z. Griliches, ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
20.
Griliches, Z.
(1994), “Productivity, R&D and the Data Constraint,”American Economic Review, March, 1-23.
21.
Griliches, Z.
and J. Mairesse (1984), “Productivity and R&D at the Firm Level,” in R&D, Patents and Productivity, Z. Griliches, ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
22.
Gummesson, E.
(1978), “Toward a Theory of Professional Service Marketing,”Industrial Marketing Management, 7 (2), 89-95.
23.
Gummesson, E.
(1991), “Service Quality—A Holistic View,” in Service Quality, E. Gummesson, B. Edvardsson, and B. O.Gustavsson, eds. New York: Lexington.
24.
Gummesson, E.
(1992), “Service Productivity: A Blasphemous Approach,” paper presented at the second international research seminar in service management, France, June.
25.
Gummesson, E.
(1993), “Service Management: An Evaluation and the Future,”International Journal of Service Industry Management, 5 (1), 57-78.
26.
Hedberg, B.
(1990), “Exit, Voice and Loyalty in Knowledge-Intensive Firms,” paper presented at the panel on the management and strategies of knowledge-intensive firms, Stockholm, Sweden.
27.
Henderson, R.
and I. Cockburn (1996), “Scale, Scope, and Spillovers: The Determinants of Research Productivity in Drug Discovery,”RAND Journal of Economics, 27 (1), 32-59.
28.
Hill, T. P.
(1977), “On Goods and Services,”Review of Income and Wealth Series, 23 (4), 77-95.
29.
Hirsch, Z.
(1990), “The Globalisation of Services and Service Intensive Goods Industries,” paper presented at the Fuqua School of Business Conference on the globalisation of professional services, Duke University, North Carolina.
30.
Hjalmarsson, L.
and A. Veiderpass (1992), “Productivity in Swedish Electricity Retail Distribution,”proceedings of a symposium on productivity concepts and measurement problems, Uppsala, 1991, 193-205. Uppsala: Uppsala University.
31.
Hjern, B. (1990), “The Private Service Sector: The Problem of Productivity Development,” Research Report No. 90:2, Karldtas, CTF.
32.
“How Consulting Firms Develop New Services” (1994), Consultants News, April, 1-3.
33.
Itami, H.
(1987), Mobilising Intangible Assets. Boston: Harvard University Press.
34.
Johnston, J.
(1963), “The Productivity of Management Consultants,”Journal of Royal Statistics Society, 126 (Series A), 237-248.
35.
Kestemont, M. P.
(1996), “Service Productivity and Structural Context in the Banking Sector: Are the Performance Indicators Robust?” paper presented at the second international workshop on service productivity, Madrid, April.
36.
Kremp, E.
and J. Mairesse (1993), “Dispersion and Heterogeneity of Firm Performances in Nine French Service Industries, 1984-1987,” in Output Measurement in the Service Sectors, Z. Griliches, ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
37.
Lowendahl, B. R.
(1997), Strategic Management of Professional Service Firms. Copenhagen: Copenhagen Business School Press.
38.
Luh, Y. H.
and S. E. Stefanou (1993), “Learning-by-Doing and the Sources of Productivity Growth: A Dynamic Model with Application to U.S. Agriculture,”Journal of Productivity Analysis, 4, 353-370.
39.
MacDonald, D. N.
and M. O. Reynolds (1994), “Are Baseball Players Paid Their Marginal Products?”Managerial and Decision Economics, 15, 443-457.
40.
Magi, A.
(1994), “On Productivity Measurement in Retailing,” in Service Productivity: Current Research, Proceedings from the First International Research Workshop on Service Productivity, October, Brussels, Gummesson and I. Thoresson-Hallgren, eds. Stockholm: Stockholm University.
41.
Maister, D.
(1993), Managing the Professional Service Firm. New York: Free Press.
42.
McKinsey Global Institute
(1992), Service Sector Productivity. Washington DC: McKinsey.
43.
Mellander, E.
(1992), “An Indirect Approach to Measuring Productivity in Private Services,”proceedings of a symposium on productivity concepts and measurement problems, Uppsala, 1991, 229-244.
44.
Montgomery, J. D.
(1991), “Equilibrium Wage Dispersion and Interindustry Wage Differentials,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, February, 163-179.
45.
Nachum, L.
(1996), “Winners and Losers in Professional Service Industries: What Makes the Difference? Evidence from the Advertising Industry,”Service Industries Journal, 16 (4), 474-490.
46.
Nachum, L.
(1999), The Origins of the International Competitiveness of Firms: The Impact of Location and Ownership in Professional Service Industries (“New Horizons in International Business” series). Aldershot, UK: Edward Elgar.
47.
“Productivity: Lost in Cyberspace” (1997), The Economist, September 13, 106-106.
48.
Quinn, J. B.
(1992), Intelligent Enterprise: A Knowledge and Service Based Paradigm for Industry. New York: Free Press.
49.
Schefczyk, M.
(1993), “Operational Performance of Airlines: An Extension of Traditional Measurement Paradigms,”Strategic Management Journal, 14 (May), 301-317.
50.
Sjorgen, S.
(1994), “Measuring Efficiency in Combined Transport Services,” in Service Productivity: Current Research, Proceedings from the First International Research Workshop on Service Productivity, E. Gummesson and I. Thoresson-Hallgren, eds. Brussels, October.
51.
Skandia
(1994), Visualising Intellectual Capital in Skandia (supplement to Skandia’s 1994 annual report). Stockholm: Skandia.
52.
Skandia
(1995), Renewal and Development of Human Capital (supplement to Skandia’s 1995 interim report). Stockholm: Skandia.
53.
Skandia
(1998), Human Capital in Transformation (supplement to Skandia’s 1998 annual report). Stockholm: Skandia.
54.
Stanback, T. M.
and T. Noyelle (1990), “Productivity in Services: A Valid Measure of Economic Performance?” in Skills, Wages, and Productivity in the Service Sector, T. Noyelle, ed. Oxford: Westview.
55.
Stewart, T. A.
(1994), “Your Company’s Most Valuable Assets: Intellectual Capital: New Ways to Build It and Measure It,”Fortune,October 3.
56.
Terpstra, V.
and C. M. Yu (1988), “Determinants of Foreign Investment of U.S. Advertising Agencies,”Journal of International Business Studies, 19 (Spring), 33-46.
57.
Thanassoulis, E.
(1993), “A Comparison of Regression Analysis and Data Envelopment Analysis as Alternative Methods for Performance Assessments,”Journal of Operational Research Society, 44 (11), 1129-1144.
