Parallel programmers must choose from a confusing array of parallel programming environments. When success has to be measured by the success of applica tion-software development rather than theoretical re search, the choice must be made quickly without the luxury of experimentation.
In this paper, we help the programmer make this choice by looking closely at four of the most heavily used portable programming environments—p4, PVM, TCGMSG, and Linda. For each of these programming environments, we look at three different programs: one that computes π by numerical integration and two that benchmark communication performance. The four programming environments are analyzed in terms of performance, support, ease of coding, and ease of debugging.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Barnett, M., Gupta, S., Payne, D., Shuler, L., van de Geijn, R., and Watts, J.1994. Interprocessor Collective Communications Library (InterComm)— Beta Release 0.0.1. Available by anonymous ftp at cs.utexas.eduin/pub/rvdg/iCC.
2.
Beguelin, A., Dongarra, J., Geist, A., and Sunderam, V.1993. Visualization and debugging in a heterogeneous environment . Computer26(6): 88-95.
3.
Bercovitz, P., and Carriero, N.1990. Tuplescope: a Graphical Monitor and Debugger for Linda based Parallel Programs. RR-782. Yale University Computer Science Department.
4.
Boyle, J., Butler, R., Disz, T., Glickfeld, B., Lusk, E., Overbeek, R., Patterson, J., and Stevens, R.1987. Portable programs for parallel processors, Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
5.
Butler, R., and Lusk, E.1992. User's Guide to the p4 Programming System. ANL-92/17. Argonne National Laboratory.
6.
Butler, R., and Lusk, E.1994. Monitors, messages, and clusters: The p4 parallel programming system. Parallel Comput. 20: 547-564.
7.
Carriero, N.J., and Gelernter, D.1990. How to write parallel programs: A first course . Cambridge: MIT Press.
8.
Carriero, N.J., Gelernter, D., Mattson, T.G., and Sherman, A.H.1994. The Linda alternative to message-passing systems . Parallel Comput.20: 633-655.
9.
Cheng, D.Y.1993. A Survey of Parallel Programming Languages and Tools. RND-93-005. NASA Ames Research Center.
10.
Douglas, C.C., Mattson, T.G., and Schultz, M.H.1993. Parallel Programming Systems for Workstation Clusters . YALEU/
11.
DCS/TR-975. Yale University Computer Science Department.
12.
Douglas, C.C., Mattson, T.G., and Schultz, M.H.1994. Experimental results for data sharing on high-performance networks. Proc. 1994 Mardi Gras Conference, Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
13.
Geist, A., Beguelin, A., Dongarra, J., Jiang, W., Manchek, R., and Sunderam, V.1993. PVM 3 User's Guide and Reference Manual. ORNL/TM-12187. ORNL.
14.
Harrison, R.J.1991. Portable tools and applications for parallel computers . Int. J. Quantum Chem.40:847-863.
15.
Heath, M., and Etheridge, J.1991. Visualizing the performance of parallel programs . IEEE Software8(5):29-39.
16.
Herrarte, V., and Lusk, E.1991. Studying parallel program behavior with upshot. ANL-91/15 . Argonne National Laboratory.
17.
Karp, A.H., and Babb II, R.G.1988. A comparison of 12 parallel Fortran dialects. IEEE Software5: 52-67.
18.
Larrabee, A.R.1994. The p4 parallel programming system, the Linda environment, and some experiences with parallel computation. Sci. Prog.2:23-36.
19.
Mattson, T.G.1994. The efficiency of Linda for general purpose scientific programming. Sci. Prog.3:61-71.
20.
Mattson, T.G., and Ravishanker, G.1995. Portable molecular dynamics software for parallel computing. To appear in Parallel computing in computational chemistry, edited by T. G. Mattson.Washington D.C.: ACS Books.
21.
Nieplocha, J., Harrison, R.J., and Littlefield, R.J.1994. Global arrays: A portable shared-memory programming model for distributed memory computers. Proc. Supercomputing '94, IEEE Computer Society Press.
22.
Sukup, F.1994. Efficiency evaluation of some parallelization tools on a workstation cluster using the NAS parallel benchmarks. ACPC/TR 94-2. Vienna: Vienna University of Technology, Computing Center.
23.
Sunderam, V.S.1990. PVM: A framework for parallel distributed computing . Concurrency: Practice and Experience2: 315-339.
24.
Turcotte, L.1993. A survey of software environments for exploiting networked computing resources. MSM-EIRS-ERC-93-2. Mississippi State University.
25.
Walker, D.W.1994. The design of a standard message passing interface for distributed memory concurrent computers. Parallel Comput.20:657.
