Frontline employees (FLEs) often face customer incivility—rude or demeaning remarks, verbal aggression, or hostile gestures. Although incivility from customers is rising at an alarming rate, most organizations refuse to act decisively to protect their FLEs and stop customer incivility. This research asserts that an organizational policy of ignoring and accepting incivility from customers is neither a wise business strategy nor has positive outcomes. In contrast, customer incivility should be handled promptly and decisively. Specifically, the authors present FLE Constructive Resistance (FLE CR) as a strategy to confront customer incivility. The authors conduct interviews with FLEs, develop a Constructive Resistance (CR) scale to fit the context of FLE–customer encounters, and test a conceptual model to examine the impact of CR by FLEs. The results suggest that customers who observe incivility perpetrated by fellow customers respond positively to FLE CR, including greater future purchase intention, greater positive word-of-mouth intention, and reduced future misbehavior intention. These effects are mediated by the observer’s perceived fairness of the FLE’s CR. Finally, the indirect effects of FLE’s CR on observer outcomes are more likely to manifest in customers with higher moral identity as well as newer customers.
AdamsJ. S. (1965), “Inequity in Social Exchange,” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 2, 267-299.
2.
AquinoKarlReedAmericusII (2002), “The Self-Importance of Moral Identity,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83 (6), 1423-1440.
3.
BakerMelissa A.KimKawon (2020), "Dealing with Customer Incivility: The Effects of Managerial Support on Employee Psychological Well-being and Quality-of-life," International Journal of Hospitality Management, 87, 102503.
4.
BaumeisterRoy F.BushmanBrad J.CampbellW. Keith (2000), “Self-esteem, Narcissism, and Aggression: Does Violence Result from Low Self-esteem or From Threatened Egotism?” Current Directions in Psychological Science, 9 (1), 26-29.
BoydHenry CIIIHelmsJanet E. (2005), “Consumer Entitlement Theory and Measurement,” Psychology & Marketing, 22 (3), 271-286.
7.
ChiNai-WenYangJixiaLinChia-Ying (2018), Service workers’ chain reactions to daily customer mistreatment: Behavioral linkages, mechanisms, and boundary conditions. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 23(1), 58.
8.
ColquittJason A. (2004), “Does the Justice of the One Interact with the Justice of the Many? Reactions to Procedural Justice in Teams,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 89 (4), 633-646.
9.
DauntKate L.HarrisLloyd C. (2011), “Customers Acting Badly: Evidence from the Hospitality Industry,” Journal of Business Research, 64 (10), 1034-1042.
10.
De CremerDavidVan HielAlain (2006), “Effects of Another Person’s Fair Treatment on One’s Own Emotions and Behaviors: The Moderating Role of How Much the Other Cares for You,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 100 (2), 231-249.
11.
De MatosCelso ARossiCarlos A. V. (2008), “Word-of-Mouth Communications in Marketing: A Meta-Analytic Review of the Antecedents and Moderators,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36 (4), 578-596.
FiskGlenda M.NevilleLukas B. (2011), “Effects of Customer Entitlement on Service Workers' Physical and Psychological Well-being: A Study of Waitstaff Employees,” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 16 (4), 391-405.
14.
FolgerRobert (1998), “Fairness as a Moral Virtue,” in Managerial Ethics: Morally Managing People and Processes, SchminkeM, ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 13-34.
15.
FolgerRobert (2001), “Fairness as Deonance,” in Research in Social Issues in Management, GillilandSSteinerDSkarlickiD, eds. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing, 3-31.
16.
FombellePaul W.VoorheesClay M.JenkinsMason R.SidaouiKarimBenoitSabineGruberThorstenGustafssonAndersAbosagIbrahim (2020), “Customer Deviance: A Framework, Prevention Strategies, and Opportunities for Future Research,” Journal of Business Research, 116, 387-400.
17.
Frey-CordesReginaEilertMeikeButtgenMarion (2020), Eye for an eye? Frontline service employee reactions to customer incivility. Journal of Services Marketing, 34(7), 939-953.
18.
GongTaeshikYiYoujaeChoiJin Nam (2014), “Helping Employees Deal with Dysfunctional Customers: The Underlying Employee Perceived Justice Mechanism,” Journal of Service Research, 17 (1), 102-116.
19.
GrandeyAlicia A.DickterDavid N.SinHock-Peng (2004), “The Customer is Not Always Right: Customer Aggression and Emotion Regulation of Service Employees,” Journal of Organizational Behavior, 25 (3), 397-418.
20.
