Growth of Government Expenditure: The Case of Canada

Abstract

This article examines empirically the secular growth of federal government expenditure in Canada using both political and economic variables. The alternative hypotheses and related controversies surrounding the measurement of the size and growth of government are discussed and tested. The results indicate that, at least in the case of Canada, the use of real or nominal measures does not alter the conclusions. However, depending on whether exhaustive or nonexhaustive measures of the size of government are used, significantly different results are obtained. Our empirical results suggest that both political and economic factors have significantly affected the growth of government in Canada. Among economic variables, internationally induced economic changes, dependency ratio, rate of unemployment and the growth in real income stand out. Political variables support the hypothesis that the more “liberal” the leader of the party in power and the higher the percentage of liberals in the House, the larger will be the size of public spending, and vice versa.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abizadeh

Gray

(1985) “Wagner's Law: A Pooled Time Series, Cross-Section Comparison.” National Tax J. 38: 209–218.

Auld

(1976) Issues in Government Expenditure Growth. C. D. Howe Research Institute: Montreal.

Beck

(1979) “Public Sector Growth: A Real Perspective.” Public Finance 34: 313–343.

Beck

(1985) “Public Expenditure, Relative Prices, and Resource Allocation.” Public Finance 40: 17–34.

Bird

R. M.

(1970) The Growth of Government Spending in Canada. Canadian Tax Foundation: Toronto.

Bird

R. M.

(1971) “Wagner's ‘Law’ of Expanding State Activity.” Public Finance 26: 1–26.

Bird

R. M.

(1979) Financing Canadian Government: A Quantitative Overview. Canadian Tax Foundation: Toronto.

Buchanan

J. M.

Flowers

M. R.

(1980) The Public Finances: An Introductory Textbook. Homewood, IL: Irwin.

Cameron

D. R.

(1978) “The Expansion of Public Economy: A Comparative Analysis.” Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev. 72: 1243–1261.

10.

Cameron

D. R.

(1986) “The Growth of Government Spending: The Canadian Experience in Comparative Perspective,” in Keith Banting (Research Coordinator) State and Society: Canada in Comparative Perspective. Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada. Univ. of Toronto Press: Toronto.

11.

Canadian Tax Foundation (1986) The National Finances: An Analysis of the Revenues and Expenditures of the Government of Canada, 1985–86. Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation.

12.

Foot

D. K.

(1979) “Political Cycles, Economic Cycles and the Trend in Public Employment in Canada,” pp. 65–80 in Meyer Bucovetsky

(ed.) Studies in Public Employment and Compensation in Canada. Montreal: Butterworth.

13.

Gandhi

V. P.

(1971) “Wagner's Law of Public Expenditure: Do Recent Cross Section Studies Confirm It?” Public Finance 26: 44–56.

14.

Herber

B. P.

(1983). Modern Public Finance. Homewood, IL: Irwin.

15.

Hook

(1962) “The expansion of the public sector: A study of the development of public expenditures in Sweden during the years 1912–1958.” Public Finance 17: 289–312.

16.

Johansen

(1968) Public Economics. Chicago: Rand McNally.

17.

Kelley

A. C.

(1976) “Demographic changes and the size of government sector.” Southern Econ. J. 43: 1056–1065.

18.

Lall

(1969) “A note on government expenditure in developing countries.” Econ. J. 79: 413–417.

19.

Larkey

P. D.

Stolp

Winer

(1981) “Theorizing about the growth of government: A research assessment.” J. of Public Policy 1: 157–220.

20.

Lewis-Beck

M. S.

Rice

T. W.

(1985) “Government growth in the United States.” J. of Politics 47: 2–30.

21.

Lots

J. R.

Morss

R. E.

(1970) “A theory of tax level determinants for developing countries.” Econ. Development and Cultural Change 18: 238–241.

22.

Mann

A. J.

(1980) “Wagner's Law: An Econometric Test for Mexico.” National Tax J. 33: 198–201.

23.

Maslove

A. M.

(1981) “Public finance,” pp. 327–344 in Bellan

R. C.

Pope

W. H.

(eds.) The Canadian Economy: Problems and Options. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson Ltd.

24.

Musgrave

R. A.

(1969) Fiscal Systems. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press.

25.

Musgrave

R. A.

(1981) “Leviathan Cometh—or Does He?” pp. 77–120 in Ladd

Tideman

(eds.) Tax and Expenditure Limits. Washington, DC: Urbana Institute.

26.

Musgrave

R. A.

Musgrave

P. B.

(1984). Public Finance in Theory and Practice. New York: McGraw-Hill.

27.

Northaus

W. D.

(1975) “The political business cycle.” Rev. of Econ. Studies 42: 169–190.

28.

Peacock

A. T.

Wiseman

(1967) The Growth of Public Expenditure in the United Kingdom. London: George Allen & Unwin.

29.

Perry

D. B.

(1977) “Major growth areas in the public sector.” Canadian Tax J. 25: 677–680.

30.

Schultze

C. L.

(1976) “Federal Spending: Past, Present and Future,” in Owen

Henry

Schultze

Charles

(eds.) Setting National Priorities: The Next Ten Years. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

31.

Thorn

R. S.

(1967) “The evolution of public finance during economic development.” Manchester School of Economics and Social Studies 35: 19–53.

32.

Tullock

(1974) “Dynamic hypothesis of bureaucracy.” Public Choice 29: 127–131.

33.

Wagner

R. E.

Weber

W. E.

(1977) “Wagner's law fiscal institutions, and the growth of government.” National Tax J. 30: 59–68.

34.

Williamson

J. G.

(1961) “Public expenditure and revenue: An international comparison.” Manchester School of Economics and Social Studies 29: 43–56.