State-Local Revenue Diversification,Balance,and Fiscal Performance

Abstract

Revenue diversification and balanced use of revenue sources have long been held as desirable policy aims by many tax policy analysts, especially the Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. Ladd and Weist asserted that revenue balance is not a valid policy goal in and of itself. The disagreements between the two schools of thought have been difficult to sort out in part because of differences in perspectives and in part because of the lack of an acceptable quantitative measure of diversification and definition of balance. This article uses an empirical method for determining diversification and shows that past definitions of revenue balance have been overly narrow. However, in contrast to Ladd and Weist, the empirical measures of diversification do show that revenue balance is related, at the margin, to improved fiscal performance, and thus that balance remains a worthwhile policy aim.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. 1987a. Government finance diskettes, FY1986. Washington, DC: ACIR.

Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. 1987b. Significant features of fiscal federalism, 1987 edition. M-151. Washington, DC: ACIR.

Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. 1987c. Significant features of fiscal federalism, 1988 edition . Vol. 1. M-155. Washington, DC: ACIR .

Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. 1987d. Measuring state fiscal capacity, 1987 edition. M-156 . Washington, DC: ACIR.

Carlton, Dennis W. , and Jeffrey M. Perloff . 1990. Modern industrial organization . Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman/Little, Brown Higher Education.

Cline, Robert J. , and John Shannon. 1983. The property tax in a model state-local revenue system. Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science 35:42-56.

Kleine, Robert. 1986. Characteristics of a balanced state-local tax system . In Proceedings of the Seventy-Eighth Annual Conference on Taxation, 134-51. National Tax Association-Tax Institute of America, Columbus, OH.

Ladd, Helen F. , and Dana R. Weist. 1987. State and local tax systems: Balance among taxes vs. balance among policy goals. In The quest for balance in state-local revenue structures, edited by Frederick D. Stocker , 39-69. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy , Tax Policy Roundtable, Property Tax Papers Series TPR-16.

Moody's Investors Service. 1988. Moody's municipal and government manual. New York. Moody's Investors Service.

10.

Phares, Donald. 1980. Who pays state and local taxes. Cambridge, MA: Oelgeschlager, Gunn & Hain.

11.

Pollock, Richard L , and Jack P. Suyderhoud . 1986. The problems and prospects of focussing a tax review. In Proceedings of the Seventy-Eighth Annual Conference on Taxation, 127-34. National Tax Association-Tax Institute of America, Columbus, OH .

12.

Shannon, John. 1987. State revenue diversification—The search for balance . In Frederick D. Stocker (Ed.), The quest for balance in state-local revenue structures, edited by Frederick

13.

Stocker (Ed.), The quest for balance in state-local revenue structures, edited by Frederick D. Stocker , 9-37. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Tax Policy Roundtable, Property Tax Papers Series TPR-16.