GreenbaumRebecca L.MawritzMary B.MayerDavid M.PriesemuthManuela (2013), “To Act Out, to Withdraw, or to Constructively Resist? Employee Reactions to Supervisor Abuse of Customers and the Moderating Role of Employee Moral Identity,” Human Relations, 66 (7), 925-950.
21.
GreenbaumRebecca L.QuadeMatthew J.MawritzMary B.KimJoongseoCrosbyDurand (2014), “When the Customer is Unethical: The Explanatory Role of Employee Emotional Exhaustion onto Work–family Conflict, Relationship Conflict with Coworkers, and Job Neglect,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 99 (6), 1188-1203.
22.
GrégoireYanyMattilaAnna S. (2020), “Service Failure and Recovery at the Crossroads: Recommendations to Revitalize the Field and its Influence,” Journal of Service Research, 24 (3), 1-6.
23.
GrewalDhruvMonroeKent B.KrishnanRamayya (1998), “The Effects of Price-comparison Advertising on Buyers’ Perceptions of Acquisition Value, Transaction Value, and Behavioral Intentions,” Journal of Marketing, 62 (2), 46-59.
24.
HabelJohannesAlaviSaschaPickDoreén (2017), “When Serving Customers Includes Correcting Them: Understanding the Ambivalent Effects of Enforcing Service Rules,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 34 (4), 919-941.
25.
HardySam A.CarloGustavo (2011), “Moral identity: What is it, how does it develop, and is it linked to moral action?” Child Development Perspectives, 5 (3), 212-218.
26.
HayesAndrew F. (2018), Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-based Approach, 2nd ed.Guilford publications.
27.
HenkelAlexander P.BoegershausenJohannesRafaeliAnatLemminkJos (2017), “The Social Dimension of Service Interactions: Observer Reactions to Customer Incivility,” Journal of Service Research, 20 (2), 120-134.
28.
HershcovisM. SandyBhatnagarNamita (2017), When fellow customers behave badly: Witness reactions to employee mistreatment by customers. Journal of Applied Psychology, 102(11), 1528.
29.
HogarthRobin M.EinhornHillel J. (1992), “Order Effects in Belief Updating: The Belief-adjustment Model,” Cognitive Psychology, 24 (1), 1-55.
30.
HogreveJensBilsteinNicolaHoernerKathrin (2019), “Service Recovery on Stage: Effects of Social Media Recovery on Virtually Present Others,” Journal of Service Research, 22 (4), 421-439.
31.
HuLi‐tzeBentlerPeter M. (1999), “Cutoff Criteria for Fit Indexes in Covariance Structure Analysis: Conventional Criteria versus New Alternatives,” Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 6 (1), 1-55.
32.
HuangYu-Shan SandyGreenbaumRebecca L.BonnerJulena M.WangCynthia S. (2019), Why sabotage customers who mistreat you? Activated hostility and subsequent devaluation of targets as a moral disengagement mechanism. Journal of Applied Psychology, 104(4), 495.
33.
JungJin HoYooJaewon JayArnoldTodd J. (2017), “Service Climate as a Moderator of the Effects of Customer-to-Customer Interactions on Customer Support and Service Quality,” Journal of Service Research, 20 (4), 426-440.
34.
KernJulie H.GrandeyAlicia A. (2009), “Customer Incivility as a Social Stressor: The Role of Race and Racial Identity for Service Employees,” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 14 (1), 46-57.
35.
MaxhamJames G.IIINetemeyerRichard G. (2002), “A Longitudinal Study of Complaining Customers' Evaluations of Multiple Service Failures and Recovery Efforts,” Journal of Marketing, 66 (4), 57-71.
36.
MoormanChristineDeshpandeRohitZaltmanGerald (1993), “Factors Affecting Trust in Market Research Relationships,” Journal of Marketing, 57 (1), 81-101.
37.
MoormanChristineZaltmanGeraldDeshpandeRohit (1992), “Relationships Between Providers and Users of Market Research: The Dynamics of Trust Within and Between Organizations,” Journal of Marketing Research, 29 (3), 314-328.
38.
PenneyLisa M.SpectorPaul E. (2005), “Job Stress, Incivility, and Counterproductive Work Behavior (CWB): The Moderating Role of Negative Affectivity,” Journal of Organizational Behavior, 26 (7), 777-796.
39.
PorathChristineMacInnisDebbieFolkesValerie (2010), “Witnessing Incivility among Employees: Effects on Consumer Anger and Negative Inferences about Companies,” Journal of Consumer Research, 37 (2), 292-303.
40.
PorathChristinePearsonChristine (2013), “The Price of Incivility,” Harvard Business Review, 91 (1-2), 114-121.
41.
