A Simultaneous Equations Model of the Demand for and Production of Local Public Services: the Case of Education

Abstract

In this article I specify a simultaneous equations model of the demand for and production of educational outputs, estimate the model for 46 Los Angeles County school districts, and use the model to simulate the effects of a county-wide property tax base sharing policy. The price elasticity estimates for educational outputs are far more inelastic than previous estimates. My income elasticity estimates are mildly inelastic and similar to previous estimates. I demonstrate that previous studies, which estimated reduced-form expenditure functions, were misspecified and did not estimate the demand elasticities for local public services. I also demonstrate that an areawide tax base sharing plan assists the poorest school districts but also benefits middle- to upper-middle-income low-property tax base districts and harms lower- to middle-income high-property tax base districts.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bahl, R. (1969) "Studies on determinants of public expenditures: a review," pp. 184-207 in S. Mushkin and J. Cotton (eds.) Sharing Federal Funds for State and Local Needs. New York: Praeger.

Basmann, R.L. (1960) "On finite sample distributions of GCLE identifiability test statistics." J. of the Amer. Stat. Assn. (December): 650-659

. Bergstrom, T.C. and R.P. Goodman (1973) "Private demands for public goods." Amer. Econ. Rev. 63 (June): 280-297

. Borcherding, T.E. and R.P. Deacon (1972) "The demand for the services of non-federal governments." Amer. Econ. Rev. 62 (December): 891-901

. Brueckner, J.E. (1981) "Congested public goods: the case of fire protection." J. of Public Economics 15, 1: 45-58

. Bucovetsky, S. (1982) "Inequality in the local public sector." J. of Pol. Economy 90 (February): 128-145

. California State Department of Education, State Testing Program (1972) 1970-71 Profiles of School District Performance. Sacramento: author .

———( 1974) 1972-73 Profiles of School District Performance Sacramento: author.

Deacon, R.P. (1977) "Private choice and collective outcomes." National Tax J. 30 (December): 374-385

10.

. Hirsch, W.Z. (1973) Urban Economic Analysis New York: McGraw-Hill.

11.

Ladd, H.F. (1975) "Local educational expenditure, fiscal capacity and the composition of the property tax base." National Tax J. 28 (June): 145-158

12.

. Los Angeles County Assessor's Office (1970) Parcel Record Tapes.

13.

McDougall, G.S. (1976a) "Hedonic prices and the demand for local public goods." Public Finance Q. 31, 2: 265-279

14.

. ---( 1976b) "Local public goods and residential property values: some insights and extensions." National Tax J. 29 (December): 436-447

15.

. Oates, W.E. (1969) "The effects of property taxes and local public spending on property values: an empirical study of tax capitalization and the Tiebout hypothesis." J. of Pol. Economy 77 (November): 957-971

16.

. Perkins, G.M. (1977) "The demand for local public goods: elasticities of demand for own prices, cross prices and income." National Tax J. 30 (December): 411-419

17.

. Prommerehne, W.M. (1978) "Institutional approaches to public expenditures: empirical evidence from Swiss municipalities." J. of Public Economics 9 (April): 253-280

18.

. Reilly, G.S. (1982) "Wealth neutrality revisited: guaranteed tax base formulas and local choice in public education." Rev. of Economics and Statistics 64 (November): 553-560

19.

. Reishoure, R.B. and R.W. Hartman (1973) Reforming School Finance Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

20.

Rosen, H.S. and D.J. Fullerton (1977) "A note on local tax rates, public benefit levels and property values." J. of Pol. Economy 85 (April): 433-440

21.

. Schoettle, F.P. (1972) "Judicial requirements for school finance and property tax redesign: the rapidly evolving caselaw." National Tax J. 25 (September): 455-472

22.

. Stubblebine, W.C. and R.K. Teeples (1974) "California and the finance of education: alternatives in the wake of Serrano V. Priest," pp. 163-178. in R. W. Lindholm. (ed.) Property Taxation and the Finance of Education. Madison : Univ. of Wisconsin Press.

23.

U.S. Bureau of the Census (1970) United States Census of Populations and Housing 1970, Block Statistics, Final Report HC(3)-18, California Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.