Incentives,Optimality,and Publicly Provided Goods: the Case of Mental Health Services

Abstract

In this article, the authors investigate the incentives present in intergovernment transfers for public mental health care. This represents an important issue because of the large portion of mental health care that is provided by local governments, the central role of states in financing care via intergovernment transfers, and recent innovations adopted by some states altering the traditional terms of these transfers. Using a relatively simple model, the authors show that when a state government provides both financing and a free input into local government production, there will be excessive use of that input. If local government and society differ in their preferences, setting the price of the input at marginal cost will not induce optimal behavior. The optimal prices are proportional to the sum of the elasticities of the provider's expected supply of services with respect to the subsidy (tax). These results are analogous to those for optimal commodity taxation. Examination of the transfer contracts for Wisconsin, Ohio, and for Texas reveals that these contracts may not be optimal. These departures from optimal decisions may be partially due to the practical issues related to implementation of optimal transfer arrangements, such as setting subsidy or tax levels or imposing budget reductions.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bachrach, L. 1982. Young adult chronic patients: An analytical review of the literature. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 33 (3): 189-97.

Brown, P. 1985. The transfer of care. New York : Routledge.

Burt, M.R. , and K.J. Pittman. 1985. Testing the social safety net. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press .

Cordes, J.J. , and B.A. Weisbrod. 1981. Compensating losers from economic change when lump sum transfers are not possible. Journal of Public Economics.

Dowell, D.A. , and J.A. Ciarlo. 1989. An evaluative overview of the community mental health centers program. In Mental health policy in the United States, edited by D. A. Rochefort. New York: Greenwood.

Faden, V.B. , and H.H. Goldman. 1979. Appropriateness of placement of patients in state and county mental hospitals. Statistical Note No. 152. Washington, DC: National Institutes of Mental Health .

Frank, R.G. , and W.P. Welch. 1982. Contracting state mental hospital systems . Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 6 (4): 676-83.

Ganju, V. , and C. Bouchard. 1990. Funding incentives for community based programs: The impact on local services of Texas' $35.50 program. Austin: Texas Department of Mental Health and Mental Retardation. Mimeo.

Glover, R.W. , T. Lutterman , N.A. Mazade , and C.R. Wurster. 1985. In Mental health, United States 1985 , edited by C. A. Taube and S. A. Barrett. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

10.

Grob, G.N. 1983. Mental illness and American society 1875-1940. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .

11.

—. 1987. Mental health policy in post World War II America. In Improving mental health services: What the social sciences can tell us, edited by D. Mechanic. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

12.

Hargreaves, W.A. , and M. Shumway. 1989. Effectiveness of mental health services for the severely mentally ill. In The future of mental health services research, edited by C. A. Taube , D. Mechanic , and A. Hohmann. National Institute of Mental Health, DHHS Pub. No. (ADM) 89-1600. Washington, DC: Supt. of Docs., U.S. Government Printing Office.

13.

Holmstrom, B. , and J. Tirole. 1989. The theory of the firm. In Handbook of industrial organization, edited by R. Schmalensee and R. Willig. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

14.

Inman, R.P. 1987a. Federal assistance and local services in the United States: The evolution of a new federalist order. Working paper 2283. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research .

15.

—. 1987b. Markets, government and the new political economy . In Handbook of public economics, edited by A. Auerbach and M. Feldstein. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

16.

Locke, B.Z. , and D.A. Regier. 1985. Prevalence of selected mental disorders . In Mental health, United States 1985, edited by C. A. Taube and S. A. Barrett. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

17.

Manderscheid, R.W. , and S.A. Barrett. 1987. Mental health, United States 1987. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

18.

Manderscheid, R.W. , and M.A. Sonnenschein . 1990. Mental health, United States 1990. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

19.

Mazade, N.W. , T. Lutterman, C. R. Wurster , and R.W. Glover. 1987. In Mental health, United States 1987 , edited by R. W. Manderscheid and S. A. Barrett. Washington, DC: U.S Government Printing Office.

20.

McGuire, T.G. , and M.H. Riordan. 1993. Contracting for community-based public mental health services. InAdvances in health economics and health services research, vol. 14, edited by T.-W. Hu and A. Rupp. Greenwich, CT: JAI.

21.

Mechanic, D. 1987. Evolution of mental health services and areas for change . In Improving mental health services: What can the social sciences tell us, edited by D. Mechanic. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .

22.

National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors. 1992. Unpublished data. Alexandria, VA.

23.

Rice, D.P. et al. 1990. The economic costs of alcohol and drug abuse and mental illness 1985. Washington, DC: Alcohol, Drug Abuse and Mental Health Administration, Office of Financing and Coverage Policy.

24.

Shapiro, C. , and R. Willig. 1990. Economic rationales for the scope of privatization. Olin Program paper 41. Princeton, NJ: Woodrow Wilson School, Princeton University .

25.

Starrett, D.A. 1988. Foundations of public economics. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.

26.

Stein, L.I. 1989. Wisconsin's system of mental health financing. In Integrating mental health systems through capitation, edited by D. Mechanic and L. Aiken. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .

27.

Stein, L. , and L.J. Ganser. 1983. Wisconsin's system for funding mental health services. In Unified mental health systems: Utopia unrealized, edited by J. Talbott. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

28.

U.S.Bureau of the Census . 1990. State finances. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

29.

U.S. General Accounting Office. 1977. Returning the mentally disabled to the community: Government needs to do more. HRD-76-152, January, Washington, DC.

30.

Wells, K.B. , and R.H. Brook. 1989. The quality of mental health services: Past, present and future. In Thefuture of mental health services research, edited by C. A. Taube , D. Mechanic , and A. Hohmann. National Institute of Mental Health, DHHS Pub. No. (ADM) 89-1600. Washington, DC: Supt. of Docs., U.S. Government Printing Office.