When they experience service failures, customers look for causes. They seek to understand whether the service firm could have prevented the failure (controllability attribution) and whether the cause of the failure is temporary or constant over time (stability attribution). To understand such attributions, we perform a meta-analysis. We find that causal attributions are related to emotional and cognitive reactions in several ways. First, controllability attributions elicit stronger negative emotions than do stability attributions. Second, controllability attributions directly affect only transaction-specific satisfaction, whereas stability attributions directly affect customers’ transaction-specific and overall satisfaction. Third, both attributions affect loyalty and negative word of mouth through negative emotions, overall satisfaction, and transaction-specific satisfaction. Finally, contextual (i.e., cultural values), methodological (i.e., type of failure), and measurement factors (i.e., measurement scale) partly explain studywise variation in the effects of attributions on customer outcomes. We recommend that companies manage reactions to service failure thrice: before customers formulate attributional beliefs, using fast and accurate communication; when the attributional beliefs are formed, offering employee assistance and compensations; and well after the attributional beliefs are established, providing feedback on process improvements by the company.
The complete list of studies included in the meta-analysis is available from the contact author upon request.
2.
BagozziRichard P.GopinathMaheshNyerPrashanth U. (1999), “The Role of Emotions in Marketing,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 27(2), 184–206.
3.
BarrowcloughChristineHooleyJill M. (2003), “Attributions and Expressed Emotion: A Review,”Clinical Psychology Review, 23(6), 849–880.
4.
BitnerMary Jo (1990), “Evaluating Service Encounters: The Effects of Physical Surroundings and Employee Responses,”Journal of Marketing, 54(2), 69–82.
5.
BitnerMary JoBoomsBernard H.TetreaultMary S. (1990), “The Service Encounter: Diagnosing Favorable and Unfavorable Incidents,”Journal of Marketing, 54(1), 71–84.
6.
BoshoffChristoLeongJason (1998), “Empowerment, Attribution, and Apologising as Dimensions of Service Recovery: An Experimental Study,”International Journal of Service Industry Management, 9(1), 24–47.
7.
BrownSteven P.PetersonRobert A. (1993), “Antecedents and Consequences of Salesperson Job Satisfaction: Meta-Analysis and Assessment of Causal Effects,”Journal of Marketing Research, 30(1), 63–77.
8.
BurnettJohn J.DunePatrick M. (1986), “An Appraisal of the Use of Student Subjects in Marketing Research,”Journal of Business Research, 14(4), 329–343.
9.
CasadoDiazAnaB.RuizFransisco J. Mas (2002), “The Consumer’s Reaction to Delays in Service,”International Journal of Service Industry Management, 13(2), 118–140.
10.
ChanHaksinWanLisa C.SinLeo Y. M. (2007), “Hospitality Service Failures: Who Will Be More Dissatisfied?”International Journal of Hospitality Management, 26(3), 531–545.
11.
ChoiSunmeeMattilaAnna S. (2008), “Perceived Controllability and Service Expectations: Influences on Customer Reactions Following Service Failure,”Journal of Business Research, 61(1), 24–30.
12.
CoussementKristofPoelDirk Van den (2008), “Improving Customer Complaint Management by Automatic Email Classification Using Linguistic Style Features as Predictors,”Decision Support Systems, 44(4), 870–882.
13.
de MatosCelso AugustoHenriqueJorge LuisRossiCarlos Alberto Vargas (2007), “Service Recovery Paradox: A Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Service Research, 10(1), 60–77.
14.
deMatosAugustoCelsoRossiCarlos Alberto VargasVeigaRicardo TeixeiraVieiraValter Afonso (2009), “Consumer Reaction to Service Failure and Recovery: The Moderating Role of Attitude toward Complaining,”Journal of Services Marketing, 23(7), 462–475.
15.
de MooijMariekeHofstedeGeert (2011), “Cross-cultural Consumer Behavior: A Review of Research Findings,”Journal of International Consumer Marketing, 23(3-4), 181–192.
16.
EdwardsJohn A. (1998), “Effects of Causal Uncertainty on the Dispositional Attribution Process,”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 34(2), 109–135.
17.
EllisPaul D. (2010). The Essential Guide to Effect Sizes: An Introduction to Statistical Power, Meta-Analysis and the Interpretation of Research Results. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
FieldAndy (2001), “Meta-Analysis of Correlation Coefficients: A Monte Carlo Comparison of Fixed- and Random-Effects Methods,”Psychological Methods, 6(2), 161–180.
