Intergovernmental Grants and the Demand for Local Educational Expenditures

Abstract

Intergovernmental grant programs can create offsetting economic incentives for recipients. This article examines the response of local school district voters to Michigan's Guaranteed Tax Base (GTB) school-aid formula and its Homestead Property Tax Credit program ("circuit breaker"). While some response was found to the price effects of both grant programs, econometric evidence suggests that efforts to reduce interdistrict spending disparities by means of GTB formula price effects will prove futile for two reasons. First, these effects are offset by the counter effects of the circuit breaker. Second, because their demand for school spending is inelastic, voters in "in-formula" districts will convert increased GTB matching aid into property tax relief by reducing tax effort. Further, the finding of statistically different price and income elasticities of demand for local expenditures in high- and low-spending districts, which are also high- and low-property wealth and income districts, suggests that the constant elasticity formulation often used in studies of local education demand is problematic.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bergstrom, Theodore , and Richard Goodman. 1973. Private demand for public goods . American Economics Review 63:280-96.

Brown, Byron W. , and Daniel H. Saks. 1983. Spending for local public education: Income distribution and the aggregation of private demands. Public Finance Quarterly 11:21-45.

Fisher, Ronald C. , and Robert H. Rasche . 1984. The incidence and incentive effects of property tax credits: Evidence from Michigan. Public Finance Quarterly 12:291-319.

Greene, Kenneth V. , and Vincent G. Munley . 1984. Perceptions of the ability to export nonresidential property tax burdens. Public Finance Quarterly 12:117-27.

Kmenta, Jan. 1971. Elements of econometrics. New York : Macmillan.

Megdal, Sharon B. 1984. Model of local demand for education. Journal of Urban Economics 16:13-30.

Moffitt, Robert. 1986. The econometrics of piecewise linear budget constraints: A survey and exposition of the maximum likelihood methods. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 4:317-28.

Netzer, Dick. 1966. Economics of the property tax. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.

Park, R.E. , and Stephen J. Carroll . 1979. The search for equity in school finance: Michigan school district response to a guaranteed tax base (R-23920NIE/HEW. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.

10.

U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census. 1980. Census ofpopulation and housing: Local education agency summaries. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.