ReynoldsScott J.CeranicTara L.. (2007), “The Effects of Moral Judgment and Moral Identity on Moral Behavior: An Empirical Examination of the Moral Individual,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 92 (6), 1610-1624.
42.
RuppDeborah E.BellChris M. (2010), “Extending the Deontic Model of Justice: Moral Self-regulation in Third-party Responses to Injustice,” Business Ethics Quarterly, 20 (1), 89-106.
43.
ShaoRuodanSkarlickiDaniel P. (2014), Service employees’ reactions to mistreatment by customers: A comparison between North America and East Asia. Personnel psychology, 67(1), 23-59.
44.
SirianniNancy J.BitnerMary J.BrownStephen W.MandelNaomi (2013), “Branded Service Encounters: Strategically Aligning Employee Behavior with the Brand Positioning,” Journal of Marketing, 77 (6), 108-123.
45.
SkarlickiDaniel P.RuppDeborah E. (2010), “Dual Processing and Organizational Justice: The Role of Rational versus Experiential Processing in Third-party Reactions to Workplace Mistreatment,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 95 (5), 944-952.
46.
SkarlickiDaniel P.van JaarsveldDanielle D.ShaoRuodanSongYoung H.WangMo (2016), “Extending the Multifoci Perspective: The Role of Supervisor Justice and Moral Identity in the Relationship Between Customer Justice and Customer-Directed Sabotage,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 101 (1), 108-121.
47.
SkarlickiDaniel P.van JaarsveldDanielle D.WalkerDavid D. (2008), “Getting Even for Customer Mistreatment: The Role of Moral Identity in the Relationship Between Customer Interpersonal Injustice and Employee Sabotage,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 93 (6), 1335-1347.
48.
SliterMichaelJexSteveWolfordKatherineMcInnerneyJoanne (2010), “How Rude! Emotional Labor as a Mediator between Customer Incivility and Employee Outcomes,” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 15 (4), 468-481.
49.
SliterMichaelSliterKatherineJexSteve (2012), “The Employee as a Punching Bag: The Effect of Multiple Sources of Incivility on Employee Withdrawal Behavior and Sales Performance,” Journal of Organizational Behavior, 33 (1), 121-139.
50.
SurachartkumtonkunJirapornMcColl-KennedyJanet R.PattersonPaul G. (2015), “Unpacking Customer Rage Elicitation: A Dynamic Model,” Journal of Service Research, 18 (2), 177-192.
51.
TepperBennett J.DuffyMichelle K.ShawJason D. (2001), “Personality Moderators of the Relationship between Abusive Supervision and Subordinates' Resistance,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 86 (5), 974-983.
52.
TepperBennett J.Uhl-BienMaryKohutGary F.RogelbergSteven G.LockhartDaniel E.EnsleyMichael D. (2006), “Subordinates' Resistance and Managers' Evaluations of Subordinates' Performance,” Journal of Management, 32 (2), 185-209.
53.
TrevinoLinda K.WeaverGary R. (2001), “Organizational Justice and Ethics Program “Follow-Through”: Influences on Employees’ Harmful and Helpful Behavior,” Business Ethics Quarterly, 11 (4), 651-671.
54.
Van den BosKeesLindE. Allan (2001), “The Psychology of Own Versus Others’ Treatment: Self-oriented and Other-oriented Effects on Perceptions of Procedural Justice,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 27 (10), 1324-1333.
55.
Van JaarsveldDanielle D.WalkerDavid D.RestubogSimon L. D.SkarlickiDanielChenYueyangFrickéPascale H. (2019), “Unpacking the Relationship Between Customer (In) Justice and Employee Turnover Outcomes: Can Fair Supervisor Treatment Reduce Employees’ Emotional Turmoil?” Journal of Service Research, 24 (2), 301-319.
56.
WalkerDavid D.van JaarsveldDanielle D.SkarlickiDaniel P. (2014), “Exploring the Effects of Individual Customer Incivility Encounters on Employee Incivility: The Moderating Roles of Entity (In) civility and Negative Affectivity,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 99 (1), 151-161.
57.
WalkerDavid D.van JaarsveldDanielle D.SkarlickiDaniel P. (2017), “Sticks and Stones Can Break My Bones but Words Can Also Hurt Me: The Relationship between Customer Verbal Aggression and Employee Incivility,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 102 (2), 163-179.
58.
WangMoLiaoHuiZhanYujieShiJunqi (2011), Daily customer mistreatment and employee sabotage against customers: Examining emotion and resource perspectives. Academy of Management Journal, 54(2), 312-334.
59.
WilsonNicole L.HolmvallCamilla M. (2013), The development and validation of the Incivility from Customers Scale. Journal of occupational health psychology, 18(3), 310.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