20.
FolkesValerie S. (1984), “Customer Reaction to Product Failure: An Attributional Approach,”Journal of Consumer Research, 10(4), 398–409.
21.
FolkesValerie S.KoletskySusanGrahamJohn L. (1987), “A Field Study of Causal Inferences and Consumer Reaction: The View from the Airport,”Journal of Consumer Research, 13(4), 534–539.
22.
GelbrichKatjaRoschkHolger (2011), “A Meta-analysis of Organizational Complaint Handling and Customer Responses,”Journal of Service Research, 14(1), 24–43.
23.
GrégoireYanyFisherRobert J. (2008), “Customer Betrayal and Retaliation: When Your Best Customers Become Your Worst Enemies,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36(2), 247–261.
24.
HeiderFritz (1958). The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York, NY: John Wiley.
25.
HessRonald L.Jr (2008), “The Impact of Firm Reputation and Failure Severity on Customers’ Responses to Service Failures,” Journal of Services Marketing, 22(5), 385–398.
26.
HessRonald L.,JrGanesanShankarKleinNoemie M. (2003), “Service Failure and Recovery: The Impact of Relationship Factors on Customer Satisfaction,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 31(2), 127–145.
27.
HessRonald L.JrGanesanShankarKleinNoemie M. (2007), “Interactional Service Failures in a Pseudorelationship: The Role of Organizational Attributions,”Journal of Retailing, 83(1), 79–95.
28.
HoffmanK. DouglasKelleyScott W.RotalskyHolly M. (1995), “Tracking Service Failures and Employee Recovery Efforts,”Journal of Services Marketing, 9(2), 49–61.
29.
HofstedeGeert (1997), Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind. London, England: McGraw-Hill.
30.
HoxJoop J. (2010). Multilevel Analysis: Techniques and Applications. New York, NY: Routledge.
31.
HuangJen-HungHuangChun-TeWuSoushan (1996), “National Character and Response to Unsatisfactory Hotel Service,”International Journal of Hospitality Management, 15(3), 229–243.
32.
HuangWen-HsienLinY.-C.WenY.-C. (2010), “Attributions and Outcomes of Customer Misbehavior,”Journal of Business and Psychology, 25(1), 151–161.
33.
HuiMichael K.ToffoliRoy (2002), “Perceived Control and Consumer Attribution for the Service Encounter,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 32(9), 1825–1844.
34.
HunterJohn E.SchmidtFrank L. (2004). Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings, 2nd ed. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
35.
JohnstonRobertMichelStefan (2008), “Three Outcomes of Service Recovery: Customer Recovery, Process Recovery, and Employee Recovery,”International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 28(1), 79–99.
36.
KastanakisM. N.VoyerB.G. (2014), The effect of culture on perception and cognition: A conceptual framework. Journal of Business Research, 64(4), 425–433.
37.
LeungKwok (1988), “Some Determinants of Conflict Avoidance: A Cross-National Study,”Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 19(1), 125–136.
38.
MaxhamJames G., IIINetemeyerRichard G. (2002), “Modeling Customer Perceptions of Complaint Handling over Time: The Effects of Perceived Justice on Satisfaction and Intent,”Journal of Retailing, 78(4), 239–252.
39.
McAuleyLauraPhamBa’TugwellPeterMoherDavid (2000), “Does the Inclusion of Grey Literature Influence Estimates of Intervention Effectiveness Reported in Meta-Analysis?”The Lancet, 356 (9237), 1228–1231.
40.
McColl-KennedyJanet R.SmithAmy K. (2006), “Customer Emotions in Service Failure and Recovery Encounters,” in Research on Emotion in Organizations: Individual and Organizational Perspectives on Emotion Management and Display, ZerbeWilfrid J.AshkanasyNeal M.HärtelCharmine E. J., eds. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing, 237–268.
41.
MuncerStevenCraigieMarkHolmesJoni (2003), “Meta-Analysis and Power: Some Suggestions for the Use of Power in Research Synthesis,”Understanding Statistics, 21(1), 1–12.
42.
OliverRichard L. (1980). “A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction Decisions,”Journal of Marketing Research, 17(4), 460–469.
43.
OrsingherChiaraValentiniSaraMatteo de AngelisM. (2010), “A Meta-Analysis of Satisfaction with Complaint Handling in Services,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 38(2), 169–186.
44.
