The Size of Government,Capital Accumulation,and the Tax Base

Abstract

A central tax policy concern is the role of particular tax bases in either stimulating or discouraging capital accumulation. While the consumption tax has been proposed as superior to the income tax in terms of its treatment of saving, the literature has shown that whether a consumption or income-based tax system is associated with greater capital accumulation is theoretically indeterminate. This article incorporates the role of public accumulation and changing government activities into its analysis of capital accumulation, which enables this ambiguity to be resolved. An examination of U.S. data for the 1929–1978 period suggests that had inflation adjustment of the income tax been adopted it would, contrary to the implication of several tax reform proposals, have resulted in greater accumulation than the implementation of a consumption tax.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barro

R. J.

(1974) “Are government bonds net wealth?” J. of Pol. Economy 82 (December): 1094–1117.

Borcherding

T. E.

(1977) “One hundred years of public spending, 1870–1970,” pp. 45–70 in Borcherding

T. E.

(ed.) Budgets and Bureaucrats: The Sources of Government Growth. Durham, NC: Duke Univ. Press.

Bradford

D. E.

(1980) “The economics of tax policy toward savings,” pp. 11–71 in von Furstenberg

(ed.), The Government and Capital Formation. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.

Bradford

D. E.

Rosen

(1976) “The optimal taxation of income and commodities.” Amer. Econ. Rev. 66: 94–101.

Buchanan

J. M.

(1959) “Saving and the rate of interest: A comment.” J. of Pol. Economy 67 (February): 79–82.

Eisner

(1977) “Capital shortage: Myth and reality.” Amer. Econ. Rev. 67 (February): 110–115.

Feldstein

(1978) “The welfare cost of capital income taxation.” J. of Pol. Economy 86 (April): S29–S51.

Feldstein

(1974) “Social security, induced retirement, and aggregate capital accumulation.” J. of Pol. Economy 82 (September/October): 905–926.

Feldstein

(1977) “Does the United States save too little?” Amer. Econ. Rev. 67 (February): 116–121.

10.

von Furstenberg

G. M.

Malkiel

B. C.

(1977) “The government and capital formation: A survey of recent issues.” J. of Econ. Literature 15 (September): 835–878.

11.

Kelso

P. R.

(1978) “New taxes for the capital shortage: A critical review.” Intermountain Econ. Rev. 9 (Fall): 67–81.

12.

Meade

J. E.

(1978) The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation: Report of a Committee Chaired by Professor J. E. Meade. London: Allen & Unwin.

13.

Nellor

D. C. L.

(1981) Timing and Expectations in the Theory of Taxation. Ph.D. dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg.

14.

Summers

L. H.

(1981) “Capital taxation and accumulation in a life cycle growth model.” Amer. Econ. Rev. 71 (September): 533–544.

15.

Tanner

J. E.

(1979) “An empirical investigation of tax discounting.” J. of Money, Credit, and Banking 11 (May): 214–218.

16.

Thompson

(1974) “Taxation and national defense.” J. of Pol. Economy 82 (July): 755–782.

17.

Treasury

U.S.

(1977) Blueprints for Basic Tax Reform. Washington DC: Government Printing Office.