ParasuramanA.ZeithamlValerie A.BerryLeonard L. (1994), “Reassessment of Expectations as a Comparison Standard in Measuring Service Quality: Implications for Further Research,”Journal of Marketing, 58(1), 111–124.
45.
PetersonRobert A. (2001), “On the Use of College Students in Social Science Research: Insights from a Second-Order Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Consumer Research, 28(3), 450–461.
46.
PetersonRobert A.BrownSteven P. (2005), “On the Use of Beta Coefficients in Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 90(1), 175–181.
47.
RichinsMarsha L. (1997), “Measuring Emotions in the Consumption Experience,”Journal of Consumer Research, 24(2), 127–146.
48.
RoschkHolgerGelbrichKatja (2014), “Identifying Appropriate Compensation Types for Service Failures: A Meta-Analytic and Experimental Analysis,”Journal of Service Research, 17(2), 195–211.
49.
RosenthalRobert (1979), “The ‘File-Drawer Problem’ and Tolerance for Null Results,”Psychological Bulletin, 86(3), 638–641.
50.
RussellDanMcAuleyEdwardTaricoValerie (1987), “Measuring Causal Attributions for Success and Failure: A Comparison of Methodologies for Assessing Causal Dimensions,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52(6), 1248–1257.
51.
SmithAmy K.BoltonRuth N. (1998), “An Experimental Investigation of Customer Reactions to Service Failure and Recovery Encounters: Paradox or Peril?”Journal of Service Research, 1(1), 65–81.
52.
SmithAmy K.BoltonRuth N.WagnerJanet (1999), “A Model of Customer Satisfaction with Service Encounters Involving Service Failure and Recovery,”Journal of Marketing Research, 36(3), 356–372.
53.
SöderlundMagnus (2006), “Measuring Customer Loyalty with Multi-Item Scales: A Case for Caution,”International Journal of Service Industry Management, 17(1), 76–98.
54.
TaxStephen S.McCutcheonDavidWilkinsonIan F. (2013), “The Service Delivery Network (SDN): A Customer-Centric Perspective of the Customer Journey,”Journal of Service Research, 16(4), 454–470.
55.
VanVaerenberghBart LarivièreYves,VermeirIris (2012), “The Impact of Process Recovery Communication on Customer Satisfaction, Repurchase Intentions, and Word-of-Mouth Intentions,”Journal of Service Research, 15(3), 262–279.
56.
Varela-NeiraConcepciónVazquez-CasiellesRodolfoIglesiasVictor (2010), “Lack of Preferential Treatment: Effects on Dissatisfaction After a Service Failure,”Journal of Service Management, 21(1), 45–68.
57.
Vazquez-CasiellesRodolfoRio-LanzaAna Belén delDiaz-MartinAna Maria (2007), “Quality of Past Performance: Impact on Consumers’ Responses to Service Failure,” Marketing Letters, 18(4), 249–264.
58.
VelázquezBeatriz M.BlancoMaria F.ContriGloria B.SauraIrene G. (2009), “Cognitive and Affective Causes of Consumer Dissatisfaction with the Hospitality Encounter,”Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management, 18(7), 653–675.
59.
ViswesvaranChockalingamOnesDeniz S. (1995), “Theory Testing: Combining Psychometric Meta-Analysis and Structural Equation Modeling,”Personnel Psychology, 48(4), 865–868.
60.
WaltonAndreaHumeMargee (2012), “Examining Public Hospital Service Failure: The Influence of Service Failure Type, Service Expectations, and Attribution,”Journal of Nonprofit and Public Sector Marketing, 24(3), 202–221.
61.
WeinerBernard (1985), “An Attributional Theory of Achievement Motivation and Emotion,”Psychological Review, 92(4), 548–573.
62.
WeinerBernard (2000), “Attributional Thoughts about Consumer Behavior,”Journal of Consumer Research, 27(3), 382–387.
63.
WeinerBernardFriezeIrene H.HuklaAndyReedLindaRestStanleyRosenbaumRobert M. (1971). Perceiving the Causes of Success and Failure. Morristown, NJ: General Learning Press.
64.
WirtzJochenMattilaAnna S. (2004), “Consumer Responses to Compensation, Speed of Recovery and Apology After a Service Failure,”International Journal of Service Industry Management, 15(2), 150–166.
65.
ZhangJingyunBeattySharon E.WalshGianfranco (2008), “Review and Future Directions of Cross-Cultural Consumer Services Research,”Journal of Business Research, 61(3), 211–224.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
